Echelon Conspiracy Blu-ray Review
Score: 44
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Echelon Conspiracy: Mediocre film with decent tech, best forgotten.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 52
Echelon Conspiracy's Blu-ray transfer showcases vibrant, occasionally inconsistent HD visuals with varied color saturation, detail levels, and grain intensity, but maintains overall appeal.
Audio: 63
Solid Dolby TrueHD audio with clear dialogue and dynamic range, offering immersive surround effects and deep bass, though lacking in bass depth and standout qualities for some tracks.
Extra: 6
Echelon Conspiracy's Blu-ray release by Paramount lacks special features, suggesting minimal confidence from the studio in this unceremonious, featureless launch.
Movie: 23
Echelon Conspiracy," panned for its clichéd storyline and lackluster performances, disappoints as a technology thriller, failing to engage or innovate despite its star-studded cast.
Video: 52
Echelon Conspiracy's Blu-ray presentation delivers a high-definition experience that, while generally pleasing, exhibits a number of inconsistencies that affect its overall impact. The 1080p, 2.40:1-framed transfer boasts a variety of scenes showcasing a rich array of colors and commendable depth, particularly in outdoor shots set in global locales like Bangkok, Prague, and Moscow. However, the video presentation suffers from fluctuations in detail sharpness. Close-up and midrange shots occasionally present a crisp and meticulous definition, while at other times, details appear hazier and less defined, especially in poorer lighting conditions or when featuring certain objects. Furthermore, the film’s aesthetic decision to oscillate between cooler and warmer color palettes results in scenes that sometimes display vibrant textures and vivid primaries, yet also features moments where fleshtones shift towards an orangish-red hue, evoking a feeling of artificiality.
The handling of contrast and black levels demonstrates a similar inconsistency; while contrast is sharp, leading to whites that might appear slightly washed out, black levels generally offer commendable depth. However, delineation in darker scenes is lacking, with details often engulfed by shadows. Grain levels are noticeable and, although they can confer a filmic texture to the image, their intermittent aggressiveness alongside occasional digital noise detracts from the clarity. These visual shortcomings are somewhat mitigated by the steady presence of film grain that adds to the cinematic quality of the transfer but doesn't fully distract from the less exemplary aspects of the production design and image transfer.
Despite these inconsistencies, the video presentation of Echelon Conspiracy on Blu-ray does have its merits. While certain indoor settings and specific color treatments (notably overly warm tones) may detract from its realism, the overall high-definition experience still presents moments of visual excellence. Scenes captured outdoors often delight with their detail and color rendition, even if the interior sequences and certain effects may not always hit the mark. Flesh tones, despite occasionally veering into less natural territories, along with some instances of exaggerated reds, underline the transfer's struggles with maintaining a consistent quality. Nonetheless, fans and viewers might appreciate the effort to provide a visually engaging experience that navigates between the film's varied thematic and geographical settings.
Audio: 63
The audio presentation of "Echelon Conspiracy" on Blu Ray, featuring a high-resolution Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack, delivers a commendable yet slightly mixed auditory experience. Viewers can expect clarity in dialogue with excellent intonation, allowing for subtle differences in the actors' voices to shine through, making each character's emotions and tones distinctly discernible. The soundtrack does an admirable job at enveloping the viewer, especially during action sequences where the dynamic range and surround mix come into play. Scenes such as the intense chase in chapter 11 demonstrate the system’s prowess in creating an immersive soundstage, filled with near field effects and techno rhythms that maintain suspense. Despite this, the surround activity is noted to be less extensive compared to other premier offerings in the genre, yet it manages to engage adequately.
However, the track shows its limitations in absolute reference quality when compared to other contemporaries in the Blu Ray format. While aggressive musical cues and sound effects are loud and clear, creating a sense of space and atmosphere, with shootouts and ambient casino sequences standing out, it doesn't push boundaries to stand out prominently among peers. The bass response, particularly from the LFE channel, presents a bit of a mixed bag; while offering deep impact and excellent tactility during music playback and certain action scenes, it sometimes falls short in providing the expected roar in scenes demanding heavy bass presence.
