The Best Man Holiday Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Best Man Holiday is a worthy sequel with exemplary video and audio presentations, engaging for fans of the original and those seeking a heartfelt dramedy.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The Best Man Holiday boasts a splendid Blu-ray image with exemplary sharpness, clarity, and detail throughout. The 1080p transfer in 2.40:1 aspect ratio shines with deeply saturated colors, natural skin tones, and dynamic contrast. Black levels are respectable, and no visible compression issues were detected.
Audio: 67
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio mix excels with clear dialogue, rich tonal variation, and dynamic music tracks, enhancing both scenes of quiet conversation and more action-packed moments, like the dance routine and fights. The mix delivers excellent clarity without any distortions, effectively utilizing surround sound.
Extra: 57
Featuring lively commentary from Malcolm D. Lee, an amusing gag reel, a behind-the-scenes featurette with cast anecdotes, and extensive deleted scenes, the Blu-ray extras for 'The Best Man Holiday' enhance the viewing experience with insider insights and engaging content, maintaining a professional and entertaining tone.
Movie: 67
"The Best Man Holiday" expertly balances laughter and heartache, leveraging the chemistry of its ensemble cast from the original film. Director Malcolm D. Lee successfully updates and deepens the characters' narratives, presenting a blend of comedic, dramatic, and poignant moments with a holiday backdrop, ensuring an engaging sequel experience.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray video presentation of "The Best Man Holiday" stands out as a high-quality transfer that aligns perfectly with the film's aesthetic. The 1080p HD transfer in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio brings the cinematographic prowess of Greg Gardiner to life, showing exemplary sharpness, clarity, and detail throughout. Colors are deeply saturated with eye-pleasing vitality, giving a vibrant and meticulous portrayal of skin textures, costumes, and decor. Notable are scenes shot inside the lavish mansion, which are rich in detail—every prop and texture is distinguishably visible. The use of deep, inky blacks enhances low-light and shadow details without any loss of discernable intricacies.
Technical aspects have been excellently managed with an average bitrate of 31.99 Mbps ensuring a smooth compression devoid of any artifacts. The dynamic contrast, although not overpowering, is adeptly handled, providing a pleasing visual consistency that caters well to the holiday-themed color palette, notably showcasing vivid greens, reds, and blues. The clarity in closely observed details such as makeup blemishes, wrinkles, and individual hairs on the actors' faces is outstanding, contributing to an overall impressive visual experience.
The film's stadium sequences for Lance Sullivan's big game, along with interactions in various locations, are equally finely detailed. This precise care ensures that elements like furrows on characters' skin or the festive atmospheres are distinctly captured. The video quality excels without any noticeable compression issues, offering an immersive viewing that thoroughly supports the narrative with its visual excellence. This makes "The Best Man Holiday" Blu-ray a commendable video presentation and a pleasure to watch.
Audio: 67
The Blu-ray release of "The Best Man Holiday" features a robust DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio track that proficiently renders the source elements with exceptional clarity and dynamic punch. Dialogue is delivered with impressive richness and crystal-clear precision, ensuring that every line is easily understood without any distracting pop, crack, or hiss. The front channel imaging exhibits excellent tonal variation while the surround channels are utilized selectively but effectively, adding depth and immersive ambience particularly aligned with the music and more action-oriented scenes.
As in "The Best Man," music remains a focal point of the audio mix. The film's celebrated soundtrack, which includes a blend of new songs and classic covers such as Ray Charles's rendition of "Santa Claus Is Coming to Town" and Nat King Cole's "The Christmas Song," is reproduced with warm, rich tonality and wide dynamic range. These musical moments, along with the film’s score composed by Stanley Clarke, foreground the audio experience, making such sequences notably vibrant. Notable scenes like the Shelby/Candace altercation and the Julian and Q mock slugfest in the SUV highlight the mix’s capability to handle more elaborate effects while maintaining balance.
