He Walked by Night Blu-ray Review
Special Edition
Score: 69
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
ClassicFlix delivers again with 'He Walked by Night', offering compelling crime drama, stunning visuals, and restored video and audio transfers—highly recommended.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f1842/f18427772997fcb5219b1282c663dc7ade3547b5" alt="He Walked by Night Blu-ray Front Cover"
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The 1080p AVC Blu-ray of 'He Walked by Night' impresses with a faithful 1.37:1 aspect ratio, showcasing John Alton’s moody cinematography with high contrast, rich blacks, and clean source material. Despite minor variances in clarity, this restoration delivers a film-like texture that noir aficionados will treasure.
Audio: 72
He Walked by Night's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track excels with clear, well-modulated dialogue, dynamic sound effects like gunshots and sirens, and Leonid Raab's occasionally brash score, maintaining a remarkably clean and vibrant audio presence free from age-related hiss or crackle.
Extra: 53
The Blu-ray extras for 'He Walked by Night' are exemplary, featuring an engaging commentary by Alan K. Rode and Julie Kirgo filled with extensive background details, a well-produced 'Below the Surface' featurette analyzing key aspects of the film, an image gallery of stills and posters, and an insightful 24-page booklet.
Movie: 80
“He Walked by Night” is a taut, artistic film noir blending procedural detail with chilling performances, particularly from Richard Basehart. Its striking cinematography by John Alton, especially in the climactic sewer chase, and its relevance in inspiring "Dragnet" and contributing to post-war noir elevate it to a classic gem of the genre.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2b2cc/2b2cc9080010215c816d97adcf7cb0c140e39aa9" alt="Loading"
Video: 72
ClassicFlix's Blu-ray presentation of He Walked by Night delivers a captivating viewing experience through an AVC encoded 1080p transfer, with the original 1.37:1 aspect ratio faithfully represented. The overall image quality is commendable, especially given the variable clarity and sharpness due to the condition of the source elements provided by MGM. Despite some isolated moments of softness, the transfer boasts impressive detail and strong contrast, crucial for John Alton's atmospheric cinematography that plays significantly with light and shadow. Viewers will especially appreciate the clean source material, with minimal dirt or debris interfering with the visuals.
The film’s grayscale variance is exceptional, providing a robust delineation of fine details and complex shots, such as the shadowy Los Angeles streets and steamy sewers. Rich blacks enhance the depth of nighttime scenes, while crisp whites from flashlights and bare bulbs contrast vividly. The natural grain structure contributes to a film-like texture without succumbing to overbearing digital alterations. Close-ups reveal subtle nuances, like sweat droplets on Richard Basehart’s face, heightening the fidelity of the presentation.
Ultimately, while some may argue about minor variances in sharpness and occasional blemishes, ClassicFlix has delivered a highly respectable and beautifully restored Blu-ray transfer. Film noir enthusiasts will find this treatment of He Walked by Night exceptionally satisfying, bringing the gritty tale to life with significant clarity and authenticity.
Audio: 72
"He Walked by Night" is presented with a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track that, while inherently narrow in scope, impresses with its compelling intensity. Sound effects such as gunshots and violent kicks resonate with a startling clarity that adds considerable heft to key scenes. One of the unique aspects of this film is the sparse use of music, giving certain scenes an almost silent movie-like ambience. This unusual approach is effectively managed by the audio track, which consistently delivers clear and intelligible dialogue without any temporal degradation.
ClassicFlix’s uncompressed mono track highlights the nuances and bold accents integral to the film’s atmosphere. The minimalistic musical score underscores a reliance on natural audio elements, which are reproduced with crisp precision. Gunshots, sirens, motorcycle engines, and watchdog barks contribute significantly to the film’s tense mood. The score, sporadically employed, benefits from a wide dynamic range that captures every high and low without distortion. During prolonged silences, there are no intrusive hisses, crackles, or pops to mar the quiet, maintaining the integrity of the cinematic experience.
Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix stands out for its exceptionally clean and vibrant reproduction of audio. Dialogue is beautifully rendered and seamlessly integrated with atmospheric effects like running water and echoes in underground tunnels. Leonid Raab’s sparse score occasionally emerges, enhancing scenes without overtaking them. Despite the track's seventy-year age, it remains remarkably pristine, free from any hiss, crackle, or flutter, ensuring that "He Walked by Night" retains its classic film noir impact.
Extras: 53
The Blu-ray extras for "He Walked by Night" are impeccably crafted and informative, representing an excellent addition to this classic film noir. The Audio Commentary by Alan K. Rode and Julie Kirgo stands out with their engaging discussion on the film’s production, cast details, striking cinematography by John Alton, and fascinating trivia about the real-life inspirations behind the film. The "Below the Surface" featurette is equally compelling, offering critical insights into the film’s unique stylistic elements and historical context, featuring contributions from a range of respected industry professionals. Furthermore, the included image gallery offers a valuable look at numerous black-and-white stills and poster art, providing fans with a rich visual history. A well-appointed insert booklet rounds out this meticulously assembled package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful discussion between Alan K. Rode and Julie Kirgo.
- Below the Surface: He Walked by Night Featurette: In-depth exploration of the film.
- Image Gallery: Collection of stills and poster art.
- Twenty-four Page Booklet: Essays and archival stills by critic Max Alvarez.
Movie: 80
"He Walked by Night" stands tall as a quintessential film noir from the late 1940s, lauded for its taut, realistic narrative and atmospheric artistry. This Eagle-Lion production, directed by Alfred Werker with notable contributions from Anthony Mann, follows the LAPD's dogged pursuit of cop killer Roy Morgan, played chillingly by Richard Basehart. Basehart's portrayal of the sociopathic Morgan is both magnetic and understated, adding layers of mystery to his character who eludes capture through cunning and meticulous planning. The film’s screenplay, penned by John C. Higgins and Crane Wilbur, is firmly rooted in true crime and enhanced by Reed Hadley's stentorian narration, lending an almost documentary feel to the storyline.
Cinematographer John Alton's masterful use of chiaroscuro lighting accentuates the film's ominous tone, particularly in its legendary underground sewer climax which predates a similar sequence in "The Third Man". The film’s semi-documentary style is evident in its procedural scenes where detectives, led by Scott Brady's Sgt. Marty Brennan, piece together clues amidst a backdrop of urban Los Angeles's gritty realism—a signature of noir that provides both a compelling narrative and a visual spectacle. The interplay of light and shadow in Alton’s compositions never fails to elevate even the most mundane sequences, making them pulse with latent menace.
Supporting performances, particularly from Jack Webb as a forensic expert, lend authenticity and depth to the film’s procedural elements. Webb's work here is an evident precursor to his iconic role in "Dragnet." Scenes such as Morgan self-operating to remove a bullet are executed with intense realism, forcing the audience into his macabre world. "He Walked by Night" is more than just a B movie; it’s a cinematic gem that expertly melds procedural rigor with stylistic flourish, standing as a testament to the artistry of its era.
Total: 69
ClassicFlix's release of "He Walked by Night" on Blu-ray showcases a remarkable restoration of a classic film noir that stands the test of time. This tightly woven narrative, directed by Alfred Werker, chronicles a gripping police investigation following a cop killing in a manner that perhaps inspired the iconic series "Dragnet." Richard Basehart’s riveting portrayal of the cold and calculating antagonist enriches the procedural storyline, further heightened by captivating cinematography and expert direction.
The video transfer is impressively clean, though it faces occasional limitations likely due to the film’s age and its public domain status. However, the meticulous restoration efforts by ClassicFlix result in a visually compelling experience with stunning imagery that revitalizes the film's atmospheric noir aesthetic. Audio quality retains some constraints inherent to its era but remains admirably clear, ensuring that the delivery matches the visual quality. A few supplements included in this Blu-ray release add valuable context and are a welcome addition for collectors and aficionados.
