Meet the Robinsons Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Meet the Robinsons stands out with its heartwarming story and stellar 3D presentation, though it falters slightly in the third act and is somewhat pricey.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
"Meet the Robinsons" Blu-ray presents a stunning video experience with its 1080p/24 AVC encoded 2D and MVC encoded 3D transfers. The 2D version offers vibrant colors, excellent contrast, and sharp detail, while the 3D version enhances depth and dimensionality, despite some minor ghosting. Both formats deliver exceptional clarity and engaging visuals, making it a standout among Disney's releases.
Audio: 74
Meet the Robinsons' Blu-ray offers an engaging DTS-HD Master Audio and PCM 5.1 experience, with dynamic soundscapes featuring deep bass, clear dialogue, and immersive directional effects. While the 3D and 2D audio mixes are virtually identical, they provide robust surround activity, enhancing the film's playful and poignant elements.
Extra: 63
Meet the Robinsons' Blu-Ray extras include a candid and engaging audio commentary by director Stephen Anderson, a detailed 'Inventing the Robinsons' featurette, and several unfinished deleted scenes. The package also offers the 'Keep Moving Forward' invention documentary, two interactive games, and music videos by Rob Thomas and the Jonas Brothers.
Movie: 78
"Meet the Robinsons" offers an engaging, whimsical tale for both children and adults, boasting a stunning digital transfer in both 2D (1.78:1) and 3D (1.85:1) formats, featuring PCM and DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1-channel soundtracks that provide a spatial, immersive experience. The release includes valuable extras like a 'making-of,' deleted scenes, and a director's commentary.
Video: 70
The new region-free Blu-ray release of "Meet the Robinsons" excels in both 2D and 3D formats. The 2D version, presented slightly opened out to an aspect ratio of 1.78:1, benefits from an immaculate 1080p/24 transfer using the AVC codec. The 3D version preserves the original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and is encoded with an equally flawless MVC encode. This harmonious transfer yields exceptionally sharp images that capture every intricate detail, from the unique hairstyles to the scales on the dinosaur. The color palette varies effectively to match the film's tone: bright and primary colors dominate the future sequences, while present-day scenes feature more subdued tones with a golden overtone. Blacks are deep and rich with excellent shadow detail, ensuring a visually engaging experience.
The 3D version notably enhances the film, given that it was initially designed with 3D in mind. The added dimensionality is both immersive and thoughtful, avoiding any gimmicky effects while creating an engaging viewing experience. Key scenes demonstrate significant depth, which is particularly compelling during sequences set in the future. Despite minor ghosting issues and some aliasing, the overall experience remains consistently arresting, with rich black levels, vibrant primaries, and excellent dimensionality retained throughout. Even with the tint of 3D glasses, color contrast and clarity stand out strikingly, edging towards reference quality.
In terms of technical performance, this Blu-ray release provides standout moments in both 2D and 3D formats. Textures are crisp, edges are sharply defined, and there is meticulous care in rendering details such as hair and environmental elements. While some minor flaws arise in later sections of the film—such as sporadic ghosting—the overall video presentation remains robust, making "Meet the Robinsons" an essential addition to any high-definition collection. This Blu-ray release elevates the visual storytelling effectively, demonstrating strong technical prowess and cinematic artistry.
Audio: 74
The audio presentation of "Meet the Robinsons" on Blu-ray, whether in 3D or 2D, is an impressive and immersive experience. Both formats feature well-crafted sound mixes, with the 2D version using an uncompressed LPCM 5.1-channel soundtrack from the original 2007 release, and the 3D version introducing a new DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1-channel mix. Though there is no perceptible difference between the two, they both provide a spacious and dynamic audio environment. The orchestral score by Danny Elfman, reminiscent of Carl Stalling's playful Looney Tunes compositions, is well-recorded, creating a wide and deep soundstage that extends to surround channels. This gives a dimensionality to the film’s sound field, particularly noteworthy in scenes featuring thunderstorms and dinosaur roars. Dialogue is clear and intelligible, though it could be more spatially integrated with atmospheric sound effects.
Technical performance shines with excellent dynamics, bold low-end output, and crisply defined high frequencies. Bass extension delves deeply to around 25Hz, adding a robust foundation to the overall sound design. The rear speakers are actively utilized to enhance the immersive experience, especially during sequences embracing the 3D effects. Directional effects are hyper-accurate, making pans transparent, albeit somewhat artificial. While the aggressive use of surrounds contributes to the lively and engaging mix, a slight critique lies in the occasional lack of sound effects which could better enrich the futuristic environments depicted in the film. Nevertheless, the playful score adds vibrancy, rounding out a robust and complete audio track.
