Automata Blu-ray Review
Aut�mata
Score: 47
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Automata is a visually compelling sci-fi noir with strong performances and effects, though it falls short on original plotting; a solid Blu-ray transfer.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 50
Automata's Blu-ray presentation, featuring a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in the 2.35:1 aspect ratio, is marked by its cold, desaturated tones and lack of vibrant colors, maintaining solid clarity and detail but plagued by minor artifacts, flat image quality, and inconsistent black levels.
Audio: 60
Automata's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track delivers an immersive surround experience with clear dialogue and atmospheric effects, though it occasionally lacks dynamic range and impact in gunfire and explosions. The mix offers solid directionality and bass activity, effectively complementing the film's visuals.
Extra: 11
The Blu-ray's supplemental content includes a succinct making-of featurette (HD, ~5 min) focusing on the plot, noir influences, and practical effects of Automata, complemented by the film's theatrical trailer (HD, 2 min) and various 480i trailers for other Millennium titles, though overall extras lack depth and comprehensive engagement.
Movie: 67
Automata skillfully crafts a visually compelling neo-noir landscape with tangible robotics, grounded performances by Antonio Banderas, and thought-provoking existential themes; however, the narrative often falters with underdeveloped plotlines and superficial character motivations, leaving unrealized potential amidst its technical achievements.
Video: 50
"Automata" presents a 1080p AVC MPEG-4 transfer that offers a varied visual experience. The film's cold, bleak aesthetic is underscored by a reliance on desaturated tones and an abundance of grays and sickly yellows. While facial hair stubble and textures of worn robots and sandy terrains exhibit occasional bursts of detail, the overall image quality can appear uneven and flat. Skin tones sometimes appear pasty, with facial details rendered inconsistently. Black levels are frequently elevated, veering towards gray, which can detract from the depth, especially in darker scenes where noisy backgrounds and minor banding issues surface.
The cinematography emphasizes a dystopian and industrial look, which the Blu-ray transfer captures adequately without any standout sharpness or vibrancy. The use of holographic effects against urban landscapes and the harsh desert sequences are notable; however, they often lack a three-dimensional pop, resulting in a rather shallow depth of field. Banding and noise are noticeable in certain sequences—most uncomfortably during an explosion around the 46-minute mark, indicating potential digital artifacts linked to special effects rather than encoding issues.
Despite its deficiencies, the transfer achieves an authentic representation of the film's low-budget sci-fi aesthetic, focusing on a gritty, worn-out dystopian environment that serves the narrative effectively. Colors are stable but intentionally subdued to enhance the film’s theme, avoiding the overly polished look of higher-budget productions. Indoor scenes can appear dim, while outdoor desert scenes offer high contrast with blown-out whites. The film’s noir-influenced sci-fi sets are highlighted with solid clarity, albeit with minimal dimension. Ultimately, "Automata" on Blu-ray delivers a competent visual experience that aligns with its artistic intent despite its technical limitations.
Audio: 60
The audio presentation of "Automata" on Blu-ray is delivered via an English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track and a Dolby Digital 2.0 track, accompanied by English SDH and Spanish subtitles. The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track showcases commendable surround usage, particularly effective with music and ambient sound effects. However, the opening title music lacks the fluidity and natural richness typical of higher-caliber soundtracks. This slightly stifled quality does not detract from the overall immersive experience, as city ambiance and atmospheric elements are well-represented, enveloping the viewer in the film's harsh exterior environments.
Dialogue clarity stands out, ensuring discernibility of both natural human speech and digitally distorted robotic voices. Directionality and imaging are performed smoothly, providing a coherent spatial audio experience. Action sequences display decent bass activity during gunfights, though explosions and gunshots lack the robust impact expected from premium mixes. Despite these occasional shortcomings, the dynamic range of the soundtrack is broad and free from technical flaws, maintaining clean volume spikes and accurate sound prioritization throughout.
In terms of surround sound presentation, "Automata" excels in creating a convincing auditory environment that complements its visual narrative. Background effects like loudspeaker announcements and ambient city noises are seamlessly integrated, enriching the overall viewing experience. While the low-frequency extension is subtle, it adequately supports atmospheric effects with sufficient depth. Although surround spread is somewhat sparse, resulting in a less than fully immersive experience, the audio design remains engaging and effective for the film's needs. Overall, "Automata" delivers a solid audio performance on Blu-ray that aligns well with its visual storytelling, despite some minor limitations in explosive impact and surround spread intensity.
Extras: 11
The Blu-ray release of "Automata" offers a modest selection of extras that provide a cursory glimpse behind the scenes. The primary feature, "Making Of," is an insightful 5-minute behind-the-scenes featurette that includes interviews with the cast and crew and covers the film’s influences, noir style, and practical effects. Although brief, it touches upon the film's plot, story structure, themes, and character development. Also included are previews for "Automata" in high definition and several other Millennium titles in standard definition. Though informative, the extras do not delve deeply into the film's creative processes or technical challenges.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Of: Brief behind-the-scenes featurette with cast and crew interviews about the film's themes, style, and practical effects.
- Theatrical Trailer: The film's trailer in 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound.
- Previews: Trailers for "Automata" (HD) and other Millennium titles (SD).
Movie: 67
"Automata" crafts a compelling yet familiar narrative set in a desolate future where solar flares have decimated Earth's population, leaving humanoid robots called Automata Pilgrims to fill the void. Antonio Banderas stars as Jacq Vaucan, an insurance investigator for ROC Robotics, embroiled in an investigation that exposes the potential evolution of these Pilgrims beyond their human-imposed limitations. The film excels in creating a palpably bleak dystopian atmosphere, enhanced by the use of practical effects and tangible robotics, providing a grounded sense of realism. The world-building is compelling, presenting detailed metaphors for real-life exploitation and prejudice.
