Goodbye, Don Glees! Blu-ray Review
グッバイ、ドン・グリーズ!
Score: 67
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
A narrative balancing poignant coming-of-age themes with expressive animation, 'Goodbye, Don Glees!' impresses despite limited Blu-ray extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
The Blu-ray of "Goodbye, Don Glees!" presents an impressive 1.78:1 AVC encoded 1080p image, showcasing vibrant colors, deep black levels, and a rich, earthy palette. The transfer is nearly flawless, delivering well-detailed landscapes and smooth motion, offering an engaging visual experience with subdued yet stunning visuals.
Audio: 75
The Blu-ray of 'Goodbye, Don Glees!' features an immersive 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix in both Japanese and English, offering distinct dialogue and vibrant atmospheric effects that enhance the cinematic experience, supported by an eclectic score that beautifully complements the visual narrative.
Extra: 35
The Blu-ray extras for "Goodbye, Don Glees!" are limited but insightful, featuring a concise interview with director Atsuko Ishizuka, who illuminates her influences from "Stand By Me," character development, and the film's settings, complemented by an array of trailers. The interview provides valuable context despite its brevity.
Movie: 73
Goodbye, Don Glees! impressively explores the emotional lives of teenage boys through a mesmerizing, richly-textured visual journey by Atsuko Ishizuka; the Blu-Ray's 1.78:1 AVC encoded transfer captures the vibrant forest settings with lush greens, golds, and ambers, though some mild banding and digital noise are present.
Video: 76
The Blu-ray presentation of "Goodbye, Don Glees!" achieves an impressive visual display in its 1.78:1 AVC encoded transfer. Opting for a variable bitrate (VBR) encoding, the video remains crisp and technically sophisticated, effectively utilizing the space on a BD-50 disc for its 96-minute runtime. The presentation is anchored by a realistic palette, yet it offers lively primaries that capture the rich natural landscapes central to the story. Colors are vibrant, with lush forest greens and bright reds punctuating scenes—such as a vivid red phone booth against the lush backdrop. Mild banding and minimal digital noise are present but do not detract from the overall stellar image quality.
The technical finesse is evident in the film’s ability to hold saturation without compression artifacts. Character designs by Takahiro Yoshimatsu, coupled with Ayano Okamoto's art direction, elevate the visual experience, presenting detailed animation supported by expressive backdrops. The animation favors a grounded aesthetic, which is apparent in its earthier tones and substantial visuals. Fireworks and other bright elements in the film pop with striking depth, contrasting beautifully against deep black levels that enrich dimensionality throughout the narrative.
Moreover, the video quality, although not flamboyant compared to more lavish anime productions, serves the coming-of-age storyline with admirable fidelity. Its subtle approach lends itself well to capturing sunbeams and cosmic sequences like those in Iceland, which adds an ethereal quality to the imagery. The stylistic choices align with Madhouse’s production values, delivering a warm nostalgic feel—a technically proficient transfer that allows the film to shine visually, resonating with its thematic essence.
Audio: 75
The Blu-ray presentation of "Goodbye, Don Glees!" delivers an engaging audio experience through its 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio tracks available in both English and Japanese. Notably, dialogue is distinct and clear, contributing to a sharp comprehension of character emotions. The mix maintains a rigorous atmosphere with effective use of environmental soundscapes and separation effects, creating immersive ambient noise like cicadas and reverberations that enhance the film’s setting. This atmospheric depth adds to the film’s warmth and intimacy, effectively drawing viewers into its heartfelt narrative landscape.
The LFE channel impressively supports scenes like fireworks displays and surging water, adding tangible impact without overpowering the overall mix. The soundtrack excels in delivering Yoshiaki Fujisawa's eclectic score, which ranges from delicate piano solos to thunderous orchestral pieces, each resonating beautifully within the soundscape. Although directional effects are minimal, the audio mix maintains constant engagement, ensuring an enveloping listener experience. Both audio tracks provide textural fidelity and are supported by English, Spanish, and French subtitle options.
While purists may prefer the original Japanese audio due to superior voice acting, the English dub offers a commendable performance with voice actors such as Adam McArthur and Nick Wolfhard bringing the characters to life. Generally, neither track overtly outshines the other, allowing for a satisfying choice based on listener preference. The thorough atmosphere presented across the front soundstage, with precise sound effects and solid dynamics, ensures that audiences receive a consistent and fulfilling auditory experience from this Blu-ray release, truly complementing the film’s evocative visual journey.
