Whiplash Blu-ray Review
Score: 70
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Sony's Blu-ray of 'Whiplash' delivers stunning performances, exceptional video and audio quality, and compelling extras, making it a top release of 2015.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
`Whiplash' on Blu-ray delivers a high-end 1080p transfer with impressive clarity, robust facial textures, and tangible detail, albeit with a warm, occasionally orange hue on skin tones. Highlights include strong blacks, minimal noise, and standout moments capturing beads of sweat and blood in vivid detail.
Audio: 75
Whiplash's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix delivers stellar clarity, with lifelike precision in music sequences and transparent dialogue rendering. The soundstage is well-balanced, offering remarkable instrument separation and ambient details, though minor ambient and surround variations could enhance it further.
Extra: 47
Whiplash's Blu-ray extras include an engaging commentary by Chazelle and Simmons touching on casting, filming, and Chazelle's drumming background; a 42-minute documentary with professional drummers; the original short film with optional commentary; a brief yet impactful deleted scene; and an insightful Q&A from TIFF.
Movie: 90
Whiplash electrifies with its unyielding tension and psychological intensity, driven by Damien Chazelle’s precise direction, J.K. Simmons’ ferocious performance, and Miles Teller’s compelling portrayal. The Blu-ray’s 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video and DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 thoroughly enhance the film’s visceral impact.
Video: 73
"Whiplash" arrives on Blu-ray with an impressive 1080p, 2.40:1-framed transfer that beautifully captures the film's digital photography. The image often appears clean with a light glossiness, maintaining a natural rather than artificial look. Details are thoroughly impressive; facial textures, including scars and lines, are robust. The meticulous attention to detail is evident in the textured sheet music, instrument surfaces, and even close-ups of band-aids, resulting in lifelike textures. Image clarity is exceptional, capturing minute details such as beads of sweat and drops of blood off the drums. Colors are generally fine, with a predominant warm, orange/yellow push affecting skin tones. Lighter daytime shots, however, offer a more stabilized and natural color array. Black levels are mostly strong but exhibit slight paleness in some scenes, with minor noise and banding evident occasionally.
Digitally captured in HD, "Whiplash" benefits from Sony's superb 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer that enhances the film’s immersive experience. Contrast and clarity are exceptionally rendered, although some low-lit scenes appear slightly hazy, which is expected. The film’s visual style employs rich blacks to underscore the internal struggles of its characters, juxtaposed with bright exteriors. Despite a generally muted color palette, critical moments are punctuated by vivid splashes of red. The transfer’s sharp detail levels allow for a deep appreciation of the gleaming brass instruments and the texture of drum surfaces, vividly presenting Andrew's injuries and subtle emotional cues in close-ups. Although flesh tones tend to adopt an orange hue due to Chazelle’s warm lighting during practice scenes, white tones are strong with minimal noise. This transfer effectively replicates the theater experience, nearly flawless in its execution.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio presentation of "Whiplash" delivers a stellar auditory experience vital for a dialogue-driven and musically entrenched film. Dialogue clarity is paramount, and this mix excels in rendering voices and instrumentation with transparent realism and lucid texture. The front soundstage effectively holds sway while the surround mix is adeptly used to extend the acoustic environment portrayed onscreen, delivering a subtly engaging and well-balanced mixture of background sounds and musical enhancement. Although sub bass frequencies are minimal, the subwoofer provides ample low bass emphasis where suitable.
The soundtrack opens with a meticulously defined drum cadence that crescendos in a center-focused alignment, setting the stage for the exceptional audio fidelity. Every rehearsal and performance sequence explodes with lifelike precision, achieving remarkable clarity and definition across the entire band. Instrument details stand out individually yet cohesively integrate to form a robust and satisfyingly collective sonic experience. Dialogue is evenly and clearly rendered from the center channel, ensuring an immersive auditory experience.
