1408
Blu-ray
Score: 66
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Decent film with mixed reviews; great audio, disappointing video. Worth a rental.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 64
Despite a theatrically accurate 1080P transfer, '1408' suffers from washed-out blacks, artificial colors, and lackluster detail, failing to impress in HD quality.
Audio: 74
The '1408' Blu-ray's TrueHD soundtrack impressively enhances the film's chills with clear dialogue, well-used rears, effective LFE, and spooky ambiance.
Extra: 60
'1408' Blu-ray offers a mix of commentary, featurettes, and deleted scenes, providing insights into filmmaking, technical aspects, and alternate content, yet some may find it dry or lacking depth.
Movie: 62
'1408' offers a mixed cinematic adaptation of King's tale, blending early promise and technical finesse with a descent into less subtle horror, yet remains a noteworthy attempt that captivates more casual viewers.
Video: 64
The Blu-ray presentation of "1408" offers a mixed bag in terms of video quality, encapsulated within a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode that respects its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio. On the positive side, the transfer is clean and free from any print damage, with a pleasing layer of grain that maintains the film's cinematic texture without overwhelming it. Detail in certain outdoor and well-lit scenes, such as the surfing sequence and daytime exterior shots of the Dolphin Hotel, can impress with visible textures on surfaces and in the wider shots of architectural elements.
However, this release struggles with its portrayal of black levels and overall color fidelity. Blacks often appear washed out rather than deep and enveloping, detracting from the potential for a truly immersive experience, especially in a film that leans heavily into its darker scenes. The color palette swings erratically; certain scenes are over-saturated with unnatural hues, while others suffer from a desaturated look that leaves skin tones looking flat and lifeless. This inconsistency mars the overall visual presentation, making it feel less than faithful to the director's vision. The use of filtering to achieve a certain mood results in an unnatural tint to many sequences, further complicating the color balance.
Detail and sharpness are sporadically adequate but fall short of expectations set by contemporary high-definition transfers. Close-ups and darker scenes, in particular, reveal a lack of clarity and depth, leaving facial textures and interior environments feeling somewhat lifeless. Despite these issues, the video is certainly watchable, benefiting from moments of higher quality that showcase the film's visual potential. While not the worst transfer available, "1408" on Blu-ray leaves viewers longing for a more consistent and immersive high-definition experience, making it clear that while the source material is pristine and grain levels are well managed, the execution in delivering a reference-quality video presentation is ultimately lacking.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of "1408" on Blu-ray is a commendable effort, featuring both a TrueHD and a Dolby Digital English soundtrack. The choice to utilize the TrueHD track may require navigation through the audio setup but rewards with a lossless audio experience that enhances the thematic elements of the film beautifully. Dialogue is anchored firmly in the center channel, ensuring clarity and precision that is never overshadowed by the soundscape's other components. The front soundstage boasts excellent separation, with both eerie and everyday sounds well-integrated, alongside a score that complements without overpowering. The mix’s subtlety in the early stages, marked by a front-heavy feel, evolves into a more aggressive and immersive experience as the narrative progresses.
The use of the surround channels and Low Frequency Effects (LFE) is both strategic and sparing, adding depth and dimension to the on-screen action without unnecessary overuse. The rear channels, although not constantly active, provide immense atmospheric contributions when employed, adding to the frightening moments with cleverly placed effects that envelop the viewer. Dynamic sequences and jump scares benefit from clear articulation and spatial cues, with the soundtrack adeptly balancing complex sound designs to build suspense and enhance the horror experience.
Moreover, the attention to detail in the audio mix ensures a stable presence for voices against the backdrop of varying intensities of sound, maintaining intelligibility throughout. The use of low bass supports the horror elements effectively, contributing to an immersive soundfield filled with ambiance. As the film unfolds, the soundtrack becomes significantly more engaging, creating a tense atmosphere that complements the psychological horror genre. Overall, the Blu-ray audio presentation of "1408" impresses with its refined mix, proving to be an integral component of the viewing experience that adeptly supports and enhances the film's eerie narrative.
