The Great Battle Blu-ray Review
안시성 Ansi-seong
Score: 61
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
"The Great Battle" combines impressive choreography and visceral action with solid technical merits, though its overstuffed narrative may not appeal to all.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
The Great Battle's Blu-ray presentation by Well Go USA features a sharp, detailed AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.39:1. While plagued by occasional banding and flattened black levels, it impressively showcases facial textures, vivid wide shots, and a primarily sun-drenched palette, enhanced by Phantom high-speed camera use.
Audio: 77
The Korean 5.1 DTS-HD MA track for 'The Great Battle' delivers an incredibly immersive experience with precise dialog placement, powerful surround usage, and dynamic LFE, though occasional limitations in low-frequency range prevent it from achieving sonic perfection.
Extra: 17
The Blu-ray extras of 'The Great Battle' provide a succinct yet informative package with a brief director and cast commentary, short character overview, and behind-the-scenes footage, complemented by teaser and standard trailers. The automatic follow-on trailers are standard for Well Go USA releases.
Movie: 63
The Great Battle offers a thrilling, though occasionally confusing, retelling of the legendary siege at Ansi; it combines epic CGI-laden action sequences, a charismatic cast led by In-sung Jo, and visual spectacle akin to *300*, despite some narrative flaws and historical liberties taken in the storytelling.
Video: 70
"The Great Battle" is presented on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer at an aspect ratio of 2.39:1, showcasing a sharp and well-detailed image despite the occasional banding that Well Go USA releases are known for. The digitally sourced image offers high resolution, drawing out facial textures with impressive clarity, including the grime in the pores of characters and intricate details on armor and weapons. Phantom high-speed cameras used for slow-motion elements contribute to the crispness of the presentation, although some contrast tweaks give a slightly blanched appearance in certain scenes.
The cinematography is particularly enhanced by the disc, with wide views of grassy plains and mountain fortresses being notably detailed. Primary colors such as costumes and blood pop against the generally dusty and earthy palette, which mostly consists of browns, beiges, and ochres. Night scenes with hearty fires bring out peak brightness, allowing armor and swords to glimmer realistically. However, black levels never fully turn over, occasionally leaving images looking somewhat flat with darkened gray as support, and leading to some compression artifacts in these dark areas.
Overall, this Blu-ray offers a vivid and well-suffused visual experience. The consistently good detail levels are occasionally masked by artistic framing but provide a compelling viewing experience nonetheless. The palette choices bring a vintage aesthetic, especially at night with scenes captured in warm, orange tones from flames, enhancing the historical ambiance. Despite minor technical quirks, "The Great Battle" remains a visually engaging and detailed presentation, highlighting Well Go USA's capability to provide an enriching home viewing experience.
Audio: 77
The audio presentation of "The Great Battle" on Blu-ray is a meticulously crafted 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix that delivers a robust and immersive experience. The Korean track stands out for its compelling and dynamic use of all six speakers, particularly during the film's numerous battle sequences. Dialog is well-centered and clear while the surrounds pulsate with the sounds of combat, enhancing the immersive atmosphere dramatically. The sonic landscape is filled with the chilling whizz of arrows, clashing swords, and distant screams, successfully creating a battlefield environment in your living room. The LFE channel, though not overly aggressive, is meticulously balanced; it provides a deep and precise bass that resonates with each booming impact or earth-shattering clash.
Alternatively, the English dubbed DTS-HD MA track offers a similar auditory architecture but falls short in the emotional resonance provided by the original Korean voices. Despite this, both tracks deliver an equally engaging mix filled with active surround channels and well-distributed background effects. Whether it’s the quiet moments or large-scale set-pieces, the audio engineering ensures every scene is richly detailed, enhancing the visual experience substantially.
In conclusion, while the soundscape in "The Great Battle" features bombastic action and engrossing surround activity, it could benefit from a more potent LFE presence to elevate certain dramatic moments further. Instances like horse stampedes and stone-slinging catapults impress with subwoofer activity but feel slightly restrained. Still, the overall clarity, balance, and attention to detail make this audio presentation a commendable effort that significantly augments the film’s gripping intensity.
Extras: 17
The extras included on the Blu-Ray of "The Great Battle" provide a brief yet insightful glimpse into the film’s production and narrative. Notably, the commentary from the director and cast offers in-depth perspectives, while the behind-the-scenes featurette showcases the filmmaking process. Although the production commentary is mislabeled, delivering a short EPK-like promo, it still adds value. The character featurette gives a concise overview of pivotal roles and story arcs. The teaser and main trailers seamlessly integrate into the viewing experience and auto-play as designed by Well Go USA.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio commentary from the director and cast: Insightful discussion on the film.
- Behind the scenes featurette: Filmmaking process highlights.
- Production Commentary: Brief promo with interviews (oddly named).
- About the Characters: Overview of key characters and storyline details.
- Teaser Trailer: Short promotional clip.
- Trailer: Extended film preview.
Movie: 63
"The Great Battle" offers an engaging and action-packed portrayal of the legendary siege of Ansi, where 5,000 Korean soldiers stood against the might of 200,000 men from the Chinese Tang empire. The film begins with a ferocious battle scene featuring the recruit Sa-mul (Nam Joo-huk) and then transitions to Commander Yang Man-chun (In-sung Jo), a seemingly traitorous leader revealed to be a steadfast protector committed to defending his people. This epic story is not only a tale of valor and resilience but also serves as a stirring dramatization of Korea’s historical folklore.
Director Kwang-shik Kim’s cinematography effectively utilizes large-scale practical effects and CGI to create striking battle sequences reminiscent of "300." The narration may confuse viewers unfamiliar with Korean history, but it becomes rapidly apparent who the heroes and villains are. The film successfully interweaves action with moments highlighting camaraderie, particularly between Man-chun and his lieutenants. While the frequent use of slow motion and CGI can appear excessive, they enrich the film's visual impact, providing thrilling spectacles of intense combat, flaming stuntmen, and dramatic swordplay.
