Khartoum Blu-ray Review
Eureka Classics
Score: 64
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Eureka's Blu-ray of 'Khartoum' offers visually stunning production and solid audio, though the film's grand visuals mask some flaws, making it a worthy watch, especially on sale.
Disc Release Date
Video: 70
Eureka's Blu-ray release of 'Khartoum' offers a 1080p/AVC-encoded presentation in the original 2.76:1 aspect ratio, showcasing its Ultra Panavision 70 origins with impressive detail and expansive vistas. However, the older remaster reveals limitations such as fluctuating color registration and digital sharpening, necessitating a future serious restoration.
Audio: 70
The Blu-ray release of 'Khartoum' features a robust English LPCM 2.0 audio track that captures the epic desert clashes with impressive clarity and dynamic balance, despite the absence of the original 6-channel sound design.
Extra: 46
Eureka's Blu Ray of 'Khartoum' impresses with valuable extras: a revealing Audio Commentary from film historians, an insightful interview with critic Sheldon Hall, a nostalgic vintage trailer, and a collector's booklet with a new essay by Phil Hoad and rare archival images.
Movie: 56
Khartoum's stunning Ultra Panavision 70mm cinematography is a visual marvel, capturing breathtaking desert vistas and epic battles, though it struggles with sluggish pacing and dated cultural portrayals. The Blu-ray includes insightful extras like a new video interview and archival commentary, making it an appealing package for classic film enthusiasts.
Video: 70
Eureka Entertainment's Region B-locked Blu-ray of "Khartoum" features a 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation in the original 2.76:1 widescreen aspect ratio. Shot on Ultra Panavision 70, the film's expansive, panoramic view showcases incredible depth and broad scope, fully utilizing the 70mm format's unique capabilities. The transfer delivers excellent detail, with Crisp visuals that encapsulate the breadth of scenes, from Charlton Heston's close-ups to distant background actions. However, a pervasive film grain might be noticeable, particularly in night sequences, suggesting possible day-for-night cinematography. Though some digital sharpening adds a slight ring to up-close characters, overall visuals remain compelling, justifying home viewing.
The Blu-ray is sourced from an older remaster also used by Twilight Time in a previous U.S. release, and while it offers strong clarity and pleasing focus in areas, it also reveals certain limitations typical of its age. Notably, the depth and delineation are not optimal, leading to background flatness and intermittent halo effects due to fluctuating color registration. Shadow definition is inconsistent, with nuanced details becoming difficult to discern. Image stability is solid, and while no large cuts or debris are present, small white flecks and dirt spots occasionally appear. The overall visuals suggest that a more thorough restoration would elevate the film to the visual standard it warrants.
This Blu-ray release captures "Khartoum's" grand vistas effectively despite its age-related constraints. It stands as a striking example of large-format filmmaking from the era but would benefit from a modern, extensive restoration similar to that of "Ben-Hur" to realize its full potential. Note the Region B restriction—ensure your player compatibility before purchase.
Audio: 70
The audio presentation of the "Khartoum" Blu-ray release is intriguingly composed, as it derives from a 70mm source originally equipped with six channels of sound design. However, this UK Blu-ray release offers only a lossless Linear PCM 2.0 track. Despite this downgrade, the LPCM audio performs admirably by capturing the raw essence of the movie's epic tone. The desert clashes are delivered with exceptional clarity and power, characterized by booming cannon fire and dynamic explosions that resonate impressively for the era. Dialogue remains consistently clear, allowing the key cast performances to be distinctly heard over the rich, rousing score that underscores the film.
While the deviation from the original 6-channel audio might disappoint audiophiles searching for an encompassing sound experience, the meticulous effort in remastering has ensured that the LPCM 2.0 track is devoid of any detectable flaws. The absence of balance and dynamic issues attests to the successful elimination of inherited damage, making this track both clean and robust. Optional English SDH subtitles are available and thoughtfully positioned within the image frame for convenience. Ultimately, while purists might lament the lack of a more elaborate soundtrack present in certain theatrical projections, this LPCM 2.0 track stands strong, effectively supporting the visual grandeur and narrative depth of "Khartoum".
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray release of "Khartoum" offers a well-curated selection of extras that provide both historical context and in-depth analysis of the film. The package excels with an engaging audio commentary featuring renowned film historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman. Additionally, an insightful interview with critic Sheldon Hall delves into the film's origins, casting decisions, director Basil Dearden’s involvement, and the socio-political backdrop against which the film was created. The supplementary vintage trailer and a collector's booklet, which includes a new essay by Phil Hoad and rare archival imagery, further enrich this comprehensive set, making it a valuable addition for enthusiasts and collectors alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: With film historians Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman.
- Interview with Sheldon Hall: Critic Sheldon Hall discusses the film's origins and themes.
- Trailer: A vintage trailer for "Khartoum".
- Booklet: Features a new essay by Phil Hoad and rare archival imagery.
Movie: 56
Basil Dearden's 1966 historical epic, Khartoum, showcases a clash of cultures and towering performances from Charlton Heston and Laurence Olivier. Shot in Ultra Panavision 70mm, the film is visually spectacular, effectively capturing the grandeur of desert vistas with stunning panoramic shots. This technique had not seen use for half a century until Tarantino revived it for The Hateful Eight. However, the screenplay, while awarded an Academy Award, depends largely on the compelling tension between Heston's and Olivier's characters. Dearden's direction manages to scale the expansive narrative but often falters in integrating this grandeur with intimate storytelling.
