Hugo Blu-ray Review
Score: 78
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Hugo is a cinematic masterpiece, impeccably crafted with stunning technical presentation, though some may find the extras limited.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 85
Hugo's Blu-ray presentation is a visual marvel, boasting an astonishing 1080p transfer that perfectly captures the film's stylized aesthetic of burnished copper, bronze, and cool turquoise. The meticulous digital photography ensures unparalleled clarity and depth, with flawless contrast, richly balanced colors, and rock-solid black levels, making it a reference-quality release.
Audio: 83
Hugo's DTS-HD MA 7.1 lossless soundtrack is an auditory marvel, offering an immersive and meticulously detailed soundstage that vividly recreates the Paris train station. With precise dialogue, enveloping ambient effects, and a richly evocative score, this audio presentation is truly reference quality.
Extra: 54
Hugo's Blu-ray extras offer intriguing but too brief featurettes, such as a 19-minute making-of segment and a 15-minute homage to Georges Méliès, while leaving much to be desired in terms of depth and comprehensive content, including the absence of commentary tracks and deleted scenes.
Movie: 88
Hugo, a deceptively enchanting film directed by Martin Scorsese, combines breathtaking visuals, historical reverence, and a heartfelt narrative to create a cinematic gem. Though opinions on the storytelling are mixed, the Blu-ray release's stellar transfer and immersive design make it a must-own for enthusiasts.
Video: 85
The 1080p Blu-ray transfer of Hugo is nothing short of mesmerizing, capturing the visually immersive world of Martin Scorsese's film with extraordinary precision. The digital photography, characterized by a stylized mix of copper, bronze, midnight blue, and turquoise, retains its captivating cinematic allure on Blu-ray. The detailed capture of worn gears, rusted metal, and scuffed floors enhances the already intricate textures present in the film. Each scene, whether a sweeping vista of Paris or a close-up of Hugo’s automaton, is presented with unparalleled clarity. Despite the digital medium, the picture never feels lifeless; instead, it showcases the dynamic range achievable through high-definition technology.
Color fidelity is superb, maintaining the film's sepia-toned aesthetic without over-saturating flesh tones or primary colors. From the amber-hued interiors of the train station to the inspector’s vibrant blue uniform, each color is rendered with remarkable accuracy. Black levels are deep and nuanced, ensuring that shadowy scenes such as those in Hugo’s lair retain their intricacies without obscuring detail. Contrast remains reliable across all lighting conditions. The flashbacks, notably diverging from the predominant blue undertone, burst with vibrancy yet remain true to the film’s artistic vision.
Overall, the transfer underscores the film’s artfully constructed environment—from its industrial machinery to the attire awarded an Oscar for Best Costume Design. The fidelity to texture and depth is evident; there’s no evidence of edge enhancement, banding, or smearing. Minor shimmering on tight patterns may be noted but does not detract from an overall flawless presentation. This Blu-ray serves as a testament to digital filmmaking's potential, celebrating Scorsese’s envisioned world with exquisite attention to visual detail and color integrity.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation of "Hugo" on Blu-ray, delivered via DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1, is both a technical marvel and a delightful immersive experience. Paramount's impeccable transfer utilizes all channels to create a seamless soundstage that vividly transports audiences to a Parisian train station teeming with life. The precise clicking and grinding of gears, reminiscent of clockwork, float effortlessly around the listener, enhancing the immersive quality of the film. Dialogue is immaculately balanced, offering clear and nuanced delivery even amidst diverse accent usage, ensuring every spoken word is distinctly audible. The orchestral score by Howard Shore receives an equally meticulous treatment, enveloping the viewers in a rich, emotionally resonant atmosphere.
Ambient effects are masterfully defined, from the faint echoes of footsteps on steel steps to the intricate mechanical noises that populate Hugo's world. The sound of Maximillian's paws on metal, along with the meticulously placed conversational babble and subtle atmospheric noises, contributes to a deeply involving auditory backdrop. Even during busier scenes, such as train maneuvers or crash sequences, the LFE channels render impactful bass frequencies that heighten the sensory impact without overwhelming the overall mix. The medley of these auditory components achieves a sense of realism so profound that it almost blurs the line between fiction and reality.
Moreover, the audio mix showcases a breathtaking spatial awareness that enhances the film's dynamic sequences. Particularly commendable is the accurate placement and movement of sound elements within the surround channels, enabling a fully enveloping experience. For instance, woodwinds and accordions blend seamlessly with orchestral swells, creating a lush soundscape. Even in moments devoid of explosive action, the subtle acoustic details shine through brilliantly. This DTS-HD MA 7.1 track exemplifies reference-quality audio engineering, making "Hugo" not just a visual delight but an auditory masterpiece as well.
