The Sniper Blu-ray Review
神鎗手
Score: 50
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Sniper's Blu-ray offers striking visuals and an impeccable 7.1 audio track, albeit with minor center channel issues; extras are fleeting but insightful.
Disc Release Date
Video: 45
The Sniper's Blu-ray transfer, presented in 1080p and a 2.35:1 aspect ratio encoded with AVC, boasts stunning clarity and contrast but suffers from heavy edge enhancement, digital noise, and occasional crushing in dark scenes, making the visual quality fluctuate dramatically despite overall improvements over the DVD.
Audio: 60
The Sniper's Cantonese Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track delivers an immersive experience with excellent directional effects and a robust bass, though dialogue can sound slightly hollow. While the surround channels are mostly effective, the overall audio treatment is solid but not outstanding. The Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks, in both Cantonese and Mandarin, are generally unimpressive but serviceable.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray extras of 'The Sniper' offer an English-subtitled 1080p trailer, behind-the-scenes making-of featurettes split into multiple segments (480p, 16-15 min), and a collection of deleted scenes (480p, ~7 min), providing insightful character explorations, stunt preparations, and a few key plot extensions.
Movie: 51
The Sniper struggles with an underdeveloped plot and clichéd elements but is partially redeemed by its thrilling action sequences, authentic weapon replicas, and the impressive stylized cinematography by Cheung Man Po. However, it ultimately remains somewhat unremarkable despite a strong final shootout.
Video: 45
The Sniper arrives on Blu-ray with a 1080p image encoded using the AVC codec and presented in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio. This transfer strives to sustain a striking visual stylization akin to Ringo Lam's prior work. The film's contrast levels are skillfully managed, despite some scenes—in particularly dark sequences—being plagued by slight crushing in clothing textures and a minor loss of shadow detail. The vivid hues during daytime scenes, with bright blue skies and green grass, appear almost too vivid, while night sequences lean towards a more monochromatic palette under fluorescent lighting. This high-concept visual design is a departure from usual genre conventions, creating an impactful viewing experience though potentially polarizing to some.
However, this Blu-ray transfer presents inconsistencies in video quality that are rather puzzling. While parts of the film exhibit near reference-quality clarity, detail, and contrast, other sections suffer from heavy edge-enhancement, digital noise, and contrast boosting. These fluctuations can switch the film's appearance from stunning to average in mere minutes, without clear explanation. Despite these issues, the transfer avoids excessive digital noise reduction (DNR), preserving some filmic qualities with slight speckles and occasional print damage. Furthermore, there are no significant scratches, warps, or debris to detract from the overall presentation. Although this unevenness might be jarring to more sensitive viewers, it is undeniably an improvement over previous DVD releases and maintains a crisp and detailed allure during its more vibrant scenes.
Audio: 60
The Blu-ray of "The Sniper" provides an array of audio tracks: Cantonese Dolby TrueHD 7.1, Cantonese Dolby Digital 5.1, and Mandarin Dolby Digital 5.1. For this review, the emphasis was placed on the Cantonese Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track, which offers a comprehensive lossless experience. The action sequences, particularly the gun battles, are remarkably dynamic, with high-frequency effects delivering a piercing realism that envelops the listener from all directions. Discrete effects are meticulously panned across both the front and rear channels, creating an immersive auditory environment. Gunshots ring with remarkable clarity and their echoes resonate effectively within closed spaces, such as during the elevator shootout. The bass is robust, providing a powerful complement to action-packed scenes.
Despite its strengths, the Cantonese Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track falls slightly short of excellence in dialogue delivery. While speech is clear and intelligible, the center channel can occasionally present a slightly hollow timbre. This minor shortcoming does not significantly detract from the overall quality, which remains impressive. The surround channels are used adeptly, capturing the chaotic essence of film's numerous shootouts. Comparatively, the Cantonese and Mandarin Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks, while competent with strong bass and clear dialog, lack the intricacy and spatial detail found in the lossless 7.1 mix.
Overall, while not without minor faults, the audio presentation on this Blu-ray is strong and effective in delivering a gripping listening experience. It ably supports the film's intense action sequences with precision and vigor, ensuring an engaging acoustic environment that propels the viewer directly into the heart of the movie's adrenaline-fueled moments.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray release of "The Sniper" offers a modest yet informative set of extras, providing a decent behind-the-scenes look at the production. The "Making of" feature is particularly noteworthy, divided into multiple segments focusing on character development, directorial intentions, and stunt preparation. Despite being presented in 480p, it includes some compelling behind-the-scenes footage that stands out from standard EPK content. The deleted scenes add depth to the characters and plot, though they are non-subtitled and presented in standard definition. The inclusion of an original theatrical trailer is a welcome addition, showcasing the film's tone and style effectively. Overall, while the extras might not delve deeply into the film's complexities, they offer valuable insights into the movie's creation process.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: A glossy showing with English subtitles.
- Making of: Divided featurettes focusing on characters, direction, and stunts.
- Deleted Scenes: Add context to character arcs and plot developments.
Movie: 51
"The Sniper," directed by Dante Lam, is a stylistic yet uneven action film that struggles to connect on a narrative level. Clocking in at a brief 87 minutes, the film feels more like a live-action video game, complete with tactical missions, sniper scopes, and end-boss showdowns. While some character development is hinted at through the enigmatic appearances of Huang Xiaoming’s Lincoln, the film does not delve deeply into its emotional or psychological layers. Despite this, the movie is redeemed by its thrilling action sequences and the high-stakes final confrontation, reminiscent of classic showdown tropes but with an Eastern twist.