In the modern viewing context, Khartoum faces scrutiny for its dated portrayal of complex cultural dynamics. Olivier's performance as Mahdi, involving blackface and a problematic accent, stands out as particularly offensive by today's standards, while Heston's role as the 'white savior' figure similarly feels antiquated. Aside from these outdated elements, the narrative lacks momentum with its painstakingly slow plotting and an overemphasis on hitting critical historical setpieces. Despite the abundant armed conflicts and politically charged machinations, many scenes come across as dry and are somewhat disconnected from contemporary sensibilities regarding character development and agency.
Despite these narrative and cultural drawbacks, Khartoum remains a cinematic marvel due to its exceptional cinematography. The Ultra Panavision 70mm technology delivers awe-inspiring imagery that can leave viewers breathless. The extensive use of extras and majestic nighttime desert scenes adds to its visual allure, making it clear why such wide-capture techniques are revered. This sumptuous visual experience, though not enough to classify Khartoum as a timeless classic, contributes significantly to its appeal and raises questions about the scant adoption of this format in subsequent decades.
Total: 64
Eureka Entertainment's Blu-ray release of "Khartoum" presents a visually captivating film that harkens back to the grandeur of large format cinema, evocative of classics like "Lawrence of Arabia." Despite its narrative flaws, the film's sweeping visuals and production scale are compelling reasons to revisit this historical epic. Sourced from an older remaster previously used by Twilight Time, the video quality is mostly decent, though it falls short of the potential demonstrated by more meticulously restored films such as "Ben-Hur."
The Blu-ray features excellent video fidelity, enhancing the rich, detailed landscapes and grandiose set pieces that define this cinematic experience. However, the audio presentation, strong as it is, lacks the immersive depth expected from a native 5.1 track—especially surprising given the inherent capabilities of the 70mm format. This shortfall slightly detracts from the overall aural experience but doesn't undermine the impact of the film's impressive soundtrack entirely.
Not enough to make this a classic, but enough to make you wonder why 70mm hasn't been used more over the past half-century. Eureka's release of "Khartoum" affords the visually stunning production largely excellent video and strong audio, along with a couple of decent new extra features. It's a great package for fans of epic features to lap up. While it may not reach the technical heights of more recent restorations, it's still a worthwhile addition to any collection of historical epics, especially when found at a discounted price.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
Shot on Ultra Panavision 70 (a 70mm gauge print, although only 65mm was for the film, with the remaining 5mm for the six-track sound), the ultra-wide scope takes a moment to get used to, but by the end...
Audio: 70
The score is strong and suitably rousing, rounding out a strong audio presentation, notwithstanding the 6-channel original audio that is conspicuously absent....
Extras: 60
Eureka deliver a couple of decent extras - an Audio Commentary with a trio of film historians, and a further Interview with another film historian; the package rounded out by a trailer and booklet....
Movie: 60
It's punctuated by a number of armed conflicts, a couple of scenes of rallying the respective men to their causes, and a brief moment where Heston and Olivier actually share a scene, with the rest of the...
Total: 70
Eureka's release of Khartoum affords the visually stunning production largely excellent video and strong audio (notwithstanding the curious lack of a native 5.1 track, given the 70mm format's inherent...
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
In fact, there is a lot of larger panoramic footage where the limitations of the remaster become painfully obvious because other issues tend to exacerbate the current limitations....
Audio: 90
On the contrary, when the remaster was prepared I believe that efforts were made to eliminate all traces of inherited damage because the current lossless track is clean and free of balance and dynamic...
Extras: 40
Interview with Sheldon Hall - in this exclusive new video interview, critic Sheldon Hall explains how and when Khartoum came to exist, the casting choices that were made for it and Basil Dearden's involvement...
Movie: 60
The supplemental features on the disc include an original trailer for the film; exclusive new video interview with critic Sheldon Hall; and archival audio commentary with film historians Lem Dobbs, Julie...
Total: 70
It is also true that it is a flawed film, but it offers grand visuals of the type that directors and producers can no longer deliver, and as far as I am concerned this is a good enough reason to track...
Director: Basil Dearden, Eliot Elisofon
Actors: Charlton Heston, Laurence Olivier, Richard Johnson
PlotGeneral Charles Gordon is sent by the British government to Khartoum in Sudan to evacuate Egyptian forces and civilians after a brutal defeat by the Mahdist rebels led by the fanatical leader, the Mahdi. Upon his arrival, Gordon is struck by the dire situation and the growing threat posed by the Mahdi's forces. Despite clear orders to leave, Gordon chooses to stay and defend the city, drawing on his deep sense of duty and faith. He fortifies the city, attempts to negotiate with the Mahdi, and makes pleas for reinforcements, all while becoming a symbol of resistance for the beleaguered citizens of Khartoum.
The situation grows increasingly desperate as the Mahdi's forces tighten their siege. The British government, preoccupied with other issues and hesitant to commit more resources, is slow to respond to Gordon's requests. Tension escalates between Gordon's determination and the political machinations back in London. Inside Khartoum, food starts running low, and morale fluctuates as hope for rescue diminishes. Gordon's leadership and tactical ingenuity are tested to their limits as he confronts a vastly superior enemy force, knowing full well the dire consequences of failure for both himself and the city he has vowed to protect.
Writers: Robert Ardrey
Release Date: 15 Jun 1966
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English