Extras: 54
The Blu-ray extras for "Hugo" offer a substantial, though somewhat limited, insight into the film's production and historical references. "Shoot the Moon: The Making of Hugo" provides a solid overview of the adaptation process, from book to screen, including notable contributions by Martin Scorsese and an exploration of the 3D technology utilized. "The Cinemagician, Georges Méliès" delves into the life and legacy of the influential filmmaker, offering context for his pivotal role in the movie. "The Mechanical Man at the Heart of Hugo" educates viewers on the history of automata and their design in the film. The brief "Big Effects, Small Scale" focuses on special effects for the train crash scene. Lastly, Sacha Baron Cohen adds a touch of humor with "Role of a Lifetime," a spoof interview. Despite the lack of commentary or more extensive features, these extras offer enjoyable insights.
Extras included in this disc:
Shoot the Moon: The Making of Hugo: Overview of book adaptation, casting, 3D technology, set design.
The Cinemagician, Georges Méliès: Delve into Méliès' life, style, and influence.
The Mechanical Man at the Heart of Hugo: History and design of automata.
Big Effects, Small Scale: Brief on special effects for train crash scene.
Sacha Baron Cohen: Role of a Lifetime: Humorous spoof interview.
Movie: 88
Martin Scorsese's "Hugo," based on Brian Selznick's acclaimed book "The Invention of Hugo Cabret," represents a visually resplendent tribute to the history and magic of cinema. The narrative follows young Hugo Cabret (Asa Butterfield), an orphan living in a Paris train station in 1931, whose life intertwines with the enigma of a mechanical automaton and the forgotten past of filmmaker Georges Méliès (Ben Kingsley). Scorsese seamlessly integrates meticulously crafted production design, set decoration, and visual effects, creating a multi-layered tapestry of early 20th-century Paris that's equal parts tangible history and magical realism. The film’s atmosphere is further enriched by Howard Shore’s enchanting score, which underpins both the boy’s poignant journey and the overarching homage to cinematic pioneers.
Despite its breathtaking aesthetic accomplishments and heartfelt nods to the roots of moviemaking, "Hugo" has received mixed opinions regarding its storytelling prowess. Some argue that the film’s narrative structure lacks emotional depth and coherence, rendering it an exercise in style over substance. Nevertheless, Scorsese’s direction—complemented by Robert Richardson’s Oscar-winning cinematography—delivers visually captivating sequences that blend digital and practical elements almost imperceptibly. This technological ingenuity, coupled with the period-authentic set pieces, crafts a wholly immersive experience that marvels both connoisseurs of film art and casual viewers.
"Hugo" ultimately serves as a testament to Scorsese's passion for film preservation and storytelling. It embodies themes of purpose, discovery, and resilience while championing the emotive power of cinema. The movie’s intricate interplay of visuals and narrative constructs an engaging experience even if its emotional resonance occasionally falls short. As a Blu-ray release, "Hugo" stands out for its stellar image quality and evocative visual aesthetics, securing its place as an essential addition to any cinephile’s collection, despite divergent views on its narrative execution.
Total: 78
Martin Scorsese's "Hugo" is an extraordinary cinematic achievement that pays homage to the art of filmmaking. From beginning to end, "Hugo" captivates audiences with its intricate storytelling, rich authenticity, and flawless execution. The film's technical aspects, from set design to visual effects, are meticulously crafted, presenting a heartfelt narrative that is both timeless and engaging. Hugo's story of love, discovery, and dreams resonates deeply, serving as a reminder of the magic movies can create. The performances, particularly that of Asa Butterfield, demonstrate remarkable depth and sincerity, further elevating this film to a classic status.
Paramount's Blu-ray release of "Hugo" shines brightly with an outstanding technical presentation. The video transfer captures the film’s vibrant and lush visual style with stunning clarity, replicating the theatrical experience impeccably. Additionally, the audio mix immerses the audience into the film’s ambiance seamlessly. Though the supplemental features may leave some craving more, they offer a commendable glimpse into the creation of the film. A 20-minute making-of documentary and several featurettes on key aspects such as George Melies and special effects provide valuable insight into Scorsese's visionary process.