In terms of atmospheric sound and directionality, "Echelon Conspiracy" does a fair job presenting a good localized sound environment where gunfire and explosions are concerned, though occasionally lacking the depth in bass that could have enhanced key action sequences further. Dialogue clarity is generally maintained throughout, barring moments where it competes unfavorably with the score. Overall, while the audio mix exceeds expectations for a film that might bear a direct-to-video quality for some, it ultimately yields a satisfying but not extraordinary auditory experience for enthusiasts seeking state-of-the-art sound intricacies.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray presentation of "Echelon Conspiracy" arrives with stark clarity albeit devoid of any extra features, which might be seen as a miss for enthusiasts looking to dive deeper into the movie's production or thematic exploration. Paramount's decision to release this title without accompanying special features suggests a minimalistic approach that may disappoint some fans. However, this straightforward release could appeal to those who prioritize the film's technical merits—resolution, black levels, color reproduction, fleshtones, and minimal compression artifacts—over supplemental content. This release serves as a reminder that sometimes, less is more, although it starkly contrasts with the expectation for modern Blu-ray releases to offer a richer, more interactive viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- No special features are included with this release.
Movie: 23
"Echelon Conspiracy" arrives on Blu-ray with a narrative that recycles and repackages familiar technological thriller tropes, delivering an experience that, despite its ambitious premise, ultimately feels uninspired and derivative. The plot centers around Max Peterson (played by Shane West), who becomes entangled in a high-stakes conspiracy after receiving cryptic messages from a seemingly omniscient cell phone. This device inadvertently plunges him into a world of danger and intrigue, involving government agents and a pervasive surveillance system known as Echelon. Despite the potential for a compelling techno-thriller, the film falters under the weight of its clichéd plot points and lackluster execution.
The cast, featuring names like Edward Burns, Ving Rhames, and Martin Sheen, unfortunately, does little to elevate the material. Many of the performances feel disengaged, contributing to the film’s overall sense of missed opportunity. Technological elements within the movie are handled with a notable lack of finesse; the film's portrayal of advanced tech veers into the realm of the unbelievable, with faux pas such as unrealistic cell phone and computer interfaces detracting from its credibility. The action sequences, which could have been the film's saving grace, instead suffer from a lack of originality and excitement, rendering them forgettable at best.
At its core, "Echelon Conspiracy" attempts to weave a narrative full of intrigue and cybersecurity threats but ends up mired in genre clichés and uninspired storytelling. The film's reliance on worn-out plot mechanics and subpar character development make it a lackluster addition to the Blu-ray technothriller catalog. Despite the promising concept of navigating the dangers of omnipresent technology and surveillance, the execution leaves much to be desired, resulting in a viewing experience that feels as though it's merely going through the motions rather than offering any new or thrilling insights into the digital age.
Total: 44
"Echelon Conspiracy" on Blu-ray struggles to carve a niche for itself in a saturated market of high-concept thrillers, hobbled by a medley of underwhelming elements that significantly detract from its total presentation. Despite being viewed through top-tier equipment such as the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector and the Oppo BDP-83 Universal disc/Blu-ray Player, among others, the film's inherent deficiencies in storytelling and character development cannot be masked by its technical execution. The Blu-ray attempts to leverage quality visuals and sound—mediocre though they are—to compensate for its lackluster narrative and uninspired performances, suggesting a disparity between the potential of its delivery systems and the actual content delivered.