Overall, while the mix isn't overly aggressive, it provides an engaging surround sound experience befitting the thematic tone of the film. The audio design predominantly focuses on music and dialogue, ensuring an enjoyable and immersive auditory environment that complements the narrative. The audio presentation of "The Best Man Holiday" stands out for its clarity, dynamic range, and musical vibrancy, making it an exemplary audio companion to the visual elements of this heartwarming film.
Extras: 57
The Blu-ray extras for "The Best Man Holiday" are extensive and well-presented. The highlights include a lively and insightful commentary by writer/director/producer Malcolm D. Lee, who discusses alternate takes, abandoned plot lines, and detailed production anecdotes. The gag reel is a delightful compilation of outtakes showcasing the cast's camaraderie. Additionally, the 'Holiday Reunion' featurette offers an engaging behind-the-scenes look with interviews and footage from the film's development process, particularly the memorable dinner where Lee pitched the sequel to the original cast. Moreover, the inclusion of exclusive content such as deleted scenes, an alternate ending, and a focused segment on filming a pivotal scene adds significant value for fans.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary with Writer/Director/Producer Malcolm D. Lee: Lively and insightful production anecdotes.
- Gag Reel: Collection of humorous outtakes.
- Holiday Reunion: The Making of The Best Man Holiday: Behind-the-scenes featurette.
- Alternate Ending with Optional Commentary: Original ending with commentary.
- Deleted/Extended Scenes with Optional Commentary: Various scenes not included in the final cut.
- Smack Talk: Filming the Girl Fight Scene: Insight into creating a key scene.
- Bonus DVD: Additional content.
- Ultraviolet Digital Copy: Digital version for convenience.
Movie: 67
"The Best Man Holiday" is a sensitive and heartwarming sequel that revisits beloved characters from Malcolm D. Lee’s 1999 hit, "The Best Man." Set fifteen years later, the film balances humor and drama, capturing the nuances of matured relationships and life’s unpredictable challenges. The plot centers around a Christmas reunion orchestrated by Mia and Lance Sullivan, whose inviting Westchester mansion becomes the backdrop for the reunion. This setting echoes the authenticity and evolution of the characters, contrasting their youthful exuberance with seasoned accomplishments and setbacks.
Malcolm D. Lee expertly rekindles the chemistry among the original cast members, delivering a narrative enriched by their life experiences. Each character brings a unique dynamic to the table: Lance (Morris Chestnut) is an NFL superstar while his wife Mia (Monica Calhoun) faces personal turmoil. Harper (Taye Diggs) and Robin (Sanaa Lathan) navigate lingering tensions from past betrayals, complicated further by Robin's late pregnancy. Jordan (Nia Long), still the successful TV producer, introduces her new white boyfriend Brian (Eddie Cibrian), subtly exploring themes of racial and cultural integration.
The movie doesn't shy away from the complexities of adult life; Julian (Harold Perrineau) and Candace (Regina King) contend with threats to their charter school due to a scandal from Candace’s past. Meanwhile, Quentin (Terrence Howard) remains the group's comic relief with his wisecracks and flashy demeanor, providing levity amidst the tension. Perhaps the most striking aspect is how Lee juxtaposes comedic elements with dramatic realities, crafting a believable ensemble piece that speaks to both continuity and growth. Despite occasional dips into cheesiness and its religious undertones, "The Best Man Holiday" succeeds as an engaging holiday film with substantial heart, offering a satisfying blend of laughter, love, and life's unplanned surprises.
Total: 67
"The Best Man Holiday" Blu-ray release is a commendable continuation of the beloved original, "The Best Man." For those familiar with the first film, this sequel provides a seamless transition that captures the cherished dynamics and narratives of its characters. The movie benefits from stunning visual and audio quality, which is immensely noteworthy given its predecessor’s lackluster presentation. Universal has rectified previous shortcomings by delivering an exemplary image that highlights fine details and colors with precision, along with an array of engaging supplements that will satisfy both casual viewers and dedicated fans.
