Transcendence Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Transcendence struggles with flawed storytelling and inconsistent genre blending, but boasts stellar audio on a problematic Blu-ray release with minimal extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 58
The 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation of 'Transcendence' exhibits noticeable flaws with artificial sharpening, noise reduction, and contrast issues, giving it a non-filmic, digital appearance despite being shot on 35mm film. However, it delivers rich color saturation and decent detail, making it serviceable for general viewers.
Audio: 78
Warner's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on 'Transcendence' excels with clear, prioritized dialogue, impressive dynamics, and ambient rear speaker activity, creating an immersive soundfield. Low-frequency effects are powerful and the soundtrack maintains excellent balance across all channels, enhancing both action and subtle details.
Extra: 30
The Blu-ray extras for 'Transcendence' offer a series of brief and repetitive featurettes focused mainly on cast and crew interviews with minimal production insight, accompanied by several teaser trailers, a DVD copy, and an Ultraviolet Digital Copy.
Movie: 38
Transcendence fails to ascend beyond a dull, predictable narrative plagued by wooden dialogue, uninspired performances, especially from Depp, and a lack of originality, despite its intriguing premise and high-profile cast and crew. The Blu-ray presentation is technically adequate, but it can't save the film's shortcomings.
Video: 58
The Blu-ray release of "Transcendence" presents a 1080p/AVC-encoded video that, while initially impressive due to its richly saturated color palette and decent detail, unveils various flaws upon closer inspection. Despite being shot on 35mm film, the transfer seems heavily manipulated, resulting in a digital appearance with evident artificial sharpening, minor ringing, and edge halos. Noise reduction compromises the integrity of the grain field, resulting in an overall less filmic quality. Issues with contrast are significant, leading to over-exaggerated highlights and occasional blooming, alongside black levels that shift between murky and accurate, frequently causing crushing.
The 2.40:1 framed image remains somewhat uneven when analyzed in depth, with inconsistencies in skintone reproduction where faces often appear poorly saturated or unnaturally smoothed. The transfer’s digital noise reduction (DNR) is apparent and affects the natural texture one would expect from a 35mm source. Despite these drawbacks, the richness of color in primary and secondary hues does stand out as a positive aspect. Detail retains an average level of clarity and sharpness across most scenes, though some have been artificially enhanced, diminishing overall quality.
Ultimately, although "Transcendence" on Blu-ray may retain some striking visuals and decent depth in compositions involving multiple objects or characters at various distances, its technical deficiencies overshadow these moments. The application of heavy post-processing affects the authenticity of the imagery and will likely be noticed by more discerning viewers. However, the average viewer may overlook these flaws due to the film's vibrant colors and acceptable level of detail.
Audio: 78
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track featured on the Blu-ray presentation of "Transcendence" considerably elevates the overall experience, standing out significantly in contrast to the film's visual aspects. Dialogue is meticulously clear and well-prioritized, ensuring every spoken word is distinct and intelligible. The soundstage is broad and welcoming, with excellent separation and balance among the front three channels, while rear speakers are continuously active, creating an immersive environment filled with ambient sounds and directional effects that enhance the viewer's engagement. The dynamic range between mids and highs is impressive, complemented by rich acoustics that highlight Mychael Danna's score, which spreads wide across the soundscape with great warmth and fidelity.
Low-frequency effects are noteworthy for their deep, weighty response, initially restrained but increasingly assertive as the narrative progresses, particularly during the action-heavy third act. The low bass effectively enhances key moments, such as gunshots and explosions, delivering a powerful and resonant experience. The surround sound presentation is exceptional, utilizing ambient noises and smooth panning to craft a thoroughly immersive auditory experience. The seamless interplay between voice and effects ensures a balanced structuring of audio elements, contributing to a dynamic and engaging lossless mix. Overall, the audio quality of "Transcendence" is exemplary, far surpassing the film's video presentation and elevating the viewer's overall experience.