Extras: 35
The extras of the "Goodbye, Don Glees!" Blu-ray may be limited, but they offer insightful content for fans and film enthusiasts alike. The standout feature is the Interview with Director Atsuko Ishizuka, a 10-minute conversation in High Definition. Here, Ishizuka delves into her creative influences, notably discussing contrasts and comparisons with films like "Stand by Me," and providing personal insights into her character development and setting choices. Despite its brevity, the interview is revealing, highlighting her thoughtful storytelling approach and the film's thematic exploration of self-discovery. Additionally, a collection of Trailers lasting over seven minutes provides various perspectives through promotional material, including teasers and full trailers in both English and Japanese dubs. Despite the sparse selection, these features add valuable context to the cinematic experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Director Atsuko Ishizuka: Insights into film influences, character and setting choices.
- Trailers: A collection of promotional trailers in various languages.
Movie: 73
Atsuko Ishizuka's "Goodbye, Don Glees!" represents a remarkable entry into the realm of feature-length anime, marking a memorable directorial debut with original material. The film tells the story of three teenagers—Roma, Toto, and Drop—embarking on an innocuous summer adventure that swiftly transforms into a profound journey of self-discovery. The film is reminiscent of classics like "Stand By Me," weaving a tale that explores adolescence, friendship, and the universal theme of coming to terms with life's realities, including mortality. This exploration is rendered through Ishizuka's sensitive direction, masterfully combining the painful echoes of teenage anxieties with moments of humor and warmth.
Technically, the film thrives on its stunning animation, which proficiently captures the lush aesthetics of the forest setting. The 1.78:1 AVC encoded transfer provides a visually rich and engaging experience, with Shout Factory employing a variable bitrate encode ensuring vibrant and lifelike color representation. The forest's palette of greens, golds, ambers, and the striking red phone booth are artfully detailed, contributing to the film's immersive visual appeal. This level of detail enhances the fantastical elements that punctuate the boys' adventure, infusing a whimsical yet poignant rhythm into their quest for innocence and identity.
Narratively, "Goodbye, Don Glees!" balances engaging coming-of-age themes with insights into social expectations and personal growth. The interactions among the trio are portrayed with authenticity and nuance, allowing viewers to traverse the spectrum of adolescent experiences from playful antics to introspective encounters. While at times veering into melodramatic territories common in anime storytelling, Ishizuka maintains a delicate balance between character-driven moments and thematic explorations. Overall, "Goodbye, Don Glees!" stands out as a thoughtfully crafted portrayal of youthful exploration and resilience amid life's unpredictabilities, promising a nostalgic and resonant experience for audiences.
Total: 67
"Goodbye, Don Glees!" is an earnest, often poignant coming-of-age anime that captures the raw emotions and adventurous spirit of three teenage outcasts as they navigate the intricacies of friendship. Atsuko Ishizuka’s direction and writing delve into the inner lives of teens, deftly exploring their evolving emotions and actions. The film's expressive animation enhances its narrative strength, although its intent to steer viewers towards emotional responses may at times overwhelm its dramatic depth.
The Blu-ray release by GKIDS and Shout! Factory delivers impressive visual and audio quality, boasting a 1.78:1 AVC aspect ratio both in English and Japanese DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio tracks. The vibrant animation style is preserved with exceptional clarity, enriching the viewer's experience. Subtitles available in English SDH, English, Spanish, and French further enhance accessibility. However, the disc’s extras are minimal, a drawback for those seeking deeper insights or bonus content.
In conclusion, though "Goodbye, Don Glees!" may not have extensive extras, its emotional resonance and technical excellence make it a standout. A bittersweet narrative that strikes a universal chord with audiences, the film is particularly memorable for its heartfelt exploration of youthful bonds and the limitless potential of imaginative storytelling within the anime genre. Despite minor shortcomings, this Blu-ray is a worthwhile addition to any collection, heartily recommended for its audiovisual presentation and emotional depth.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
Banding is very mild and I only noticed a little bit of digital noise in some of the overhead shots of a grain field....
Audio: 90
...
Extras: 30
Movie: 80
I had to rewind and play the scene a couple of times because I was laughing so hard) is by far my favorite, but the final act of the movie in the middle of the forest is tear jerking....
Total: 80
My only complaint was that Gkids didn’t supply many extras to Shout Factory, as they are a tad anemic on the disc....
