We, the Marines 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Engaging film with excellent audio and visuals, and immersive IMAX footage.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 84
We, The Marines offers a visually stunning presentation, balancing sharp details and vibrant colors in both UHD and Blu-ray, despite minor flaws.
Audio: 77
Dolby Atmos enriches immersion with precise sound placement and atmospherics, enhancing 'We, the Marines' through detailed audio, though slightly lacks low-end punch.
Extra: 60
We, the Marines" features both Blu-ray and Ultra HD editions, including trailers exclusive to UHD, a 21-minute in-depth behind-the-scenes addendum on Marine life, and a digital copy, encased in a standard slipcover.
Movie: 70
We, the Marines" narrated by Gene Hackman, offers an insightful yet concise tribute to the US Marine Corps' dedication, training, and significant role in history and modern defense, highlighted by exceptional footage and a focus on the unity and sacrifice of Marines.
Video: 84
We, the Marines," rendered from a 4K DI and originally filmed using a 15 perf. 70 MM negative for IMAX theaters, delivers an exceptional Ultra HD presentation, particularly striking on large screens. The video quality shines through with a lifelike reproduction of textures and details, from the meticulous construction of military uniforms and weaponry to the majestic views of training landscapes. The clarity and depth of image bring an immersive experience, with even the minutiae of skin details and wear on weapons presented with razor-sharp precision. The large-screen 1.78:1-framed visuals maintain color accuracy and detail consistently throughout the presentation, although there's a minor flaw with some banding in the Blu-ray version. Natural elements like greens and blacks are rendered with accuracy, contributing to a visually striking big-screen feel.
The UHD format provides the option between HDR and SDR color presentations, with HDR substantially enhancing the viewing experience by offering bold, intense colors without over-saturation, akin to those in "National Parks Adventure." This version excels in delivering a palpable sense of depth and a more sophisticated tonal dynamic that significantly elevates the material. The HDR color brings landscapes to life with remarkable intensity, particularly benefiting scenarios requiring high contrasts and vibrant colors. Despite a few issues like halos in certain shots and an unnatural look in some aerial views due to non-IMAX footage, the overall sharpness and texture detail, from Marine uniforms to natural landscapes, are impeccably defined.
However, the presentation is not without minor concerns. Some images exhibit notable halos, especially shots of aircraft carriers, resulting in an edgier, less natural appearance. Yet, when these faults are not present, the video quality is nothing short of dazzling. The HDR 10+ enhancement adds vibrancy and a glossy finish to visuals under bright lighting conditions, with spectacular highlights and a wide range of colors vividly displayed. From the glistening whites of Marine hats to the intense blues of the sky, "We, the Marines" offers an engaging and highly detailed visual tour de force, notwithstanding a few technical imperfections.
Audio: 77
The audio presentation of "We, the Marines" on its 4K UHD Blu-ray, particularly through the Dolby Atmos surround mix, reveals a moderately active soundscape that pleasantly surpasses expectations given the source material. The mix proficiently utilizes overhead audio objects to enhance atmospheric conditions, panning fills, and occasional discrete effects to a considerable extent, particularly during sequences involving aircraft or simulators. The nearfield sound placement excels, fostering an immersive listening experience that convincingly transports the audience to the heart of the action. Moreover, the soundtrack's music is seamlessly integrated across the soundscape, providing depth with orchestrated elements and vocals that complement the onscreen narrative without detracting from the thematic content.
The Blu-ray disc offers a Dolby Digital 5.1 lossy sound presentation, while the UHD version includes a secondary DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless track alongside the Dolby Atmos configuration—a fitting accompaniment for the material at hand. This Atmos soundtrack springs to life with nuanced sounds like helicopter rotors and Marines shouting, enveloping the listener in a convincingly realistic and detailed auditory experience. Atmospheric effects such as harsh winter winds and battlefield sounds including gunfire and rocket blasts are meticulously rendered, contributing to an engaging and believably lifelike soundscape. Moreover, dialogue and narration by Hackman are crystal-clear, emanating naturally from a front-center position, ensuring that every word resonates with clarity.
However, the Dolby Atmos mix exhibits a shortfall in its low-end delivery, particularly noticeable in scenes involving mortar fire and missile launches, where the expected sonic impact falls somewhat short. Despite this minor drawback, the soundstage remains lively and expansive, with adept handling of directional audio cues—such as radio calls and the sweeping motion of aircraft—that contribute to an enveloping audio experience. Gunfire during target practice sequences and Hackman’s steady narration contribute to a well-balanced mix, with a score that achieves an impressive range without overpowering, rounding out an overall commendable auditory presentation for "We, the Marines.