ClassicFlix has delivered yet another indispensable release for noir enthusiasts with "He Walked by Night." Its combination of stellar performances, meticulous restoration, and essential additional materials make this Blu-ray a must-have. Highly recommended for both serious collectors and new fans looking to delve deeper into classic film noir.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Like T-Men, there are a lot of opticals in this film (many dissolves, for example), and while those of course add to some of the variances, others accrue when there aren't any opticals at all, something...
Audio: 70
While Leonid Raab's score sounds okay if a bit brash, one of the interesting things about He Walked by Night is how certain key scenes play without music, or indeed without many effects at all, giving...
Extras: 40
Below the Surface: He Walked by Night Featurette (1080p; 11:47) features Rode and Kirgo again in an appealing overview of the film....
Movie: 80
That probably coincidental connection has long given He Walked by Night a certain allure for film trivia buffs, but there's another nugget of pop culture the film offers as well, courtesy of a supporting...
Total: 80
Video here has occasional hurdles, and audio is probably unavoidably constrained by its age, but ClassicFlix has done an admirable job of spiffing up this film, which evidently fell into the public domain....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Blacks are rich and deep, the whites of flashlights and naked bulbs are crisp, while well-defined shadow lines, especially on Venetian blinds, heighten the impact of many complex shots....
Audio: 80
Gunshots burst forth with a startling intensity that reverberates throughout the room, while screaming sirens, rumbling motorcycle engines, and the dissonant barking of a watchdog add immeasurably to the...
Extras: 40
Kirgo calls the film “one of the most effective portraits of Los Angeles of the period,” while Rode provides facts about the real-life killer who inspired the film and plenty of background information...
Movie: 80
By combining terse storytelling with a couple of dazzling set pieces and a host of fine performances, He Walked by Night holds our attention from start to finish as it methodically chronicles how the LAPD...
Total: 80
He Walked by Night may have inspired Dragnet, but Alfred Werker’s tightly woven film noir stands on its own as a well-acted, involving, and artistic production....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
Apart from some very slight line twitter, this is another masterful restoration with superb sharpness that relays lots of details in facial features in close-ups and a grayscale that’s second to none,...
Audio: 100
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix is solid as a rock with dialogue beautifully rendered and mixed with surety with galvanizing atmospheric effects (gunshots, running water, echoes in the underground...
Extras: 90
Below the Surface: He Walked by Night (11:47, HD): excellent critical summary of the film’s great strengths with contributions by, among others, historians Alan Rode, Julie Kirgo, Courtney Joyner, Todd...
Movie: 90
Much more straightforward and direct performances are offered by Scott Brady and James Cardwell as the two police sergeants on the case, Brady always in search of a match for his cigarette and Cardwell...
Total: 90
Another winner from Classic Flix who is rapidly making a name for itself with these brilliant Blu-ray restorations of classic films noir, He Walked by Night is a release not-to-be-missed....
Director: Alfred L. Werker, Anthony Mann
Actors: Richard Basehart, Scott Brady, Roy Roberts
PlotA cunning and methodical criminal, Roy Martin, commits a series of brazen thefts and murders in Los Angeles. The film begins as Roy is interrupted by a police officer during a burglary, leading to a fatal shootout where the officer is killed. As Roy systematically evades capture by using his technical expertise and adapting his tactics, the Los Angeles Police Department becomes increasingly desperate to apprehend him. Sergeant Marty Brennan and his partner, Chuck Jones, along with Captain Breen, head the intense investigation. Utilizing emerging forensic technologies and investigative techniques, the team works tirelessly to piece together clues and track Roy's movements.
As the story unfolds, tensions rise within the department and among the officers as they confront both personal and professional challenges in their pursuit of the elusive fugitive. Each close encounter with Roy heightens their determination and reveals more about his cold, calculated nature, but capturing him proves increasingly difficult. The manhunt intensifies, pushing the police force to their limits as Roy continues to stay one step ahead. The relentless pursuit builds suspense through a meticulous depiction of police procedures versus the cunning of a hardened criminal, leading to a riveting chase that keeps the audience on edge.
Writers: John C. Higgins, Crane Wilbur, Harry Essex
Release Date: 10 May 1949
Runtime: 79 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish, Cantonese