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
With much of the tale occurring in the outdoors, a rich sense of greenery is found, exploring different environments....
Audio: 90
Atmospherics are active, capturing a sense of nature and neighborhood activity, helped along by mild panning and separation effects....
Extras: 50
Interview (10:33, HD) is a conversation with writer/director Atsuko Ishizuka, who covers topics including the ages of the boys, her "Stand by Me" influences, her decision on gender, characterization, personal...
Movie: 60
A plot forms with the wildfire incident, but "Goodbye, Don Glees" is mostly invested in character, with Ishizuka trying to remain intimate with the boys as they deal with external pressures and fixations,...
Total: 80
"Goodbye, Don Glees" is nicely animated for this type of endeavor, capturing expressive characters and the beauty of the world, which helps the viewing experience immensely....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 95
While directionalized effects are kept to a minimum, there’s constant atmosphere from the sounds of cicadas or other insects, and reverberations are used throughout in order to expand the sense of presence—when...
Extras: 40
She does address the similarities to Stand by Me, but points out that Goodbye, Don Glees! is really a dramatic reversal of that film—it’s not a case where adults are returning to see just how small their...
Movie: 90
That’s true despite the fact that the story bears some passing similarities to Stand by Me, in that it’s a coming-of-age tale about a group of friends who journey into the wilderness in search of something,...
Total: 79
While a few more extras would have been appreciated, Goodbye, Don Glees! is the kind of film that’s best appreciated on a subconscious level, rather than over-analyzing why it works the way that it does....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
Character designs and art direction lean towards realism, though it’s a detailed style with expressive backgrounds and substantial visuals....
Audio: 60
The surround mixes offer excellent atmosphere and cleanly intelligible dialogue, if sometimes lacking in the engaging discrete activity of bigger productions....
Extras: 20
Interview with Director Atsuko Ishizuka (10:33 in HD; Japanese audio w/ English subtitles) – Rare for anime films, the female director and writer behind this movie discusses the setting and characters....
Movie: 80
While the movie dabbles in fairly common anime conventions, there are obvious Hollywood influences strewn throughout the engaging plot....
Total: 55
An earnest and often poignant coming-of-age anime film influenced by Hollywood about three teenage outcasts maturing together and the power of their friendship....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The dream-like sequences in Iceland and the meteor shower offer a cosmic sense of wonderment to the images beefing up the nostalgia quotient....
Audio: 60
The two available tracks are a Japanese 5.1 and an English 5.1 audio track both offering identical listening experiences and textural fidelity....
Extras: 40
You get a series of trailers for the film including: English dub, Japanese dub, 60 second Japanese dub trailer, 90 second teaser Japanese dub, and a full length Japanese dub....
Movie: 60
While the film wrestles with many heady ideas, its visual clarity through the animation allows the feature to attain a magical aesthetic working in parallel with the boy’s whimsical adventure....
Total: 60
Goodbye, Don Glees! is a bittersweet coming-of-age tale that tugs at the heartstrings with the same subtlety as teenagers fighting off a bear in the woods....
Director: Atsuko Ishizuka
Actors: Natsuki Hanae, Yûki Kaji, Ayumu Murase
PlotRōma, Toto, and Drop are three teenage boys who form an adventurous trio named "Don Glees," spending their days exploring their rural town, seeking excitement and camaraderie. The narrative kicks off with Rōma returning from Tokyo to reunite with his close friend, Toto. Meanwhile, Drop, an eccentric newcomer with a vibrant personality, joins their group, forming a strong bond with Rōma and Toto. During a summer fireworks festival, their care-free joy is cut short when they are falsely blamed for causing a forest fire that occurs in the area. To clear their name and prove their innocence, the trio embarks on a thrilling journey into the wilderness.
The boys' adventure takes them through breathtaking landscapes and challenges them in unpredictable ways. Along the way, they confront personal fears and hidden truths about themselves and each other, strengthening their friendship as they navigate the obstacles thrown their way. Their mission becomes a quest for self-discovery just as much as it is about finding vindication. As they inch closer to proving their innocence, they are tested to the limits both physically and emotionally in the vast natural world around them. The story paints a vivid picture of youthful innocence intersecting with the harsh realities of growing up, beautifully intertwining themes of friendship, trust, and coming-of-age.
Writers: Atsuko Ishizuka
Release Date: 18 Feb 2022
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: PG
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese