The Polar Express Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Polar Express Blu-ray 3D offers a visually engaging experience with solid, though not top-tier, 3D and audio; ideal for new collectors at a reasonable price.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 57
The Polar Express Blu-ray 3D offers a visually inconsistent experience, with a 2.4:1 1080p transfer that excels in color accuracy and defined edges but suffers from occasional ghosting, limited 3D depth, and overly thick blacks that diminish detail, making it an average upgrade from the anaglyph 3D version.
Audio: 42
The Polar Express Blu-ray boasts an impressive English DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack with vivid sound effects and natural dialogue, though set rather quiet at first. Train arrivals and specific scenes like the train on ice and the elf factory offer immersive, room-rattling moments, but overall, it remains a solid, if unremarkable, audio experience.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras of 'The Polar Express' offer a series of brief but insightful featurettes, highlighting Tom Hanks' motion capture work, Chris Van Allsburg's inspirations, and the film's animation process, although some content, like the Josh Groban performance, may feel redundant for some viewers.
Movie: 71
"The Polar Express" is a heartwarming homage to Christmas, offering top-notch picture quality and above-average sound in its 3D Blu-ray release. Though older audiences may find the animation less appealing, the film's enchanting adventure and message of self-discovery resonate widely, despite the disc's limited extras.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray 3D presentation of "The Polar Express" offers a region-free, theatrically correct widescreen 2.4:1 1080p transfer available in both 2D and 3D. This film, purpose-built for 3D, displays a variable layering effect that occasionally provides decent depth, though it often fails to fully immerse viewers. Key scenes, such as the exhilarating roller-coaster ride and the encounter with a herd of caribou, are well-realized, showcasing good depth and engaging visuals. Nevertheless, the overall effect remains somewhat intermittent, drawing attention to the 3D format rather than seamlessly integrating it. While detail is generally commendable, with strong and well-defined edges, certain animations appear smoother compared to modern standards, likely a result of the animation techniques used at the time.
Colors in "The Polar Express" are bright and bold, maintaining a clear distinction between the warm interiors and the cold exteriors. Brightness and contrast are effectively balanced, delivering respectable black levels that contribute to the depth of the picture. However, some scenes suffer from murky, overwhelming blacks that obscure finer details, notably during the film’s opening sequences. Additionally, the occasional appearance of banding and ghosting is noted, though these issues are typically brief and minimally distracting. Digitally, the transfer is proficient with no significant compression problems or edge enhancement.
The 3D elements can best be described as serviceable but not exceptional. While there are moments of notable depth—such as inside the train cars and during key action sequences—the majority of the film retains an average level of 3D immersion. A few standout moments, like the train's triangular iron bumper seemingly crashing into the living room, do elevate the experience temporarily. Fans of "The Polar Express" will appreciate the superior colors and steadiness of this Blu-ray 3D release compared to previous anaglyph versions. However, for general Blu-ray 3D audiences, this transfer may fall short of fully capturing their imagination.
Audio: 42
The audio presentation of "The Polar Express" Blu-ray is delivered through an impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack. This marks a significant improvement over its previous Dolby Digital 5.1 and Dolby TrueHD 5.1 iterations. The surround tracks span multiple languages, but the focus here is on the English DTS-HD MA 5.1 track. The audio track exhibits a solid dynamic range and utilizes all speakers effectively, particularly shining during pivotal moments such as the train's dramatic arrival, which is underscored by powerful bass and the vivid high-pitched whistle.
The soundstage of this release proves to be wide and spacious, enhancing the overall viewing experience with notable surround elements. Scenes depicting the jingling sleigh bells and the transient noises of wind atop the speeding train demonstrate impressive clarity and directionality, although they occasionally lack full immersion. Dialogue is consistently natural and well-aligned with the on-screen action, contributing to a coherent auditory experience. Noteworthy sequences include the thrilling ride over icy tracks and the children's fast-paced adventures in the elf factory.
