The Ladykillers Blu-ray Review
StudioCanal Collection
Score: 60
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Ladykillers on Blu-ray offers a definitive presentation of this classic dark comedy with exceptional directing, clever dialogue, and extensive supplemental material.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 55
The Ladykillers' Blu-ray, presented in 1080p AVC at 1.33:1, showcases impressive restoration of its Technicolor source despite some color fringing and grain. Improvements include brighter images and better solidity of color compared to the previous DVD release. Fans will appreciate this faithful visual upgrade.
Audio: 51
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix for 'The Ladykillers' offers a faithful, crisp, and distortion-free preservation of the original dialogue-heavy soundtrack, achieving subtle clarity and balance gains without artificial enhancements or defects, maintaining an authentic audio experience true to its 55-year-old source material.
Extra: 73
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Ladykillers' offer a treasure trove for film buffs, featuring insightful commentaries and interviews with industry veterans, a compelling 'Forever Ealing' documentary narrated by Daniel Day-Lewis, and an impressive restoration segment showcasing meticulous efforts by MTI.
Movie: 80
'The Ladykillers' Blu-ray features an exceptional 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer at 1.33:1, eliminating past imperfections for a sharp, true-to-period image. The DTS-HD MA 2.0 sound mix ensures clear dialogue without interference. Coupled with a compelling commentary, a documentary on Ealing Studios, and engaging interviews, this release rejuvenates the classic dark comedy featuring standout performances from Alec Guinness and Katie Johnson, blending wit, irony, and charm seamlessly.
Video: 55
The Blu-ray release of "The Ladykillers" features an impressive 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 encoded transfer, presented in the accurate 1.33:1 aspect ratio (previously misrepresented as 1.37:1 in some discussions). This meticulous restoration by MTI rekindles the film’s original aesthetic, despite the inherent grain from the three-strip Technicolor process. While grain may be visible, it aligns with the authentic period look. The Blu-ray surpasses previous DVD editions with a brighter, more solid color representation. Skin tones remain pink, true to the film's original palette, and black levels maintain adequate depth. Notably, a subtle chromatic distortion—color fringing—may catch the eye but does not detract crucially from the viewing experience given its limited presence.
MTI Film’s restoration effort is commendable, involving advanced digital techniques to remove scratches, dirt, burn marks, and other degradations without compromising on director Alexander Mackendrick's vision. The transfer maintains the film grain, ensuring an untampered cinematic authenticity. Despite some remaining issues such as the misalignment of primary colors leading to occasional red fringing and a notable light bleed in a taxi scene with Mrs. Wilberforce, the presentation looks notably cleaned up compared to its initial damaged state. Colors and contrast reflect the original lightly hued dull scheme faithfully, though high-definition clarity does amplify the artificial look of rear-projection scenes.
Overall, while “The Ladykillers” may not achieve the pristine clarity of modern productions or HDR enhancements like Dolby Vision, this Blu-ray release provides a significant visual upgrade from its predecessors, making it the best presentation yet of this classic film. Fans and purists alike will appreciate the visual fidelity achieved in this meticulous remastering effort.
Audio: 51
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix for "The Ladykillers" offers a commendable audio presentation that remains faithful to the original sound design. This adherence to the source material ensures that the heavily dialogue-driven film maintains clarity and precision throughout its runtime, with no unwanted scratchiness, distortion, or noise artifacts such as hiss or pops. A welcome upgrade to lossless audio provides a subtle but appreciable enhancement in clarity and balance, ensuring the dialogues are crisply rendered. Vocal nuances of each character are reproduced with an exceptional degree of accuracy, which is critical for a film reliant on verbal interaction.
While lacking an immersive surround sound experience, the 2.0 mix compensates by balancing environmental sound effects well within the overall composition without them being intrusive. The whimsical score composed by Tristram Cary adds a charming layer to the soundtrack, fitting seamlessly into the mix and augmenting the film’s aesthetic. Although there are no significant gains in dynamic range or bass impact due to the confines of the original recording quality, elements like music and occasional sound effects, such as train noises, stand out with greater clarity during pivotal moments.
