Adaptation. Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Adaptation on Blu-ray is a clever, meta-comedy with engaging yet complex storytelling, maintaining its original performance but adding some noteworthy features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
Adaptation's Blu-ray presentation (1.85:1 aspect, 1080p, AVC) offers well-balanced hues, faithful skintones, and compelling detail with natural grain and deep blacks. Despite not being a new transfer, it features respectable clarity and definition, providing a realistic color palette akin to 1970s films.
Audio: 72
Aptly presented in 5.1 DTS-HD MA, 'Adaptation.' offers secure dialogue exchanges, respectful atmospherics, and satisfying low-frequency effects, though it maintains a primarily front-based soundstage with occasional immersive moments. Visuals are clear and natural with above-average black levels.
Extra: 33
Extras for the 'Adaptation.' Blu-ray include a short swamp shoot featurette (SD, 2:03), an image gallery (HD, 1:51), and the theatrical trailer (SD, 2:33). The special features are disappointingly minimal, lacking depth and new content, making it a tepid reissue for previous owners.
Movie: 86
Adaptation masterfully blends reality and fiction through Charlie Kaufman's neurotic struggle to adapt 'The Orchid Thief,' featuring Nicolas Cage's standout dual performance as Kaufman and his twin brother, along with Meryl Streep and Chris Cooper delivering exceptional, award-winning support.
Video: 76
The transfer of "Adaptation." on Blu-ray presents a satisfactory visual experience, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC and maintaining the 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Licensed from Sony and released by Shout Factory, the video quality holds up well considering it's likely based on an older telecine or 2K effort. The 1080p resolution ensures consistent detail and clarity throughout, with a fine, film-like grain structure that enhances its cinematic quality. Colors are well-balanced, capturing the varied moods of Florida's bright and vivid landscapes alongside the darker tones of Charlie's apartment life. Noteworthy is the accurate rendering of skin tones, from Susan's ivory white to John's deep tan, contributing to a natural visual authenticity.
Delineation and depth are particularly noteworthy; the film's visuals offer an expansive depth of field, with characters well-integrated into both interior and exterior environments. The overall definition permits a compelling inspection of facial textures and costuming details, adding to the immersive viewing experience. While the black levels are close to natural, exhibiting excellent usage in shadow-heavy sequences without significant crushing, grain may become marginally prominent in darker scenes but remains unobtrusive. The occasional softness is noted but does not detract significantly from the overall picture quality. Given its older source material, the image remains clean with negligible noise or artifacts.
Technically speaking, the AVC encoding on a BD-50 disc, combined with the original 35mm film elements in fine condition, ensures no major issues with motion distortions even during rapid movements. Although this transfer does not represent a significant upgrade over the previous releases, it stands as a small improvement due to the enhanced AVC encode by Shout Factory. Overall, this Blu-ray transfer maintains an engaging and technically sound presentation for "Adaptation.," delivering a reliable visual performance for both casual viewers and videophiles alike.
Audio: 72
The audio presentation of "Adaptation" on Blu-ray delivers a commendable listening experience with its 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix and a 2.0 DTS-HD MA stereo option. Dialogue is rendered crisply, maintaining secure and defined exchanges that respect the film's dramatic intent. Inner monologues are clearly articulated, enabling audiences to grasp whispered thoughts without straining. Carter Burwell’s score, enriched with satiric nuances, is effectively balanced with dialogue, adding depth to the overall auditory palette. Surround functionality is employed modestly, offering city bustle and natural swampland ambience that contribute to a sense of place without overwhelming the listener.
The soundtrack is devoid of flashy moments but fulfills its purpose with a solid and pedestrian soundstage. Occasional musical selections, such as "Wild Horses" by The Rolling Stones, burst forth with impressive fidelity and dynamic range. Low frequencies provide adequate support during action sequences, with noticeable impact during car crashes and other intense moments. The front-centric track benefits from ambient noises in the rear channels, enhancing the immersive experience.
