Outside the Law Blu-ray Review
Hors la loi
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Outside the Law attempts to tackle too many genres, resulting in a chaotic narrative that lacks depth despite a strong cast; Days of Glory was far superior. RENT IT.
Disc Release Date
Video: 52
Outside the Law’s Region Free UK Blu-ray delivers a 1080p transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, with consistently good detail and pleasing video clarity despite variable settings. While edge enhancement and artifacts are present, they don't detract significantly from the viewing experience. The color scheme adeptly reflects the changing locales and times.
Audio: 62
The Blu-ray of 'Outside the Law' features a well-executed DTS-HD Master Audio track in French with portions in Arabic and fixed English subtitles. The audio delivers clear dialogue, dynamic surround effects, and intense bass in action scenes, though it prioritizes nuanced dynamics over sheer aggressiveness.
Extra: 56
Extras feature insightful content reflecting on the film's production and thematic depth, including a comprehensive 27-minute Making-Of featurette, a detailed 12-minute director interview, and the original trailer, all in French with English subtitles. Note: PAL format demands a region-free player for North American viewers.
Movie: 61
Outside the Law is a tough, historical war drama set against the backdrop of the Algerian War, blending personal and expansive narratives, rooted in dynamic character arcs and moral complexity. The Blu-ray release offers decent video and audio quality with solid extras. Ultimately, it's a controversial yet worthy follow-up to 'Days of Glory'.
Video: 52
"Outside the Law" comes to UK Blu-ray with a 1080p High Definition video transfer in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio, ensuring an immersive viewing experience faithful to its theatrical presentation. The transfer exhibits commendable detail, manifesting even in darker sequences, though clarity and contrast levels fluctuate as the narrative transitions from Algeria to France. The film employs a variable color scheme reflective of its shifting locales and eras: dusty, sun-bleached yellows dominate early Algerian scenes, while Parisian settings showcase a mix of cold, dilapidated shantytowns and vibrant night streets illuminated by warm streetlamps.
Edge enhancement is subtly present but minimally distracting; minor artifacts and occasional ringing are discernable yet do not significantly impact the viewing experience. The high-definition transfer, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, maintains a relatively consistent detail level throughout, despite the absence of high saturation in black levels. The changing settings—from Algeria's deserts to Paris's contrasting nightlife and slums—are effectively conveyed through evolving color palettes from warm earth tones to cooler grays and greens. Contrast falls short of perfection, lacking the "3D-pop" characteristic of high-end demos, but remains sufficient for delivering a compelling visual presentation.
While "Outside the Law" does not qualify as demo-quality material, it proves to be a respectable and engaging representation of the film on Blu-ray. The artifacts' presence is generally minor, with occasional light edge-enhancement evident yet non-intrusive. Stability remains solid throughout, contributing to the overall satisfactory experience of this Blu-ray release from Optimum Home Entertainment.
Audio: 62
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Outside the Law" features two distinct tracks: a French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and a French LPCM 2.0 mix, with segments in Arabic. Fortunately, Optimum Home Entertainment provides accurate English subtitles embedded within the movie image. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track stands out with its well-balanced dynamic range, integrating clear and coherent dialogue throughout. While the film leans heavily on dialogue-driven scenes, the action sequences are executed with notable depth, utilizing the LFE channel and surrounds to enhance immersive moments, such as the intense Setif massacre and various explosive gun battles.
The surround channels are intelligently employed, providing a robust yet nuanced sonic experience that enhances both the quieter, dramatic moments and the more action-oriented scenes. Although the score may not leave a lasting impression, it effectively complements the film and leverages the surround system. Despite not being demo-quality, the track comes close, offering solid, engaging audio—albeit not one designed to push your audio equipment to its limits. The nuanced dynamics and stable dialogue presentation make the French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track a commendable effort worth experiencing.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray disc of "Outside the Law" includes a select but high-quality set of extras, which enhance the viewing experience with insightful behind-the-scenes glimpses and directorial perspectives. The main highlight is a comprehensive Making-Of Featurette where director Rachid Bouchareb, along with key cast members such as Jamel Debbouze and Roschdy Zem, delve into the inspiration behind the film, detailed thematic discussions, and provide substantial behind-the-scenes footage. Additionally, an engaging 12-minute interview with the director further unpacks his goals and thematic focus, implicitly prepared to continue in an eventual trilogy conclusion. The original theatrical trailer offers a succinct glimpse into the film’s essence. It’s important to note that all extras are presented in French with English subtitles, and the content is encoded in PAL format, necessitating a Region-Free player for North American viewers.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making of: An in-depth featurette exploring inspiration, themes, and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Interview: Director’s detailed discussion on film's goals and thematic focus.
- Trailer: Original theatrical trailer with subtitles.
Movie: 61
Rachid Bouchareb's "Outside the Law" is a harrowing, era-spanning historical war drama that offers an intense and complex portrayal of the Algerian War. The film explores the nuanced moral landscapes inhabited by its characters, drawing comparisons to thematic elements from other crime epics such as "The Godfather" and "Once Upon a Time in America." Through a meticulous narrative structure, Bouchareb chronicles the lives of three brothers who embark on disparate paths following the upheaval in their small Algerian village. The film carefully navigates their journey from Algeria to France, shedding light on their involvement in the FLN and the fraught struggle for Algerian independence within French territories. This meticulous attention to historical context serves as both an educational and emotionally impactful experience for viewers, making it a compelling piece of cinema.
