The Bank Dick Blu-ray Review
Score: 78
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
W.C. Fields' 'The Bank Dick' is an essential comedy classic, now stunningly presented in high definition by Kino Lorber; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
Aged but visually refreshed, 'The Bank Dick' on Blu-ray impresses with its 1.36:1 aspect ratio, 1080p transfer via MPEG-4 AVC codec, maintaining authentic grain and detail, all with stable image and solid grading. Despite minor flaws, it offers an organic and pleasing experience for fans.
Audio: 93
The Blu-ray's English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track delivers a clear, stable, and pleasing audio experience, expertly balancing dialogue, music cues, and sound effects, with optimizations ensuring minimal age-related imperfections.
Extra: 36
Engaging and informative, the Blu-ray extras for "The Bank Dick" include a meticulously researched commentary by Michael Schlesinger, which explores W.C. Fields' career, character depth, and cinematic craftsmanship, alongside vintage trailers enriching the classic American film context.
Movie: 91
Edward F. Cline’s 'The Bank Dick' is a testament to W.C. Fields’ undeterred comedic genius, blending subversive humor with impeccable spontaneity. The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber highlights Fields' ability to humanize comedy through a loose narrative, eclectic characters, and a climactic car chase, maintaining quirky authenticity.
Video: 83
The Bank Dick arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Kino Lorber, maintaining its original aspect ratio of 1.36:1. The video presentation is encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, featuring a 1080p transfer that, while not derived from a new master, stands out positively. The master supplied by Universal is notably devoid of severe flaws; it shows slightly pronounced grain alongside occasional specks and black marks. Fortunately, no overreaching digital corrections plague this transfer, preserving the film's original charm. The grading effectively balances grayscale, presenting strong blacks and well-calibrated grays and whites, providing a solid visual experience.
Despite minor digital impressions in some scenes, the image quality remains commendable, with appropriate grain and excellent detail throughout. This sharpness allows viewers to discern specifics such as the presence of a stunt driver in pivotal chase scenes. The stability of the image contributes to the preservation of the film's overall quality. The fine grayscale and well-executed contrast inject a renewed freshness into this classic work, making it particularly appealing to longtime fans. It's important to note that this Blu-ray release is Region-A locked, necessitating a native Region-A or Region-Free player for access. Overall, this presentation should satisfy both casual viewers and avid collectors alike.
Audio: 93
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Bank Dick" features a single English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, which delivers an unexpectedly robust auditory experience. Despite the film's vintage, the mono sound mix excels in clarity and balance, offering a compelling distinction between dialogue, musical cues, and sound effects. This audio track is free from any age-related imperfections such as hiss, crackles, pops, or flutter, indicating a diligent restoration effort to enhance its quality.
Listeners who raise the volume to catch every nuance of Mr. Souse's dialogue will benefit from the clear and stable audio output. The precision in the mix ensures that no dialogue is overshadowed by music or sound effects, resulting in an immersive experience. This level of detail suggests careful optimization was employed during the master preparation to maintain auditory fidelity, which contributes significantly to the overall enjoyment of the film.
Optional English SDH subtitles are available for the main feature, providing accessibility and ensuring that viewers can fully appreciate the wit and humor intrinsic to the film's dialogue. Overall, this audio presentation meets expectations for a film of this era, offering a comfortable and engaging listening experience that complements its visual counterpart effectively.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray edition of "The Bank Dick" offers a thoughtfully curated collection of extras that enrich the viewer's understanding of this classic film. Notably, the audio commentary by filmmaker and historian Michael Schlesinger is a standout. It provides an engaging and informative exploration of W.C. Fields' iconic work, his career trajectory, and his collaborations with notable figures such as director Edward F. Cline and cinematographer Milton R. Krasner. Schlesinger's commentary is both comprehensive and entertaining, delving into the contributions of various cast and crew members with depth and precision. In addition to the commentary, the collection includes a vintage trailer for "The Bank Dick" and other related Kino trailers that further contextualize the film within its era—a valuable resource for both enthusiasts and scholars of classic American cinema.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: A vintage trailer for "The Bank Dick" in English.
- Commentary: In-depth audio commentary by Michael Schlesinger.
- Kino Trailers: Includes trailers for "The Old Fashioned Way," "You Can’t Cheat an Honest Man," "My Little Chickadee," and "Road to Zanzibar."
Movie: 91
Edward C. Cline’s "The Bank Dick" arrives on Blu-ray through Kino Lorber, bringing with it the comedic genius of W.C. Fields, pure and undiluted. This 1940 film encapsulates Fields' longstanding comedic style, offering him a platform to exhibit his characteristic wordplay, inventive sight gags, and uniquely subversive humor unfettered by the presence of big-name co-stars. Crucial elements of the movie revolve around Fields as Egbert Sousé, a henpecked husband who navigates quirky misadventures in the fictional town of Lompoc, highlighted by an accidental entanglement with a bank robbery leading to an ironically inappropriate job as a bank detective.
