Silent Night Blu-ray Review
Score: 71
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Silent Night offers stylish action and superb audio-visual quality, though its predictable plot and lackluster extras may not impress all viewers.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 85
Silent Night's Blu-ray presentation delivers an impressive 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 2.00:1, showcasing gritty, blood-popping details with no black crush and strong contrast, even in its darker scenes. Though some grain persists, Woo's skilled direction ensures a consistently engaging visual experience.
Audio: 90
Silent Night's Dolby Atmos track brilliantly blends Marco Beltrami's immersive score with dynamic sound effects, creating a rich listening experience that compensates for minimal dialogue and effectively utilizes directional audio across the surround channels.
Extra: 21
The Blu-ray extras for 'Silent Night' include a noteworthy featurette, 'Actions Speak Louder Than Words' (HD; 16:50), which offers comprehensive insights with cast and crew interviews, surpassing typical 'Making of...' segments, complemented by a theatrical trailer and additional DVD and digital copies, all in a slipcovered package.
Movie: 56
Silent Night ambitiously eschews dialogue, leaning on John Woo's signature action flair to drive a revenge plot. Despite echoes of Woo's past visual mastery, the mute gimmick and familiar vengeance narrative fail to recapture his classic intensity, leaving a somewhat lukewarm yet visually engaging experience.
Video: 85
The Blu-ray presentation of "Silent Night" by Lionsgate Films showcases an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.00:1 aspect ratio. While the exact digital intermediate (DI) resolution remains unspecified, the visual narrative is strikingly detailed. The film's darker thematic elements result in frequently somber and grisly sequences, accentuated by a vibrant depiction of blood against a predominantly slate gray and blue palette. This stylistic choice effectively heightens the visceral impact of the film's violence, with reds particularly standing out with unsettling clarity. Conversely, the cinematography also offers moments of warmth through golden hued and sepia-toned sequences, capturing the lighter moments in the story with commendable fine detail and excellent facial feature resolution through Woo and cinematographer Sharone Meir's use of extreme close-ups.
As a hallmark of its genre, "Silent Night" navigates a predominantly dark visual landscape with remarkable precision. The Blu-ray’s 2.00:1 AVC HD image remains unchallenged in delivering a robust and stable representation of shadowy scenes, devoid of black crush or shadow movement. This strong contrast performance is complemented by outstanding detail retention, even in the film's more monstrous displays. Despite some minor instances of grain on select scenes, the overall video quality adheres to contemporary Blu-ray standards, providing an immersive visual experience that does justice to John Woo's cinematic craftsmanship.
Audio: 90
The audio presentation of "Silent Night" on Blu-ray boasts a uniquely crafted Dolby Atmos track that stands out due to its reliance on sound effects and Marco Beltrami's compelling score rather than traditional dialogue. The track skillfully incorporates background elements, such as chatter on police radios, offering moments of clarity and depth. The impressive mix ensures an immersive experience with dynamic stunt and action sound work that utilizes the surround channels effectively, creating a feeling of sounds almost boomeranging around the audience. Beltrami discusses in the supplementary materials how scoring a virtually dialogue-free movie was a distinct challenge, yet his composition integrates seamlessly within the expansive soundstage.
Additionally, the Dolby Atmos track enriches the auditory experience with crisp and rich vocals where they occur naturally, maintaining clarity and richness albeit limited by design. The directional effects are employed with commendable precision, keeping the front stage actively engaged. While the mix may not reach the level of the most robust tracks available, it proves to be highly competent, delivering an immersive environment that matches modern standards for action-driven films. The inclusion of English and Spanish subtitles adds further accessibility, underscoring the film's creative audio execution. Despite the film's unique audio approach, "Silent Night" emerges as an audio experience that does not wait for a 4K update to be appreciated fully.
Extras: 21
The Blu Ray extras for "Silent Night" present a well-rounded glimpse into the making of the film, albeit limited. "Actions Speak Louder Than Words" serves as a substantial addition to the disc, offering viewers a comprehensive 16-minute exploration into the film’s production. This feature surpasses typical “Making of” offerings by including insightful commentary from the cast and crew, coupled with behind-the-scenes footage that enhances the understanding of the filmmaking process. The inclusion of the theatrical trailer provides a brief, yet immersive revisit to the film’s original promotional material. Packaging-wise, the disc includes both DVD and digital copies, along with a slipcover, adding value for collectors and enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Actions Speak Louder Than Words: A comprehensive exploration of the film’s production with cast and crew insights and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material for the film's release.
Movie: 56
"Silent Night" delivers a distinctive take on the action thriller genre by eliminating traditional dialogue—a bold direction for John Woo's return to American cinema. This film revels in visual storytelling while sidestepping unnecessary exposition, highlighting Woo's renowned mastery of action choreography. The narrative opens in medias res, introducing Brian Godlock, portrayed by Joel Kinnaman, in a frenetic escapade through gritty back alleys, catalyzed by the gang-fueled death of his son. This traumatic event, rendered with a palpable sense of melancholy, becomes the nucleus for a plot threading together Brian's silent quest for vengeance after being rendered mute.