The film itself stands strong as a dramedy, combining heartwarming moments with comedic elements effectively. Seeing the original actors reprise their roles after fifteen years adds depth and a nostalgic charm to the viewing experience. Those passionate about the first movie will find much to appreciate as the long-standing character relationships are explored further, providing emotional gravitas and continuity. Moreover, the Blu-ray’s technical execution – particularly audio fidelity – ensures that dialogue remains crisp and the soundscape enriches the film's emotional beats.
In conclusion, "The Best Man Holiday" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for fans of the original film as well as newcomers seeking an entertaining dramedy. With stellar video and audio performance, coupled with rich supplementary content, this release serves as an excellent addition to any collection and sets a high bar for potential future installments.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
Sharpness, clarity and detail are exemplary throughout, and because so much of the action takes place inside a Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous-type mansion that has been decked out for the holidays,...
Audio: 80
The film spawned a successful album composed of a mix of new songs and covers of traditional Christmas songs, and the film's soundtrack has even more, including Ray Charles's cover of "Santa Claus Is Coming...
Extras: 70
Holiday Special: The Making of The Best Man Holiday (1080p; 1.78:1; 12:14): The best part of this EPK is the cast's recollections of the dinner at which they gathered with Lee twelve years after the first...
Movie: 80
After fifteen years of life experience, the characters from The Best Man could no longer be young people just out of college and starting their careers (or, in the case of Terence Howard's "Q", doing everything...
Total: 80
If you liked Best 1, the sequel is an appropriate and engaging continuation of its multiple stories....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Most of the film takes place in a large mansion, but the depth is surprisingly good as we can make out every prop and texture very well....
Audio: 80
The dynamic range is fairly wide with some scenes that feature some bigger sound effects, such as the bigger dance routine, and a couple of fights....
Extras: 40
This is a standard promo kit that features some interviews and footage from the film on how they made the movie....
Movie: 60
It's good to see that Harper and Robin Stewart (Taye Diggs and Sanna Lathan) are married and still together, even though there seems to be a little bit of bad blood between Lance and Harper from the first...
Total: 60
For fans of the original film and those looking for a decent dramedy, you might want to check this one out....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Contrast is dynamic without being overpowering and blacks are respectable in depth with discernible detail visible in low lighting and shadows....
Audio: 84
The lossless audio presentation is solid and renders the source elements with excellent clarity and punchy dynamics....
Extras: 70
Filming the girl fight scene – 4 minutes (HD) Gag reel – 5 minutes (HD) Holiday reunion: The making of The best man holiday – 12 minute featurette Feature commentary with writer/director/producer Malcom...
Movie: 70
Share the laughter, love, and surprises as Harper (Taye Diggs), Lance (Morris Chestnut), Quentin (Terrence Howard), Jordan (Nia Long), Robyn (Sanaa Lathan), Mia (Monica Calhoun), Murch (Harold Perrineau),...
Total: 79
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Director: Malcolm D. Lee
Actors: Monica Calhoun, Morris Chestnut, Melissa De Sousa
PlotA group of college friends reunite over the Christmas holidays after 15 years to celebrate and catch up on each other's lives. Among them are Harper, a struggling writer facing pressure to meet deadlines and provide for his family, and Lance, a star football player nearing retirement. Harper's wife, Robyn, is pregnant with their first child, adding stress to their relationship. Harper's latest novel creates tension among the group as it reveals secrets and uncovers lingering issues. Despite their past conflicts, the close-knit group comes together with hopes of rekindling their old friendships.
As they share the festive season, old rivalries and romances resurface, forcing each character to confront unresolved issues. The holiday gathering becomes a catalyst for forgiveness, healing, and renewed focus on what truly matters. Throughout their stay, the friends navigate through personal challenges, rediscovering their bonds and realizing the importance of love and support. Emotions run high as they are pushed to face the consequences of their past actions and decisions.
Writers: Malcolm D. Lee
Release Date: 15 Nov 2013
Runtime: 123 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English