Frailty 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Collector's Set
Score: 88
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Frailty’s 4K UHD Blu-ray delivers secure technical merits, outstanding supplements, and handsome packaging, earning strong professional praise.
Our Stores
Our stores are dedicated, independent and share our values and love for physical media.
Video: 88
Frailty’s 4K UHD transfer offers a significant improvement in color palette with Dolby Vision/HDR highlights, although heavier grain is more noticeable; blues and reds are more vivid, but HDR does not dramatically enhance shadow detail in darker scenes.
Audio: 88
Frailty's new Atmos mix offers regular surround channel engagement with intermittent ambient effects and some overhead activity in key scenes; while not highly layered or nuanced, dialogue remains consistently clear.
Extra: 90
Both discs feature a comprehensive set of legacy and new extras—including three commentaries, in-depth featurettes, restored trailers, deleted scenes with optional commentary, galleries, and a script reproduction—housed in a well-designed DigiPack with digital copy.
Movie: 81
Lionsgate’s 4K UHD release of ‘Frailty’ features a new transfer for both 4K and 1080 discs, enhanced supplements, and a collectible booklet with Paxton’s handwritten notes, making it a technically impressive and thoughtfully curated edition.

Video: 88
Frailty's 4K UHD Blu-ray video presentation, mastered from a new 4K restoration and encoded in HEVC/H.265 at 2160p with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, offers a notable improvement over previous releases. The transfer presents heavy but mostly organic grain, which is more pronounced due to the heightened resolution—this will likely be a point of contention for those sensitive to grain, though it adheres to the film’s original texture. Occasional anomalies are visible, such as isolated moments with slightly muddy appearances—most notably around the 21-minute mark where grain combines with background detail for an uneven look. Still, these instances are infrequent.
The new 4K and accompanying 1080p discs both benefit from significant improvements in color reproduction and palette accuracy over Lionsgate's earlier Blu-ray edition, which suffered from digital harshness and pushed red tones with increased brightness. The application of Dolby Vision and HDR grading is impactful yet subtle, bestowing more natural and compelling highlights throughout. Blues, especially during early interrogation scenes and flashbacks, and reds in memory sequences are now vibrant and well-saturated. The iconic backlit blues in key scenes gain notable depth and intensity on the 4K disc, while interior greens acquire a richer emerald-to-jade character. Shadow detail generally benefits from the HDR grade, though some of the darkest scenes maintain average black detail without dramatic enhancements. Overall, this UHD transfer delivers a faithful and visually dynamic viewing experience that corrects past shortcomings, leveraging modern HDR technology for added nuance without undermining the film’s authentic visual style.
Audio: 88
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Frailty" features a newly crafted Dolby Atmos audio mix. While the original soundtrack was not known for extensive sound design or dynamic layering, this new mix introduces a broader surround engagement. Surround channels are utilized for intermittent ambient environmental effects and musical scoring choices, adding a subtle sense of immersion and spatial dimension to the presentation. Notably, the mix attempts to incorporate overhead activity in key scenes—especially those involving the axe—offering listeners a more enveloping experience typical of contemporary Atmos tracks, though without overt showmanship.
Dialogue reproduction stands out, with voices presented cleanly and intelligibly, ensuring that critical narrative beats are never lost amid the film’s restrained sonic environment. While not as aggressive or intricately layered as more modern Atmos soundtracks, this mix provides a considered upgrade in soundstage and environmental presence compared to earlier encodings. Optional English and Spanish subtitles are included for accessibility.
Extras: 90
Lionsgate’s 4K UHD release of "Frailty" delivers a comprehensive set of extras, appealing to both new viewers and long-time fans. Newly produced content spotlights Bill Paxton’s directorial vision and legacy through interviews and anecdotes, while technical coverage details the new 4K restoration and Atmos mix. The package also faithfully ports over a substantial slate of legacy features, including multiple audio commentaries, in-depth making-of featurettes, storyboards, and deleted scenes with optional director commentary. The physical release is bolstered by attractive packaging—echoing an "American Gothic" aesthetic—and includes a reproduction of the shooting script and a digital copy. This thoughtful selection of supplements provides a thorough look behind the film’s production and ongoing legacy.
Extras included in this disc:
- Father Figure: Documentary exploring Bill Paxton’s career and impact, with archival and new interviews.
- Establishing Shot: Overview of the 4K restoration process and Atmos soundtrack creation.
- More Stories from the Frailty Set: Additional cast and crew anecdotes from recent interviews.
- Teaser Trailer: Original promotional teaser.
- Theatrical Trailer: Full-length theatrical preview.
- Audio Commentary with Director Bill Paxton
- Production Audio Commentary with Editor Arnold Glassman, Producer David Kirschner, and Composer Brian Tyler
- Audio Commentary with Writer Brent Hanley
- Anatomy of a Scene: Sundance Channel featurette dissecting a sequence from the film.
- The Making of Frailty: In-depth documentary about the film's production.
- Deleted Scenes with Optional Director Commentary
- Storyboard Gallery: Collection of original storyboards.
- Photo Gallery: Selection of behind-the-scenes images.
- TV Spots: Vintage television advertisements for the film.