Fields' screenplay under the pseudonym Mahatma Kane Jeeves enriches this golden age comedy with a tapestry of eccentric characters, among them a nagging family and colorful townsfolk. The comedic narrative thrives on Sousé’s propensity to meddle in situations, which sometimes eschews the storyline but consistently delivers humor—be it fixing a broken engine or emulating a director. The humor reaches its peak during an uproarious chase sequence, perfectly exhibiting the nuthouse tone that Cline masterfully directs.
Despite Fields moving slower compared to his earlier works due to alleged alcoholism impacts, his portrayal remains indelibly curmudgeonly. The supporting cast—including Shemp Howard as a bartender and Grady Sutton as Og Oggilby—adds richness to the humor. Franklin Pangborn is notable as the meticulous bank auditor cleverly gaslighted by Fields. Slightly imperfect execution aside, Fields’ spontaneous antics and clever dialogue ensure "The Bank Dick" remains a classic in American comedy, further validated by its selection for preservation by the United States National Film Registry in 1992 as culturally significant. This Blu-ray release is an essential testament to Fields' comedic brilliance and cinematic influence.
Total: 78
"The Bank Dick" is a quintessential piece featuring W.C. Fields at his comedic best, offering a delightfully subversive and human portrayal that stands in contrast to the classic styles of Chaplin or Keaton. The Blu-ray release from Kino Lorber extends this timeless humor with an impressive high-definition presentation. Retaining the film's charmingly loose narrative, it captures Fields' unique ability to craft humor that resonates with modern audiences as much as it did upon its original release.
Technically, the Blu-ray transfer maximizes both clarity and fidelity, ensuring that every visual gag and subtle comedic expression is preserved with remarkable detail. The restoration work allows Fields' nuanced performances to shine, providing an authentic viewing experience that is faithful to the film’s original composition. Accompanying audio tracks are cleanly presented, supporting Fields' iconic voice and delivery with clarity that heightens the comedic timing.
In conclusion, "The Bank Dick" on Blu-ray is an essential addition to any comedy aficionado's collection. Offering an enduring and heartwarming glimpse into a bygone era of film, it delivers laughter and nostalgia in equal measure. Its high-quality presentation makes it a significant offering for both Fields enthusiasts and those newly introduced to his work. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
All in all, I think that this is a very pleasing organic presentation of The Bank Dick that will make a lot of its fans very happy....
Audio: 100
The audio track is very clear, clear, and stable, so when the current master was prepared some optimizations were almost certainly performed to ensure optimal quality....
Extras: 40
Commentary - in this exclusive new audio commentary, filmmaker and historian Michael Schlesinger highlights many of the reasons for which The Bank Dick is considered a classic American film, W.C. Fields'...
Movie: 90
Of course, what makes Fields' craft so special is his ability to convince that everything he does before the camera, and especially the awkward, is entirely spontaneous....
Total: 80
While they come from a very different era, virtually all of them have a character or two that you can still recognize at your local market place of favorite pub....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
While occasionally looking a bit digital, most of the image quality is top notch with appropriate grain structure and excellent detail in the imagery (it’s definitely sharp enough to discern that it’s...
Audio: 100
The dialogue has been well-recorded and has been mixed nicely with the occasional burst of music cues and the frequent sound effects to make a pleasing aural experience....
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: filmmaker and film historian Michael Schlesinger offers an entertaining, well researched commentary chock-full of information on almost everyone from the biggest stars to the tiniest...
Movie: 100
Sousé’s continual practice of interjecting himself into situations without being asked (to fix a broken engine, for example, or to replace a drunken director played by Jack Norton) might have nothing to...
Total: 90
The Kino Lorber high definition presentation offers another most welcome addition to its growing Fields library of comedy classics....
Director: Edward F. Cline
Actors: W.C. Fields, Cora Witherspoon, Una Merkel
PlotEgbert Sousé, a clumsy and perpetual drunkard, spends his days avoiding any form of responsibility, much to the chagrin of his overbearing wife and mother-in-law. His life takes an unexpected turn when he inadvertently stumbles upon a bank robbery and apprehends the culprit through a series of comical accidents. Mistaken for a hero, Egbert is offered a job as the bank's security guard, which he reluctantly accepts to please his family and gain some respectability. Despite his new position, Egbert's bumbling nature leads to a string of humorous mishaps at the bank, where his association with the establishment becomes more of a hindrance than a help.
As he settles into his new role, Egbert also learns about an enticing investment opportunity from J. Frothingham Waterbury, a swindler posing as an honest businessman. Tempted by the prospect of quick riches, Egbert persuades his daughter’s suitor to embezzle funds from the bank to invest in the scheme. This decision sets off a chain of chaotic events and precarious situations, threatening both his job and his family's future. Amidst the mounting trouble, Egbert tries to navigate his way through misunderstandings and calamities, relying on luck and wit to avoid disaster. Tensions build as circumstances spiral out of control, leaving Egbert in a tight spot where he must find a way to resolve the impending crisis he unwittingly initiated.
Writers: W.C. Fields, Richard Carroll
Release Date: 29 Nov 1940
Runtime: 72 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: English