The 5.1 mix does not seek to showcase grand demonstration potential but rather delivers a respectful and complementary auditory experience. The sound mix features good ambiance, with a swell balance of effects, vocals, and score that feel fluid and unrestrained. The low-end response is sufficient, registering weighty impacts where necessary. Overall, the audio experience is consistently engaging, providing a stable complement to the film's visual presentation. Optional English SDH subtitles are available in a white font to aid accessibility.
Extras: 33
The Blu-ray release of "Adaptation." includes a selection of supplemental features that, while limited in quantity, provide intriguing insights into the film's production. The core extra is a brief behind-the-scenes featurette showcasing footage from a demanding swamp shoot, emphasizing the cast and crew's dedication in challenging environments. Highlights include glimpses of Nicolas Cage embodying his character, though the featurette suffers from its brevity and lack of detailed explanations. Additionally, an image gallery and a theatrical trailer are part of the offerings, but they do not add significant depth or context to the film's acclaimed standing. Overall, while these extras may appeal to dedicated fans, they leave something to be desired in terms of comprehensive content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind The Scenes Shooting In The Swamp Featurette: Insights into the swamp shoot with cast interactions.
- Image Gallery: Poster art, film stills, and behind-the-scenes photos.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer for the film.
Movie: 86
"Adaptation" follows the tumultuous journey of Charlie Kaufman (Nicolas Cage) as he grapples with a myriad of personal and professional insecurities while attempting to adapt Susan Orlean’s “The Orchid Thief” into a screenplay. Directed by Spike Jonze, this film is a daring blend of reality and fiction that dissects the writer’s own neuroses through a layered narrative structure. As Kaufman’s life spirals amidst feelings of inadequacy and his twin brother Donald’s unexpected success with a derivative thriller script, the movie dials into the intricate interplay between inspiration and self-loathing, brilliantly portrayed by Cage.
Jonze’s direction is respectful yet playful, offering a controlled environment for Kaufman’s imaginative chaos. The film elegantly intertwines the true story of Orlean and her subject, John Laroche (Chris Cooper), with Kaufman’s anxious journey, converting personal demons into a meta-commentary on creativity itself. The seamless integration of fact and fiction, aided by impeccable performances—particularly Cooper’s Academy Award-winning portrayal—adds depth to what could have been mere comedic eccentricity. Streep's nuanced performance as Orlean further enriches the narrative tapestry, balancing the absurdity with emotional gravity.
Adaptation stands out as a unique endeavor that encapsulates the brilliance of Kaufman’s writing while maintaining accessibility in its complexity. Notably, Cage’s dual roles as Charlie and Donald distinguish themselves with clarity and finesse, adding layers to the film’s exploration of success and self-sabotage. The film's cleverness lies in its fearless examination of artistic struggle, where Kaufman's screenplay morphs into an adventure itself, filled with unexpected turns and self-reflective humor. Jonze’s approach allows these intricate dynamics to flourish, making "Adaptation" a must-watch for those appreciating films that challenge conventional storytelling while delivering unforgettable comedic moments.
Total: 67
The Blu-ray release of "Adaptation" stands as a testament to the creative prowess of writer Charlie Kaufman and director Spike Jonze. This film delves deeply into the labyrinthine mind of Kaufman's alter ego, Charlie, navigating his tumultuous and often humor-laden thought processes. The movie artfully straddles the line between a semi-comic narrative and an anxiety-ridden exploration of a writer's struggle with creativity. Jonze skillfully renders Kaufman's elaborate narrative techniques approachable, ensuring the film remains engaging despite its complex thematic undertones. While the final act meanders slightly with overt meta-commentary, the journey is an intellectually stimulating enigma.
Shout Select’s Blu-ray edition reintroduces this unique cinematic experience with a few enhancements from its previous release. Although visually and acoustically consistent with its predecessor, the inclusion of some previously unavailable features adds value for collectors and new audiences alike. The new slip cover with updated artwork provides an aesthetically pleasing bonus, though it may not warrant a repurchase for those who already own earlier editions.
