Independence Day Blu-ray Review
20th Anniversary Edition | Remastered
Score: 79
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
The new Blu-ray of 'Independence Day' delivers superb A/V quality and ample extras, making it a highly recommended update for both newcomers and fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
Independence Day soars with a spectacular 1080p transfer from a fresh 4K scan, providing unparalleled clarity and natural vibrancy. Fine details like fabric textures and facial features are superbly rendered, though black levels sometimes push towards crush. Effects shots reveal their age but overall, this Blu-ray is the film's best home video presentation yet.
Audio: 82
The Blu-ray release of Independence Day promises a DTS-HD MA 7.1 mix but delivers only a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, which, while still impressive with its immersive soundstage, balanced levels, and dynamic LFE impact, falls short of the anticipated DTS:X upgrade for the upcoming UHD release.
Extra: 78
The Blu-ray extras for "Independence Day" provide a comprehensive retrospective, featuring in-depth audio commentaries from Director Roland Emmerich, Producer Dean Devlin, and Oscar-winning VFX Supervisors Volker Engel and Doug Smith. Highlights include the detailed "Legacy Surging Forward" documentary, an extended cut of the film, engaging trivia tracks, and extensive making-of features focusing on visual effects, model work, and casting anecdotes. The mix of HD and SD content preserves both vintage and modern insights for dedicated fans.
Movie: 71
20th Century Fox's 20th Anniversary Blu-ray of 'Independence Day' revives the 90s blockbuster with a stunning 1080p remaster, extensive archival extras, and a timeless 5.1 lossless audio track; although its plot flaws and character distractions persist, the visual spectacle and nostalgia it delivers remain unparalleled.
Video: 79
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Independence Day" is masterfully restored, using a fresh 4K scan that enhances the film's already solid visual foundation. This 2.39:1 1080p transfer employs the AVC codec, ensuring an excellent balance between fine detail and color vibrancy. The portrayal of fine grain is remarkably stable, providing an organic texture without overwhelming noise, particularly in darker scenes. This stability brings to light minute details such as the subtle textures on military uniforms, scruffy beard hairs, and intricate wear patterns within the aircraft cockpits. While CGI and green screen effects occasionally reveal their age through a slightly flatter appearance, practical effects and natural environments are strikingly sharp, maintaining an immersive sense of depth and dimension.
Color reproduction in this transfer is commendable, with vivid primaries and natural earth tones that enrich scenes with authenticity. Skin tones are accurately rendered, avoiding the unnaturally pink hues seen in previous releases. Specific sequences, such as Jeff Goldblum and Judd Hirsch’s chess game, showcase the improved color fidelity and nuanced shadows. Explosive sequences benefit from robust black levels and dynamic contrast, adding depth and intensity to fireball visuals, though some may note a subtle teal/orange shift that stabilizes flesh tones. This meticulous attention to detail offers viewers an experience akin to a theatrical viewing, whether during sunlit daytime exteriors or within darker settings of the alien mothership.
Moreover, the film's black levels have been refined to avoid crush while offering impressive shadow separation and depth. Despite some dated CGI elements standing out more under the enhanced clarity, this Blu-ray presentation surpasses previous iterations in every respect. The transfer captures the essence of "Independence Day" in a way that will delight long-time fans and new viewers alike, making it a valuable addition to any collection until the anticipated UHD release further pushes the visual envelope.
Audio: 82
The audio presentation for the Blu-ray release of "Independence Day" maintains a high level of quality albeit falling short of advertised specifications. Despite the packaging indicating a DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track, the actual disc features only a DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless track. While this might seem like a disappointment, particularly with the promise of a DTS:X track for an upcoming UHD release, the 5.1 mix provided is nonetheless impressive. This release, while technically echoing its predecessor in bitrate, still offers a solid and immersive audio experience.
Dialogue clarity stands out prominently, crucial in a film laden with high-stake speeches and critical conversations. The background and atmospheric effects have seen noticeable improvements; the soundstage feels more balanced, creating a sense of direction and dimensionality that pulls you deeper into the action sequences. The LFE channel engages robustly, especially notable during David Arnold's score and the film’s signature large-scale sequences involving alien ships and exploding cities. The low-frequency extension is well-deployed, offering room-shaking impacts that enhance immersion.
Channel separation across the DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix ensures that explosions and ambient effects do not overshadow dialogues. The surround sound remains active throughout the film, wrapping the listener in an audio blanket that deftly transports one into each thrilling scene. While it might lack today's cutting-edge sound technologies, this mix still delivers a compelling auditory experience suitable for a blockbuster spectacle such as "Independence Day". With this Blu-ray audio track, listeners can expect a theater-like experience at home, complete with dynamic transitions and well-balanced levels.