Extra: 60
The "1408" Blu-ray special features compilation offers a technically dense and insightful look into the film's making, led by an audio commentary with Director Mikael Hafström and co-screenwriters Scott Alexander & Larry Karaszewski. Though the commentary can lean towards the technical, it provides an in-depth discussion on the adaptation from Stephen King's story, including the rationale behind its multiple endings. The special features are bolstered by "The Secrets of '1408'"—a four-part mini-documentary that explores the film's character development, directorial vision, practical effects, and meticulous production design. Additionally, the inclusion of deleted scenes, particularly the original and alternate endings, adds a layer of interest for fans and newcomers alike, showcasing the filmmakers' varying visions for the film's conclusion. Two webisodes and the theatrical trailer round out the extras, offering a more promotional glance at the film. Despite some content feeling more like filler, overall, these extras enrich the Blu-ray viewing experience, making it compelling for both enthusiasts of horror cinema and filmmaking.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Mikael Hafström joined by co-screenwriters Scott Alexander & Larry Karaszewski share insights.
- The Secrets of '1408': A four-part featurette focusing on characters, direction, physical effects, and production design.
- Webisodes: Two short pieces including "John Cusack on '1408'" and "Inside Room 1408" offering promotional insights.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes five scenes with an option for commentary, adding depth to character and plot.
- Alternate Endings: Two endings giving viewers a glimpse into different narrative possibilities.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original high-definition trailer that helped pique audience interest.
Movie: 62
"1408," an adaptation of Stephen King's tale of the same name, serves as a somber exploration of skepticism, loss, and horror. Starring John Cusack as Mike Enslin, a jaded writer who delves into the paranormal with a skeptical lens, and Samuel L. Jackson as the Dolphin Hotel's manager, the film intricately weaves a narrative that straddles the fine line between psychological dread and the supernatural. The movie excels in its initial setup, creating a tension-filled atmosphere that promises an unforgettable horror experience. Cusack's portrayal of Enslin is a career highlight, capturing the essence of a man gradually succumbing to the horrors of Room 1408, an entity that challenges his disbelief in the paranormal with terrifying precision.
The adaptation ambitiously expands on King's concise story, attempting to flesh out the emotional and thematic complexities without losing sight of its source material. This approach results in a narrative that is both faithful and innovative, offering an emotional depth to Enslin's descent that is as unexpected as it is impactful. However, the film's pacing and coherence suffer under the weight of its ambitions, particularly in its second half. While it commendably tries to elevate beyond conventional horror tropes, its execution falters, devolving into a sequence of over-the-top setpieces that detract from the psychological horror established earlier.
Despite these shortcomings, "1408" remains a significant entry in King's cinematic oeuvre, noteworthy for its strong performances and its capable handling of psychological depth and supernatural scares. Mikael Håfström's direction adeptly balances these elements, even if the film eventually loses some steam. The cinematography and production design deserve mention for successfully creating an oppressively eerie ambiance that complements the narrative. While not without its flaws, "1408" provides a room worth visiting for those seeking a horror experience that challenges both the senses and the intellect, standing out as a thought-provoking piece in Stephen King's adapted works.
Total: 66
The Blu-ray release of "1408" delivers a mixed bag of qualities that might leave some viewers wanting more, especially in terms of the video transfer. Despite being branded as a decent adaptation of Stephen King's work, featuring engaging performances from John Cusack and Samuel L. Jackson and commendable direction from Mikael Håfström, the video quality does not live up to expectations and is noted as quite disappointing across the board. It seems the transition to Blu-ray didn't fully capture the atmospheric depth and visual clarity one might hope for in such a psychological thriller. However, the release is not without its merits, offering a superior and subtle sound mix that greatly enhances the viewing experience, alongside a lossless audio track that does justice to the film's nuanced soundscapes.
Moreover, the extras package, while substantial in quantity, has been critiqued for its lack of quality content, although the inclusion of the director's cut with an alternative ending may hold value for some viewers. The film itself is seen as solid, if not groundbreaking, with its initial intriguing setup tapering into a somewhat predictable yet still engaging narrative. This Blu-ray edition was tested across an extensive array of high-end home cinema equipment, suggesting that while the audio aspects are well-served, the visual presentation leaves room for improvement.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of "1408" stands as a peculiar case where its audio qualities shine brighter than its visual counterpart. While it falls short of being an essential purchase due to the underwhelming video transfer, it remains a worthy rental for those intrigued by King's narrative and the performances within. Enthusiasts and collectors might find the director's cut appealing, but for newcomers or casual viewers, previewing the film before committing to buy would be advisable. The atmospheric sound mix and solid yet predictable plot make "1408" an interesting, if not essential, addition to a horror aficionado's collection.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 40
Audio: 80
A lot of artificial processing seems to be going on here, and the suppression of detail is one unfortunate result....