Despite the central revenge theme mirroring countless predecessors, "Silent Night" injects a refreshing twist: Brian lacks the prototypical skills of vengeance-seekers, making his mission more perilous and his blunders relatable. This amateur element adds tension and authenticity to confrontations with Harold Torres’s villainous Playa. A detective played by Scott Mescudi hovers at the periphery, setting the stage for an expected climactic showdown. While this setup might entice action aficionados with its unique gimmick, it occasionally falls short of the exhilarating Woo experiences from decades past.
Visually, "Silent Night" retains snippets of Woo's iconic style, though it may not match the visual splendor of his earlier classics. Some may find the absence of dialogue a mere novelty that overemphasizes the film's inevitable comparisons to similar revenge narratives. Nevertheless, fans of both Woo and Kinnaman are likely to appreciate this streamlined cinematic experience for its attempt at innovation within the well-trodden vigilante sub-genre. While it doesn't quite capture the explosive magic of Woo's formative works, it lays a decent ground for appreciation among those who long for simplicity and raw emotion over complex storytelling.
Total: 71
"Silent Night" on Blu-ray delivers an exhilarating, if not entirely fresh, experience emblematic of John Woo's directorial style. With action-heavy sequences and the hallmark fluid camera work that Woo fans cherish, this film caters effectively to those who appreciate high-octane cinematics. The film employs a unique conceit with its lack of dialogue, an artistic choice that may intrigue or perplex viewers in equal measure. Some might consider it unnecessary, yet it adds to the film's distinct identity. The production, done on a relatively shoestring budget, resulted in a rapid shooting schedule which contributes to its inconsistent tone, oscillating between raw intensity and brooding melancholy.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray release from Lionsgate stands out. The video quality is exceptional, capturing intricate details and vibrant colors that enhance the viewing experience. The audio presentation matches this, delivering an immersive soundscape that underscores the film's dynamic sequences. However, the disc does fall short in terms of bonus content, offering limited supplementary material, which might disappoint collectors looking for an in-depth exploration behind the scenes.
In summary, "Silent Night" may not reach the iconic status of Woo's past classics but remains an engaging watch with notable stylistic elements and technical prowess. It's a film that resonates well with action enthusiasts and offers a visual spectacle that's effectively rendered on Blu-ray. While the storyline may tread familiar ground and lacks depth in bonuses, it remains a worthy addition for those who appreciate the genre and Woo’s signature cinematic flourishes.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Some interior moments in the wake of the tragedy have an almost sepia tone, but despite all of these grading choices (sometimes rather smartly in tandem with the palette of sets and costumes), fine detail...
Audio: 100
Silent Night offers a rather interestingly designed Dolby Atmos track, one that relies on, yes, actual understandable words at least now and again courtesy of some background chatter on police radios and...
Extras: 20
Theatrical Trailer (HD; 2:21) Additionally, DVD and digital copies are included, and packaging features a slipcover....
Movie: 60
That's the "big" conceit of this John Woo film, which has a lot of Woo's trademark flourishes in the gunfire and fisticuffs departments, and which actually manages to convey its plot mechanics rather artfully...
Total: 60
There's a fair amount of style on hand in Silent Night, and John Woo fans in particular might want to check this one out for those flourishes....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
Detail looks good as well, as we’d might expect, this is particularly unnerving when we see some of the creates that the film has to offer....
Audio: 90
Vocals are crisp and rich (to a point and once you’ve seen the film, you’ll know why), directional effects are used with great ambition and the front stage manages to stay pretty active throughout....
Extras: 30
It’s a step above the average “Making of…” featurette and we get insight from the cast and crew as well as, you guessed it, some behind the scenes shots....
Movie: 0
This isn’t one of his better works when it comes to visuals, but there are some tell tale signs of the acclaimed director....
Total: 70
This might be a far cry from some of Woo’s films from the 90’s, but it’s actually a fairly decent flick....
Director: John Woo
Actors: Joel Kinnaman, Kid Cudi, Harold Torres
PlotIn the heart of a city gripped by a relentless snowstorm, a trio of strangers find their lives unexpectedly intertwined on Christmas Eve. Joel, a disillusioned war veteran struggling to reconcile with his past, crosses paths with Cudi, a charismatic street artist with a mysterious agenda. As the night unfolds, they encounter Torres, an enigmatic figure with a complex connection to both men. Each harboring secrets and battling personal demons, they find themselves on a collision course with fate, forced to confront their deepest fears and desires.
As the storm intensifies, the city becomes a labyrinth of snow-covered streets and hidden dangers. The unlikely trio must navigate the treacherous urban landscape, pursued by a shadowy adversary with a vendetta that threatens to destroy them all. Their journey is a test of survival, friendship, and courage, pushing them to the limits of endurance and forcing them to make impossible choices. In the silence of the night, amidst the chaos of the storm, they discover the true meaning of redemption, sacrifice, and hope.
Writers: Robert Archer Lynn
Release Date: 01 Dec 2023
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Mexico
Language: None