In summary, "Meet the Robinsons" on Blu-ray offers a robust audio experience that matches its visual charm. The LPCM and DTS-HD Master Audio tracks provide an equally immersive and dynamic soundscape, making it a noteworthy upgrade for enthusiasts who appreciate finely tuned audio detail in animated features.
Extras: 63
The Blu-ray release of "Meet the Robinsons" offers an extensive selection of extras that enhance the viewing experience. Director Stephen Anderson's audio commentary provides a rich and engaging deep dive into the film's development, themes, and characterizations, with personal anecdotes that add a unique dimension. The "Inventing the Robinsons" featurette is an informative look at the production process, from its origins as a live-action feature to its final animated form, complete with insightful interviews and fascinating behind-the-scenes footage. The six deleted scenes, introduced by Anderson, reveal the creative decisions behind key changes and include a mix of storyboards and near-complete CG animations. Additionally, "Keep Moving Forward: Inventions That Shaped the World" offers a brief yet enlightening overview of historic inventions. The disc also includes two interactive games that, while simplistic, add a layer of fun. Two music videos by Rob Thomas and the Jonas Brothers round out the supplemental content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Stephen Anderson discusses the evolution of the film.
- Inventing The Robinsons: Behind-the-scenes look at the making of the film.
- Deleted Scenes: Six scenes with introductions from Anderson.
- Keep Moving Forward - Inventions That Shaped The World: Short documentary on historic inventions.
- Bowler Hat Barrage!: Interactive game.
- Family Function 5000: Family tree interactive game.
- Kids Of The Future Music Video by Jonas Brothers: Music video mixed with movie scenes.
- Little Wonders Music Video by Rob Thomas: Music video mixed with movie scenes.
Movie: 78
"Meet the Robinsons" is an engaging animated movie that effectively captures the imaginations of children and adults alike. The plot follows young orphan Lewis, a brilliant inventor, on a time-traveling quest to save the future with the help of the eccentric Robinson family. Though the movie's fluctuating tone and whimsical characters may seem scattered, this narrative style fits well within Disney's imaginative world. Notably, John Lasseter's influence played a critical role in salvaging and refining this touching story about perseverance and self-belief.
Technically, the Blu-ray release is impeccable. It includes both 2D and 3D versions on separate discs. The 2D version features a slightly expanded aspect ratio of 1.78:1, while the 3D retains the theatrical 1.85:1. Both formats boast pristine 1080p/24 transfers, utilizing AVC and MVC codecs respectively, ensuring stunning picture quality with vivid colors and exceptional detail. Equally impressive is the audio experience: the 2D version uses a PCM 5.1-channel soundtrack, while the 3D version offers DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1-channel. Both soundtracks deliver robust, clear dialogue, deep bass down to 25Hz in the LFE channel, and a highly immersive sound field.
While the storyline may not match the consistent brilliance of Pixar classics like "Toy Story" or "The Incredibles," "Meet the Robinsons" offers ample visual splendor and humor to keep viewers entertained. The film balances whimsical action scenes with more meaningful themes of loneliness and self-worth, providing a richer viewing experience for adults. Despite some pacing issues, the movie stands as a heartfelt tribute to Walt Disney’s enduring legacy of imaginative storytelling. This Blu-ray package enhances that experience with superior technical quality and thoughtful supplemental content.
Total: 71
"Meet the Robinsons" stands out among Disney's animated offerings over the past decade, presenting a heartwarming narrative fused with tough subject matter, quirky characters, and an engaging depiction of the future. The Blu-ray's 3D presentation is technically impressive, complemented by excellent DTS-HD Master Audio and LPCM 5.1 surround tracks, providing an immersive audio-visual experience. While the supplemental package enhances the offering, the inclusion of a few more newly produced special features could have elevated it further. Nonetheless, this release ranks highest among Disney's November 8th 3D editions.
The film's accessible time travel story caters to all ages, featuring memorable scenes and a positive underlying message. However, the Blu-ray 3D release exhibits a noticeable decline in quality during its third act. Despite this inconsistency, the package includes the 2D disc and DVD, making it a comprehensive collection. It falls short of achieving a perfect video score but remains a commendable effort. It's noteworthy that "Meet the Robinsons" offers near-demo quality for most of its duration, a significant improvement compared to earlier 3D discs that had only brief moments of excellence.