Despite some secondary storylines that feel underdeveloped, "The Great Battle" keeps viewers engaged through its two-month build-up and subsequent skirmishes that maintain a relentless pace. Historical accuracy may be relaxed, but the film’s thrilling action scenes compensate for its lack of subtlety. Ultimately, "The Great Battle" is a well-constructed epic that mesmerizes audiences with its heroic depiction of outnumbered forces overcoming larger foes through sheer determination and strategic brilliance.
Total: 61
"The Great Battle" on Blu-ray is a compelling piece of cinematic artistry that excels in delivering visceral action and punctuated battle scenes. Directed by Kwang-shik Kim, the film has been likened to notable epics such as "300" and "Braveheart," albeit on a different scale. The movie's straightforward narrative approach, focusing more on survival rather than delving deeply into convoluted historical lore, renders it easily accessible for a broad audience. The Blu-ray release features a meticulously polished visual presentation with a 2.39:1 aspect ratio and impressive audio offerings, including DTS-HD MA 5.1 and DD 2.0 in both English and Korean. However, the extras are minimal, which is somewhat expected but still slightly disappointing.
Despite its straightforward storyline, "The Great Battle" occasionally ventures into a dichotomy of styles, balancing between intense action sequences and more reflective themes of duty and loyalty. This split might make it challenging for some viewers to fully engage with both aspects simultaneously. Nevertheless, the high-caliber fight choreography and strategically executed battle spectacles stand out as the film’s primary highlights. The ensemble cast, featuring In-sung Jo, Sung-woong Park, and Joo-Hyuk Nam among others, delivers strong performances that enhance the film's gripping narrative.
In conclusion, "The Great Battle" may not redefine the genre but holds its own with solid action, clear good-versus-evil portrayals, and a technically sound Blu-ray presentation from Well Go USA. Although it possess a few shortcomings, the film remains an exhilarating watch for fans of Asian action cinema, blending historical drama with spectacular, immersive battle scenes that guarantee both entertainment and visual thrill.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 80
I couldn’t find out much about the cameras or resolution of the master used for this release, but The Great Battle is a very nice looking Blu-ray that’s only major flaw happens to be the ubiquitous banding...
Audio: 90
Clarity and tonality of the low end is superb, as each hit and each wave of bass is unique and balanced, instead of being bloated and one noteish as can be the case with over cooked action tracks....
Extras: 20
Audio commentary from the director and cast • Behind the scenes featurette • Teaser Trailer • Trailers...
Movie: 80
The idea of a last stand carries with it a sense of bravery, honor, and awe that stems from wanting to root for the underdog....
Total: 80
I really enjoyed The Great Battle , and while it’s not some massive CGI epic like 300, or as inspiring as Braveheart , The Great Battle is a fun film that features some amazing choreography and visceral...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
I haven't been able to track down a ton of technical information on the shoot, other than that Phantom high speed cameras were evidently utilized for the ubiquitous slow motion elements, but one way or...
Audio: 90
The set pieces provide plenty of opportunity for excellent surround activity, but even in some of the quieter moments, the frame tends to be stuffed so full of characters that there's often a very engaging...
Extras: 20
About the Characters (1080i; 3:55) offers some brief information about some of the characters and the film's story....
Movie: 60
The Great Battle may well be kind of intermittently confusing for those without a background in Asian history, as mentioned above, but as I did background reading on the so-called "siege of Ansi" in preparation...
Total: 60
There seem to be two different films at play here, one action adventure epic and another, ostensibly more thoughtful, enterprise about duty and loyalty....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Beautiful cinematography is enhanced by way of this disc, especially wide views of grassy plains....
Audio: 80
The best moment comes as a dirt mound collapses, thundering and finally matched to the action’s size....
Extras: 20
For an additional 25 Great Battle screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 20,000+ already in our library), 60+ exclusive 4K UHD reviews, and more, support us on Patreon....
Movie: 60
Elements of loyalty feed the South Korean mood, subsiding current anxieties against the north through such a story....
Total: 60
Another in a line of South Korean historical epics, The Great Battle doesn’t rise above its generic name, but does have fine action....
Director: Kwang-shik Kim
Actors: Nam Joo-hyuk, Nazeeh Tarsha, Bae Sung-woo
PlotDuring the latter years of the Goguryeo era, a ferocious battle looms as the Tang dynasty, led by Emperor Taizong, plans an invasion to seize control of Ansi Fortress. The daunting task of defending this critical stronghold falls into the hands of Yang Man-chun, an unyielding and resourceful general. Despite limited resources and facing an imposing Tang army, Yang rallies his men with unwavering determination, creating a formidable defense strategy. Reinforcements from the central army are scarce, and skepticism about their survival permeates among his soldiers, yet Yang’s leadership instills hope.
As the siege ensues, Yang and his troops face relentless assaults from the formidable Tang forces. Utilizing clever tactics and displaying remarkable bravery, they manage to hold off wave after wave of attackers. Amidst the turmoil, bonds of brotherhood and loyalty are tested and deepened in the face of overwhelming odds. Despite the constant threat of betrayal and the weariness of prolonged combat, Yang’s strategic brilliance and unyielding spirit drive his men to exceed their limits. Their valiant efforts not only symbolize resistance but also a defiant stand for their homeland’s pride and honor against a seemingly unstoppable enemy.
Writers: Eui-Mok Jung, Kwang-shik Kim, Yoo-jin Kim
Release Date: 21 Sep 2018
Runtime: 136 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean, Mandarin