Despite occasional missed opportunities for truly immersive surround support, "The Polar Express" Blu-ray delivers a strong audio experience that complements its visual narrative. The sound effects are lively, music is crisply delivered, particularly during notable moments like the full rendition of the theme song, and crowd scenes along with firework displays are rendered with spectacular realism. While not groundbreaking, this soundtrack effectively supports the film’s magical atmosphere, offering both technical proficiency and engaging content.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray extras for "The Polar Express" offer a comprehensive behind-the-scenes glimpse into the film's production, showcasing various aspects of its creation and the stories behind it. Led by Tom Hanks' multi-character performance captured through motion capture technology, "You Look Familiar" reveals the complexity of bringing the story to life. The most extensive featurette, "A Genuine Ticket to Ride," is divided into five segments that explore motion capture, virtual cameras, hair and wardrobe, North Pole creation, and music. Fans can also enjoy a reflective interview with author Chris Van Allsburg in "True Inspirations: An Author's Adventure," as well as an inside look at the recording of the theme song in "Behind the Scenes of Believe." Other highlights include a comparison of motion-capture performances with finished scenes in "A Flurry of Effects," a deleted scene/song "Smokey and Steamer," and live performances.
Extras included in this disc:
Extras included in this disc:
- You Look Familiar: Revealing Tom Hanks' motion capture process.
- True Inspirations: An Author's Adventure: Chris Van Allsburg discusses his inspirations.
- Behind the Scenes of Believe: Recording of the theme song.
- A Genuine Ticket to Ride: Five-part making-of feature on film production aspects.
- Deleted Scene/Song, Smokey and Steamer: Explains the ghost character with animatics.
- Josh Groban at the Greek Theatre: Live performance of the theme song.
- Meet the Snow Angels: Cast and crew discuss Christmas memories.
- A Flurry of Effects: Before and after motion capture comparisons.
- Theatrical Trailer
Movie: 71
Robert Zemeckis' "The Polar Express," based on Chris Van Allsburg's book, shines as a quintessential Christmas film that appeals primarily to a younger audience. The movie tells the story of a boy who is quickly losing his faith in Christmas and belief in Santa Claus. On Christmas Eve, he is awoken by a train outside his house, and embarks on a magical journey aboard The Polar Express. This trip leads him and his newfound friends to not only discover the physical wonders of the North Pole and Santa Claus but also deeper truths about friendship, belief, and the true spirit of Christmas.
Visually, the animation in "The Polar Express" is unique and innovative, although it may not be universally appealing, particularly to older audiences who might find the style less engaging. However, the film's heartwarming story compensates for any visual shortcomings. The characters, notably unnamed except for Billy, facilitate audience immersion, allowing viewers to connect with them on a personal level through their distinct traits and growth arcs. The film effectively conveys important themes like trust, heart, friendship, and belief in the good and magical aspects of life.
As a Blu-ray release, "The Polar Express" offers an excellent picture quality and above-average soundscapes that bring the magical train ride to vivid life. Featuring both 2D and 3D versions, it serves as a future-proof purchase catering to varied viewing preferences. While it may lack in extensive extras, the package remains a solid buy for those looking to relive or introduce this holiday classic in enhanced resolution and sound—elements that ensure a thoroughly enchanting viewing experience each Christmas season.
Total: 55
The Polar Express The Blu-ray release of "The Polar Express" brings the magic of this beloved Christmas classic to life with remarkable visual clarity and engaging audio performance. Utilizing cutting-edge animation techniques, the film transcends traditional holiday offerings with its unique blend of motion capture technology and CGI, creating an enchanting and immersive viewing experience. Capturing the mystical essence of Christmas and the nostalgic perspective of a child's imagination, the narrative effortlessly weaves elements of adventure, emotion, and drama, making it an endearing family favorite.
