Black Snake Moan Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Black Snake Moan blends shocking imagery and blues legacy in a tale of redemption.
Disc Release Date
Video: 72
Black Snake Moan's Blu-ray dazzles with stunning 1080p visuals, deep contrasts, and vivid textures, making it a reference-quality presentation that captures the essence of its setting and characters.
Audio: 49
Black Snake Moan's Blu-ray audio disappoints with its lack of uncompressed sound, yet delivers clear dialogue and potent blues music, though lacks dynamism.
Extra: 70
Blu-ray of 'Black Snake Moan' features diverse extras, including insightful commentary by Brewer, in-depth making-of documentaries, and musically focused featurettes, though some content falls short in resolution and depth.
Movie: 63
'Black Snake Moan' is a gritty drama with strong performances and themes of redemption amidst controversial and complex issues, delivering a visually compelling but narratively uneven experience.
Video: 72
"Black Snake Moan" emerges on Blu-ray with a stunning High Definition 1080p video presentation, perfectly preserving the film's original theatrical widescreen aspect ratio of 2.35:1. Viewers will be immediately struck by the exceptional level of detail present in each frame, offering almost a 3D quality that enhances the cinematic experience. The picture clarity is remarkable, with minimal softness and an effectively restrained grain level, ensuring that even the darkest scenes maintain their integrity without any loss of detail. The color palette is rich and diverse, truly capturing the steamy atmosphere of the Deep South with vibrant hues that breathe life into the rural settings. Black levels are impressively deep, contributing to solid shadow details and giving the film a visual depth that stands out among recent HD releases.
The AVC MPEG-4 codec utilized for this transfer does an exemplary job at rendering sharp, detailed images that showcase incredible texture in skin tones, clothing, and the environment. This level of detail allows viewers to appreciate the subtle nuances of the film's production design, from the natural imperfections of skin to the intentional wear on costumes. The color stabilization is noteworthy, presenting bold and natural colors that remain consistent and convincing throughout. Despite a couple of minor instances where the picture appears slightly washed out, the overall contrast and clarity are nearly flawless, demonstrating an exceptional transfer process that rivals the quality seen in high-profile titles like "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest."
However, it's important for enthusiasts and newcomers alike to be aware that the film's 2.35:1 aspect ratio results in black bars at the top and bottom of the screen on standard displays. This is not a flaw but rather an intentional choice by the director to enhance the cinematic scope of the film. The careful balance of light and shadow, combined with the detailed presentation and lack of significant grain, contributes to a visually striking experience that sets a high standard for Blu-ray releases. While some may note the slight compromise on audio quality due to bandwidth allocation for video, the visual fidelity of this Blu-ray edition makes "Black Snake Moan" a reference-quality release that is sure to impress both casual viewers and ardent cinephiles alike.
Audio: 49
The Blu-ray release of "Black Snake Moan" offers a Dolby Digital 5.1 track which, while functional, doesn't exploit the full potential of the Blu-ray format due to the absence of an uncompressed audio option such as PCM 5.1 or Dolby TrueHD. Listeners will find dialogue clear and coherent, capturing the intensity of emotions from the shouts and screams to quieter moments and musical performances predominantly through the front channels. Ambient effects and the film's potent score, especially the blues tracks, provide a satisfactory auditory experience but are somewhat limited in their spatial dynamics, leaving the surround channels underutilized and resulting in a soundstage that feels constrained.
The soundtrack plays a crucial role in encapsulating the film's essence, particularly through its blues influences, which are highlighted from the opening scenes. However, the audio presentation suffers from a lack of depth and a two-dimensional quality that fails to do justice to the rawness of blues music, with some moments sounding harsh or overly compressed. The LFE channel is effectively employed, but moderate use of surrounds, shallow soundstage depth, and poor imaging detract from the overall immersive experience. The electric guitar scenes demonstrate both potential and limitations within this mix, as they vividly convey emotion yet reveal the audio's compression issues.
Despite these shortcomings, the Dolby Digital 5.1 mix delivers in several key areas. The moans of the blues guitar and vocal performances are particularly impactful, filling the room with engaging sound. Dialogue clarity and sound prioritization stand out, ensuring that elements like ambient noise and effects—such as chains dragging on wood floors—are conveyed with impressive realism. Nevertheless, inconsistencies in audio quality, notably in classic recordings and some sound effects, alongside a disparity in audio treatment between this release and its HD DVD counterpart, indicate missed opportunities to fully immerse viewers in the film's atmospheric blues soundtrack. This results in an audio experience that satisfies but doesn't astonish, reflecting a balance between technical adequacy and the limitations imposed by the chosen audio format.