The sound design, honored with the Best Sound Mixing Academy Award, is bursting with organic purity. Each instrument—from striking drums and screaming brass to silky piano and smoky bass—merges to create an enveloping soundscape. Marvelous nuances are plentiful, capturing details such as instrument case claps, drumstick clicks, and sheet music shuffling with superb stereo separation. However, a tad more surround activity during performance sequences could enhance the experience. Additionally, more acoustic variation between rehearsal and concert settings would be welcome. Despite these minor quibbles, the track remains almost perfect and deeply satisfying for even the most discerning audiophile.
Extras: 47
The Blu Ray extras for "Whiplash" offer a robust and engaging mix of content, providing a deep dive into the film's production and creative processes. The audio commentary by Damien Chazelle and J.K. Simmons combines technical insights with light-hearted banter, although it may lean more on the humorous than the analytical side for some viewers. The "Timekeepers" documentary is a standout, presenting in-depth interviews with professional drummers discussing their careers and influences. The original short film with optional commentary provides fascinating context for how "Whiplash" evolved into a feature-length project. Additionally, the deleted scene “Fletcher at Home” is compact yet impactful, elucidating how subtle changes can shift the film's tone. Lastly, a brief yet informative Q&A from the Toronto International Film Festival rounds out the extras, allowing insight into the actors' and director's experiences during production.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: Engaging insights from Damien Chazelle and J.K. Simmons.
An Evening at the Toronto International Film Festival: Q&A session on film production.
Timekeepers: A documentary featuring professional drummers.
Whiplash Original Short Film: The original short with optional commentary.
Deleted Scene (Fletcher at Home): A significant deleted scene with commentary.
Theatrical Trailer: Preview of the film.
Digital HD Copy: Voucher for a digital version of "Whiplash".
Movie: 90
"Whiplash," an extraordinary film by Writer/Director Damien Chazelle, delves deeply into the tumultuous relationship between an ambitious jazz drummer and his ruthless instructor. Andrew Neyman (Miles Teller), a driven first-year student at the elite Shaffer Conservatory of Music, is hell-bent on achieving legendary status in the world of jazz drumming. His mentor, Terence Fletcher (J.K. Simmons), is a fiercely demanding teacher known for his unorthodox and brutal methods. As Andrew grapples with his obsession for perfection, the film explores the razor-thin line between rigorous instruction and outright emotional and physical torment. The narrative captures their intense back-and-forth as Fletcher goads Andrew far beyond his breaking points, creating a study of unyielding determination against relentless vitriol.
The movie is compared aptly to "Full Metal Jacket," showcasing a ballet of determination meeting fierce opposition. Chazelle draws from his own experiences, presenting a mesmerizing script that is both richly detailed and emotionally wrenching. The film pulses with a rhythm akin to a jazz riff, largely due to Tom Cross' Oscar-winning editing, which keeps viewers engrossed through its concise yet impactful storytelling. Miles Teller delivers a compelling performance as Andrew, embodying his character’s inner drive and turmoil with emotionally raw intensity. However, it is J.K. Simmons' portrayal of Fletcher that stands out—his character oscillates between sheer malevolence and an enigmatic depth, keeping audiences questioning his true intentions until the very end.
"Whiplash" challenges the audience to reflect on the cost of excellence and the ethical boundaries in the pursuit of greatness. Despite a few minor plot discrepancies, the film’s execution is nearly flawless. It underscores a profound message about dedication and societal expectations, all while pushing its characters—and viewers—to their limits. This duality of outward drama and inward exploration of the human condition makes "Whiplash" an indisputably significant work in contemporary cinema.
Total: 70
"Whiplash" is a remarkably intricate film that defies initial impressions of a straightforward student-teacher drama. Directed by Damien Chazelle, the movie explores deep and dark layers of human obsession and the extremes of teaching methodologies. Central to this exploration are two of the year's most compelling performances, with J.K. Simmons delivering an Oscar-winning portrayal of a fearsome bandleader and Miles Teller excelling as the driven, nearly obsessive young drummer. Their dynamic provides a riveting, raw, and often brutal look at the pursuit of artistic excellence.
