Steel Magnolias Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Steel Magnolias' Blu-ray offers an exceptional video and audio experience, beautifully presenting the timeless story with an all-star cast; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 85
Steel Magnolias offers a high-quality 1080p transfer that showcases excellent detail, stable color balance, and natural cinematic texture, faithfully rendering its 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Colors are pleasing, contrast is well-calibrated, and the lack of source blemishes confirms this Blu-ray as a top-notch Sony release.
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray release of Steel Magnolias features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack that delivers clear, detailed dialogue and charming small-town atmospherics, with minimal sonic impact from effects like gunshots and firecrackers, and a supportive, though unobtrusive, musical score.
Extra: 51
Sony's Blu-ray of 'Steel Magnolias' retains the dry audio commentary from director Herbert Ross, the nostalgic 'In Full Bloom' featurette, and ten brief deleted scenes. It also includes the original trailer but lacks the isolated score track from the Twilight Time release.
Movie: 81
"Steel Magnolias," directed by Herbert Ross, is a heartwarming and poignant blend of comedy and drama, focusing on the resilience and friendship of six Southern women. The Blu-ray release boasts robust performances, particularly from Sally Field, Julia Roberts, and Dolly Parton, with strong video and audio quality enhancing this touching, episodic narrative.
Video: 85
The Blu-ray presentation of "Steel Magnolias" provides a superbly filmic 1080p transfer, delivering crisp imagery and a reliable, consistent detailing. The transfer adheres to the film's theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1, utilizing the AVC codec. This ensures a natural sharpness that complements the film’s aesthetic without appearing overly aggressive. The grain structure is meticulously maintained, adding a handsome cinematic texture that enhances facial features, make-up details, and hair styles. The suburban Louisiana settings, both indoor and outdoor, are showcased with stability and ease, revealing intricate details such as manicured grasses, big trees, and subtle room decorations with precision.
Colors in the Blu-ray are subtly vibrant and well-calibrated. They may not be eye-popping but remain consistently pleasing and naturally appealing. Particularly, outdoor scenes benifit from natural greens and the pastel colors in costumes, especially during the wedding sequence. Flesh tones are mostly accurate with a hint of warmth that complements the overall look. Nighttime scenes are handled well, achieving deep black levels without succumbing to crush, notably in festival sequences. The transfer shows no major source blemishes or encoding artifacts, indicating a solid effort in preservation and presentation.
This Blu-ray uses the same transfer as the acclaimed 2014 Twilight Time release, now out-of-print. It continues to impress with bright, eye-pleasing imagery free from any age-related issues. Hues and saturation are balanced to perfection, and contrast is finely tuned to offer a visually engaging experience. In summary, Sony's MOD release successfully honors the original essence of "Steel Magnolias," making it an excellent addition to any film enthusiast's collection.
Audio: 80
Sony's Blu-ray release of "Steel Magnolias" is equipped with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack, which delivers a front-heavy, naturally reserved presentation. While the film primarily hinges on dialogue, which is delivered with clarity, detail, and prioritization in the front-center channel, the mix subtly integrates small-town atmospherics, lending an authentic feel to the setting. Natural ambient sounds include light Louisiana ambience folded organically into exterior scenes, adding quiet depth and nuance to the aural landscape.
The sound mix handles various elements with mixed results. For instance, gunshots in the film’s first act, used by Drum Eatenton to scare away birds, provide a fair crack but lack the expected heft and weight, barely penetrating the stage. Similarly, the firecrackers tied to an arrow yield pops that are more timid than aggressive, failing to deliver significant sonic impact despite the surrounding chaos of screams, barking dogs, and flapping birds. The background score by Georges Delerue is skillfully integrated but remains subdued, creating a supporting rather than dominating presence with wide front-end engagement and good clarity.
Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix serves the film’s narrative needs efficiently without drawing undue attention to itself. The soundtrack steers clear of hiss, flutter, crackle, or pops, showcasing technically sound engineering. Dialogue remains at the forefront, precisely rendered throughout the cinematic experience.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray release of "Steel Magnolias" by Sony carries over key extras and adds valuable insights into the film's creation. The included audio commentary by Director Herbert Ross, although somewhat dry and descriptive, offers insights into casting and production decisions. "In Full Bloom: Remembering Steel Magnolias" is an engaging featurette where Robert Harling, Herbert Ross, and Shirley MacLaine discuss the film's transition from stage to screen, casting, direction, and the integration of humor and drama. Additionally, the disc includes ten deleted scenes, which add context to the storyline, and the original theatrical trailer. Note that the isolated score track from the Twilight Time Blu-ray is not included.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: With Director Herbert Ross.
- In Full Bloom: Remembering Steel Magnolias: Discussions on the adaptation and film production.
- Deleted Scenes: A collection of ten brief scenes.
- Steel Magnolias Theatrical Trailer: The original promotional preview.
Movie: 81
Sony’s Blu-ray release of Herbert Ross' "Steel Magnolias" provides a moving experience, showcasing both its heartwarming and heartbreaking tone. The film vividly captures Robert Harling’s tribute to his late sister, portraying the compelling camaraderie among six Southern women. The performances are esteemed, with notable mentions to Shirley MacLaine’s scene-stealing appearance as Ouiser, and Sally Field and Julia Roberts’ dynamic mother-daughter relationship, M’Lynn and Shelby. The narrative unfolds primarily in Truvy’s beauty shop, run by Dolly Parton, which serves as a sanctuary for intertwining stories and heartfelt exchanges. Daryl Hannah and Olympia Dukakis further amplify the film’s charm, offering a balanced mix of drama and comedy.
