The Seduction of Mimi Blu-ray Review
Mim� metallurgico ferito nell'onore
Score: 39
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A sharp satire on politics and gender with decent Blu-ray presentation despite minor video issues, buoyed by Giancarlo Giannini’s masterful performance.
Disc Release Date
Video: 43
Kino-Lorber's 1080p/AVC transfers of 'The Seduction of Mimi' deliver reasonably sharp, nicely colored visuals typical of mid-1970s Italian films, despite some compression artifacts and inconsistent grain structure. Clarity falters in wider shots, yet close-ups and vivid color palettes remain striking.
Audio: 48
The Seduction of Mimi's DTS-HD Master Audio mono track is respectable despite inherent limitations, delivering clear dialogue with slight thinness and minor age-related issues. Music and sound effects are well-managed, with high frequencies handled cleanly, and an overall balanced presentation fitting the film's nature.
Extra: 6
Extras include a simple HD stills gallery with five images, though the quality is grainy.
Movie: 61
'The Seduction of Mimi' on Blu-ray is a clever blend of satirical comedy and social critique, showcasing Lina Wertmüller's keen direction and Giancarlo Giannini's comedic prowess. Despite some pacing issues, the film's humor, visual gags, and incisive take on sex and politics offer a memorable and engaging experience.
Video: 43
Kino Lorber's 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer of "The Seduction of Mimi" presents a mixed bag in terms of video quality. At first glance, the mid-1970s Italian film exhibits decent sharpness and a vibrant color palette, with pleasing pastel hues and striking costume details. However, a closer inspection reveals a range of inconsistencies. Specifically, there is evidence of grain that appears somewhat unnatural and static, coupled at times with a flurry of buzzing compression artifacts. These issues occasionally obscure fine textures and soften hard lines, which is noticeable, particularly on larger screens or projectors. Despite these shortcomings, this transfer still represents an improvement over older home video editions.
Examining the details further, the overall print is in satisfactory condition with minimal specks and vertical lines visible sporadically. Grain structure, while present, can appear both diminished and noisy, resulting in a smeary quality in some shots. The film does maintain good clarity in close-ups though, but it struggles with wider shots that lack distinct detail and texture. Contrast levels are generally high with bright whites, and while shadow detail is good, the black levels can sometimes appear slightly washed out. Despite its occasional softness, the film's colors remain vivid and engaging. Although the image is not without flaws, from a normal viewing distance, these issues are not overtly distracting and the transfer will likely satisfy most viewers considering its age and source constraints.
Overall, while not perfect and showing some signs of compression and age, Kino Lorber's release of "The Seduction of Mimi" offers a respectable video presentation that captures the vibrant essence of Lina Wertmüller's work. For fans of the director or cinematic enthusiasts of mid-1970s Italian films, this transfer should make for an enjoyable viewing experience despite its technical imperfections.
Audio: 48
The audio presentation of "The Seduction of Mimi" on Blu-ray is provided in an uncompressed DTS-HD Master Audio 1.0 mono track, which delivers a respectable listening experience. The single channel audio does exhibit some inherent age-related imperfections, particularly in the dubbing, where plosives like p's, b's, k's, and t's can sound somewhat crackly. Additionally, the music score by Piero Piccioni, though occasionally brash in the high end, remains clear and well-detailed. The dialogue maintains clarity, albeit with a slightly thin quality, and while dynamic range is somewhat flat with negligible bass activity, there are no significant issues of crackle or hissing.
The handling of effects and the musical score within this single channel is notable, with high frequencies manifesting cleanly without distortion. This ensures that elements such as whistling in the film's opening are conveyed effectively. Optional English subtitles are available, presented in easy-to-read white lettering, adding further accessibility to the track. Despite the limitations of a mono mix, the DTS-HD Master Audio presentation complements the film aptly, offering a listenable and fairly well-managed audio experience overall.
Extras: 6
The extras featured on the Blu Ray of "The Seduction of Mimi" are notably minimal, focusing solely on a small collection of stills from the film. While the inclusion of these images provides a nostalgic glimpse into the film's production and aesthetic, their limited number and somewhat grainy quality may not offer much for enthusiasts seeking in-depth special features or higher fidelity content. The stills are presented in high definition but their inherent quality leaves something to be desired for those anticipating more comprehensive or detailed supplemental material.
Extras included in this disc:
- Stills Gallery (HD): A gallery featuring five stills from the film, offering a nostalgic glimpse into its production.
Movie: 61
Lina Wertmüller’s 'The Seduction of Mimi' is a penetrating social satire set against the backdrop of 1970s Italy, capturing the intersection of labor politics and personal relationships with biting humor and sharp observation. An early collaboration with leading actor Giancarlo Giannini, the film navigates the comedic contradictions of male infidelity and patriarchal hypocrisy through the character of Carmelo "Mimi" Mardocheo, a Sicilian sulfur miner who finds himself embroiled in both romantic entanglements and political machinations. Forced to leave his wife after defying the local mafia's election orders, Mimi's journey introduces a colorful array of characters and situations that highlight Wertmüller’s critique of power structures and gender roles.