Extras: 60
The "We, the Marines" 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation provides a compelling and immersive exploration into the life of Marine recruits, achieved through both its main feature and an enriching suite of extras. The Addendum Exclusive Behind the Scenes Interviews and Footage stands out, offering a 21-minute delve into the strenuous training regimes and the spirit of camaraderie among Marines. This feature, presented in both 1080i and 1080p depending on the disc, adds substantial value by depicting the challenges and growth experiences of young Marines in a personal and impactful manner. The additional 4K trailers on the UHD disc, exclusive to this format, showcase a variety of other visually stunning documentaries, enriching the overall package. Additionally, the inclusion of a digital copy code and the uniformity of supplements across both Blu-ray discs, while maintaining simplicity in packaging with a non-embossed slipcover, ensures that collectors and enthusiasts receive a comprehensive experience focused squarely on the essence of Marine life.
Extras included in this disc:
- We, The Marines Addendum – Behind-the-Scenes Interviews/Footage: Insightful behind-the-scenes look into Marine recruit training and camaraderie.
- We, the Marines Trailer: Official movie trailer in high definition.
- 4K Trailers (UHD Disc Only): Collection of trailers for various documentaries.
Movie: 70
We, the Marines," narrated with distinction by Gene Hackman, a former Marine himself, presents a compelling and well-rounded brief on the esteemed United States Marine Corps. This film encapsulates the essence of the Marines with an efficient blend of historical context, an insider's look into the demanding training regimen, and a showcase of the corporeal and mental transformation recruits undergo. Through vivid IMAX footage, viewers are transported to various training locations, from the rigorous paths of Parris Island to the officer's training at Quantico, revealing both the individual and collective journeys of becoming Marines. Despite its concise runtime, the film manages to highlight critical aspects like the use of cutting-edge technology and the Corps' role in disaster relief, fostering a deeper appreciation for the Marines' dedication and their pivotal role in national security.
Directed by Greg MacGillivray, "We, the Marines" thrives on its ability to convey a profound narrative within time constraints, exploring beyond the battlefield duties to touch upon the Corps' humanitarian missions. The choice of Hackman as the narrator adds an authentic resonance, his voice embodying the spirit and pride of the Marines. The documentary skillfully balances its focus on physical prowess and tactical expertise with moments that humanize the recruits, allowing audiences a glimpse of their vulnerabilities and triumphs. By employing IMAX technology, the film elevates its visual storytelling, delivering breathtaking aerial shots and immersive frontline action that accentuate the grandeur and peril inherent in Marine life.
Despite its brisk pace, the documentary doesn't forsake depth for speed; it judiciously uses its time to weave together elements of camaraderie, discipline, and sacrifice that define the Marine Corps. From historic battles to contemporary engagements, "We, the Marines" presents a mosaic of marine experiences, forging a connection with viewers that goes beyond mere admiration to a profound respect for those who navigate this challenging yet rewarding path. While individual stories might not be at the forefront, the documentary succeeds in painting a collective portrait of resilience, unity, and honor that underscores the timeless valor of the Marines.
Total: 75
We, the Marines" comes to life in an engaging and vivid manner on its 4K UHD Blu-ray release, offering viewers an immersive exploration of the life within the Marine Corps. The film, narrated by Gene Hackman, takes us from the rigorous beginnings of basic training to the multifaceted roles Marines play in combat and humanitarian efforts. The visual splendor is largely due to the stunning IMAX footage that stands at the forefront of this documentary's appeal. While the narrative navigates through historical and present-day valor, it's the technical execution on the Blu-ray formats that amplifies its impact. Both the Dolby True HD 7.1 (with Atmos core) and DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio tracks deliver outstanding dynamic range and clarity. The surround sound mix, though not overly aggressive, skillfully enhances the atmosphere and integrates discrete sound placements, especially in scenes of immersive action or detailed environmental ambiance. However, there's a slight critique regarding the audio mix where Gene Hackman’s compelling narration could have been accentuated for a more pronounced presence amidst the film's soundscapes.