However, while the 3D presentation excels in some aspects, it falls short of the upper echelon typically expected of high-end 3D Blu-ray formats. The depth and realism provided by the 3D effects do add to the immersion, but minor inconsistencies in the transfer may be noticeable to discerning viewers. The lossless soundtrack is commendable, delivering clear and dynamic audio that complements the film's visual splendor, though it does not quite reach the pinnacle of auditory excellence found in other top-tier releases. Additionally, the supplementary materials remain largely unchanged from previous editions, offering little new content to long-time collectors.
In conclusion, "The Polar Express" Blu-ray release is a visually stunning and heartwarming addition to any holiday film collection. Its vivid portrayal of the Christmas spirit and timeless message ensure its status as a seasonal favorite. While perhaps not a requisite upgrade for those who already own earlier versions, it remains highly recommended for first-time purchasers, particularly once it is priced within the $15-$20 range. This release captures the essence of what makes "The Polar Express" a treasured classic, perfect for gathering the family around during the festive season.
avforums review by Simon CrustRead review here
Video: 80
But the solidity of the characters themselves is very limited; considering the extent that the animation process goes to, to keep everything realistic, this aspect is sorely lacking....
Audio: 70
For the most part this track is pretty solid, however, it is set rather quiet, especially in the beginning, until the train first turns up with its thundering bass; use of all the speakers and an increased...
Extras: 60
A Genuine Ticket to Ride – SD, 13.32Is a featurette split into five featurette-ettes, which can be played individually or all together, narrated by ‘in character’ actors and looks at the motion capture...
Movie: 60
As a 3D Blu-ray package, Warner deliver a Region free disc presenting an excellent picture and above average sound that is slightly let down by the short amount of extras, but is once again a future proof...
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
There's nothing at all special or unique here; The Polar Express 3D gives off a "so what?" sort of vibe, one that certainly looks good and stable at-a-glance but never really captures the imagination or...
Audio: 50
The jingling of sleigh bells heard off in the distance at the beginning of the movie and foreshadowing what will become a symbol for one's belief in Christmas later in the film is expertly handled; the...
Extras: 80
Flurry of Effects (480p, 8:48) is yet another five-part feature that provides a fascinating real-time comparison showing both the motion-capture acting simultaneously with the final version of the film....
Movie: 90
One of the film's true charms and perhaps overlooked decisions is that it never assigns a name to any of the characters, save for Billy, and by doing that, it facilitates the act of placing the audience...
Total: 60
Featuring action, adventure, heartfelt drama and emotion, dancing waiters, and a strong message about the importance of finding that inner gift that is more precious than anything that might appear underneath...
Director: Robert Zemeckis
Actors: Tom Hanks, Chris Coppola, Michael Jeter
PlotOn Christmas Eve, a young boy who is starting to doubt the existence of Santa Claus lies awake in his bed, eagerly listening for the sound of sleigh bells. Suddenly, his house trembles as a mysterious train appears outside his window. The train's conductor invites him aboard what he calls the Polar Express, a magical train bound for the North Pole. Intrigued by the prospect of meeting Santa Claus, the boy boards the train, embarking on a journey of self-discovery and wonder. Aboard the train, he meets other children, each with their own beliefs and stories, including a spirited girl who believes strongly in the spirit of Christmas, a know-it-all boy who flaunts his knowledge, and a shy boy from a poor background who longs to believe in something greater.
Throughout their adventure to the North Pole, the children encounter a series of astonishing and mystical experiences. The Polar Express races through treacherous territories, including steep mountains and ice-covered tracks. The boy and his newfound friends face various challenges that test their courage, trust, and perceptions of reality. Their camaraderie grows as they share hot chocolate, sing carols, and navigate their way through the picturesque yet perilous landscapes. These shared experiences bond the children as they learn important lessons about belief, friendship, and the enduring magic of Christmas, all while they draw ever closer to their ultimate destination where they are promised a meeting with Santa Claus himself.
Writers: Chris Van Allsburg, Robert Zemeckis, William Broyles Jr.
Release Date: 10 Nov 2004
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: G
Country: United States, Australia
Language: English