Presented in French and Arabic with English subtitles, "Outside the Law" commands attention with its powerful storytelling and morally ambiguous characters. The film does not shy away from depicting the brutality on both sides of the conflict, refusing to propagate any simplistic narrative where one side is wholly justified. Messaoud, Abdelkader, and Said's actions encapsulate the harsh realities and complexities inherent in their cause, revealing individuals driven by necessity rather than nobility. The Blu-ray release from Optimum Home Entertainment offers a solid presentation with decent video and audio quality, complemented by relevant supplemental features like the original theatrical trailer, a making-of featurette, and an insightful video interview with Bouchareb.
Unlike its predecessor "Days of Glory," “Outside the Law” abstains from romanticizing its protagonists. The film immerses itself into the gritty and often ethically murky operations undertaken by FLN members, reflecting their ideological and tactical diversities. The narrative seamlessly interweaves historical fact with artistic storytelling, making it a superb exposition on Algerian resistance efforts on French soil. As controversial as it is compelling, Bouchareb's masterful direction ensures that the film remains grounded, providing an unflinching look at a war that continues to reverberate through both Algerian and French histories.
Total: 57
Outside the Law, directed by Rachid Bouchareb, is an ambitious film that attempts to weave together political intrigue, crime drama, and family dynamics within its narrative. Set against the backdrop of the Algerian struggle for independence from French colonial rule, the film follows three brothers who take divergent paths in their fight for freedom. While the movie features a strong cast and some compelling scenes, it often buckles under the weight of its multifaceted storyline.
The Blu-ray edition delivers crisp visuals and an immersive audio experience, capturing the essence of 1960s Paris and Algeria with remarkable detail. The high-definition transfer is excellent, presenting vivid color palettes and intricate textures, which contribute significantly to the viewing experience. The sound design is equally commendable, offering clear dialogue and well-balanced ambient sounds that enrich the film's atmosphere. Special features on the disc provide additional insights into the historical context and production process, enhancing appreciation for the film's ambitious scope.
However, despite these technical achievements, Outside the Law struggles to maintain narrative cohesion. The film's pacing is uneven, and its attempt to juggle multiple genres results in a lack of depth in its storytelling. The emotional impact of the brothers' journey is often diminished by abrupt tonal shifts and a script that tries to cover too much ground without giving each element its due attention.
In conclusion, Outside the Law is a technically proficient Blu-ray release that will likely appeal to those interested in historical dramas and films focusing on anti-colonial movements. Nevertheless, its attempts to be a multi-genre epic leave it feeling disjointed and scattered. While there are moments of brilliance, particularly in its visual and auditory presentation, the overall execution falls short of expectations. For a more focused and impactful experience from Rachid Bouchareb, his previous work Days of Glory is a better recommendation. RENT IT.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 70
Detail is generally very good, despite the variable settings and era-spanning narrative, with clarity pervading throughout even the darkest of sequences....
Audio: 80
Dialogue comes across clearly and coherently throughout, dominating the frontal array wherever appropriate but, whilst you might assume that this is quite a dialogue-driven drama, there are a fair few...
Extras: 60
InterviewThis accompanying 12 minute Interview (again, in French, with English subtitles) gives us yet more detail from the Director as to his sources of inspiration and his goal with bringing the story...
Movie: 70
Sure, there is a certain amount of artistic licence that has been taken here in order to show a more entertaining, affecting drama, but at least this isn’t another Seagal film, as you might have assumed...
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
The color-scheme also evolves - early on soft and warm yellows and browns are the prominent colors, while during the second half of the film, after the brothers reunite in Paris, grays and light greens...
Audio: 80
There are plenty of actions scenes in the film where the bass is fairly intense and the rear channels intelligently used, but do not expect the French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track to test the muscles...
Extras: 60
The featurette also contains footage from the various sets (quite elaborate) used during the shooting of the film....
Movie: 60
Unlike Gillo Pontecorvo's legendary The Battle of Algiers, however, Outside the Law does not explore the ideas and philosophy that united Algerians in their fight for independence; rather it deals with...
Total: 60
It feels like Outside the Law wants to be too many things at once - a convincing political film, a crime film, and perhaps a good family saga....
Director: Rachid Bouchareb
Actors: Jamel Debbouze, Roschdy Zem, Sami Bouajila
PlotSet against the backdrop of mid-20th century Algeria and France, the film follows three brothers - Saïd, Messaoud, and Abdelkader - who are forced to take separate paths after their family's land is seized in Algeria. Saïd relocates to Paris and becomes involved in the underworld, organizing boxing matches and managing a cabaret. Messaoud enlists in the French army, fighting in Indochina with the hopes of bettering his circumstances. Meanwhile, Abdelkader is drawn to the burgeoning independence movement, becoming a pivotal figure in the fight for Algerian liberation from colonial rule.
As the brothers' lives diverge, a fateful reunion in Paris brings them together, fueled by their shared desire to see an independent Algeria. Messaoud, now disillusioned with the French army, joins Abdelkader in the resistance, employing his combat skills in their insurrection efforts. Saïd, though initially reluctant to get involved in politics, finds himself inevitably entangled in the cause. The tension escalates as their acts of rebellion grow bolder, facing brutal retaliation from French authorities and leading them down a dangerous, irreversible path. The story chronicles their compounded struggles, aspirations, and sacrifices as they navigate the complexities of loyalty, brotherhood, and their relentless pursuit of freedom.
Writers: Rachid Bouchareb, Olivier Lorelle
Release Date: 22 Sep 2010
Runtime: 138 min
Rating: R
Country: France, Algeria, Belgium, Tunisia, Italy
Language: French, Arabic, English