The narrative effortlessly blends farce with incisive social commentary, with Wertmüller employing exaggerated characterizations and visual gags—such as the comical fisheye-lens depiction of Mimi's sexual revenge—to underscore the absurdities of male entitlement and political opportunism. Giancarlo Giannini’s performance is a tour de force, infusing Mimi with a mix of goofy charm, melancholic frustration, and naive hypocrisy that keeps the audience engaged even as they recognize his flaws. The chemistry between Giannini and Mariangela Melato, playing Mimi’s progressive lover Fiore, adds a layer of genuine affection against the backdrop of broad satire.
Wertmüller's directorial style is playful and dynamic, utilizing frequent zooms to comedic effect and framing scenes to enhance the absurdity of the social critiques. While some sections may drag slightly, the film maintains a lively pace overall, culminating in a memorable climax that exemplifies its blend of humor and pointed commentary. Despite some uneven moments, 'The Seduction of Mimi' remains a compelling and entertaining work that showcases Wertmüller's unique voice in Italian cinema.
Total: 39
"The Seduction of Mimi" remains a praiseworthy entry in Lina Wertmüller's filmography, masterfully blending satirical commentary on sex, politics, and societal norms through the engaging performance of Giancarlo Giannini. The film holds its own as a sharp critique of patriarchal attitudes and offers witty and incisive humor amidst its narrative structure. While some scenes experience minor script lulls, Giannini's memorable reaction shots and comedic timing maintain viewer interest throughout its runtime.
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Seduction of Mimi" falls short of the exceptional standards typically expected from Kino. Notable technical flaws include slight compression noise and artifacting in the video transfer, which detracts from the visual experience. The audio quality is largely solid but constrained by the inherent limitations of the source material. The disappointing inclusion of only a sparse, unremarkable stills gallery as the sole supplement further reduces the disc's overall value.
In conclusion, "The Seduction of Mimi" is sometimes overshadowed by Wertmüller's later work "Swept Away," but it stands strong as a vital satire in its own right. Despite its Blu-ray presentation not meeting the highest expectations, fans of Italian cinema and satirical comedy will still find this release a worthy addition to their collection. Recommended!
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 60
To me, these look like high definition masters that were originally intended for a DVD release�natural filmic grain seems somewhat diminished and softened, but the image is still quite noisy....
Audio: 70
The music can also be slightly brash in the high end, but the score by Piero Piccioni�who also did Swept Away and Jean-Luc Godard's Contempt�is otherwise clear and detailed, and suits the film well....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 70
Mimi and Fiore First up is The Seduction of Mimi, a sex farce that skewers male attitudes about affairs and cuckoldry�that is, men love cheating but hate being cheated on�while giving a satirical overview...
Total: 70
The Seduction of Mimi is sometimes overlooked as a warm-up to Swept Away�a film that deals more forcefully with the overlap of politics and gender�but it's a very sharp satire in its own right, skewering...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The film's grain structure is a bit suspect at times and there are some faint signs of compression, but the majority of the picture looks pretty good....
Audio: 60
Effects and score are handled well within the single channel of the mix, and even high frequencies (like some high pitched whistling in the film's opening) come through cleanly without straining or distorting....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
Beyond the surface comedy of the role, the actor also imbues a few deeper qualities into the character, and though the impulsive rogue does a few fairly detestable things throughout the runtime, he always...
Total: 40
Disappointingly, the only supplement we get is a fairly useless gallery of five unremarkable stills....
Director: Lina Wertmüller
Actors: Giancarlo Giannini, Mariangela Melato, Agostina Belli
PlotMimi, a Sicilian laborer, is caught in a web of corruption and social oppression under a mafia-controlled system. After losing his job for casting a vote against the Mafia's wishes, he leaves his wife and child behind and relocates to Turin in search of employment. In Turin, he finds work in a factory and becomes involved with Fiore, a politically-active woman with whom he begins a passionate affair. Mimi's exposure to the radical political environment and his relationship with Fiore challenge his views on class and power.
Mimi's new life takes an unexpected turn when he decides to visit his wife back in Sicily, only to discover that she has been unfaithful. Humiliated, he seeks revenge not only on her but on the societal structures that keep him powerless. Navigating between revenge and his growing ideals of social justice, Mimi's choices set off a chain of events that lead to unforeseen, transformative consequences. The film paints a vivid portrait of a man struggling against the intertwined pressures of personal pride and systemic injustice.
Writers: Lina Wertmüller
Release Date: 19 Feb 1972
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: R
Country: Italy
Language: Italian