On the video front, the documentary showcases impeccable visuals that do justice to its IMAX origins, pairing superbly with audio presentations that bring every scene to life. Although supplements accompanying the film are minimal, they effectively extend the narrative and educational value of the package. The inclusion of varied audio formats ensures a rich auditory experience, complementing the visuals with precise imaging and an enveloping atmosphere generated through both front and rear channels. LFEs add a dimension of richness, particularly noticeable in musical scores and live-action sequences.
In conclusion, "We, the Marines" is a must-watch for those interested in military documentaries or seeking a comprehensive showcase of the Marine Corps' ethos and evolution. The combination of Hackman's passionate narration and the exemplary technical quality of the 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation makes it a worthwhile addition to any collection. Despite wanting slightly more from the audio mix regarding narration prominence, this production stands out for its holistic portrayal of Marine life, underpinned by stellar video and sound quality. It’s not just a visual treat but an homage to the spirit and dedication of the Marines, highly recommended for its insightful and immersive viewing experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
HDR offers a level of visual sophistication with the added tonal dynamics that bring the movie to life with striking boldness that amplifies the material quite a bit....
Audio: 90
Music is large, full and detailed, emanating from every speaker with commanding posture and clarity to match the dominance....
Extras: 90
We, the Marines - Addendum Exclusive Behind the Scenes Interviews and Footage (1080i Blu-ray, 1080p UHD, 21:44): Additional scenes that explore life as a young Marine recruit, depict training exercises,...
Movie: 80
It's a quickly paced and compact but nevertheless fruitful and purposeful picture that brings a surprisingly full and rich view of life in the Martine Corps into focus, even under severe time constraints....
Total: 30
Perhaps one day Greg MacGillivray will assemble similar documentaries chronicling the other branches of the United States' armed forces, but until then We, the Marines proves to be a capable and engaging...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Much of We, the Marines takes place during daylight, keeping image density high with minimal reliance on black levels....
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 60
Other than the trailers, the only bonus is 21-minute addendum to the main feature – and quite frankly, it’s better....
Movie: 60
We, the Marines is worth watching for its footage though, dazzling as the IMAX camera sweeps overhead of aircraft carriers, follows helicopters as they fire missiles during an exercise, and get right into...
Total: 70
Sold primarily on its gorgeous IMAX footage, We, the Marines discusses the history of this military force while following the training regime....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
Whether it be the finest minutia visible in the make of the uniforms or variety of weaponry/equipment, or the majestic vistas of the regions used for training, the imagery is breathtaking....
Audio: 90
The music is subtly mixed over the platform so as to add natural depth to its orchestrated elements and vocals, without drawing attention away from the thematic details of what is transpiring onscreen....
Extras: 40
Disc 1:We, The Marines Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2 : We, The Marines Blu-ray We, The Marines Addendum – Behind-the-Scenes Interviews/Footage Digital Copy...
Movie: 80
There’s lots of excellent footage to go along with it as we learn about the tools the Marines employ, the geographic locations where they learn to use them, and lastly, the sacrifices undertaken to allow...
Total: 78
This isn’t an aggressive surround mix but when applied the surround channels generate plenty of atmosphere and where appropriate, discrete sound placement....
Director: Greg MacGillivray
Actors: Gene Hackman
PlotNarrated by a seasoned Marine Corps veteran, the documentary serves as an homage to the commitment and valor of the United States Marines. Beginning with the rigorous and demanding nature of their training, it delves into the transformation that recruits undergo at boot camp – particularly at Parris Island and San Diego – where they develop from civilians into disciplined warriors ready to serve their country. The film highlights the both the physical and psychological trials that these individuals face, revealing the core principles that the Corps instills in them: honor, courage, and commitment. This foundational segment of the narrative sets the stage for understanding the unique character and brotherhood that define the Marine Corps.
Transitioning from the training environment, the narrative progresses to showcase the diverse roles and missions that the Marines undertake around the world. Through a series of vignettes and cinematic footage, the documentary highlights the varied skills and specialties within the Corps, from piloting high-tech aircraft to delivering humanitarian aid in crisis situations. It underscores the versatility and adaptability of the Marines, who are always ready to respond at a moment's notice wherever they are needed. As it captures the essence of Marine service, the film pays tribute to those who have embraced the sacrifices required to protect and serve their nation with unwavering dedication and patriotism.
Writers: N/A
Release Date: 21 Jul 2017
Runtime: 38 min
Rating: N/A
Country: United States
Language: English