Available in English, French, and Spanish, this audio track allows for multilingual accessibility but doesn't leverage modern surround sound imaging or extensive dynamic breadth. In some instances, Dolby ProLogic can be employed to center-channel dialogues, supporting a slightly more authentic listening experience reflective of the original source. Overall, it is a meticulously handled upgrade that respects the integrity of the original 55-year-old recording while offering clear and dependable sound quality for contemporary audiences.
Extras: 73
The Blu-ray release of "The Ladykillers" offers an impressive array of extras that enhance the viewing experience for any film enthusiast. Although original storyboards and deleted scenes are absent due to their unfortunate destruction, the supplemental content provided compensates for this loss. The inclusion of an insightful audio commentary by film historian Philip Kemp, although somewhat dry in delivery, is particularly noteworthy for the depth of information it offers. Additionally, Terry Gilliam's brief introduction conveys his admiration for the film. The "Forever Ealing" documentary, narrated by Daniel Day-Lewis, serves as an enlightening exploration of Ealing Studios' storied history. Interviews with Allan Scott, Ronald Harwood, and Terence Davies provide valuable perspectives on director Alexander Mackendrick's influence and working methods. Lastly, the restoration feature showcases the extensive efforts made to clean and preserve the original film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by Terry Gilliam: The director briefly offers some thoughts on the film.
- Audio Commentary: Film historian Philip Kemp delivers a well-researched commentary.
- 'Forever Ealing' Documentary: Narrated by Daniel Day-Lewis, this documentary covers the history of Ealing Studios.
- Interview with Allan Scott: Discusses acting, themes, and production history.
- Interview with Ronald Harwood: Shares experiences with Alexander Mackendrick.
- Interview with Terence Davies: Explains Mackendrick's influence on his style.
- Cleaning up 'The Ladykillers': Details techniques used to restore the film.
- Trailer: High-definition trailer showcasing the film.
Movie: 80
The Ladykillers (1955), the quintessential Ealing comedy directed by Alexander Mackendrick, stands as a benchmark in British dark humour. With its meticulous restoration for the Blu-ray release, the film is presented in a visually pleasing 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer at a 1.33:1 aspect ratio. The cleanup efforts have effectively removed the dust, dirt, and scratches that previously marred its quality, resulting in a sharp image with period-accurate coloration. The monochrome detailing adds a nostalgic charm, enhancing both visual storytelling and character features.
Accompanied by a crisp DTS-HD MA 2.0 sound mix, this version brings clear dialogue without any hiss, snap, crackle, or pop, thereby preserving the auditory integrity of the film. The audio commentary by film historian Philip Kemp and a 50-minute documentary on Ealing Studios enriches the viewing experience by providing in-depth insights into the production.
The narrative centers around Mrs. Wilberforce (Katie Johnson), an elderly widow living near London’s Kings Cross Station. Her life takes a drastic twist when Professor Marcus (Alec Guinness) rents her upper apartment under the pretext of rehearsing with his ensemble of 'musicians', who are in fact orchestrating a heist. This naive woman gradually finds herself entangled in their criminal web, serving biscuits and tea to a gang comprising Peter Sellers, Herbert Lom, Cecil Parker, and Danny Green.
Alec Guinness' portrayal of Professor Marcus is marked by natural comedic flair paired with sinister undertones, his appearance enhanced by disheveled hair and fake teeth. Katie Johnson’s performance remains a highlight, with her seamless switch from a doting grandma to a steely adversary capturing the audience's admiration. Her encounter with the inept crooks is hilariously complex, blending tragic elements with moments of genuine folly. William Rose’s script is an exemplary dark comedy where situational humor trumps conventional jokes, epitomizing cinematic sophistication.
Total: 60
'The Ladykillers' on Blu-ray is a delightful blend of dark comedy and suspense, cementing its status as a classic over five decades. Directed with precision and supported by a first-rate cast, this release will undoubtedly appeal to fans of both genres. The humor and tension are carefully balanced, making it a film that remains engaging and relevant even today. The StudioCanal Collection's effort to compete alongside The Criterion Collection is commendable, and this Blu-ray release showcases their dedication to presenting high-quality films.
