Throw Down Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Throw Down" by Eureka Entertainment is a significant upgrade from older versions, primarily due to being sourced from a recent 4K master. Encoded with MPEG-4 AVC and presented in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, the 1080p transfer delivers excellent contrast and sharpness. The improved density and surface refinement in darker scenes is especially notable. Earlier issues with shadow definition, which created black blocks and blurred backgrounds, are now resolved, enhancing the intricate details and depth crucial for the movie’s aesthetics. The color balance and stronger encode presence rectify prior saturation inconsistencies, producing a more accurate and stable image.

Black levels are deep and maintain visual integrity even in the film's numerous dimly lit scenes inside various clubs. The color reproduction stands out with vivid storefronts, billboards, and clothing, particularly excelling in reds. Flesh tones appear natural and balanced throughout. There are no intrusive artifacts such as banding or pixilation, maintaining the integrity of the 35mm source with a pleasing grain structure. This masterful transfer will undoubtedly satisfy viewers, especially when displayed on larger screens where the improvements and finer details are more pronounced. Note that this is a Region-B locked Blu-ray, requiring compatible playback equipment for access.

The Blu-ray release of "Throw Down" features two standard audio tracks: Cantonese LPCM 2.0 (48kHz/24-bit) and an English LPCM 2.0 dub. Optional English subtitles for the main feature appear seamlessly within the image frame when activated. Both audio tracks deliver a surprisingly strong performance, with particular praise given to the original Cantonese LPCM 2.0 track. This track impresses with its clarity, sharpness, and depth, offering a balanced dynamic range that exceeds previous releases. Past editions, such as the Kam & Ronson Enterprises 7.1 remix, suffered from dramatic dynamic spikes, but this 2.0 track is far more consistently balanced, providing a refined listening experience.

The LPCM 2.0 soundtrack stands out in its ability to create an expansive auditory space despite its stereo configuration. Martial arts scenes and hand-to-hand combat sequences are rendered vividly, positioning the listener right in the middle of the action without any sense of audio crowding or competition for front speaker placement. Dialogue reproduction is equally commendable, with levels that are clean, clear, and crisp throughout. Though the English LPCM 2.0 dub was available, reviewers consistently leaned towards the original Cantonese version for a more authentic and immersive experience.

The Blu-ray extras for "Throw Down" offer a comprehensive and engaging deep dive into Johnnie To's tribute to Akira Kurosawa. Standout features include two insightful audio commentaries: one by Asian film expert Frank Djeng, discussing production intricacies like the wire-free action choreography and the visual aesthetics, and another from the DVD era by Ric Meyers and Djeng, enriched with humorous anecdotes and detailed analyses of To's directorial methods. Also notable is an extensive interview with To himself, shedding light on the movie's conceptual evolution and thematic underpinnings. The "Making of" featurette offers raw behind-the-scenes footage and interviews, while vintage TV spots and a 24-page illustrated booklet furnish additional contextual layers to the film's reception and stylistic nuances.

Extras included in this disc:

• Making of: Standard featurette with raw footage and interviews.
• Audio Commentary One: By Frank Djeng, exclusive for Eureka Entertainment.
• Audio Commentary Two: By Ric Meyers and Frank Djeng from the DVD era.
• Johnnie To Interview: Archival video detailing the film's evolution and themes.
• TV Spots: Vintage TV spots with interviews.
• Booklet: Illustrated booklet featuring essays by David West and Simon Ward.
• Cover: Reversible cover with original poster art.

Johnnie To's 2004 film Throw Down arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Eureka Entertainment, offering a unique blend of homage to Akira Kurosawa and contemporary Hong Kong cinema aesthetics. Set against the neon-lit backdrop of downtown Hong Kong, the film explores themes of redemption and self-discovery through its three main characters: Sze-To (Louis Koo), a disillusioned former judo champion turned club owner; Tony (Aaron Kwok), an eager drifter aspiring to prove his judo prowess; and Mona (Cherrie Ying), a hopeful singer looking for her big break. The narrative skillfully oscillates between Sze-To’s poetic recollections and intense judo confrontations, painting a multifaceted portrait of each character’s struggle for purpose in a city teeming with hidden perils and fleeting emotional connections.

Visually, Throw Down is a masterstroke. The film's cinematography bathes viewers in lush neon lights, transforming the city's gritty textures into a mesmerizing urban tapestry. The fights, choreographed with almost balletic precision, add an elegant yet raw dimension to the narrative. Peter Kam's evocative score complements the visual dynamism by accentuating both moments of quiet reflection and explosive action. While Tony’s encounters with imposing adversaries and Sze-To's introspective journey add depth, Mona’s character draws parallels to Chungking Express, injecting a sense of whimsical melancholy.

Despite its superficial sheen of style, Throw Down also delves into profound emotional territory. Some critics find it meandering with a heavy reliance on visual flair over substantive storytelling, but others appreciate its meditative pacing and intricate character interplay. Whether seen as a tribute to Kurosawa’s storytelling or as an original narrative filled with idiosyncrasies, Throw Down stands out as one of To’s most complex films. It not only won the Golden Horse Award for Best Screenplay but also endures as an affecting cinematic piece that resonates both visually and emotionally.

Eureka Entertainment's recent Blu-ray release of Johnnie To’s "Throw Down" delivers a laudable presentation that significantly enhances the viewing experience of this atmospheric film. This edition utilizes a pristine 4K master, resulting in a visually stunning transfer that captures the film's stylistic nuances and complex narrative brilliantly. The video presentation is superb, ensuring that each scene's mood and intricate details are vividly brought to life. The rich and expressive visuals are complemented by outstanding audio quality that adds depth and immersion to the overall film experience.

Special features on this Blu-ray release are indeed impressive, providing fans with in-depth insights and behind-the-scenes content that enriches their understanding of the film. While "Throw Down" may not resonate with everyone due to its specific stylistic and narrative choices, this release stands out as an exemplary edition for aficionados. Those unfamiliar with Johnnie To's work might approach with caution, as it is a sophisticated and highly stylized piece that might not cater to all tastes. Regardless, this release ensures that those who admire the film have access to the best possible version.

Dedicated to the great Akira Kurosawa, Johnnie To's "Throw Down" is a deeply atmospheric film that many consider to be one of the Hong Kong auteur's best. I have to agree. It is quite complex but not overwhelming and very stylish. This recent release from Eureka Entertainment is sourced from a gorgeous 4K master that offers exactly the type of solid presentation I always thought the film deserved. It was quite a treat to revisit it. Hopefully, the guys at Eureka Entertainment will consider bringing to Blu-ray more films from Milkyway Image's catalog. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.