The Odessa File Blu-ray Review
Score: 46
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Odessa File Blu-ray offers a thrilling, classic experience with exceptional 1080p visuals, despite lackluster audio; a highly recommended, nostalgically rich purchase.
Disc Release Date
Video: 68
The 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray of 'The Odessa File' is a stellar release with detailed, meticulously lit scenes and natural grain structure. Despite its muted palette appropriate for 1963 Germany, colors remain accurate and the image clean and debris-free, making it one of the best-looking discs from the 1970s.
Audio: 43
The Blu-ray's Uncompressed PCM Stereo (PCM 2.0) track recreates the film's original mono sound with clear dialogue and dynamic range, but suffers from dated audio quality, occasional background hum, and awkward dynamics.
Extra: 0
The Blu-ray of 'The Odessa File' is disappointingly barebones, lacking even basic extras such as trailers or production notes that were present in the 2000 Sony DVD version.
Movie: 76
"The Odessa File" Blu-ray offers a gripping thriller with a captivating plot of Nazi conspiracies, enhanced by authentic location shots and a faithful transfer. Despite Jon Voight's uneven performance and the film's occasional overuse of English, Ronald Neame's direction sustains suspense throughout its 128-minute runtime without major action scenes.
Video: 68
The 1080p, AVC-encoded Blu-ray of "The Odessa File" is an exemplary release from Sony and Image Entertainment. The film's cinematography, executed by the Oscar-winning Oswald Morris (Fiddler on the Roof), is rendered with exceptional detail on this Blu-ray. The outdoor scenes, such as the training sessions by Israeli intelligence and nighttime pursuits through Hamburg streets, demonstrate Morris's meticulous lighting techniques. The muted color palette aptly reflects Germany's post-war atmosphere, although accurate fleshtones and occasional vibrant colors, predominantly red, affirm the disc's precise color reproduction. Moreover, the visible yet naturally moving grain structure indicates a well-preserved film quality without digital tampering. Despite the use of BD-25s, compression artifacts are absent, thanks to the efficient compression balanced by the 2.35:1 aspect ratio and the limited number of action sequences.
In stark contrast to many older titles dumped onto discs with subpar quality, "The Odessa File" stands out as one of the best-looking releases from the 1970s. Utilizing the AVC MPEG-4 tool, this Blu-ray offers an impressively clean viewing experience, free from dirt and debris. The film maintains stability with no wobble, while colors are solid and detail levels are commendable, albeit not as sharp as contemporary films. Skin tones are largely accurate with minimal warmth issues, and black levels are impressive especially in the flashback sequences to the Riga camp. The picture depth is generally superb, despite occasional softness adding a slight haze in some scenes. The disc boasts clean whites and an unwavering grain structure, free from digital manipulation, making this Blu-ray a standout release that surpasses expectations for films of its era.
Audio: 43
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Odessa File" remains somewhat contentious among reviewers, with diverging opinions about its quality. Encoded in Uncompressed PCM Stereo (PCM 2.0), the sound's fidelity is technically accurate to the original mono track, with both the left and right channels identical. When played through a matrix decoder, the audio collapses centrally, faithfully reproducing the mono experience. Despite this, there are commendations for the dynamic range which remains fine, dialogue clarity that stands out, and well-edited effects. The score by Andrew Lloyd Webber, although from his early career, adds a moody underpinning to the film and the title song "Christmas Dream," performed by Perry Como with lyrics by Tim Rice, integrates seamlessly into the mix.
Conversely, some reviewers assert that the audio didn't age gracefully. The uncompressed Linear PCM 2.0 format, while presenting mostly clear dialogue, suffers from significant issues in certain sequences where dynamics are notably poor and sounds appear awkwardly hollow. Furthermore, busy scenes occasionally include distracting background hum. While praises for Andrew Lloyd Webber’s composition vary—described by some as cheesy with light bass only—there is recognition of good high-range pop in the music. However, these elements do not culminate in a truly immersive sonic experience. It seems Sony prioritized video quality over audio restoration, extracting as much as they could from a dated source material.
In conclusion, while "The Odessa File" on Blu-ray preserves the technical integrity of a vintage mono track and offers clear dialogue and an atmospheric score, it simultaneously showcases limitations inherent to its age, reflecting a mixed auditory reception among users. The presence of isolated background noise and less-than-ideal dynamic execution detract from what could have been a fully engaging auditory accompaniment to the film.
Extras:
In juxtaposition to previous editions, the Blu-ray release of "The Odessa File" regrettably includes no special features, severely diminishing its appeal to collectors and enthusiasts of supplementary content. Past releases, such as the 2000 Sony DVD, featured basic but essential extras like the film’s trailer, a set of bonus trailers, production notes, and talent bios. In stark contrast, this Blu-ray edition is devoid of any additional material—not even a single trailer is included. This lack of extras is a missed opportunity to enrich viewers' understanding and appreciation of the film, making it a disappointment for those who value comprehensive home video packages.
Extras included in this disc:
- None: This disc contains no additional features.