The high-definition transfer of 'The Ladykillers' is superb, exceeding prior versions in every technical aspect. The picture quality is crisp with vibrant colors that enhance the visual experience, and the audio is clear, maintaining the integrity of the original sound design. In addition, the supplemental package is extensive, offering a wealth of value-added material that provides deeper insight into the film's production and legacy. Fans will appreciate the effort put into this release, making it a worthy addition to any collection.
In conclusion, 'The Ladykillers' is a must-own title for any and all fans of classic dark comedy. Combining lasting appeal, a first-rate cast, exceptional directing, and clever dialog, the film's relevance is undeniable. This new high-definition presentation offers a definitive technical presentation that exceeds prior versions in every possible way while also delivering an extensive supplemental package of value-added material. If you've been waiting for the right time to buy 'The Ladykillers', this is it.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
As a result of being shot using the three strip Technicolor process, there is a certain amount of visible grain in the transfer, but that's how it was and how it should be left....
Audio: 70
As the film is heavily reliant on dialogue, it's good to know that what we now have is crisp and clear with no muddiness at all....
Extras: 80
This short item gives us the opportunity to fully appreciate the effort put in by MTI to restore 'The Ladykillers' through various 'before and after' split screen views of the film....
Movie: 80
Gone is the dust, dirt and scratches that plagued previous releases and we're given a sharp, realistically coloured image for the period....
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Dustin SomnerRead review here
Video: 80
Some might complain that the image is too bright to reflect an accurate representation of the source material (the prior DVD was much darker), but given the depth of the color palette and black levels,...
Audio: 80
Listening to the dialog-heavy track, I never noticed a shred of distortion, hiss, or dropout, and the vocal nuances of each character were reproduced with a high level of accuracy....
Extras: 90
Introduction by Terry Gilliam (480p, Dolby Digital 2.0, 2:58 min): This brief interview with the talented director demonstrates the level of appreciation he has for the classic production, yet barely scratches...
Movie: 90
Alec Guinness had already made a name for himself through his roles in other Ealing productions, so despite not being the first choice for the villainous role of Professor Marcus, he turned out to be the...
Total: 90
This new high-definition presentation offers a definitive technical presentation that exceeds prior versions in every possible way, while also managing to deliver an extensive supplemental package of value-added...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Contrast is flat, and textures can be seen in the foreground, but lose their sharpness when they recede into the background, limiting depth....
Audio: 60
The loudness is limited to infrequent music stings and train activity, the latter of which increases during the climax....
Extras: 60
Modern directors, such as Martin Scorsese, John Landis, Richard Attenborough, and Stephen Frears, speak about the films that came out of the studio....
Movie: 80
Director Mackendrick used a light, yet purposeful touch, as he allowed the story to unfold before the camera, the results are both surprising and truly entertaining....
Total: 60
Looking to compete alongside The Criterion Collection, they have delivered a comparable product with this good Blu-ray release featuring a decent number of extras....
Director: Alexander Mackendrick
Actors: Alec Guinness, Peter Sellers, Cecil Parker
PlotIn a quaint London neighborhood, an elderly widow named Mrs. Wilberforce lives alone with her parrots. She unknowingly rents a room to a group of criminals masquerading as a string quintet, led by the cunning and eccentric Professor Marcus. The crooks plan to use her home as the base for a meticulously planned heist, intending to rob an armored car without arousing suspicion. They convince Mrs. Wilberforce that their frequent comings and goings are merely for rehearsals, deceiving her with their musical instruments and polite manners.
As the plot unfolds, the gang's uneasy cohesion begins to fray, and Mrs. Wilberforce becomes suspicious. Her genuine kindness and naivety, combined with a series of humorous misunderstandings, complicate the criminals' straightforward scheme. The discord among the thieves grows, leading to a series of comedic and chaotic mishaps. The tension between the group's superficial charm and concealed malice intensifies, revealing the precariousness of their plan. Thwarted by their own blunders and the unexpected savvy of their unsuspecting landlady, the situation escalates, teetering on the brink of failure.
Writers: William Rose, Jimmy O'Connor
Release Date: 03 Feb 1956
Runtime: 91 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English