In conclusion, "Hugo" on Blu-ray is a triumph in home entertainment. Despite fewer extras than some might prefer, the superior quality of the film and its dazzling technical presentation make this Blu-ray an essential addition to any collection. Hugo is required viewing for all cinema lovers, serving both as a tribute to filmmaking’s origins and a source of inspiration for dreamers of all ages. Without reservation, "Hugo" earns our highest recommendation.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 100
About the only detrimental effect that I noticed was some slight shimmering on tight patterns – costumes, grill-work etc – but this is not enough to detract from a transfer that is, to all intents and...
Audio: 90
Scorsese has not made this a film full of explosions, gunfire or high-velocity impacts, yet this is as dynamic, exhilarating and richly evocative a mix as you could wish for, and one that makes such amazingly...
Extras: 50
We get to learn a bit more about how the film’s automaton was crafted in The Mechanical Man at the Heart of Hugo, but this is better at establishing the history of these splendid, but eerie contraptions....
Movie: 60
You know, cinema has the capacity to make children of us all – and I would love that line to be an argument that I could proffer in the film’s defence – but Hugo has such a cold lack of character and a...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Not only are facial texture marvelous and clothing textures faultless, but the transfer's ability to capture and display the finest little nuances of worn gears, rusted metal, scuffed floors, and rough...
Audio: 100
Dialogue is steady and accurate as it plays from the center channel, with a few playful moments of expert reverberation capturing the size and scope of the station....
Extras: 50
Shoot the Moon (The Making of Hugo) (1080p, 19:48): A solid overview piece that features cast and crew -- including Author Brian Selznick -- discussing the process of adapting the book to screen, the work...
Movie: 100
That's a nod to the quality of effects work but also to Scorsese's quality of storytelling; he absorbs his audience not just into the movie, but into an entirely different world where authenticity and...
Total: 90
Here's hoping Hugo is awarded the Best Picture Oscar; after all, how could a movie about the beauty of movies, a picture that so lovingly celebrates the medium, be denied?...
The Digital Bits review by Barrie MaxwellRead review here
Video: 100
Audio: 100
On the audio side, Paramount offers up a 7.1 DTS HD Master audio track that vies with the video excellence throughout, and generally accomplishes what a good Blu-ray lossless mix should - reproduce faithfully...
Extras: 85
Movie: 100
The story about a young boy named Hugo who lives behind the scenes in a Paris railway station where he tends the station's clocks and also tries to solve the puzzle of a clockwork automaton that his father...
Total: 96
The supplement package may well leave you wanting more given how delightful is the film, but it does include a reasonably good 20-minute making-of documentary and four shorter featurettes on the real-life...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The color palette is drenched in frosty sepia-like colors and textures that accentuate the browns, golds, bronzes, but don’t over-saturate the flesh and general color palette....
Audio: 100
Music, chatter, clocks, gears, and every other imaginable sound come through with such clarity that I had to make sure my watch was working properly....
Extras: 40
All we get is several featurettes on the making-of aspects of the film along with a really funny featurette featuring Sacha Baron Cohen talking about the “role of a lifetime.”...
Movie: 100
Hugo, being the layered feast of sights and sounds that it is, also has a layered enough storyline which never drags, but sets up different plotlines here and there that resolve themselves as the film...
Total: 100
Usually, the low score of the extras would have dropped the overall rating down a bit, but I believe in the final product so much that I will cheat on the final grade....
Director: Martin Scorsese
Actors: Asa Butterfield, Chloë Grace Moretz, Christopher Lee
PlotIn 1930s Paris, an orphan boy named Hugo lives within the walls of a bustling train station, maintaining the clocks and keeping his presence hidden from the station inspector. Prior to his father's death, Hugo and his father had been restoring an automaton, a mechanical man designed to write with a pen. The key to its function, a heart-shaped lock, remains elusive to Hugo. Driven by the belief that the automaton contains a message from his late father, Hugo is determined to fix it. He steals mechanical parts from the station's toy booth, run by the grumpy toy merchant Georges, to aid in the repair of the automaton.
One day, Hugo is caught stealing by Georges, who confiscates Hugo's notebook containing the automaton's blueprints. The threat of losing the notebook and the automaton's secret devastates Hugo, but a chance encounter with Isabelle, Georges' goddaughter, provides hope. She is intrigued by Hugo's project and decides to help him. The two form an unlikely friendship as they embark on a quest to solve the mystery of the automaton. Sharing a love for literature and adventure, they get swept up in an adventure that takes them through the hidden wonders of the train station and the dusty memories of the past. Together, they dive deep into the world of early cinema, where they uncover the forgotten treasures of a bygone era and the beauty of the dreams encapsulated within it.
Writers: John Logan, Brian Selznick
Release Date: 23 Nov 2011
Runtime: 126 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, United Kingdom, France
Language: English