In conclusion, "Adaptation" is a masterful piece of meta-comedy that remains relevant and thought-provoking. Whether you are a fan of Kaufman’s intricate storytelling or Jonze’s directorial finesse, this Blu-ray release is a worthy addition to any film aficionado’s collection—especially if you missed out on earlier editions. The added features and visual presentation ensure a fulfilling cinematic experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
The AVC encoded image (1.85:1 aspect ratio) presentation handles the moods of "Adaptation" satisfactorily, blending the brightness of Florida and California locations with the darker world of Charlie's...
Audio: 90
Scoring supports with satisfactory instrumentation and placement, while soundtrack selections are offered a bit more power, especially with percussion....
Extras: 40
Featurette (2:03, SD) is a brief look at the swamp shoot, highlighting the crew's effort to assemble shots, dealing with a potentially dangerous location and stunts....
Movie: 90
"Adaptation" follows Susan's experience with a Floridian man who's clearly intelligent and interested in the world around him, using habitual obsessiveness to create different careers over time, including...
Total: 80
He can't quite nail a final act, getting lost in the cutesiness of Donald and McKee's structural influence on Charlie with a cheeky finale, which goes on for too long, but the trip there is fantastically...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
Shout’s Blu-ray represents a small improvement over the Image disc, almost entirely due to the improved AVC encode....
Audio: 60
A score from Carter Burwell with satiric touches and nicely balanced dialogue exchanges are heard in the 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack....
Extras: 20
Shout Factory basically reissues the out-of-print 2012 BD from Image Entertainment (now known as RLJ Entertainment) without any significant new special features....
Movie: 100
The Oscar-winning screenwriter’s uniquely stunted and twisted style reinvents the traditional Hollywood screenwriting formula, often mocking it with moving and hilarious results....
Total: 60
Spike Jonze and Charlie Kaufman team up for a wildly inventive and magically clever meta-comedy made for thinking people....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 84
Black levels are above average and shadow delineation reveals good visible detail in backgrounds during low light sequences and within dark areas of the picture....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 80
Nicolas Cage is Charlie Kaufman, a confused L.A. screenwriter overwhelmed by feelings of inadequacy, sexual frustration, self-loathing, and by the screenwriting ambitions of his freeloading twin brother...
Total: 74
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-RS2000 4K Ultra High Definition Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 90
There’s a nice layer of grain that really helps keep it looking cinematic and flourishing in detail and definition....
Audio: 80
This is amore front based track, but it does add plenty in the rear with the ambient noises, especially out in the wild with insect sounds....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 80
Originality is a tough cookie in today’s Hollywood landscape, but the likes of Charlie Kaufman and Spike Jonze make it look easy still to this day....
Total: 70
I’m not sure if you have it already that this is a big upgrade, but if you don’t own it, this would be the one to get....
Director: Spike Jonze
Actors: Nicolas Cage, Meryl Streep, Chris Cooper
PlotA neurotic and self-doubting screenwriter struggles with the seemingly impossible task of adapting a non-fiction book into a screenplay. The book, "The Orchid Thief," is about the real-life exploits of a passionate orchid poacher in Florida. The screenwriter's difficulty stems from the book's lack of traditional narrative structure and his own personal crises, including his battles with writer's block, feelings of inferiority when compared to his more successful twin brother, and his longing for a romantic connection. The screenplay's progress is hindered by the protagonist's incessant self-reflection and obsession with the essence of storytelling, leading him to constantly question his abilities and the nature of creative adaptation.
Meanwhile, threads of the screenwriter's story intertwine with flashbacks depicting the book's content. The narrative explores the life of the orchid thief, his love for plants, and the depth of his obsession with the rare Ghost Orchid. It also delves into the backstory of the author of "The Orchid Thief," reflecting her experiences with the thief, her fascination with the beauty and intrigue of the orchid underworld, and her own personal desires. As the screenwriter becomes more engrossed in the book's world and the lives of its subjects, the boundaries between his screenplay, the book, and his reality begin to blur, mirroring the chaotic process of adaptation itself.
Writers: Susan Orlean, Charlie Kaufman
Release Date: 14 Feb 2003
Runtime: 115 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Latin