The designers have realised that it is not always necessary to hammer you with unnecssary ambience, and have used the whole soundscape well....
Extra: 60
Movie: 50
The participants do provide some interesting insights into the making of the film, how it differs from its source, and the different endings shot....
The source story is so brief as to be inconsequential, and through necessity the filmmakers have added much to the meat of the original....
Total: 60
This rather disappointing feature is provided with a superlative, subtle sound mix that enhances the atmosphere greatly, and a video transfer that is very disappointing - with little to impress....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Audio: 80
There are a few very nice looking moments, such as a surfing scene in chapter three that is drenched in natural light, but the vast majority of the movie that takes place in room 1408 rarely provides viewers...
I don't want to mention any specific instances for fear of ruining parts of the movie, but rest assured the soundtrack does a fine job in recreating the tension and fear that is to be found in room 1408....
Extra: 50
Movie: 60
The Characters (1080i, 8:00) looks at the character the room in the film becomes, the real effects seen in select moments of the film, and moving on to take a closer look at the various characters that...
Everything we learn about his past predictably becomes integral to the story, though at two hours, movies don't really have the luxury of a novel that can delve fairly deep into character development and...
Total: 70
1408 is a decent movie, better than a lot of the junk out there, but it's not one you'll regret not seeing should you find yourself on your deathbed looking back on what you missed in life....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Audio: 80
The color palette is seriously whacked out, too -- oranges and blues are way pumped up to distracting levels, leaving fleshtones rather unattractive and washing out most of the other primaries (reds in...
Low bass suitably supports the horror elements, and dynamic range is spacious and expansive....
Extra: 40
Movie: 60
The challenges of shooting a story that takes place essentially all in one room are initially fascinating but eventually grows tiresome (especially as the film piles on the over-the-top setpieces)....
The result makes '1408' the rare King adaptation that's both faithful to its source but also better developed, allowing the film to deliver an emotional impact that's unexpected, rather than just come...
Total: 60
I still can't recommend this disc for an outright purchase due to the weak video, but it's definitely worth a rental if you're a fan of the genre, or King....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 82
Audio: 86
Images were cleanly rendered with good visible detail on the surfaces of objects, clothing and physical characteristics of the cast....
Extra: 70
Movie: 60
The secrets of 1408: The characters, Director, Physical effects, and Production design (HD) John Cusack on 1408:...
When he insists on staying in the reportedly haunted room 1408 at the Dolphin Hotel against the grave warnings of the hotel manager (Samuel L. Jackson), he discovers the room's deadly secret - an evil...
Total: 75
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Outlaw Audio Model 7700 seven channel amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Mikael Håfström
Actors: John Cusack, Samuel L. Jackson, Mary McCormack
PlotA skeptical author, specializing in debunking supernatural phenomena, zeroes in on his next challenge: a notoriously haunted hotel room in New York City. Despite his disdain for superstition, his latest project intrigues him due to the room's dark history of over 50 deaths. Ignoring warnings from the hotel manager, who insists that the room is genuinely dangerous and not just a subject of ghost stories, the author demands to stay in the room, driven by a mixture of skepticism and a secret personal quest for something genuine after losing his daughter to illness and separating from his wife.
Once inside the ominously numbered room, the author's skepticism quickly erodes as inexplicable events begin to unfold, challenging his sanity and his staunch disbelief in the paranormal. The room seems to warp reality itself, presenting terrifying visions and manipulations of time and space, each more harrowing than the last. As his stay progresses, it becomes a fight for survival against an unseen force that seems to know his deepest fears and regrets, pushing him to the edge of madness. The line between the supernatural and his own psyche blurs as he struggles to uncover the truth behind the room's malevolent nature and escape with his life.
MoreWriters: Matt Greenberg, Scott Alexander, Larry Karaszewski
Release Date: 22 Jun 2007
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English