Moss Blu-ray Review
Iggi
Score: 60
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Moss is a film with excellent acting but is ultimately too chaotic due to multiple subplots; rental is advisable before deciding to purchase.
Disc Release Date
Video: 57
"Moss" comes to Blu-ray with a commendable 1080p transfer encoded in AVC, presented in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. The disc offers strong contrast, vibrant colors, and consistent detail, despite minor edge enhancement and slight artifacts. A solid release with pleasing filmic quality and stable hues throughout.
Audio: 67
The Korean DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on the Blu-ray of 'Moss' delivers clear dialogue and a naturalistic soundscape, integrating effectively with front channels while providing nuanced dynamics, though bass performance can be inconsistent and the score lacks polish.
Extra: 56
While the Blu-ray disc of 'Moss' includes seven extras such as trailers, interviews, and a lengthy behind-the-scenes feature, none are subtitled in English, leaving their full value inaccessible to non-Korean speakers.
Movie: 56
Moss, a Korean mystery thriller, showcases excellent performances and cinematography but suffers from a convoluted narrative and overwhelming subplots. The Blu-ray release, while offering commendable picture and sound quality, lacks tighter editing and adequate English subtitles to elevate the viewer's experience.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray presentation of "Moss" by Art Service delivers a high-quality 1080p transfer encoded with AVC and framed within a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. With a commendable level of clarity and contrast, the video presentation provides consistently pleasing fine object detail and stable color reproduction. The exterior scenes of the Korean countryside are notably vibrant, showcasing a myriad of green and brown hues that capture the natural beauty of the landscape. Interior shots and specific elements, like Chun’s leather jacket, display a robust handling of colors, maintaining skin tones without fluctuation. Mild edge-enhancement and occasional artifacts appear but are generally minimal and do not significantly detract from the overall viewing experience.
While delineation is generally good, offering a filmic quality with consistent motion and grain—some minimal sharpening can be detected at times. Black levels are strong, though they occasionally fall just shy of absolute inkiness, while whites remain crisp throughout. Shadow detail is well-preserved, though some darker, more intricate scenes reveal minor crushing and artifacts. These instances are negligible and unlikely to affect the overall enjoyment. Importantly, the Blu-ray maintains stable video quality without heavy noise reduction or stability issues. Additionally, subtitles are conveniently placed within the frame for those with CIH setups.
Audio: 67
The audio presentation of "Moss" on Blu-ray is anchored by a solitary Korean DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that impressively captures the film's nuanced sound design. Dialogue is a particular highlight, with the center channel delivering crisp, clear speech without ever appearing out of alignment. The integration between the center and front channels is seamless, ensuring that murmured conversations remain distinct and effectively blended with environmental sound elements. The use of the surrounding channels is both intelligent and restrained, adding to the immersive audio landscape without overshadowing the main soundstage.
Bass performance is somewhat variable; while the LFE can deliver powerful, punchy lows, it occasionally feels underwhelming during pivotal moments when Jo Young-wook’s score kicks in. The score itself alternates between formulaic and engaging, but it would have benefited from more consistent support from the low-frequency effects. Nevertheless, the high frequencies resonate nicely, and despite a few missed opportunities, the overall dynamic range remains commendable. The track maintains an organic feel with no forced effects, contributing to a natural ebb and flow that underscores the film’s dramatic tension.
Additional technical merits include a distinct lack of audio artifacts such as pops, cracks, or hissing, confirming the high quality of the DTS-HD track. Although the English subtitles provided by Arts Service are grammatically flawed and sometimes distracting, they do not detract from the excellence of the audio experience. This intricate and thoughtful audio design encapsulates the atmospheric essence of "Moss," providing a soundscape that is both compelling and technically accomplished.
Extras: 56
The supplemental features of the "Moss" Blu-ray offer notable insight into the production, though limited by the absence of English subtitles. Featuring a range of content from interviews to behind-the-scenes footage, these extras provide a deeper dive into the film for those fluent in Korean. The materials are diverse, adding substantial value to enthusiasts keen on understanding the creative process behind the movie. Notably, an hour-long behind-the-scenes segment stands out for its extensive coverage. However, the lack of subtitles may frustrate non-Korean speaking viewers.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: An audio commentary with director Kang Woo-suk.
- Interviews: Conversations with director Kang Woo-suk and various cast and crew members.
- Trailer: The original theatrical trailer for "Moss".
- Photo Shoot: Behind-the-scenes photo shoot.
- Behind-the-Scenes: An extensive one-hour feature exploring the making of "Moss".