The adaptation from stage to screen by director Ross is commendable, ensuring that the episodic nature of the story does not dilute its emotional weight. Key sequences, such as Shelby's wedding preparations and subsequent diabetic episode, are executed with precision and sensitivity. Moments of humor are skillfully interwoven with dramatic highlights, contributing to a multidimensional portrayal of Southern life. The rich performances ensure that each actress has her spotlight moment; particularly, Sally Field's intense dramatic portrayal stands out. The film’s authenticity is slightly marred by inconsistent Southern accents but is overshadowed by the cast’s overall likability.
Relying largely on character interactions and dialogue, the movie delivers substantial emotional impact. The ensemble cast works harmoniously, their chemistry rendering even the film's more episodic segments engaging. Ross's directorial approach leverages close-ups to capture nuanced expressions, enhancing the depth of the characters' experiences. In expanding the original play’s scope to fit the cinematic format, the integration of male characters played by Tom Skerritt and Sam Shepard adds sporadic humor but doesn't detract from the central female narrative. Overall, "Steel Magnolias" stands as a testament to resilience and friendship, brought vividly to life through adept direction and stellar performances.
Total: 76
"Steel Magnolias" on Blu-ray is a heartwarming yet poignant cinematic experience, capturing the intricacies of life, friendship, and loss. The film, an adaptation of the popular stage play, boasts an all-star cast whose performances breathe life into the episodic narrative. Sony's Blu-ray release presents the film with remarkable video and audio clarity, enhancing the viewing experience and allowing the vivid setting and emotional depth to shine through. This high-definition presentation surpasses the quality of previous editions, thereby offering a more immersive experience to both new audiences and longtime fans.
The Blu-ray edition also includes a more substantial selection of bonus features compared to the Twilight Time release, though it misses the opportunity to introduce new content despite the availability of key cast members. While this is a minor drawback, it does not detract significantly from the overall value of the release. The included extras still provide meaningful context and additional layers to the viewing experience, making it a worthwhile purchase for those who appreciate the film’s touching narrative and stellar ensemble.
In conclusion, "Steel Magnolias" on Blu-ray is a must-have for enthusiasts of heartfelt cinema. It skillfully traverses themes of life and death, friendship, and resilience—qualities that render it timeless and universally relatable. With superior audiovisual quality and a robust set of extras, Sony’s Blu-ray edition is highly recommended for both existing fans and new viewers seeking an emotionally rich and visually compelling film experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Facial features, including densely applied makeup and poofy hair, are nicely revealing, stable, and consistent in the level of pleasing definition the image has on offer....
Audio: 80
Against the relative quiet -- even considering some bustle around the Eatenton house as the final preparations for the wedding ceremony are underway -- there's a fair crack and sense of stage penetration,...
Extras: 50
Remembering Steel Magnolias (480i, 23:22): Writer Robert Harling and Director Herbert Ross discuss the story that inspired the original production, transitioning the material to film, casting and performances,...
Movie: 90
Clairee Blecher (Olympia Dukakis) and Louisa "Ouiser" Boudreaux (Shirley McLaine), the older widows of the group, come to Truvy's on the big day, too, where they all bond over a particularly bad bout of...
Total: 80
It transcends places, accents, and time, getting to the heart of what it means to give life, see it slip away, and the strengths that life experiences form in the soul....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
Using the same transfer that Twilight Time used in their 2014 Blu-ray release now out-of-print, the image is bright, colorful, and devoid of any age-related problems....
Audio: 100
The all-important dialogue is clearly and cleanly presented in the center channel, and the surrounds are filled with occasional ambient sound effects and Georges Delerue’s lovely background score....
Extras: 60
The disc offers some of the same contents of the 2000 DVD release: Audio Commentary: director Herbert Ross delivers a somewhat dry and unemotional commentary on the film, offering some insights into his...
Movie: 80
Director Herbert Ross, used to handling women’s stories in such previous movies as The Turning Point and Funny Lady, focuses on the women’s faces, and etched there are the laughter and tears that everyday...
Total: 80
While it’s wonderful that Sony has made the film available once again in high definition after the sellout of the Twilight Time edition, it’s a shame no new bonus material was collated since many of its...
Director: Herbert Ross
Actors: Shirley MacLaine, Olympia Dukakis, Sally Field
PlotIn a small Louisiana town, a close-knit circle of friends comes together at Truvy's beauty salon, the hub of gossip and support. The women share life's joys and hardships, with each bringing her distinct personality and perspective to the fold. There’s Truvy, the warm-hearted salon owner; Clairee, the witty widow of the former mayor; sharp-tongued Ouiser; M'Lynn, the nurturing mother; and her eager-to-live life daughter, Shelby. The story centers around Shelby's wedding and her spirited determination to live her life to the fullest despite her serious health issues, much to the concern of her loving but overprotective mother, M'Lynn.
The dynamics of the group are tested as they navigate through personal struggles and triumphs. M'Lynn’s maternal instincts and fears for Shelby fuel the narrative, showcasing the depths of a mother's love. As life's events unfold, the resilience of their bond highlights the strength found in friendship and community. Through laughter and tears, the film beautifully captures the heartaches and joys of life, emphasizing the notion that amid life’s fragilities and inevitable challenges, the support and love of friends provide a formidable strength, echoing the underlying theme of enduring female friendship and resilience.
Writers: Robert Harling
Release Date: 22 Nov 1989
Runtime: 117 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English