In conclusion, "Meet the Robinsons" as a Blu-ray offers a solid technical presentation and an enjoyable film experience. While the higher price point may be a consideration, the overall value provided by this release—especially when viewed in 3D—makes it a recommended addition for Disney fans and HD enthusiasts alike. With its combination of charm and technical prowess, "Meet the Robinsons" is undoubtedly a significant release in Disney's catalog.
avforums review by Steve WithersRead review here
Video: 80
Overall this is an absolutely reference picture in both 2D and 3D, with images that are beautifully animated with bold colours and exceptional detail, all of which means that Meet the Robinsons provides...
Audio: 100
The surrounds are used quite aggressively and when they are, the rear speakers direct sounds around the room, often in support of elements of the picture that are utilising the 3D very effectively, resulting...
Extras: 70
The scenes are presented through a combination of storyboards, black and white CG animation and fully rendered scenes, which gives you an idea of how near completion the film was before the changes were...
Movie: 80
Overall this is an absolutely reference picture in both 2D and 3D, with images that are beautifully animated with bold colours and exceptional detail, all of which means that Meet the Robinsons provides...
Total: 90
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
Spindly frog legs stretch into the distance, robot claws seem to extend out of the screen, hover cars dart in and out of the foreground, inventions protrude and retreat nicely, and the entire experience...
Audio: 90
It only helps that the audio is as immersive as it is, transporting the listener to the present, the future and the past in one stirring experience....
Extras: 90
Inventing the Robinsons (HD, 18 minutes): A fairly standard but nevertheless revealing featurette that charts the film's development from past to future to past to present, filling in some of the gaps...
Movie: 80
Meet the Robinsons drifts into kooky futuristic territory and has some trouble striking a consistent tone, but the plight of orphaned child prodigy Lewis is one of the sweeter, more touching and more relevant...
Total: 60
A few more special features would've been welcome, particularly newly produced exclusives, and the 3-disc set, like most Disney 3D releases, is a tad pricey....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Ghosting, for the most part, is very light and sporadic, with some very prolonged sequences of not a single ghost in sight, but by the end of the film, you can't escape the random misfires, as they add...
Audio: 80
The crisp dialogue is naturally spread across the front channels and sounds nice and even....
Extras: 40
This set includes a DVD that was not found in original pressings of the film, and was later a double dip to make a combo pack....
Movie: 80
Of course, like most films in its brethren, there's some subtext to the story as well, as lurking beneath the surface of the shiny futuristic setting is a dark tale of loneliness and self-worth....
Total: 80
This combo pack includes the 2D disc, as well as a DVD, making it a solid all-around release, but this one had potential for a five star video score, and botched it....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 92
This is a superlative high definition video presentation that boasts vivacious colors that are rich in saturation and bold in depth....
Audio: 88
Meet the Robinsons doesn't have the stirring emotion, endearing characters and compositional mosaic of some of Disney's more memorable/popular animated films but it's an entertaining and poignant family...
Extras: 60
Inventions that shaped the world - 6 minutes Bowler hat barrage interactive game Family function 5000: Family tree interactive game Music videos: Kids of the future by The Jonas Brothers, Little wonders...
Movie: 80
In an amazing twist, Lewis discovers that the fate of the future rests in his hands, but he can't save it alone - he'll need every bit of help he can get from the wonderfully wacky Robinson family, who...
Total: 80
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Stephen J. Anderson
Actors: Daniel Hansen, Wesley Singerman, Angela Bassett
PlotLewis is a young, brilliant inventor who lives in an orphanage. His latest project is the Memory Scanner, a machine designed to recover his earliest memories to find his birth mother who abandoned him at the orphanage's doorstep. Despite his intelligence, Lewis struggles with feelings of rejection and the fear that no one will ever want to adopt him. During the school science fair, an unforeseen disaster strikes, leading to the failure of his Memory Scanner. Disheartened, Lewis vows to give up on inventing, but his path takes a surprise turn when Wilbur, a mysterious boy claiming to be from the future, appears.
Wilbur convinces Lewis to embark on a journey to the future to restore Lewis's faith in himself and his inventions. In this futuristic world, Lewis discovers an eccentric family that defies his expectations of what a family could be, challenging his previous beliefs about his place in the world. The future holds wonders beyond Lewis's wildest dreams, filled with advanced technology and heartwarming eccentricity. However, lurking beneath this utopian veneer, there's a sinister plot that threatens the future. As Lewis gets further entangled in this adventure, he learns valuable lessons on perseverance, acceptance, and the true meaning of family, all while trying to unravel the mysteries of his own past and the key to saving the future.
Writers: Jon Bernstein, Michelle Bochner Spitz, Don Hall
Release Date: 30 Mar 2007
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: G
Country: United States, Japan
Language: English, Russian