The plot follows top sniper Hartman (Richie Ren) and his ambitious protégé OJ (Edison Chen) as they track down a rogue ex-colleague, Lincoln, who blames the HKPD for his downfall. The narrative is punctuated by a series of frenetic shootouts and meticulous sniper setups, leading to an explosive climax in an industrial warehouse setting. Cinematographer Cheung Man Po adds a distinct visual flair, blending intense color schemes with dramatic shadow work, which accentuates the high-octane atmosphere of the film. However, the music score is forgettable and does little to enhance the film's tension or drama.
What stands out in "The Sniper" is its impressive array of weaponry and meticulously crafted replicas, thanks to the collaboration with military specialists. This attention to detail brings a heightened sense of realism to the firefights. Visual effects maestro Stephen Ma showcases his expertise particularly in the final act, delivering an exhilarating spectacle that unfortunately doesn't extend to the rest of the film. Though lacking in narrative depth and originality, "The Sniper" offers enough visual panache and action-packed sequences to engage action genre enthusiasts.
Total: 50
Dante Lam's "The Sniper" on Blu-ray primarily caters to enthusiasts of Hong Kong action cinema, showcasing some visually striking and stylistically apt scenes. The Blu-ray offers a satisfactory representation of the film's gritty aesthetic, though there is a consensus that the visuals, while good, could have been enhanced further. The audio quality is a standout, delivering a near impeccable 7.1 mix that immerses the viewer in the high-stakes environment, albeit with some minor issues relating to the cohesion of the center channel. This slight flaw does not significantly detract from the overall auditory experience, which remains engaging and dynamic.
The supplementary features, though brief, provide some intriguing behind-the-scenes content that highlights the actors' preparations and proficiency with firearms. These extras, while limited in scope, add value for those interested in the intricacies of film production and action choreography. The Blu-ray package manages to capture some of the more impressive shootouts effectively, ensuring that fans of visually driven action sequences will be satisfied with their portrayal.
In conclusion, while "The Sniper" may not reach the heights of other globally acclaimed Hong Kong releases, it does enough to cater to its target audience. The Blu-ray is worth a watch for aficionados of the genre who appreciate well-executed action scenes, despite its somewhat familiar narrative and limited supplemental content. For those particularly interested in the visceral experience of Hong Kong action films, this disc offers sufficient quality to merit a rental.
avforums review by Mark BotwrightRead review here
Video: 70
There are also possible hints of edge enhancement but this is well in keeping with the videogame stylings and extremes of the image as opposed to being distracting....
Audio: 80
Overall though this is a fine audio mix that is built on precise handling of the action sequences and its ability to thrill the viewer with crisp lossless audio that bounds from all directions....
Extras: 50
If you can look past the proud musings of the director and writer's high regard for the finished piece and its supposed complexities, there are some fantastic shots from behind the scenes showing actors...
Movie: 60
If it weren't for the thrilling action sequences, slow drip feeding of the viewer with the ambiguous Lincoln's appearances and the twist to the story that reveals all, this would have been a failure....
Total: 70
The audio on the other hand is impeccable regarding many of the criteria for a standout 7.1 track, with the caveat being a few questions regarding the cohesion of the centre channel which doesn't seem...
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 60
It really is quite puzzling to see that in a matter of minutes The Sniper could switch from looking incredible to looking average....
Audio: 80
Generally speaking, its basics are intact � the bass is strong, the high frequencies not overdone and the dialog crisp and easy to follow � but its dynamics are far from pleasing....
Extras: 40
The overwhelming majority of the comments here address the main characters and their placement in the film....
Movie: 50
There is hardly any mention in the supplemental features provided on this Blu-ray disc about these weapons, but director Lam and a team of military specialists spent a great deal of time making sure that...
Total: 50
There is no denying that a few of the shootouts in it are rather impressive, but everything else is painfully familiar....
Director: Dante Lam
Actors: Richie Jen, Xiaoming Huang, Edison Chen
PlotHartman Wu is a seasoned sniper with the Special Duties Unit in the Hong Kong Police Force. Known for his unparalleled shooting skills and calm demeanor, he prepares his team for any dangerous mission that comes their way. Meanwhile, a former top sniper, Lincoln, is released from prison after serving a sentence for a failed mission that resulted in his team being killed. Driven by a thirst for revenge against those he believes betrayed him, Lincoln sets out to exact his form of justice, leading to a personal vendetta against Hartman.
The escalating tension between Hartman and Lincoln draws the attention of OJ, a young and talented sniper who idolizes Hartman but is increasingly swayed by Lincoln's charismatic but dangerous influence. As OJ is torn between his loyalty to the law and Lincoln's rebellious ways, the city becomes a battleground for these highly skilled snipers. High-stakes confrontations, strategic mind games, and intense shootouts ensue as Hartman fights to bring Lincoln to justice and guide OJ back to the righteous path. The story builds towards a climactic showdown where the true cost of vengeance, loyalty, and the burden of past mistakes come to light.
Writers: Wai-Lun Ng, Dante Lam
Release Date: 09 Apr 2009
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese, English, Hokkien