Sweet Smell of Success Blu-ray Review

Criterion's Blu-ray release of Alexander Mackendrick's "Sweet Smell of Success" features a new 1080p transfer encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, presented in an aspect ratio of 1.67:1. This immaculate transfer was derived from a 4K resolution scan conducted on a SCANITY Film Scanner, drawing from the original 35mm camera negative. Utilizing MTI's DRS system and Pixel Farm's PFClean system, thousands of imperfections such as dirt, debris, scratches, and flicker were meticulously eliminated. The Digital Vision's DVNR system further enhanced the transfer by addressing minor dirt, grain, and noise reduction.

The resulting image is nothing short of spectacular. The black-and-white presentation boasts exceptional contrast levels and fine object detail, with rich blacks, grays, and whites that provide a visually striking experience. The depth and clarity are notably improved over previous DVD releases, with no significant edge-enhancement issues or background shimmer previously seen in the older R1 DVD version. Grain remains present but is light and maintains the film’s authentic celluloid texture.

Both interior and exterior scenes are rendered with impressive distinction. Interiors benefit from deep, inky blacks, and marvelous gray scale variance, making shadow delineation excellent. Exterior scenes maintain a slightly harsher, natural aesthetic that complements the film's gritty storytelling. Fine details such as fabric textures and facial features are remarkably clear even in close-up shots, adding to the overall immersive experience. There is no noticeable noise or stability issues, with the image remaining practically spotless from start to finish. Fans of classic cinema will find this to be the definitive visual presentation of "Sweet Smell of Success."

The audio presentation of "Sweet Smell of Success" on Blu-ray features a singular English LPCM 1.0 track. Remastered at 24-bit from the original 35mm magnetic soundtrack, the Criterion team has employed Pro Tools HD and Audio Cube's integrated workstation to meticulously remove clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum, while attenuating crackle. Optional English SDH subtitles are also provided for the main feature, ensuring accessibility.

The LPCM 1.0 track delivers a clear and stable audio experience with crisp and easily comprehensible dialogue. Noteworthy is the absence of balance issues, ensuring that Elmer Bernstein’s iconic score complements the vocal delivery perfectly. Despite occasional slight hiss, the overall fidelity remains high, and no disturbing pops or cracks are present. The soundtrack's dynamic range broadens the vocal timbres effectively, providing an immersive auditory environment.

Elmer Bernstein’s brash, jazzy score resonates well within the mono track, avoiding any distortion issues even during intense brass segments. Criterion’s painstaking remastering efforts have yielded an impressive audio presentation from an older and challenging source material, making this Blu-ray a worthy addition for both audio purists and fans of classic cinema alike.

Criterion provides an outstanding supplemental package for the Blu-Ray of "Sweet Smell of Success," catering to serious film enthusiasts with an array of in-depth extras. Delving into the film's production, the insightful commentary by film scholar James Naremore stands out, offering a comprehensive analysis filled with fascinating behind-the-scenes details and contextual background. The various documentaries and interviews exploring key figures like director Alexander Mackendrick, cinematographer James Wong Howe, and journalist Walter Winchell add significant value, providing viewers with multi-faceted perspectives. This package also includes thoughtful contributions from notable filmmakers like James Mangold, enhancing the overall understanding of the film’s impact and its creator’s legacy.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Insightful analysis and background by film scholar James Naremore.
• Mackendrick: The Man Who Walked Away: Documentary featuring reflections on director Alexander Mackendrick.
• James Wong Howe: Cinematographer: Masterclass and career insights by the legendary cinematographer.
• Gabler on Winchell: Historian Neal Gabler discusses Walter Winchell’s life and influence.
• James Mangold: Director James Mangold shares his experiences and insights on Mackendrick.
• Trailer: Original theatrical trailer in high definition.
• Booklet: Includes essays and an excerpt from Mackendrick's On Film-Making.

Alexander Mackendrick's "Sweet Smell of Success" is a biting, incredibly smart, and stylish portrayal of insatiable ambition, greed, and the darker sides of human nature. Led by riveting performances from Burt Lancaster as the unscrupulous newspaper columnist J.J. Hunsecker and Tony Curtis as his ambitious lackey Sidney Falco, the film masterfully explores the corruptive influence of power and the desperate lengths to which individuals will go for fame and recognition. Ernest Lehman and Clifford Odets contribute a script rich with sharp, quotable dialogue and incisive commentary on the moral decay underpinning the cutthroat world of tabloid journalism.

The plot centers on J.J.'s attempt to sabotage his sister Susan's (Susan Harrison) relationship with a jazz musician (Martin Milner) whom he deems unworthy. This intricate game of manipulation is vividly brought to life through James Wong Howe's sumptuous black-and-white cinematography, which imbues the film with an atmospheric noir aesthetic, and Elmer Bernstein's bold jazz score that punctuates this world of smoky bars, chic nightclubs, and shadowy power plays. Mackendrick’s adept direction ensures that every scene bristles with tension and energy, effectively immersing viewers into the gritty New York City of the 1950s.

Despite featuring protagonists devoid of traditional heroism, Lancaster and Curtis’s performances are compelling, drawing audiences into the sordid underbelly of Broadway's high society with magnetic charisma. Their characters' manipulative maneuvers embody the ruthless essence of survival in the entertainment industry. "Sweet Smell of Success" remains a potent reflection on how the mechanisms of media influence have evolved yet stayed fundamentally the same in their exploitative nature. The film, initially unappreciated, has garnered acclaim over the decades for its brutal honesty and artistry, solidifying its place as a timeless critique of celebrity culture and journalistic ethics.

Criterion’s Blu-ray release of "Sweet Smell of Success" is a masterful presentation of Alexander Mackendrick's incisive exploration of ambition, ego, and manipulation. Even after more than 50 years, the film retains its captivating ferocity, driven by a taut and lyrical screenplay along with outstanding performances from Burt Lancaster and Tony Curtis. This release features a splendid restoration that elevates the sharp, edgy presentation to meet modern high-definition standards. The audio is crisp and clear, preserving every nuance of the original score and dialogue.

In addition to the stellar audiovisual quality, Criterion includes a robust selection of supplemental features. Noteworthy among these extras is an insightful audio commentary by film scholar James Naremore, which adds depth to an already rich cinematic experience. The packaging is stylish and befitting of a collector's item, making this edition stand out among home media releases. These cohesive elements enhance the viewing experience and offer an engaging journey through the film's production and thematic substance.

Criterion has delivered yet another must-own package. This time around it is Alexander Mackendrick's thought-provoking and hugely entertaining "Sweet Smell of Success" that gets the special treatment. The supplemental features are also very good. Make sure you find the time to listen to film scholar James Naremore's audio commentary. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.