- A reproduction of the script with director’s notes
- Digital Code
Movie: 81
Lionsgate’s new 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Frailty" provides a visual and archival upgrade for Bill Paxton’s well-regarded directorial debut. The package includes both 4K and 1080p discs, with the 1080p disc featuring an all-new transfer and alternate set of supplements compared to its earlier 2009 release. Of note is the meticulous packaging, which presents a perfect-bound booklet that contains the shooting script, highlighted by what appear to be Paxton’s own handwritten notes—giving insight into his creative process and further increasing the set’s appeal for collectors and cinephiles.
The film itself continues to benefit from critical appreciation, not only as a tightly executed psychological thriller but also as a showcase of Paxton’s skills both in front of and behind the camera. This edition stands out not just for its upgraded visual presentation but for the contextual value delivered through its unique physical supplements. Those familiar with the previous Blu-ray release will appreciate that both the 4K and new 1080p transfers offer a fresh visual experience, addressing legacy limitations and making this edition especially relevant for dedicated fans of the film or those newly discovering Paxton’s dark, atmospheric work.
Total: 88
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Frailty" stands out as a technically impressive and thoughtfully curated edition of a cult psychological thriller. The film, often underappreciated, receives a meticulous transfer with secure technical merits, ensuring image clarity and fidelity that respect the original cinematography’s moody palette. High Dynamic Range implementation enhances shadow detail and subtle color distinctions, preserving the film’s unsettling atmosphere. Sound is presented with full-bodied spatial effects and clean dialogue reproduction, further immersing viewers in the chilling narrative. Packaging is described as visually appealing and robust, lending additional value for collectors.
This release notably features a compelling slate of supplemental material. Of particular interest is the inclusion of interview content where it’s revealed that James Cameron influenced a key narrative reveal through pre-release feedback—a thoughtful detail that enriches fans’ understanding of the film’s editing choices. The mix of technical achievement and curated extras demonstrates a commitment to both casual viewers and enthusiasts seeking deeper engagement.
In conclusion, this 4K UHD release of "Frailty" delivers a reference-quality upgrade for home viewing, balancing top-tier audiovisual performance with insightful supplements and elegant packaging. It revitalizes a deserving genre title with the care required to appeal to both new audiences and longtime fans, cementing its status as an essential collector’s edition.
Video: 96
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Audio: 94
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Extras: 100
More Stories from the Frailty Set • Teaser Trailer • Theatrical Trailer Legacy Special Features: • Audio Commentaries with Director Bill Paxton and Writer Brent Hanley • Production Audio Commentary with...
Movie: 80
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Total: 93
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
- Read review here
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey Kauffman
Video: 90
Ken wasn't especially enthused about Lionsgate's now pretty ancient 1080 release, and specifically mentioned some digital noise reduction in the opening two acts, and maybe just a bit ironically, then,...
Audio: 90
Frailty has been granted a new Atmos mix, and while what Ken referred to in his review as a lack of actual sound design layering and nuance, there is regular engagement of the surround channels throughout...
Extras: 100
Father Figure (HD; 34:02) is an interesting overview that focuses on Paxton, and which includes both archival and newly shot interviews....
Movie: 90
Lionsgate released a 1080 version of Frailty way back in 2009, and now their boutique etailer Lionsgate Limited is revisiting the film in a handsomely designed edition that includes both 4K and 1080 discs...
Total: 90
I will admit that in my seemingly inescapable role as "twist guesser" I had figured out at least the general outlines of the "one two punch" the film delivers at its climax, but in that regard, it's really...
- Read review here
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt Brighton and Christopher Bligh
Video: 90
This is the first time the film has been shown in 4K and having said that, the transfer is best in it’s darker shots and the light is nicely displayed without any over-saturation of color....
Audio: 90
The score was not overbearing like most desperate scare horror films and it comes across very clear throughout the front and the back speakers....
Extras: 80
Makes perfect sense… More Stories from the Frailty Set – This piggybacks the first supplement with the same crew of folks as they, as the title would suggest, give us some anecdotes from the film....
Movie: 0
This particular one was directed by a little known actor at the time who had a few film credits and was most noted in a bit role in Stripes and would go on to be a part of one of the biggest movies of...
Total: 70
From it’s intriguing setup at the start to the final minutes in the end, Frailty gives something refreshing to a genre that’s been laden with special effects for scares to giving subtle touches and recalling...
Director: Bill Paxton
Actors: Bill Paxton, Matthew McConaughey, Powers Boothe
PlotA troubled man named Fenton Meiks walks into an FBI office late at night, claiming to have crucial information about the notorious "God’s Hand" serial killer who has eluded authorities for years. He insists on speaking with Agent Wesley Doyle alone and reveals that he knows the killer's identity. Fenton recounts a disturbing story from his childhood, set in a small Texas town. After the death of their mother, Fenton and his younger brother Adam were raised by their widowed father, whose sudden religious visions lead him to believe that God has chosen their family to destroy demons disguised as humans. Their father impresses upon his sons the sacred duty of carrying out these divine judgments, making them parties to terrifying rituals.
Fenton narrates how their father’s increasingly fanatic behavior begins to blur the line between good and evil, testing both boys in different ways. Adam quickly accepts their father’s claims, embracing his role without question, while Fenton becomes horrified and resistant, fearing for their sanity and safety. As the father’s mission grows more violent and consuming, Fenton struggles under the weight of his secret, desperate to find a way to save himself and his brother from a cycle of violence justified in the name of faith. The family’s tightly held secrets, twisted loyalties, and mounting body count lead Fenton to take a drastic step that will forever alter their lives and set in motion the events that connect to the present-day investigation.
Writers: Brent Hanley
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Germany
Language: English