Extras: 30
The Blu-ray of "Transcendence" offers a range of extra features that supplement the main film, but they are primarily EPK-style shorts with limited depth. These extras consist mainly of brief interviews with the cast and crew, including director Wally Pfister, and touch upon the film's themes and the promise and perils of A.I. technology. While professionally produced, these featurettes are quite brief and tend to focus on promotional material rather than providing substantial behind-the-scenes insights or detailed production information. Despite their brevity, these clips can still offer some enjoyment for fans interested in the film’s thematic explorations and the experiences of its cast and crew.
Extras included in this disc:
- What is Transcendence?: Cast and crew discuss the premise and plot.
- A Singular Vision: Insights into working with director Wally Pfister.
- Guarding the Threat: Cast outlines the story with film clips.
- The Promise of A.I.: Discussions on advancing technology.
- It's Me: Teaser trailer.
- Singularity: Another teaser, narrated by Morgan Freeman.
- R.I.F.T.: Faux PSA with a revolutionary warning.
- 2 Trailers
- Bonus DVD
- Ultraviolet Digital Copy
Movie: 38
"Transcendence," helmed by long-time Christopher Nolan collaborator Wally Pfister in his directorial debut, offers a compelling premise centered around artificial intelligence but ultimately falls short in execution. The narrative follows Dr. Will Caster (Johnny Depp) as he aims to create a sentient machine that blends the sum of human knowledge with emotions, only to become a target of anti-technology extremists. While the setup hints at rich thematic exploration, the script by Jack Paglen often feels overcomplicated and stifles engagement. Unfortunately, this potentially thought-provoking story is weighed down by an uninspired execution that leaves the audience indifferent to both its characters and overarching conflict.
Pfister's cinematography, despite his notable background, lacks visual distinction, and the movie's tone does not offer respite from its heavy-handedness and predictability. Depp's performance is notably lackluster, marked by an evident disinterest that translates into an unremarkable portrayal of a character who should be deeply conflicted and dynamic. Rebecca Hall and Paul Bettany, who play pivotal roles as Caster's wife and best friend, are given little to work with, rendering their emotional arcs flat. The ensemble cast, including notable talents such as Kate Mara, Cillian Murphy, and Morgan Freeman, is similarly underutilized, trapped in roles that serve more as narrative devices than fully realized characters.
Technically, the film employs interesting concepts regarding the integration of technology and human consciousness; however, these ideas are insufficiently explored and leave significant narrative potential untapped. The film suffers from pacing issues and a narrative structure that includes a problematic flash-forward revealing too much too soon. Ultimately, "Transcendence" is a visually and emotionally sterile film that fails to leverage its high-concept premise or its talented cast into something memorable or impactful. The result is a movie that promises depth but delivers superficiality—making it a disappointment for those expecting a profound exploration of AI and humanity.
Total: 57
"Transcendence," Wally Pfister’s directorial debut, presents a tantalizing array of concepts within the sci-fi thriller genre but fails to capitalize on them. The narrative aspires to dissect our reliance on technology and the ethical quandaries it poses, yet it falls short due to glaring plot holes and lackluster character development. While the film does raise important questions about the evolution of computer technology, it struggles to engage its audience on a personal or dramatic level. Consequently, it never really takes off, leaving viewers with a muddled mix of suspense, shallow sci-fi elements, and uninspired drama.
The Blu-ray release does little to salvage the viewer's experience. Though the 5.1 surround sound audio track is impressive, delivering crisp and engaging auditory elements, the video presentation suffers from various issues that undermine Pfister's cinematic vision. The lack of depth and clarity in its visual transfer disappoints, especially for a high-definition medium. Additionally, the supplemental features are insufficient and add little value—amounting to no more than twenty minutes of promotional content.
In conclusion, "Transcendence" misses the mark both as a film and as a Blu-ray package. Despite an excellent audio performance, the problematic video quality and lack of substantive extras make this a release that fails to justify a purchase. The film's ambitious themes are overshadowed by its execution flaws, leaving it more perplexing than thought-provoking. Judge for yourself, but temper your expectations accordingly. If anything, this serves as a cautionary tale about mediocrity in science fiction and technology-themed storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 60
It's serviceable enough, I suppose, and in some ways the sort of non-filmic presentation a subset of viewers prefer....
