Sliding Doors Blu-ray Review
Collector's Edition
Score: 72
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Sliding Doors excels with its unique concept and Gwyneth Paltrow's dual performance, bolstered by Shout Factory's Collector's Edition Blu-ray featuring extensive bonus content and a notable A/V upgrade.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
Shout Factory's Blu-ray of *Sliding Doors* delivers a solid 1080p transfer sourced from a recent 2K scan of the original camera negative with some interpositive inserts for uncensored scenes. The 1.78:1 presentation retains much of the film's 1990s color warmth and accurate skin tones, although it displays occasional low-light softness and inconsistent gamma levels.
Audio: 71
The Blu Ray edition of Sliding Doors features two impressive uncensored audio tracks: a superior DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio with excellent discrete effects and clear dialogue, and a solid DTS-HD 2.0 option. Both mixes highlight the 1990s soundtrack effectively without defects or sync issues, but the 5.1 track is notably better for its richer soundstage.
Extra: 86
Shout Factory’s collector’s edition of *Sliding Doors* provides extensive new features including a detailed behind-the-scenes documentary, a somewhat narratively unfocused but enthusiastic audio commentary by director Peter Howitt, and engaging guided tours of shooting locations, making it a definitive release for fans.
Movie: 71
Sliding Doors, featuring Gwyneth Paltrow's impressive dual performances and Peter Howitt's intriguing direction, cleverly explores parallel life scenarios stemming from a single missed train. Though fundamentally a charming rom-com with clichéd characters, the Blu-ray's decent 1080p transfer and robust bonus features make it a delightful revisit.
Video: 66
Shout Factory's new 1080p transfer of "Sliding Doors" harnesses a recent 2K scan of the original camera negative, supplemented with select inserts from an interpositive. This meticulous approach delivers a marked improvement over the 1998 Region 1 DVD, now exhibiting impressive image detail that softens only in low light conditions. The transfer retains the film's 1990s color palette, showcasing appropriate warmth and accurate skin tones. Shadow detail and contrast are generally well-rendered with minimal black crush and no evident blooming or banding. However, some scenes display inconsistent gamma levels, possibly inherent in the source material, and film grain appears slightly chunky.
The transfer from Shout Factory presents the film in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio, a slight alteration from the original 1.85:1 OAR. This adjustment results in marginally opened compositions to fit modern 16x9 displays. The definition and HD resolution imparted by this presentation are more than satisfactory, capturing the film’s cinematography with smooth grain structure and fine detail. While color saturation and contrast settings are not aggressively enhanced, leading to somewhat pale fleshtones, the overall HD presentation is consistently clean and reliable. This Blu-ray release substantially elevates the visual experience compared to its non-anamorphic DVD predecessor, with greatly improved black levels and texture.
Audio: 71
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of "Sliding Doors" offers two excellent choices: the original DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio and a DTS-HD 2.0 track. The 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack significantly enhances the viewing experience with cleaner separation and more discrete activity, particularly noteworthy with the distinctively 1990s soundtrack featuring artists like Aqua, Jamiroquai, The Brand New Heavies, and Dido. The dialogue is well-balanced within the mix, predominantly anchored to the front soundstage. The LFE response contributes positively to the overall aural immersion. While the film's nature doesn't demand heavy rear speaker utilization, the occasional subtle background ambiance and stray effects add to the richness without overwhelming the viewer.
In contrast, the DTS-HD 2.0 option, while still offering excellent fidelity and clear dialogue, lacks the immersive depth of its 5.1 counterpart. Both tracks are uncensored UK versions of the film, ensuring an authentic audio experience without any sanitization for a stateside PG-13 rating. Minor rear activity provides some nice touches, though it's more subdued in the 2.0 mix. Optional English SDH subtitles are available, presented in a well-formatted white font, albeit with occasional minor spelling and grammatical errors. Despite that, overall, this release delivers a robust and satisfying audio experience free from any drop-outs, sync issues, or other defects.
Extras: 86
Shout Factory excels again with its collector’s edition of "Sliding Doors," offering well-packaged extras and aesthetically appealing reversible cover art. This Blu-ray release, part of their Shout Select line, is a major upgrade from previous Region A editions, making it a must-have for fans. The star-studded bonus content stands out, including a comprehensive audio commentary by writer/director Peter Howitt and a near feature-length documentary on the making of the film, compiled from exclusive on-set footage and interviews with key cast members like Gwyneth Paltrow and John Hannah. These additions not only entertain but also provide deep insights into the film's production and narrative intricacies. The extras cover almost every aspect imaginable, ensuring a thorough and engaging experience for enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Writer/director Peter Howitt discusses various aspects of the film's production.
- The Sliding Doors Moments: Detailed documentary featuring 1997 on-set footage and recent interviews.
- A Stroll Through Sliding Doors London: Guided tour of the film's shooting locations by Peter Howitt.
- Trailers & TV Spots: Original theatrical trailer and several TV promos in appropriate aspect ratios.
Movie: 71
"Sliding Doors," a riveting rom-com helmed by Peter Howitt, offers an intriguing twist on the genre with its dual-narrative structure. Gwyneth Paltrow stars as Helen Quilley, expertly portraying two divergent paths her life could take after a single, seemingly trivial event: missing a train. Paltrow's adept transition between the two Helens, each distinguished by subtle visual cues like different haircuts and personality nuances, is commendable. The film deftly navigates the parallel lives, juxtaposing Helen’s developing relationship with the charming James (John Hannah) and her strained ties with unfaithful boyfriend Gerry (John Lynch). The narrative is enriched by moments of serendipity and fate that add layers to the storytelling, though it stops short of delving deeply into the metaphysics of its premise.