Further hampering its appeal is the Blu-ray's lackluster array of special features, which might have offered some redemption or insight into its production but instead leaves the viewer wanting. The video transfer and audio quality, while adequate, do not elevate the experience beyond the film’s fundamental flaws, characterized by poor production values, indolent direction, and an unmemorable score. The effort to showcase "Echelon Conspiracy" as a visually and audibly appealing product is undermined by a glaring absence of engaging material or substantial extras, rendering even a cursory viewing largely unrewarding.
In conclusion, "Echelon Conspiracy" as presented on Blu-ray epitomizes a missed opportunity to rejuvenate an otherwise forgettable film. Its technical merits, though present, are insufficient to distract from the core issues—a derivative script, lackluster acting, and an overall absence of originality or intrigue. This release serves as a stark reminder that high-quality playback equipment and competent technical specs are only as effective as the content they present. With little to recommend beyond passable picture and sound quality, this Blu-ray edition of "Echelon Conspiracy" struggles to justify even a rental, let alone a purchase. Paramount's lackluster treatment of the release mirrors the apathy it merits—suggesting that consumers might best serve themselves by steering clear entirely.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
The inside of the Prague casino never looks all that convincing, and while awash in color, it takes on a decidedly warm appearance that highlights red and oranges considerably....
Audio: 80
Shootouts generally impress; whether the weapon is suppressed or not, whizzing rounds scream across the soundstage, the subsequent impacts on glass and other objects delivering a pleasing and seemingly...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 20
Echelon Conspiracy is nothing but predictable drivel that takes on the look and feel of a bad made-for-TV movie, replete with name actors who appear only to cash a paycheck, plenty of technical gibberish,...
Total: 40
Without an original bone in its celluloid body, Echelon Conspiracy can only hope to impress with creativity behind the camera and decent performances in front of it, but the film wallows in mediocre-to-poor...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Black levels are decent, though delineation is quite poor, especially in darker interior sequences, when the shadows swallow up detail like Pac-man....
Audio: 80
Extras: 0
This may be a good thing, really, and saved me a small headache, but a barebones new release doesn't exactly scream confidence in the release by the studio....
Movie: 20
A conspiracy is afoot, and the few people before Peterson to get a phone in this manner all died soon after their life changing gift....
Total: 40
Paramount has treated 'Echelon Conspiracy' like an unwanted child with this release, hoping that we'll do them a favor and adopt their mistake....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
These segments didn't have the resolute clarity and dimensional perspective of some of the brighter scenes and on occasion looked a little flat....
Audio: 86
Surround activity wasn't extensive however the action based elements provided an enriching level of immersion that generated a seamless soundstage....
Extras: 10
Resolution/Clarity: Black level/Shadow detail: Color reproduction: Fleshtones: Compression:...
Movie: 40
Chased by a lethal team of government operatives, Max races across the planet in a desperate attempt to unravel a conspiracy that threatens the stability of the entire world....
Total: 55
Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio...
Director: Greg Marcks
Actors: Shane West, Edward Burns, Ving Rhames
PlotMax Peterson, a young American computer engineer, receives a mysterious mobile phone in the mail during his international travels. At first, this unexpected gift seems benign, providing him with unexplainable but highly accurate stock market tips that lead to a rapid fortune. However, the phone's intentions soon take a more sinister turn. Max finds himself at the center of a dangerous game, receiving ominous messages that propel him into increasingly perilous situations. Unbeknownst to Max, he has become a pawn in a much larger scheme that has global implications.
As Max tries to unravel the mystery behind the phone and its seemingly omniscient messages, he crosses paths with a determined FBI agent, an efficient and seasoned field agent, and a powerful government official with a deep, vested interest in the phone's technology. Their interests align against a backdrop of high-tech espionage and a shadowy conspiracy aiming to use the phone's advanced technology for surveillance and control on a global scale. Racing against time, Max must outwit his unseen adversaries, uncover the conspiracy's roots, and decide whom he can trust in a world where the line between ally and enemy is blurred.
Writers: Michael Nitsberg, Kevin Alyn Elders
Release Date: 27 Feb 2009
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Russian