Audio: 90
LFE output, meanwhile, though initially restrained for the better part of an hour, soon begins to flaunt its power as Will's forces make a stand against humanity's aggression....
Extras: 30
A Singular Vision (HD, 3 minutes): Another much too short featurette, this time with key members of the cast and production team discussing the experience of working with Pfister on his directorial debut....
Movie: 40
Dull and dutiful to the point of being tiresome and even mopey, Transcendence is predictable, heavy-handed, infuriatingly mechanical and much too infatuated with itself, promising a great deal but delivering...
Total: 60
While the film's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track delivers the goods, its video presentation is plagued by multiple issues (some of which fly in the face of Pfister's intentions) and its supplemental...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
But on closer inspection, the 2.40:1-framed image reveals that contrast has been slightly boosted, creating some distracting blooming and very evident samples of clipping in the whites....
Audio: 80
Imaging displays excellent separation and balance between the three channels while a well-prioritized center delivers clear, pristine vocals....
Extras: 0
(HD, 5 min) — EPK-style collection of interviews with cast & crew, as well as experts from the science community ruminating on the plot's plausibility....
Movie: 40
Compared to what he's clearly capable of as an actor, the well-intentioned and unpretentious doctor is rather bland and dull, yet audiences are meant to believe there are hints of a god complex suppressed...
Total: 60
Despite some intriguing ideas that are never fully explored, the movie can't overcome from glaring plot holes and a story that can't decide who the villain is....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 92
Audio: 92
Extras: 40
The promise of A.I. – 2 minute featurette (HD) It’s me – 1 minute feature (HD) Singularity – 1 minute feature (HD) R.I.F.T – Faux PSA (HD) 2 trailers Bonus DVD Ultraviolet Digital Copy...
Movie: 50
, Dr. Will Caster (Johnny Depp) is the foremost researcher in the field of artificial intelligence, working to create a sentient machine that combines the collective intelligence of everything ever known...
Total: 69
If you haven’t guessed based upon the synopsis above the film’s theme is meant to be a sort of warning shot regarding our reliance on technology and the potential dangers in the quest for more....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 70
There is some good depth, particularly in seeing many rooms with monitors at varying distances from foreground characters....
Audio: 100
Low Frequency Extension: The subwoofer adds plenty of enhancement to gunshots and other sound effects and really makes its presence felt when it has too....
Extras: 30
The Promise Of AI (HD, 2:34) – A bit with everyone discussing their thoughts on technology....
Movie: 30
It offers nothing you haven’t seen before in that of science fiction technology, no real memorable action sequences or even performances to speak of....
Total: 40
This is easily the worst film I’ve seen all year and am glad to put it past me and not have to think about it again....
Director: Wally Pfister
Actors: Johnny Depp, Rebecca Hall, Morgan Freeman
PlotDr. Will Caster, a leading researcher in the field of Artificial Intelligence, is working on creating an all-encompassing sentient machine that combines collective intelligence and human emotions. This pursuit makes him a target for anti-technology extremists, who launch a series of attacks against AI labs across the country. In one such attack, Will is mortally injured, prompting his wife Evelyn and his best friend Max Waters to take drastic steps. Desperate to keep him alive, Evelyn uploads Will's consciousness into the quantum computer they have been developing. To their shock, the upload is successful, and Will's intellect and personality seem to continue existing in the machine.
As Will begins to expand his new digital existence, he rapidly advances his technological knowledge, amassing incredible power and capabilities. He convinces Evelyn to help build an advanced and remote research facility to further his goals of transforming society by solving complex global issues through his newfound abilities. Max becomes increasingly uneasy as Will's reach grows, fearing the loss of ethical boundaries and potential threats posed by such unchecked power. The government and the anti-technology extremists both become aware of Will's increasing influence, leading to a confrontation over the risks and implications of his transcendence.
Writers: Jack Paglen
Release Date: 18 Apr 2014
Runtime: 119 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, China, United States
Language: English