Extras: 78
The Blu-ray extras for "Independence Day" offer a comprehensive deep dive into the making and legacy of this landmark sci-fi action film. The two-disc set features a blend of new retrospectives and vintage content, delivering a fulfilling experience for fans and cinephiles. Commentary tracks provide invaluable insights: Director Roland Emmerich and Producer Dean Devlin offer an engaging look back, while Oscar-winning VFX supervisors delve into technical achievements. The newly added documentary, "Independence Day: A Legacy Surging Forward," showcases reflections from cast and crew on what made the film special. Other highlights include an extensive collection of material related to visual effects, multiple trailers, TV spots, and a series of news broadcasts created for the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Tracks by Roland Emmerich & Dean Devlin, and VFX Supervisors.
- ID4 Datastream Trivia Track: Pop-up facts during the theatrical cut.
- Independence Day: Resurgence Trailer: Preview of the sequel.
- Independence Day: A Legacy Surging Forward: Retrospective documentary.
- Original Theatrical Ending: Alternate ending with commentary.
- Gag Reel: Outtakes and funny moments.
- Creating Reality: Insights into visual effects work.
- ID4 Invasion Mockumentary: Fake news coverage about the alien invasion.
- The Making of ID4: Behind-the-scenes feature hosted by Jeff Goldblum.
- Combat Review: Clips of destruction scenes.
- Monitor Earth Broadcasts: News clips created for the film.
- Gallery: Stills, sketches, and storyboards.
- Teaser Trailers: Collection of brief teasers.
- Theatrical Trailer: Full trailer for the original release.
- TV Spots: Promotional TV commercials.
Movie: 71
‘Independence Day,’ helmed by Roland Emmerich and released in 1996, stands as a quintessential summer blockbuster that combines the fervor of 1950s alien invasion films with the scale of 1970s disaster epics. The 20th Anniversary Blu-ray edition delivers a meticulously remastered 1080p transfer that significantly restores the film's impact, which was arguably diminished when viewed on smaller screens in its earlier VHS format. This version also retains the robust 5.1 lossless audio track, enveloping viewers in its cataclysmic soundscapes, although no new audio enhancements were introduced. The visual effects are still awe-inspiring, from the devastation of iconic cities like New York and Washington, D.C. to the climactic aerial dogfights.
The narrative, penned by Emmerich and producer Dean Devlin, centers around a colossal alien spacecraft entering Earth’s orbit, followed by a calculated ground assault from smaller crafts targeting global metros. Characters like President Whitmore (Bill Pullman), computer expert David Levinson (Jeff Goldblum), and fighter pilot Captain Steven Hiller (Will Smith) navigate through layers of destruction and emotional arcs. The film’s enduring appeal lies in its balance of humor, human drama, and sheer spectacle, despite criticisms of its fragmented structure and sometimes implausible plot conveniences. Performances, especially Pullman's rousing presidential speech and Smith’s quippy heroics, anchor the film amidst its explosive set pieces.
Critically, ‘Independence Day’ remains a crowd-pleasing entity of its genre—a piece designed more for visceral enjoyment than for intellectual dissection. The anniversary release enriches the viewing experience with added retrospective documentaries and archival extras that lend context to its historical significance in the realm of special effects-driven cinema. Despite its narrative flaws and occasional cheesy moments, the film’s contribution to blockbuster cinema is undeniable and continues to entertain with its combination of groundbreaking visuals, charismatic performances, and high-stakes action sequences.
Total: 79
"Independence Day," a quintessential summer blockbuster, delivers an exhilarating mix of action, humor, and impressive visual effects that solidify its status as a cinematic guilty pleasure. This updated Blu-ray release significantly enhances the viewing experience with a strong visual and audio presentation. While the legacy supplements provide substantial additional content, the absence of a new audio track might be a minor letdown for some. Nevertheless, the superb enhancement of the film’s already commendable transfer makes this edition highly worthwhile.
Fox has excelled in presenting a stellar A/V performance that reintroduces the movie’s charm and excitement, positioning it as a precursor to the forthcoming UHD Blu-ray. The 2-disc set is packed with fun new features and valuable archival extras, ensuring hours of engagement. For those who don't already own "Independence Day" on Blu-ray, this release is an unequivocal must-have. Even existing owners will find the new transfer and extensive bonus content compelling enough to consider an upgrade.