Set in London, the film capitalizes on its location to enhance the romantic and dramatic elements, bolstered by strong performances from the supporting cast, including Jeanne Tripplehorn as Gerry's conniving mistress Lydia. Despite a story that occasionally leans into soapy melodrama and clichés, the innovative hook keeps audiences engaged. This clever narrative device, combined with Paltrow's robust performance and a well-crafted script, makes "Sliding Doors" much more than your average rom-com. The film not only held audience interest upon its 1998 release but continues to resonate due to its timeless charm.
Technically, the Blu-ray release by Shout Factory is a significant improvement over past editions. It features a solid 1080p transfer that maintains the film's visual clarity. The uncut version offers a more authentic viewing experience with restored scenes and dialogue initially trimmed for the domestic release. Additional bonuses such as behind-the-scenes features further enrich this package, making it a must-have for fans and collectors alike. In summary, "Sliding Doors" is an engaging blend of romance and drama elevated by its unique storytelling technique and Paltrow's compelling dual role.
Total: 72
Shout Factory's new Collector's Edition Blu-ray of "Sliding Doors" offers a rich mix of modern video quality and robust bonus features that will satisfy both new viewers and long-time fans. The film, directed by Peter Howitt, brilliantly showcases Gwyneth Paltrow's engaging dual role, exploring the life-altering impact of missed opportunities. The British setting and distinct '90s aesthetic add a nostalgic veneer, enriching the viewing experience.
The A/V presentation has seen a significant upgrade from its previous DVD release, despite a few minor faults that do not detract from the overall quality. The visual and audio enhancements provided in this edition make it a substantial improvement over the 1998 non-anamorphic DVD, ensuring that every scene is represented with clarity and vibrancy.
Fans of "Sliding Doors" will find this Blu-ray edition to be the definitive home video release. Comprehensive bonus features delve into the movie's production and reception, offering added depth to an already intriguing narrative. This Collector's Edition is a must-have for those looking to revisit or discover this unique and thought-provoking romantic comedy.
Sliding Doors stands out in a crowded genre for its concept alone, but honestly is not much more compelling than that. It's still good for a first watch or revisit thanks to its British setting and heavy 90s aesthetic, not to mention the winning dual performance by Gwyneth Paltrow. Any reservations I have about the main feature, though, are easily smoothed over by Shout Factory's new Collector's Edition Blu-ray: it goes all out on the bonus features and serves up a decent A/V presentation that, while not without a few faults, is way beyond Paramount's 1998 non-anamorphic DVD. Fans will want to pick this up immediately -- it's about as definitive a home video package as the film will ever receive.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 70
Regardless, it's a serviceable presentation that shows a little room for improvement, but it's so far ahead of the 1998 Region 1 DVD (no surprise there) that fans will likely overlook a few flaws....
Audio: 80
Both offer excellent fidelity and clear dialogue with obvious channel separation, but the 5.1 track is a clear winner for its better use of discrete effects and LFE response....
Extras: 80
Howitt seems thrilled to be revisiting the film -- his first -- and speaks proudly of its production, covering such topics as early development, shooting locations, multiple takes and happy accidents,...
Movie: 70
Much like the various international Blu-ray editions of this film, Shout Factory's disc features the original uncut version including a few restored swear words (as well as a quick shot or two during an...
Total: 70
Any reservations I have about the main feature, though, are easily smoothed over by Shout Factory's new Collector's Edition Blu-ray: it goes all out on the bonus features and serves up a decent A/V presentation...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 80
The jump is quite massive from the original DVD, showcasing far better black levels and texture....
Audio: 80
The decidedly more impressive 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack has cleaner separation and more discrete activity, especially when it comes to the film’s various songs....
Extras: 100
The new featurette sees the director revisiting many of the spots seen in Sliding Doors, including the phonebooth that inspired the entire premise to begin with and the subway station....
Movie: 80
Gerry’s continued indecision stringing Helen and Lydia along, wreaking their lives in the process, make him a perfect cad in a romantic comedy....
Total: 85
A smart, engaging romcom that uses movie magic exploring Gwyneth Paltrow playing two different versions of the same character....
Director: Peter Howitt
Actors: Gwyneth Paltrow, John Hannah, John Lynch
PlotHelen, a young PR executive in London, is fired from her job and rushes to catch an early train home. From this pivotal moment, the film diverges into two parallel storylines: in one timeline, Helen catches the train and in the other, she misses it. In the version where she catches the train, she meets James, an affable stranger who sparks her curiosity and provides comfort during a difficult time. She arrives home earlier than expected and makes a startling discovery about her boyfriend, Gerry, leading her to reevaluate their relationship.
In the alternate timeline, where Helen misses the train, she faces a series of delays that keep her unaware of Gerry's deceit. Consequently, she continues to navigate life under a heavy cloud of professional and personal uncertainty, searching for new job opportunities and increasingly trying to support Gerry's attempts at being a successful novelist. As both narratives unfold, Helen’s life takes on drastically different trajectories, illustrating how seemingly minor events can set the course for our fate, influencing the people we meet and the choices we make.
Writers: Peter Howitt
Release Date: 01 May 1998
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English