Although the film's strengths lie in its visually impressive and deeply atmospheric execution, it falters with narrative cohesion and character motivations. The plot sometimes leaves crucial connections ambiguous, and antagonists lack depth, resulting in motivations that feel ill-defined. Despite its excellent setup through a captivating title sequence, "Automata" struggles to develop its intriguing themes about artificial consciousness into fully-fledged ideas. However, Banderas delivers a strong performance, embodying the despair and determination of his character seamlessly within the film's setting.
Ultimately, "Automata" stands out for its production design, strong visual direction, and intelligent use of practical robotics over digital effects. While it may not reach the narrative heights of genre classics like "Blade Runner" or "I, Robot," it offers a thought-provoking experience that rewards viewers looking for more contemplative science fiction. Its deliberate pacing and reflective tone distinguish it from action-oriented counterparts, making it an engaging film that melds dystopian noir with existential inquiry.
Total: 47
"Automata," directed by Gabe Ibáñez, is a sci-fi film that seeks to explore deeper existential themes amidst a backdrop reminiscent of dystopian classics like "Blade Runner" and "I, Robot." While it doesn't break new narrative ground, the film's aesthetic qualities impress. The practical effects and real robots are standout elements complemented by Antonio Banderas, who delivers a compelling performance. The film resonates with thematic depth and spectacle, even if the storytelling isn't entirely groundbreaking.
Visually, "Automata" is captivating. The Blu-ray presentation boasts a solid video transfer that accurately captures the film's intricate details and atmospheric nuances. Audio mixing is robust, providing an immersive experience that enhances the film's tension and mood. However, the Blu-ray edition is otherwise sparse in supplementary features, with only a brief making-of featurette available to viewers. This limited bonus content may disappoint those anticipating a thorough exploration behind the scenes.
In conclusion, "Automata" is a commendable sci-fi film that, despite its narrative shortcomings, offers visual and thematic engagement. Ibáñez's thoughtful direction and Banderas's strong lead performance contribute to a movie that invites contemplation and analysis. The Blu-ray's technical fidelity makes it a worthwhile addition for genre enthusiasts, despite the lack of substantial extras. Recommended for its merits as both a visual treat and a thought-provoking cinematic experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 60
Shades of gray dominate with only hints of bold color scattered throughout, whether an industrial-yellow robot, a blue plastic bag, or a few other odds and ends around the film....
Audio: 70
Dialogue does come through clearly and effortlessly from the center, whether natural human verbiage or more stifled, necessarily tinny and muddled robotic words....
Extras: 20
This Blu-ray contains previews for Automata (1080p, 2:26) and several other Millennium titles (all 480i) as well as a supplement entitled "Making Of" Featurette (1080p, 4:50), a piece that recounts the...
Movie: 70
Movies like The Terminator and I, Robot have depicted a future world in which man's interactions with machines have taken a turn for the worst, with the machines more a hindrance than a help when self-awareness...
Total: 50
It looks good, plays well, the real robots are a great asset, and Banderas is excellent in the lead....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
While detail is never razor sharp and the image lacks dimension and pop, these deficiencies are likely a result of the original shooting methods and digital equipment used....
Audio: 80
The sound design isn't as layered or textured as bigger budget sci-fi efforts, but the effects create a convincing surround sound environment that complements the visuals well....
Extras: 0
Theatrical Trailer (HD, 2 min) - The film's trailer is included in 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound....
Movie: 60
The central conceit involving robots who have apparently grown beyond their original programming holds a lot of potential, but the eventual solutions to the script's mysteries are very anticlimactic, uninspired,...
Total: 40
The movie never lives up to its initial promise, but this disc is still worth a look for fans of the genre....
Why So Blu? review by Nate BossRead review here
Video: 70
Regardless of setting, detail levels aren’t affected, and there is nary a soft shot in the film....
Audio: 70
This particular weakness is one that hurts the film greatly, as true absorption into this film would help one stay drawn in to the story, immersed and interested....
Extras: 10
Previews (HD and SD): A trailer for Automata (in HD), as well as the SD trailers that are found in the pre-menu content: Stonehearst Asylum, Good People, Dead Within, and The Taking of Deborah Logan....
Movie: 80
With the introduction of Banderas’ Vaucan, there is a step back for the obvious need for a relatable subject, whose eyes will be what we see the rest of the film through, and his misery represents that...
Total: 60
In Automata, there’s a similar sequence with similar meaning, as a Pilgrim 7000 robot self-immolates, a sacrifice it makes in an attempt to avoid the further persecution of his kind....
Director: Gabe Ibáñez
Actors: Antonio Banderas, Birgitte Hjort Sørensen, Dylan McDermott
PlotIn a dystopian future ravaged by solar flares, Earth's population dwindles and society relies on robots created to assist humans. These robots are governed by two unbreakable protocols: not to harm any living being and not to alter themselves or other robots. Jacq Vaucan, an insurance investigator for the ROC robotics corporation, is tasked with looking into cases where robots have violated these protocols. During his investigations, Jacq comes across a unique robot seemingly capable of self-repair and autonomy, sparking suspicions of a potential revolution.
As Jacq delves deeper, he uncovers a conspiracy that not only challenges the established societal norms but also puts his own life in danger. The discovery leads him to question humanity's dependence on technology, the true nature of consciousness, and the ethical boundaries of artificial intelligence. His journey propels him through stark, hostile landscapes and encounters with both human and robotic adversaries who will stop at nothing to maintain the status quo.
Writers: Gabe Ibáñez, Igor Legarreta, Javier Sánchez Donate
Release Date: 17 Oct 2014
Runtime: 109 min
Rating: R
Country: Spain, Bulgaria
Language: English