Hollow Triumph Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Hollow Triumph" uses an AVC encoded image with a 1.37:1 aspect ratio, marketed as a new HD remaster. This transfer does a commendable job of recreating the film's original theatrical presentation. Although the source material shows some signs of wear, such as mild scratches, speckling, and noticeable reel changes, it manages to retain a high level of clarity. The period cinematography benefits from this clarity, enhancing facial details and the texture of costuming. While there is some softness, it remains within acceptable limits, preserving the film's authentic feel. Notably, the delineation handles the limited lighting conditions effectively, though some banding is present.

The film's age is respected in this 1.33:1 1080p transfer, which is rated as "Newly Mastered in HD." The sourced print is in relatively good condition for its time, with speckling visible throughout and only a few significant scratches. Detail levels are strong, albeit with occasional softness in certain scenes. The black and white greyscale presentation offers substantial shadow separation and deep blacks along with balanced whites. Contrast control is adeptly managed, ensuring there are no hyper whites or blown-out areas. While this may not be the pinnacle of HD restorations, it certainly serves the film well, providing a suitable visual experience that remains faithful to its era.

The audio presentation of "Hollow Triumph" on Blu Ray features a solid English DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono track, exemplary of period aural craftsmanship. Dialogue is clear and front-centered, though it occasionally lacks precision; this allows for open interpretation while preserving the performances. The scoring is sharp and moody, successfully conveying suspense and dread with effective volume control, although it lacks some edge. Sound effects are prominent, with snappy gunshots and other effects contributing to the atmosphere, effectively layering in environmental elements to enhance the viewing experience.

Notably, while the track is generally dynamic and immersive, minor hiss and pops are present throughout the film. These imperfections, however, are non-intrusive and expected in restorations of films of this age. Overall, this audio track does an admirable job of maintaining the film's original sound characteristics while providing a clean and engaging listening experience suitable for modern audiences.

The extras included with the Blu-ray of "Hollow Triumph" are somewhat limited but noteworthy for those interested in film history. The highlight is the audio commentary by Imogen Sara Smith, which provides insightful analysis and contextual background that adds significant value to the viewing experience. The package also features a selection of theatrical trailers for other classic films, which complement the main feature nicely and provide additional vintage entertainment. While it would have been beneficial to include the theatrical trailer for "Hollow Triumph" itself, the existing extras are a commendable effort to enhance the disc's appeal.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary with Film Historian Imogen Sara Smith: Insightful commentary providing contextual background.
• He Ran All The Way: Theatrical trailer in HD.
• Boomerang: Theatrical trailer in HD.
• Shield For Murder: Theatrical trailer in HD.
• Cry of the City: Theatrical trailer in HD.
• 99 River Street: Theatrical trailer in HD.

Steve Sekely's 1948 noir thriller, The Scar (originally titled Hollow Triumph), is a masterful exploration of identity, paranoia, and the relentless ambition of its protagonist. Paul Henreid, who also co-produces, delivers a compelling performance as John Muller, a recently paroled criminal. Henreid's portrayal of Muller is exquisite; he brings to the fore the character’s sharp intellect and inevitable self-sabotage. Sekely's direction sets a dark, shadowy playground typical of film noir, enhanced by a restless screenplay from Daniel Fuchs, based on Murray Forbes' novel. The tone is expertly maintained to keep viewers guessing as Muller spirals deeper into his web of deception.

The plot kicks off with Muller botching a casino robbery, putting him under the relentless pursuit of armed goons. Muller's only escape hinges on his uncanny resemblance to Dr. Bartok, a respectable therapist with a prominent facial scar. Henreid’s character engages in intricate schemes that make the audience both root for and pity him as he navigates quicksand-like circumstances. Along the way, Muller becomes entangled with Evelyn, Bartok’s assistant (played by Joan Bennett), adding layers of romantic tension and moral complexity. Despite the seemingly fantastical elements, the story retains a sense of grim realism facilitated by Sekely’s meticulous direction and Henreid’s layered performance.

While The Scar is atmospheric and rich in suspense, some of Muller's schemes might strike viewers as overly complex or poorly thought out. This aligns with the film's broader theme: no matter how cunning a person may be, inherent flaws can lead to downfall. Despite occasional narrative softness, the film maintains its grip on the audience, who find themselves paradoxically hoping for Muller’s success even as his strategies unfold. Supporting performances, particularly from Bennett, enhance the film’s textures and layers, making it a noteworthy entry in the noir canon worthy of its engaging mysteries and moral questions.

"Hollow Triumph," also known as "The Scar," demonstrates Paul Henreid's adeptness in dual roles, capturing the essence of classic film noir. Directed by Steve Sekely, the film skillfully employs chase sequences and snapshots of Los Angeles to maintain an engaging pace. These elements contribute significantly to the film's immersive atmosphere, while meticulous cinematography captures the genre’s signature mysterious allure. Henreid shines in his portrayal of a character torn by duality, lending depth to the suspense-laden narrative.

Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Hollow Triumph" is commendable, offering a notable A/V presentation that brings the visual starkness and shadow play to life with remarkable clarity. The film’s restoration respects its original aesthetic, while the enhanced audio ensures that the score and dialogue are crisply delivered. Supplementary features include an insightful audio commentary, adding a layer of appreciation for noir aficionados and general audiences alike. This attention to detail underscores Kino Lorber's commitment to preserving and elevating classic cinema.

In conclusion, although "The Scar" may not stand as the quintessential example of the noir genre, it excels in delivering suspense and engaging performances, particularly from Henreid. The robust storyline and steady direction make it a worthwhile addition to any crime thriller collection. With Kino Lorber's high-quality Blu-ray edition, "Hollow Triumph" achieves an added layer of timelessness and accessibility, undoubtedly making it worth a watch.