Sony's Blu-ray release of "Whiplash" is an exceptional presentation that does justice to the film’s high-caliber production values. The Blu-ray offers an excellent video transfer that captures the film's cinematic aesthetics with pristine clarity and detail. The audio is near-reference quality, providing an immersive experience that enhances the film's intense musical sequences and emotional beats. Additionally, the disc includes a wealth of supplementary content, offering deeper insight into the filmmaking process and further appreciation for this critically acclaimed work.
In conclusion, "Whiplash" on Blu-ray is a must-have for enthusiasts and collectors. Its phenomenal picture and sound quality, coupled with enriching extras, make it one of the standout releases of early 2015. The film itself is a complex, thought-provoking masterpiece that is guaranteed to leave a lasting impact. This high-definition release earns our highest recommendation.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The digital photography occasionally takes on a lightly glossy appearance, but for the most part it's only clean rather than artificial....
Audio: 100
Music is obviously key to the film and the soundtrack explodes with incredible lifelike precision in every rehearsal and performance, even if it's in short bursts interrupted by Fletcher's displeasure...
Extras: 60
Audio Commentary: Actor J.K. Simmons and Writer/Director Damien Chazelle provide a quality track in which Chazelle plays the serious side and Simmons the comic relief....
Movie: 100
Miles Teller is terrific as Andrew, finding an inner obsession and evolving from a state of unflinching determination to multiple breaking points and beyond in a performance that's not only physically...
Total: 90
But the movie absolutely shines as a dark and wonderfully complex examination of the human condition, punctuated by two of the most outstanding performances of the year, including an Oscar-nominated effort...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Sharp detail levels allow us to drink in the purity of the gleaming brass, feel the texture of the drum surfaces, and appreciate Andrew's painful war wounds, and close-ups are equally fine, highlighting...
Audio: 80
Sure, the drums take center stage - and the variance of tone between them and the cymbals is striking - but the tight strains of screaming brass, silky tickling of the piano keys during Fletcher’s club...
Extras: 20
“An Evening at the Toronto International Film Festival with Miles Teller, J.K. Simmons. and Damien Chazelle” (HD, 8 minutes) - This brief excerpt from a Q&A session following a screening of the film allows...
Movie: 80
Yet his immense talent, dedication, and slightly superior attitude don’t impress his peers, all of whom possess the eye of the tiger and brandish a formidable fierceness, arrogance, and deep competitive...
Total: 80
Much has been written about J.K. Simmons' blistering Oscar-winning performance as a bullying bandleader who strikes terror in his musicians' hearts and minds, but Miles Teller is equally good, fashioning...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Audio: 86
Voices and instrumentation are reproduced with transparent realism and lucid texture that appropriately holds sway over the front soundstage....
Extras: 70
An evening at the Toronto International Film Festival with Miles Teller, J.K. simmons and Damien Chazelle – 7 minutes (HD) *Exclusive* Timekeepers – 42 minute documentary (HD) *Exclusive* “Whiplash” Original...
Movie: 100
Andrew Neyman is an ambitious young jazz drummer, single-minded in his pursuit to rise to the top of his elite east coast music conservatory....
Total: 86
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" and In-Ceiling series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers...
Director: Damien Chazelle
Actors: Miles Teller, J.K. Simmons, Melissa Benoist
PlotAn ambitious young jazz drummer, enrolled in a prestigious music conservatory, yearns to achieve greatness and leave his mark on the world of music. He lands a spot in the school's top jazz ensemble, but soon discovers the cutthroat world that awaits him. The band is led by a fearsome and relentless instructor, known for his ruthless teaching methods and unyielding demand for perfection. The instructor pushes his students to their limits, blurring the line between mentorship and tyranny, all in pursuit of producing the best musicians possible.
As rehearsals intensify, the young drummer struggles to meet the exceedingly high standards set by his instructor, leading to a potent mix of fear, ambition, and desperation. He practices incessantly, his life consumed by his drive to succeed and his fear of failure. This obsession strains his relationships and takes a toll on his physical and mental health. Caught in a cycle of grueling practice and harsh criticism, the young man's determination is constantly tested, forcing him to confront his limits and decide how much he's willing to sacrifice for his art.
Writers: Damien Chazelle
Release Date: 15 Oct 2014
Runtime: 106 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English