Bird of Paradise Blu-ray Review
Score: 29
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Bird of Paradise" on Blu-ray presents a visually arresting yet dated exotic romance, with clear video marred by poor audio and lacking essential extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 48
Kino Classics' Blu-ray of 'Bird of Paradise' showcases a sharp 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer from an original nitrate 35mm print with minor, non-distracting specks and scratches, maintaining high fidelity to the source. The grayscale is well-managed with clear close-ups and deep blacks, though some scenes exhibit occasional overexposure and crush.
Audio: 18
Max Steiner's memorable score on the Blu-ray's LPCM 2.0 mono track, though historically significant, suffers from age-related issues such as crackles, peaky moments, and muffled dialogue, reflecting the primitive audio quality of an 80-year-old film.
Extra: 6
The only extras on the 'Bird of Paradise' Blu-ray are high-definition trailers for 'Pandora and the Flying Dutchman,' 'Nothing's Sacred,' and 'A Star is Born.' This limited offering provides previews of other Kino releases without additional disc supplements.
Movie: 46
"Bird of Paradise" (1932), directed by King Vidor and featuring Joel McCrea and Dolores del Rio, is a lavish Depression-era escapist romance set in the South Seas, praised for its visual charm, Max Steiner's pioneering original score, and notable pre-Hays Code risqué scenes, despite its simplistic and antiquated narrative.
Video: 48
Kino Classics has delivered a commendable Blu-ray presentation of "Bird of Paradise," a film that's historically suffered from subpar home video releases. Utilizing a 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer mastered from an original nitrate 35mm print preserved by the George Eastman House Motion Picture Department, the disc offers a significant improvement over prior editions. Although little digital clean-up has been performed, this hands-off approach allows the film's natural texture to shine through without sacrificing detail. Minor specks and scratches are present but rarely distracting, ensuring a faithful reproduction. The monochromatic gradient has been meticulously managed, featuring deep blacks, bright whites, and a rich spectrum of grays, maintaining clarity without overt compression issues.
Contrary to some expectations, the print isn't in pristine condition, owing to its public domain status and historical neglect. Viewers will notice a veneer of print defects, including scratches, vertical lines, specks, and debris that vary in severity across scenes. However, grain is minimal and contrast is well balanced, aided by a varied gray scale that enriches the film's exotic setting. While daytime scenes occasionally appear overexposed and some night sequences suffer from crush, close-ups remain crisply detailed despite the vintage soft focus. Kino wisely avoided digital enhancements, preserving the film's antique charm and respecting its historical context. Overall, Kino Classics has done an admirable job with the available materials, producing a Blu-ray that both respects and revitalizes "Bird of Paradise."
Audio: 18
The audio presentation of "Bird of Paradise" on Blu-ray offers a unique experience, but it is notably constrained by the limitations inherent to an 80-year-old film. The LPCM 2.0 mono track presents Max Steiner’s memorable, Polynesia-influenced score with both charm and flaws. Steiner's early work shows his burgeoning mastery of film music, blending traditional orchestration with South Pacific motifs. However, the audio quality betrays its age; the music often sounds crackly, brittle, and occasionally shrill, particularly in heavy string sections. Dynamic range is perceptively limited, yet at certain moments, the score fills the room pleasantly despite these constraints.
Dialogue reproduction is another critical area of concern. English-speaking characters' lines are often low in the mix and at times slightly muffled, making comprehension a challenge. Del Rio's dialogue, primarily in another language, suffers greatly from unintelligibility. The overall distortion and tinny quality give the impression that the audio is being funneled through a restrictive medium. Though hiss, pops, and crackles persist, these imperfections are somewhat more forgivable and expected for a film of this era.
In summary, while the audio track does its best to be listenable, it reflects significant limitations set by its primitive source material and decades of public domain neglect. Viewers should temper their expectations for high fidelity; despite Kino’s efforts, the audio remains rough and may impact the overall enjoyment of this classic film.
Extras: 6
The extras on the Blu-ray disc of "Bird of Paradise" are minimal, consisting solely of high-definition trailers for other Kino releases. This sparse selection of supplements includes previews for the 1937 version of "A Star Is Born," 'Nothing Sacred,' and 'Pandora and the Flying Dutchman.' While these trailers are presented in high quality, the lack of additional content, such as behind-the-scenes features, interviews, or commentary, is a notable omission that may disappoint enthusiasts looking for deeper insights into the film's production and context.
Extras included in this disc:
Pandora and the Flying Dutchman Trailer: High-definition preview. Nothing Sacred Trailer: High-definition preview. A Star Is Born Trailer: High-definition preview.
Movie: 46
"Bird of Paradise" (1932), directed by King Vidor and produced by David O. Selznick, epitomizes the adventure/capital-R-Romance genre prevalent in early 20th-century Hollywood. It follows Johnny (Joel McCrea), a yachting young sailor who becomes enamored with the exotic island princess Luana (Dolores del Rio) amidst the lush settings of the South Seas. Their romance, marked by adventure, cultural clashes, and impending sacrifice to appease an angry volcano, unfolds within a narrative that reflects the racial attitudes of its era. Although the film’s trope of the civilized man going native is rendered with less self-awareness than later films like "Avatar" or "Dances with Wolves," it does offer an idyllic escape from its Depression-era context.