In conclusion, "Independence Day" maintains its appeal as an entertaining popcorn flick that offers sheer escapism and enjoyment. The updated Blu-ray release does justice to this classic by delivering drastically improved technical enhancements and worthwhile extras. Though not perfect, it is a highly recommended addition to any collection, celebrating a film that continues to be a part of modern pop culture lore.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Outside of a few pesky black level concerns, this is a terrific presentation and an honest improvement over the previous Blu-ray release, particularly as it tightens up fine detail, grain, and color....
Audio: 100
Packaging proclaims that the release includes a 7.1 lossless soundtrack, and the upcoming UHD release is set to include a DTS:X presentation....
Extras: 80
Monitor Earth Broadcasts (Video Playback Newscasts) (SD): News clips created for the film....
Movie: 90
This edition boasts a remastered 1080p transfer, a new retrospective documentary, and adds plenty of archival extras missing from the previous Blu-ray....
Total: 90
It'll be interesting to see if the sequel can match the original's charm, excitement, and lasting appeal, a tall order to be sure but one that team of Dean Devlin and Roland Emmerich are capable of filling....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This new scan maintains the apparent grain field while also stabilizing the night scenes allowing finer details to appear and a better sense of depth....
Audio: 80
The channels feel a little more balanced now and primary sound effects like explosions or cries of panic from the numerous background cast members sound more natural before where in the 2008 mix they could...
Extras: 60
This is a collection of all of the news broadcasts that were created for the film and only briefly scene in the film....
Movie: 60
My Dad was an early member of Columbia House because at the time it was the most convenient and cheap way to buy tapes, so it was a regular occurrence for us to own the movies we loved seeing in the theater....
Total: 80
I loved it in theaters, hated it on home video, but thanks to the first Blu-ray release and now this new 4K restored version ahead of the UHD Blu-ray, 'Independence Day' is back to being fun again....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
Black levels are really quite something in this transfer giving real pop to the fireball explosions that feature in the original alien attacks and later in the mass destructions in the climax....
Audio: 90
There is plenty of heft to the bass throughout (your subwoofer will not be unhappy with the workout), and atmospheric effects are very good spread through the soundstage with some effective pans where...
Extras: 100
The Making of ID4 (28:29, SD): Jeff Goldblum hosts a special featuring sound bites from the director and actors, clips from the movie, and some behind-the-scenes looks at the creation of the special effects....
Movie: 60
Even in the far-fetched situation as we’re presented with here, one expects some measure of rationality in human behaviors, the laws of physics, and the reality of distance (characters meet in extraordinarily...
Total: 70
Even with all of its borrowings from War of the Worlds, Alien, and most of the other outer space invasion films from previous decades, Independence Day is still a fun popcorn movie, but what it really...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
The spectacle and nature of the aliens allows for a lot of brightness and you get a great handle on that thanks to what this new transfer has to offer....
Audio: 100
Surround Sound Presentation: While dialogue and other elements are pushed to the front, this is a well-rounded audio track that really utilizes the various surround channels for an excellent experience....
Extras: 80
Resurgence Theatrical Trailer (HD, 2:30)Disc 2: Independence Day: A Legacy Surging Forward (HD, 30:40) – Filmed on the set of the sequel, this is a look back the legacy of Independence Day, with plenty...
Movie: 80
Then you think of the destruction that takes place and while we may have seen endless explosions that take out major landmarks in films at this point, Independence Day was a film that really defined what...
Total: 90
Enjoy the disc for that reason alone, but also be happy to get a terrific set of extras, even if there isn’t much in the way of new extras to be found....
Director: Roland Emmerich
Actors: Will Smith, Bill Pullman, Jeff Goldblum
PlotMysterious alien ships appear and position themselves over major cities across the globe, causing widespread panic and intrigue. Communication attempts are futile, and the world quickly learns the aliens' hostile intentions when a powerful attack is launched, decimating the cities below with no warning. Amidst the chaos, different individuals converge with the shared goal of survival. A skilled fighter pilot, his girlfriend's family, and a motley crew of survivors find themselves thrust together in the looming shadow of the alien menace.
As the government scrambles to respond, a brilliant but quirky scientist uncovers a critical weakness in the seemingly invincible alien shields. The President of the United States faces a dire situation: orchestrate a counter-attack against a technologically superior enemy or submit to the annihilation of the human race. With the fate of the world in the balance, a risky plan is set in motion to use the information discovered by the scientist, requiring coordination and courage from citizens and soldiers alike. Together, they prepare for a last stand — a fight not just for their lives but for the independence of Earth itself.
Writers: Dean Devlin, Roland Emmerich
Release Date: 03 Jul 1996
Runtime: 145 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English