Extras: 70
The Blu-ray extras for "Black Snake Moan" offer a comprehensive and engaging exploration into the film's creation, providing fans and newcomers alike with a deeper understanding of its unique narrative, characters, and musical roots. At the forefront is an insightful Audio Commentary by writer/director Craig Brewer, who shares captivating details about the film's development, the collaborative efforts behind its production, and personal anecdotes that enrich the viewing experience. "Conflicted: The Making of Black Snake Moan" delves into the complexities of bringing this almost fantastical story to life, featuring candid interviews with cast and crew alongside abundant behind-the-scenes footage. Musical featurettes, "Rooted in the Blues" and "The Black Snake Moan," focus on the film's auditory landscape, though they crave more in-depth treatment of the genre's historical significance. Despite this, they provide a fascinating glimpse into the music's creation. The collection also includes six Deleted Scenes in high definition, offering optional directorial commentary that sheds light on their exclusion from the final cut. While these additions provide greater insight into the narrative and characters, they're likely to be of interest mainly to die-hard fans. The theatrical trailer rounds off the disc's content, but it's the thoughtful inclusion of all these extras—especially Brewer's commentary—that significantly enhances the appreciation of this culturally rich and emotionally powerful film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Craig Brewer: Director Brewer provides an engaging, informative commentary.
- Conflicted: The Making of Black Snake Moan: A behind-the-scenes documentary with in-depth production insights.
- Rooted in the Blues: Discusses the film's music and its influence on the soundtrack.
- The Black Snake Moan Featurette: Focuses on the iconic song and its significance to the film.
- Deleted Scenes: Six scenes with optional director commentary, presented in high definition.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original theatrical trailer for the movie.
Movie: 63
"Black Snake Moan" emerged as a provocative and bold narrative, melding the soulful despair of blues with the gritty essence of the Deep South. Director Craig Brewer orchestrates this unusual tale with a finesse that veers between exploitation and deep exploration of redemption, sexuality, and salvation. While the film flaunts a mesmerizing visual quality, showcased by its crisp and vivid 1080p presentation on Blu-ray, its thematic execution dances on the edge of audacity without fully committing, leaving a residue of unfulfilled potential amidst its raw energy. Samuel L. Jackson's portrayal of Lazarus, the broken yet determined bluesman, alongside Christina Ricci’s daring performance as Rae, the nymphomaniac with a tormented psyche, delivers an undeniable on-screen chemistry that simmers with intensity and authenticity. Their complex characters anchor the movie’s emotional landscape, challenging viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about human frailty and the quest for inner peace.
The audiovisual elements of "Black Snake Moan" receive commendable treatment on Blu-ray, highlighting the Paramount release's technical prowess before the studio's shift in format allegiance. However, despite its technical specifications not entirely impressing on an audiophile level, the sound performance, particularly the blues-heavy soundtrack, envelops the narrative in an atmosphere so thick it becomes almost tangible. This sonic backdrop is crucial in driving the film's emotional core, meshing perfectly with the visual grittiness to encapsulate Lazarus's world. Yet, amidst its rich textural composition and impactful performances, the movie grapples with narrative cohesion. The story unfurls a tapestry of race, abuse, and redemption that occasionally falters under its ambitious weight—propelling forward with a momentum that feels both electrifying and erratic. The film’s conclusion draws mixed feelings, wrapping up complex themes in a resolution that leans towards being neatly tied rather than authentically resolved. While "Black Snake Moan" boasts originality and showcases Brewer’s bold vision, it ultimately teeters on the brink of becoming a cinematic enigma that intrigues as much as it divides.
Total: 63
In evaluating the Blu-ray presentation of "Black Snake Moan," it becomes evident that the film is a divisive piece of cinema that swings between the audacious and the profound. The story, centered around the unlikely relationship between Samuel L. Jackson's bluesman and Christina Ricci's troubled character, is bolstered by performances that turn potentially lurid material into a compelling narrative about redemption and healing. The visual and audio fidelity of the Blu-ray enhance this experience significantly, capturing the gritty ambiance of the South and the raw energy of the blues music that underscores the film's thematic core. The controversy stemming from its provocative imagery, especially the use of a chain in its marketing, underscores complex racial and historical connotations, which may challenge or discomfort some viewers. Yet, within the context of the film, these elements serve as a backdrop to the characters' journey rather than mere shock value.