The film’s visual allure is undeniable, employing vivid imagery to communicate passion and emotion more effectively than its dialogue. Dolores del Rio delivers a compelling performance without uttering a comprehensible word, embodying an idealized notion of untamed eroticism unbound by Western mores. The picture also boasts innovative cinematography, including underwater sequences and stunts that were impressive for their time. Max Steiner's pioneering score, making use of instruments like marimbas and ukuleles, enhances the exotic atmosphere, setting a precedent for future films depicting tropical settings.
However, "Bird of Paradise" primarily serves as an aesthetic spectacle rather than a substantive narrative. The plot’s reliance on caricatured native customs, such as human sacrifices to volcanos, strains credulity even for contemporary audiences seeking escapism. While director Vidor effectively captures the allure of its stars amid picturesque locales, the film’s outmoded cultural representations and simplistic storyline render it more of an antique curio than a timeless classic. Despite these shortcomings, its romantic escapades and scenic charm still offer moments of swoon-worthy allure.
Total: 29
King Vidor's 1932 film "Bird of Paradise" is a classic Hollywood romance that epitomizes the lush, sweeping narratives of its era. This Blu-ray release marks a visual improvement over previous versions, delivering a clearer and more immersive video experience after years languishing in the public domain. The vibrant visuals capture the exotic allure of the setting, despite some noticeable imperfections. However, the audio quality often falters, detracting from the overall immersion and betraying the film’s age.
The plot, entailing an island love story with a primitive twist, feels undeniably dated, and modern viewers may find it thin and unsatisfying. Still, the performances from Dolores del Rio and Joel McCrea inject a degree of charm and vibrancy that provides some redeeming value for classic film enthusiasts. The Blu-ray disc itself is notably sparse in terms of additional content, lacking substantial extras or supplemental features that might have enhanced the package's appeal.
In conclusion, although "Bird of Paradise" suffers from outdated racial and gender attitudes and offers a corny, thin storyline, it remains a notable entry in Kino Classics' David O. Selznick series. The lack of value-extending extras is unfortunate, but the improved visual quality makes it worth considering for diehard classic cinema collectors. Supporting distributors like Kino who continue to release films from the early decades of cinema is commendable, ensuring such historical pieces remain accessible.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 70
Like most titles in the public domain, Bird of Paradise has been subject to some underwhelming home video releases in the past, so it's great to see that Kino Classics has given the film such a wonderful...
Audio: 50
Bird of Paradise is sometimes claimed to be the first talkie with a full-length film score, and while that's not exactly true, Max Steiner's lulling, Polynesia-influenced score is memorable, blending traditional...
Extras: 10
The only extras on the disc are high definition trailers for Pandora and the Flying Dutchman, Nothing's Sacred, and A Star is Born....
Movie: 60
Where many of Vidor's previous films--like The Crowd and The Big Parade--boasted a humanistic slant, a social realism that empathized with common people, Bird of Paradise is atypical, an epic wish-fulfillment...
Total: 60
Although King Vidor's Bird of Paradise is hokey and understandably outdated when it comes to racial and gender attitudes, it's also a prime example of the sort of lush, sweeping romance that Hollywood...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Lots of care, a sizeable bankroll, and meticulous restorative powers are necessary to bring films from the early 1930s and before up to Blu-ray standards, and the task is even tougher for public domain...
Audio: 20
The dynamic scale is limited, but when the music doesn't push the limits on either end of the spectrum, it comes across fairly well....
Extras: 0
Previews for 'Nothing Sacred,' the 1937 version of 'A Star Is Born,' and 'Pandora and the Flying Dutchman' are included....
Movie: 40
Eye candy is the raison d'etre for this film, which often seems like its sole purpose is to showcase its attractive stars wandering through the jungle half naked in a sarong and loincloth and smooching...
Total: 40
The island love story with a primitive twist can be visually arresting at times, but the corny story is thin and unsatisfying, and even the vibrant personalities of the stars can't successfully put it...
Director: King Vidor
Actors: Dolores del Rio, Joel McCrea, John Halliday
PlotJohnny Baker, an American sailor on leave in the South Seas, befriends a native islander named Kalama. During his visit, Johnny meets and falls deeply in love with Luana, the beautiful daughter of the island chief. Despite initial resistance from the islanders and cultural differences, Johnny and Luana's bond grows stronger. As their love deepens, they navigate the challenges posed by their differing backgrounds and the societal expectations placed upon them.
Tensions begin to rise when an insidious threat emerges, forcing Johnny to confront his own values and the extent of his commitment to Luana. Caught between his world and hers, he faces difficult choices that could seal their fates. Amidst the picturesque backdrop of the tropics, a story of profound love, sacrifice, and cultural clash unfolds. Ultimately, the lovers must decide whether to pursue their relationship despite overwhelming odds.
Writers: Richard Walton Tully, Wells Root, Wanda Tuchock
Release Date: 12 Aug 1932
Runtime: 80 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English, Hawaiian