The Conversation 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 89
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The 4K restoration of 'The Conversation' is technically stunning with strong detailing and standout soundtracks, making it a must-have release despite minor color grading concerns.
Disc Release Date
Video: 83
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of 'The Conversation' is a technically impressive restoration, utilizing a 4K scan of the original camera negative for the first time, with meticulous digital cleanup and HDR grading in Dolby Vision and HDR10, presenting a cinematic experience that aligns with Coppola's vision.
Audio: 93
The audio presentation of "The Conversation" on its 4K UHD Blu-ray features English 2.0 mono LPCM and a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio remix by Walter Murch, offering added sound effects to enhance the initial mono. While some effects are repurposed, new elements like transit sounds bring a fresh auditory experience.
Extra: 89
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of 'The Conversation' features expertly crafted sound options with a dynamic 2.0 track, showcasing its original theatrical mix, and a 5.1 remix with aggressive surround use. Coppola's commentary, blending personal memoir with insightful film analysis, offers depth into the film's thematic and technical intricacies.
Movie: 96
The Conversation, Coppola's intricately crafted masterpiece, offers a poignant character study of paranoia through Gene Hackman's mesmerizing portrayal of surveillance expert Harry Caul, utilizing subtle visual and aural cues, a brilliant score by David Shire, and expert editing to create a technically superb narrative that profoundly reflects the frailties of human condition.
Video: 83
Studiocanal's 50th Anniversary Limited Edition release of "The Conversation" on 4K UHD Blu Ray represents a meticulous effort to elevate the film's visual presentation. The transfer stems from the first-ever use of the original 35mm camera negative for any home video iteration of this classic, scanned in 4K by Roundabout Entertainment. Restoration supervisor James Mockoski's work at American Zoetrope was comprehensive, addressing frame-by-frame imperfections and eschewing global correction tools. The film, originally shot by acclaimed cinematographers Bill Butler and Haskell Wexler using Panavision cameras with spherical lenses, is presented in its intended 1.85:1 aspect ratio, maintaining the director's visual integrity.
The resulting UHD presentation embodies an exceptional balance of vintage film grain and modern digital clarity, enhanced by High Dynamic Range (HDR) grading. Both Dolby Vision and HDR10 bring enriched depth to the contrast, rendering shadows with exceptional detail and preserving the nuanced play of light critical to the film's tension. Notably, the restoration used a print approved by Bill Butler and received Francis Ford Coppola's endorsement, ensuring adherence to the original artistic vision. This iteration surpasses prior releases in both detail and authenticity, capturing the atmospheric nuances that define "The Conversation" as a suspenseful masterpiece.
Through their technical prowess and dedication, Studiocanal provides a Blu Ray experience that elevates the film's visual storytelling. This careful restoration and presentation echo the innovative techniques initially employed by Wexler and Butler, aligning with Coppola’s avant-garde narrative style. The release not only does justice to the historical relevance of "The Conversation" but also caters professionally to both cinephiles and collectors, reinforcing its significance within cinematic history.
Audio: 93
The audio presentation of "The Conversation" on the 4K UHD Blu-ray stands out with nuanced offerings that cater to varied preferences. The release provides English 2.0 mono LPCM and a newly-remixed English 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track, alongside options in German. The original theatrical mono mix remains available, preserving its vintage integrity, while the 5.1 remix brings a modern, spatial dimension to the sound experience, crafted by Walter Murch for Paramount's DVD release in 2000.
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio remix introduces subtle enhancements, aiming to enrich the auditory experience without compromising the film’s original ambiance. Added sound effects, such as the electrically dynamic arcing of the Muni transit system, complement the film's narrative tension and drama. However, it is worth noting that some sounds are repurposed from within the film itself, like the manipulated dog barking effect during the opening sequence. This decision underscores a respectful but cautious approach to sound augmentation, preserving the authenticity of Francis Ford Coppola's vision.
Overall, this audio presentation offers flexibility for audio purists and modern audiences alike. While the mono track maintains the film's historical authenticity, the intelligently executed 5.1 remix provides a richer auditory texture ideally suited for contemporary home-theater experiences. Appreciators of the film will find the updated soundtrack an effective balance between fidelity to the original and auditory enhancement.
Extras: 89
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "The Conversation" offers compelling extras that illuminate the film's intricate sound design and production context. Two distinct English soundtracks are available: a remarkably dynamic 2.0 track, likely the original theatrical mix, and a 5.1 remix supervised by Walter Murch, showcasing aggressive surround use. Each track beautifully highlights David Shire’s melancholic score, with precise dialogue and a stunning audio range. The included commentaries enrich the viewing experience further; Francis Ford Coppola’s commentary delves into his personal journey and creative process for the film, spiced with anecdotes about his collaboration with Walter Murch and perspectives on new recording technologies.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentaries: Engaging tracks recorded for the 2000 DVD release, providing personal insights from Francis Ford Coppola.
- Sound Mixes: Includes both the 2.0 original mono track and a 5.1 surround remix.
Movie: 96
Francis Ford Coppola's "The Conversation" is a chilling exploration of technology's encroachment on privacy and its effects on the human psyche. This masterful film deals with complex themes of surveillance and paranoia, reflecting the anxieties of a society becoming acutely aware of governmental overreach post-Watergate. Gene Hackman delivers a compelling performance as Harry Caul, a deeply paranoid surveillance expert. Tasked with recording a conversation between two people in a crowded environment, Caul finds himself embroiled in a sinister plot as the terms of his task shift unexpectedly. Hackman's portrayal of Caul's internal struggle—a man torn between professional integrity and personal guilt—is deeply resonant, revealing the frailties and contradictions of human nature.