Movie: 76
"The Odessa File" directed by Ronald Neame, adapts Frederick Forsyth's novel into a tight, action-driven thriller set against the backdrop of 1963. Here, journalist Peter Miller (Jon Voight) dives into the clandestine world of ex-Nazis hidden in plain sight, following the trail of a concentration camp commandant who vanished at the war's end. The film kicks off with a compelling prologue in the Middle East and utilizes authentic location shots to create an atmosphere that cannot be replicated in studios. With an emphasis on logistics over psychology, Neame orchestrates a narrative that builds tension steadily over its 128-minute runtime.
Jon Voight delivers an intriguing performance as Miller. His portrayal is significant, with his German-accented English lending credibility to the role. Despite some criticisms about his tendency to overact, Voight's youth and determination keep the audience engaged. The film expertly intertwines historical events like the assassination of JFK with the fictional story, and Voight's character shifts between roles—a zealous journalist and an unlikely espionage agent—revealing a complex, albeit sometimes naive, protagonist. The cast is rounded out by Maximilian Schell and Derek Jacobi, who provide solid support despite not reaching legendary status.
"The Odessa File" excels in crafting a believable yet fictional narrative through well-researched historical contexts and adept direction. The authenticity is bolstered by a faithful Blu-ray transfer from Image and Sony, which ensures that every detail is meticulously preserved for modern audiences. Neame’s invisible directing style maintains suspense throughout, despite a few slow sections. This makes "The Odessa File" not just an entertaining period thriller but also a testament to deft filmmaking that integrates factual history with compelling fiction.
Total: 46
"The Odessa File" on Blu-ray delivers an impressive cinematic experience that captures the essence of a classically filmed thriller. The narrative seamlessly meshes reality with fiction, creating a highly believable and gripping story. Despite its somewhat erratic themes and tone, the film remains engaging throughout, guiding the viewer through intense scenes with precision and skill. Its potent conclusion marks one of the best endings imaginable, making it a memorable piece in the espionage thriller genre.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray release by Image and Sony excels in visual quality. The film's transfer to 1080p is nothing short of fantastic, showcasing crisp and detailed imagery that highlights the meticulous craftsmanship of the original cinematography. While the audio quality might not meet modern standards and can be considered forgettable by today’s benchmarks, this minor shortfall does not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience. The visual fidelity alone makes it a catalog standout and a worthy addition to any film collection.
Conclusion: The Odessa File is an artfully constructed, classically filmed, old-fashioned thriller. They don't make 'em like this anymore because no one knows how. Image and Sony have produced a first-rate Blu-ray, which is highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Michael ReubenRead review here
Video: 90
The detail in these and many other scenes is exceptional, and the Blu-ray renders them faithfully....
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray case lists the sound mix as "Uncompressed PCM Stereo" and, indeed, the track is PCM 2.0, but the film was released in mono, and the left and right tracks are identical....
Extras: 0
The 2000 Sony DVD of The Odessa File contained the film's trailer, a few "bonus" trailers, production notes and so-called "talent" bios....
Movie: 80
But where Zinneman faced the challenge of telling his story through a protagonist who happened to be a cold-blooded assassin (hired to kill French president Charles de Gaulle), Neame had a different problem:...
Total: 80
...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Black levels are appropriate, especially in the black and white flashback sequences to the Riga camp, where the picture is truly phenomenal....
Audio: 40
It's really, really cheesy) has some light bass hints, and some good high range pop, but it is hardly a sonic marvel....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
And while the charges in the film are trumped up due to personal agenda by the historic advisor for the novel, a Nazi hunter much like Olivier's Ezra Lieberman in 'The Boys From Brazil,' it's the result...
Total: 40
The film is somewhat forgotten today, and seems almost archaic compared to '3 Days of the Condor,' which came out the very next year, but it's a nice blast from the past....
Director: Ronald Neame
Actors: Jon Voight, Maximilian Schell, Maria Schell
PlotSet against the backdrop of post-World War II Germany, a young freelance journalist named Peter Miller stumbles upon the diary of a Holocaust survivor who recently committed suicide. The diary details horrific experiences in a Nazi concentration camp and names former SS officers involved in war crimes. Driven by a quest for justice and intrigued by the peculiar circumstances of the man's suicide, Miller embarks on an investigation to track down these war criminals hiding under assumed identities. His search leads him to uncover traces of a secret Nazi organization known as ODESSA, which stands for the Organization of Former SS Members.
As Miller delves deeper, he faces increasing dangers and obstacles from various forces seeking to keep the truth hidden. The journalist's personal commitment is tested as he navigates through layers of deception, betrayal, and violence. Finding leads that connect high-ranking officials in modern society to these hidden war criminals, his pursuit grows increasingly perilous. Obstacles and confrontations intensify as he pieces together a shocking conspiracy, pushing him closer to the heart of a dark, sinister truth from which there may be no return.
Writers: Frederick Forsyth, Kenneth Ross, George Markstein
Release Date: 18 Oct 1974
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, West Germany
Language: English, German