The Blu-ray edition excels not just in storytelling but also in technical presentation. Boasting an exceptional visual transfer that vividly brings to life the film's setting and intense emotions, it pairs this with immersive audio quality that does justice to its critically integral blues soundtrack. The supplementary materials provided add depth to the viewing experience, offering insights that may reshape one's interpretation of the narrative and its characters. This package offers more than just the movie; it presents an enveloping sensory and intellectual experience.
In conclusion, "Black Snake Moan" on Blu-ray is a testament to the power of cinema to provoke thought, elicit emotion, and captivate through sensory richness. Jackson and Ricci's performances are elevated by the high-quality transfer, making their portrayal of damaged souls seeking solace all the more impactful. While certain thematic elements might stir controversy or discomfort, the overall presentation makes a compelling case for the film's artistic merits. It's a journey well worth taking for those seeking cinema that marries challenging narrative with technical excellence.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
The sun-drenched daytime scenes probably look the best, but it would be difficult to falter much with the visual presentation of this movie, with solid blacks allowing for decent shadowing and rounding...
Audio: 70
Still, dialogue comes presented clearly and coherently throughout, from the shouts and screams that dominate the first act, to the more quiet, contemplative offerings and then even the singing later on....
Extras: 80
Conflicted: The Making of Black Snake Moan is nearly half an hour in length and takes an in-depth look at this production, with comments from the crew: the writer, director, the composer and the producers,...
Movie: 70
It has two solid performances from the ever watchable Samuel L. Jackson and the surprisingly versatile Christina Ricci, and a dramatic story, with equal parts of depth and shallowness that make it average...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 90
And it looks extraordinary, which is a testament not only to the excellent transfer during Blu-ray production, but to the makeup and costume team....
Audio: 60
But for more lifelike sounds of voices and acoustic guitar and, in the same scene, the thunder itself, the BD falls short....
Extras: 80
That family relationship is about the strongest tie to the past, and much of the acoustic guitar work, although prerecorded, was actually played by Samuel Jackson....
Movie: 70
Early in the film, Lazarus' wife expresses resentment for his boring lifestyle and mentions with disdain his old-fashioned radiator as part of a world she wants to escape....
Total: 70
The image of a chain used by a black man to imprison a white woman has such stigma attached that one can't help but find it disturbing for a multitude of reasons....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
It's a stretch, but there are a couple of shots that looked slightly washed out compared to the rest of the ideally-contrasted picture....
Audio: 80
Some moments suffer from hollow treble ranges (listen to S. Epatha Merkerson's voice when she speaks to Jackson outside of the pharmacy), the audio quality of the classic recordings is predictably inconsistent,...
Extras: 60
Granted, there's some repetition here with Brewer's commentary, but this one's still informative with a lot of solid analysis from Jackson and Ricci on their characters....
Movie: 60
But then things start to unravel -- characters unexpectedly shift priorities, emotional healing happens off camera, seemingly deep-rooted impulses are abruptly under control, and the last ten minutes are...
Total: 80
Better still, this Blu-ray edition of the film features one of the best visual transfers I've seen, impressive audio, and a nice set of supplements that ultimately increased my appreciation of the film....
Director: Craig Brewer
Actors: Christina Ricci, Samuel L. Jackson, Justin Timberlake
PlotIn a small Tennessee town, Lazarus, a deeply religious farmer and former blues guitarist, is struggling to come to terms with his wife's betrayal. His life takes an unexpected turn when he finds Rae, a young woman with a troubled past, severely beaten and left for dead on the side of the road. Rae is known in the town for her promiscuity, which is partly a coping mechanism for her traumatic experiences and abandonment issues. Her boyfriend, Ronnie, who suffers from severe anxiety, has recently left for military service, exacerbating Rae's feelings of loneliness and vulnerability.
Feeling a moral obligation to help, Lazarus takes Rae into his home to nurse her back to health. Dissatisfied with her dangerous lifestyle and determined to mend her ways, Lazarus uses unconventional methods to keep her from further self-destruction. A unique bond forms between them as they share their stories and vulnerabilities. Lazarus finds a new purpose in helping Rae, seeing it as a way to redeem both of their lives. This unconventional relationship sets the stage for a journey of mutual healing, self-discovery, and redemption, against a backdrop of the Mississippi blues culture that shapes their environment and interactions.
Writers: Craig Brewer
Release Date: 02 Mar 2007
Runtime: 116 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English