Coppola's storytelling technique brilliantly manipulates the film's narrative perspective, creating an immersive experience where viewers unknowingly adopt Caul's viewpoint. The film’s subtle use of imagery and sound design draws audiences into Caul’s fractured perception, gradually exposing the themes inherent in his character. As tension mounts, Coppola masterfully guides viewers to a climactic revelation, using eight pivotal words to deliver an unexpected twist. The clever intertwining of Caul’s quest for truth and his emotional conflicts heightens the film’s intensity, ensuring that by the end, the audience is thoroughly invested in both the narrative and Caul’s personal journey.
Technically exquisite, "The Conversation" showcases a haunting score by David Shire and exceptional editing from Richard Chew and Walter Murch, artfully emphasizing the film’s structural layers and emotional undertones. While it may lack the mythic scale of Coppola's other masterpieces like "The Godfather," it stands as a testament to the director’s ability to meld character-driven storytelling with technical prowess, making it a profound reflection on modern-day existential dilemmas.
Total: 89
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Conversation" delivers a technically impressive and aesthetically compelling package that does justice to Francis Ford Coppola’s 1970s classic. The film thrives in its character-driven narrative, encapsulating a unique conspiracy thriller atmosphere that Coppola himself claims has never been replicated. The new 4K restoration stands out, particularly for its precise detailing and enhanced color grading, though some viewers might find the teal hues slightly off-putting. Nevertheless, the comprehensive addition of two exceptional soundtracks and a wealth of extras, including a remarkable new interview, superbly compensates for any minor visual grievances.
This limited edition release not only attracts loyal fans but also serves as a robust offering for new audiences discovering the film's timeless appeal. The retro analogue format of the soundtrack embodies a nostalgic charm that complements the aesthetics of the package. While the updated artwork might stir some debate within the physical media community, it undeniably adds a fresh layer to the set's striking presentation. Overall, this release stands as one of the most remarkable offerings of the year, with its stellar video and audio quality and abundant supplemental content.
In conclusion, nestled within an oeuvre full of cinematic masterpieces, "The Conversation" remains a defining work in Coppola’s career. Despite modern claims of "they don’t make them like this anymore," it's clear that Coppola's brilliance captured something unique and enduring even back then. The new 4K edition from Studiocanal elevates this experience, reinforcing its status as an indispensable piece for collectors and film enthusiasts alike. Available from July 15th, 2024, this edition is truly worthy of the film’s storied legacy and comes with the highest recommendation.
avforums review by Mark CostelloRead review here
Video: 80
The Conversation is being released by Studiocanal in a two-disc, region-free 4K and region B 1080p Blu-ray 50th Anniversary Limited Edition set, coming in one of the label’s usual big box releases, with...
Audio: 100
The new colour grade, while now obviously different from the previous one, is darker, but deeper, richer and much more realistic, adding further subtlety and nuance to the overall sense of detail now visible...
Extras: 90
It's completely free from any sibilance or hiss, with the all-important dialogue beautifully seated in the mix – even this particular element is hugely dynamic, with words purposefully lost in the mix,...
Movie: 100
It waits until almost the film’s very last minute to deliver a gloriously revealed about face that beautifully introduces the notion of the malevolent and insidious ways in which small cogs can play significant...
Total: 90
The new 4K restoration is strong in terms of detailing and most of its new colour grading… however the teal push that is present will prove off-putting for some....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 95
The completed restoration was then graded for High Dynamic Range in both Dolby Vision and HDR10 using a print that had been approved by the late Bill Butler as a reference, with Coppola approving the final...
Audio: 95
For example, there are some added sounds of a dog barking near the beginning of the opening zoom, but it’s a reworked version of the same barking from later on in the same shot when the Doberman appears....
Extras: 95
He also offers his thoughts about the cast and crew, including his fruitful collaboration with Walter Murch and his less successful one with Haskell Wexler, and explains some of the details like Harry’s...
Movie: 100
With literature, it’s relatively easy to define whether a work is being written from a first-person or third-person perspective through the choice of language; the use of first-person pronouns like “I”...
Total: 96
That doesn’t change the fact that this is a fantastic release, with stellar video and audio quality, copious extras, and striking packaging....
Director: Francis Ford Coppola
Actors: Gene Hackman, John Cazale, Allen Garfield
PlotExpert surveillance operative Harry Caul is renowned for his exceptional skill at audio spying and his commitment to privacy. His latest assignment seems straightforward enough: to record a conversation between a young couple as they meander through San Francisco's bustling Union Square. Armed with state-of-the-art technology and accompanied by his assistant Stan, Harry manages to capture a cryptic dialogue that hints at a potential tragedy. Obsessive about his craft and consumed by a past experience where his eavesdropping may have cost lives, Harry becomes fixated on deciphering the couple's ambiguous words, trying to determine their underlying meaning and intent.
As Harry delves deeper into the recording, layering sound upon sound to isolate phrases, he is plunged into a vortex of paranoia and moral ambiguity. Struggling with a guilty conscience and the fear of a repeat of his previous mistake, Harry begins to suspect that the couple may be in danger. His secretive nature, combined with the weight of potentially life-threatening information, strains his relationships with those around him, fueling his isolation. As he confronts his employers for more information, Harry finds that the stakes are higher than he anticipated, compelling him to make choices that risk his safety, his professional ethics, and his personal sense of right and wrong.
Writers: Francis Ford Coppola
Release Date: 12 Apr 1974
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English