Movie: 56
"Moss" is a Korean film that promises much with its cerebral underpinnings but falls short in its execution. The narrative, built around dark secrets in a small village, is overloaded with complexities and subplots that are not fully explored, leaving viewers overwhelmed by the sheer volume of information. Set against a backdrop of meeting daily life in a remote village, the story follows Ryu, who arrives to settle his father's affairs only to be sucked into the village’s web of secrets. The characters include a varied cast – from a retired detective to a beautiful young woman, each with their own intrigue.
Despite the intriguing setup, the storytelling teeters on being chaotic. Flashbacks and numerous revelations clutter the plotline, making it difficult for audiences to keep track of crucial details. There’s an evident mismatch between the film's intent and its execution, as it veers off from its source material—the web-comic—in pursuit of a more somber atmosphere. This divergence, coupled with the film's sprawling structure, strains the audience's patience and detracts from the potential impact of its final revelations.
Technically, "Moss" benefits from excellent cinematography that captures the eerie atmosphere of the village, accompanied by stellar performances, notably from Jeong Jae-yeong. Despite its technical merits and some interesting plot points, the film ultimately feels too long and unfocused. The Blu-ray presentation by Art Service is commendable, with decent extras including an audio commentary and interviews; however, the lack of English subtitles for these features is a notable drawback. In summary, while "Moss" has all the makings of a gripping mystery thriller, it demands more cohesion and tighter editing to truly resonate with its audience.
Total: 60
Moss is an ambitious film that showcases excellent acting performances, yet it suffers from an overabundance of subplots that distract from the main narrative. The Blu-Ray transfer is of high quality, delivering sharp visuals and a robust audio experience, but the editing choices make the story difficult to follow. As a result, viewers might find themselves struggling to stay engaged throughout the film. I suggest renting before making a purchase decision to see if its complexities resonate with you.
While Moss offers a compelling premise and superb acting, its chaotic structure detracts from the overall experience. The Blu-Ray technical specifications are commendable, with high-definition picture quality and immersive sound design that truly enhance the viewing experience. However, the film's multiple subplots and directionless narrative arc ultimately weaken its impact. For those who appreciate intricate storytelling and meticulous performances, Moss might still hold significant appeal, depending on personal taste.
In conclusion, Moss presents a dichotomy between exceptional performances and a convoluted storyline. The Blu-Ray release does justice to the visual and auditory elements, making it a noteworthy addition for dedicated fans of unique cinema. Nonetheless, due to its disjointed narrative, renting the film first could be a wise choice for those unsure about committing to a purchase.
avforums review by Mark BotwrightRead review here
Video: 70
This is a strong image that, whilst having a couple of moments where the ball is perhaps not dropped but fumbled a little, copes with all the key areas well....
Audio: 80
It has an organic feel to it with no one effect being obvious or forced, the result is a track that is natural, keeps to a good level, ebbs and flows and barring more consistent range (perhaps a better...
Extras: 60
A total of seven extras are included on this disc – two trailers, three interviews, a photo shoot and an hour-long behind-the-scenes....
Movie: 60
The wealth of ideas thrown in are far more suited to the original format of a web-comic or perhaps a TV series as a segmental approach (as well as the greater running time/episodes afforded it) to investigating...
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
Most of them are rather difficult to spot, but the larger your screen is, the better the chance is that you will notice them....
Audio: 90
The bass is potent and punchy, the rear channels not overly active but intelligently used, and the high-frequencies not overdone....
Extras: 60
Interviews - a collection of interviews with director Kang Woo-suk and various cast and crew members....
Movie: 60
By the time Ryu arrives in the village and begins playing detective, it becomes clear that with the assistance of his father they have tried to rebuild their lives....
Total: 60
My recommendation would be that you find a way to RENT IT first, and then, if you enjoy it, consider a purchase....
Director: Kang Woo-suk
Actors: Jeong Jae-yeong, Park Hae-il, Yoo Joon-sang
PlotA young man named Ryu Hae-guk travels to a secluded village following the mysterious death of his estranged father. Upon arrival, he encounters the villagers who, despite their outward friendliness, exude a strange and unsettling vibe. Ryu soon realizes that the village is under the strict control of a seemingly benevolent elder named Cheon Yong-deok. As Ryu delves into his father's past, he uncovers a series of cryptic and suspicious circumstances surrounding his father's death, raising his suspicions about the true nature of the villagers and their leader.
Determined to uncover the truth, Ryu investigates the village's hidden secrets and his father's life there. As he digs deeper, he finds himself entangled in a web of deceit, corruption, and power struggles that extend beyond anything he could have imagined. Piece by piece, Ryu begins to connect the dots, discovering shocking revelations that not only shed light on his father's demise but also threaten to expose the dark underbelly of the once-idyllic village. The more he learns, the more dangerous his quest becomes, as he realizes that some secrets are guarded more fiercely than he ever anticipated.
Writers: Ji-woo Jung, Yoon Tae-ho
Release Date: 14 Jul 2010
Runtime: 163 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean