Rudo y Cursi Blu-ray Review
Score: 52
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Rudo y Cursi' shines with its balanced mix of humor, drama, and action, offering high-quality A/V presentation and a solid extras package—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 50
Rudo y Cursi's Blu-ray video presentation delivers a fair 1080p, 1.78:1-framed transfer with clean imagery, stable color palettes, and well-rendered close-ups, yet falls short in long-range clarity and interior shadow detail. The Dolby TrueHD soundtrack offers crisp dialogue and minimal low-frequency detail.
Audio: 53
The Blu-ray release of 'Rudo y Cursi' features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack that delivers crisp, front-centric dialogue and atmospheric effects with limited rear activity. While sports scenes enhance the soundstage with robust bass and immersive crowd noise, overall, the track offers good but unremarkable audio quality. Subtitles available in English and French.
Extra: 43
'Rudo y Cursi' Blu-ray boasts engaging special features including a lively commentary with Carlos Cuaron, Gael Garcia Bernal, and Diego Luna; an informative 27-minute making-of featurette; a 71-minute Q&A session; six deleted scenes; entertaining music videos and a humorous faux theater ad, all primarily in standard definition.
Movie: 77
Rudo y Cursi is a captivating exploration of sibling rivalry and the pitfalls of fame, seamlessly combining humor and drama with a compelling third act, showcasing the natural chemistry of Diego Luna and Gael García Bernal amidst the harsh realities of professional sports.
Video: 50
The Blu-ray presentation of "Rudo y Cursi" delivers a competent, if not spectacular, visual experience. This 1080p, 1.78:1-framed transfer brings out clean images with consistent rendering that faithfully represents the film's original photography. Close-up shots reveal decent textural details and are well-resolved, while long-range visuals and darker interior scenes tend to soften and lack definitive clarity and depth. The exterior scenes, particularly those taking place in the banana plantation, are a visual highlight with stable color palettes, where green vegetation and brown dirt stand out vividly.
Color saturation is generally balanced, with earth tones rendered pleasingly in sequences shot in the Mexican village. Blacks are stable but exhibit only average depth and gradational quality, especially in lower-lit interiors where shadow detail is less defined. Flesh tones remain accurate with discernible highlights and a natural lifelike depiction, albeit with a slightly red tint at times. A very fine layer of grain is present throughout, contributing to a natural texture without any print damage.
Overall, "Rudo y Cursi" offers an adequate high-definition video presentation for its fans, providing a reasonably enjoyable viewing experience. While the encode might not be top-tier for a recent film, the video remains clean and likely faithful to the original cinematography. Daylight sequences fare better with good color saturation in the primary hues whereas interior dark scenes lack the sharpness necessary to give that true high-def impact expected from a modern Blu-ray release.
Audio: 53
The Blu-ray release of "Rudo y Cursi" features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack that delivers a proficient audio experience, albeit with some limitations. The majority of the audio presentation, including crisp and well-constructed dialogue, is front-centric, offering minimal, but noticeable, surround channel activity. The track performs admirably in quieter, dialogue-driven scenes by maintaining clear and dynamic acoustics. Background elements such as meowing cats, television programming, and buzzing insects contribute to a consistent immersion in the film's audible world, though without ever overshadowing the primary dialogue.
Dynamic moments are effectively rendered, particularly during the film’s sports sequences. The brief horse race scene and the climactic soccer match exemplify the track's potential to envelop the listener in robust soundscapes with deeper bass responses and vibrant crowd noises, providing a palpable sense of atmosphere. Despite these highlights, the overall spatial design still feels somewhat limited due to the lack of rear channel presence and broad ambient details, which results in a less immersive experience than one might expect for a film set in bustling Mexico City.
Musical elements throughout the film are handled impressively, enhancing the soundfield significantly. However, the soundtrack doesn’t quite reach the level of finesse seen in finer high-resolution audio tracks. Light ambient splashes through the surround channels offer some dimensionality, but there's an absence of substantial low-frequency detail outside specific key scenes. Though not groundbreaking, the Dolby TrueHD audio track successfully delivers a satisfying and engaging listening experience that resonates well with the film's narrative and settings.
Extras: 43
The Blu-ray edition of "Rudo y Cursi" offers a compelling set of special features, blending informative content with lighthearted moments. The commentary track with director Carlos Cuarón and actors Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna stands out for its engaging, rowdy nature, providing English subtitles for non-Spanish speakers, albeit imperfectly capturing the spirited banter. The "Making-of Featurette" explores the filmmaking process with cast and crew interviews and behind-the-scenes footage. An extensive Q&A session featuring the director and stars, hosted by Jeff Goldsmith, delves deeper into their perspectives on the film and careers. Additional extras include six deleted scenes, entertaining music videos, a humorous cell phone PSA, and various HD trailers. Overall, these supplements add significant value and enjoyment for fans of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary with Carlos Cuarón & Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna: A lively track with English subtitles.
- Making of Featurette: Insights into the moviemaking process with behind-the-scenes footage.
- Q&A with Carlos Cuarón, Gael García Bernal & Diego Luna: In-depth discussion hosted by Jeff Goldsmith.
- Deleted Scenes: Six segments cut from the final film.
- Music Videos: Performances by Juana Molina and Gael García Bernal plus a karaoke version.
- Turn off your cell phone!: Faux ad featuring main characters.
- Trailers: Previews for "Rudo y Cursi," "Coco Before Chanel," "It Might Get Loud," "Tyson," and "Sugar."
- BD-Live enabled: Online interactive content.
Movie: 77
"Rudo y Cursi" is a captivating dramedy from director Carlos Cuarón, featuring a dynamic portrayal of two brothers, Beto (Diego Luna) and Tato (Gael García Bernal), hailing from a small Mexican village. The film offers a poignant yet humorous exploration of themes such as fame, family, and societal influences, devoid of the typical underdog triumph narrative. Spotting their soccer talent, sleazy scout Batuta (Guillermo Francella) propels them into Mexico City's professional sports scene. The film delicately balances comedy and drama, with distinct characters—Rudo for his fierce goalkeeping and hotheaded demeanor, and Cursi for his flamboyant scoring and offbeat ambition to become a pop singer.
Cuarón’s film excels in transforming the simple premise of sibling rivalry in sports into a complex, multifaceted narrative about ambition and downfall. As the brothers rise to stardom, they grapple with the intoxicating allure of wealth and fame. Rudo's descent into gambling and drug abuse contrasts sharply with Cursi’s naïve dreams of musical brilliance, highlighted by his comically unforgettable performance of a Norteño version of Cheap Trick's "I Want You to Want Me." Their struggles serve as a subtle satire of modern society’s capricious nature, illustrated through encounters with frenzied fans and personal vices that threaten their careers and fraternal bond.
The film’s technical execution is commendable, complemented by an engaging script and insightful direction. Cuarón skillfully blends sports action with character-driven drama, culminating in a tense climax reflective of the stakes both on and off the soccer field. Luna and Bernal showcase exceptional chemistry, bringing depth to their characters' journey from rustic simplicity to the complexities of city life. "Rudo y Cursi" is an exemplary piece not just in sports cinema but also in its broader commentary on human nature and societal expectations, ensuring its place as a noteworthy title in contemporary filmmaking.
Total: 52
The Blu-ray release of "Rudo y Cursi" stands as a testament to exceptional filmmaking, combining humor, drama, action, and tragedy into a nuanced narrative. Directed by Carlos Cuarón, the film skillfully navigates the complexities of rural life through the story of two brothers involved in professional football. This multi-layered plot is rendered with superb cinematography and authentic performances, particularly from leads Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna. The product delivers an above-average transfer that captures the film's vivid palette and dynamic visuals effectively.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray offers an impressive A/V presentation. The high-definition transfer ensures detailed imagery that enhances the cinematic experience, while the lossless soundtrack enriches the auditory immersion. The supplemental package complements the main feature with insightful extras, adding depth and context to the viewing experience. The combination of these elements ensures that "Rudo y Cursi" offers not only a compelling story but also a rich sensory engagement suitable for enthusiasts of high-quality Mexican cinema.
In conclusion, "Rudo y Cursi" is a well-executed blend of different cinematic elements that makes it an engaging viewing choice. Its thematic exploration of life's ironies through the lens of football, coupled with an excellent A/V presentation and valuable extras, makes this Blu-ray release highly recommended. Whether you're a fan of sports dramas or simply appreciate finely crafted films, this release is sure to meet your expectations and provide a memorable addition to any movie collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Although the image appears somewhat soft and dull on the whole, it's rather good nevertheless, exhibiting a fairly stable color palette, with the film's exterior scenes serving up a mostly eye-popping...
Audio: 80
For instance, a brief scene of a horse race in chapter eight does well to fill the soundstage with the smacking of beating hooves, the effect accompanied by a rather robust low end....
Extras: 60
Q&A with Carlos Cuarón, Gael García Bernal & Diego Luna (1080i, 1:11:32) is an extended piece where the trio answers a series of questions about the film and their careers....
Movie: 90
Sugar, a superbly-crafted and brutally honest look at the life of a young Dominican pitcher struggling to find his way in the United States, professional baseball, and life, is perhaps the most poignant...
Total: 70
Rudo y Cursi is a complete movie that offers a great story that's composed of humor, drama, action, and tragedy....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
But despite not being very detailed for a freshly-minted release, the encode is clean and likely faithful to its original photography....
Audio: 60
The lack of rear activity throughout is what really hinders the sound design, which is surprising for a film which takes place in Mexico City....
Extras: 20
'Rudo y Cursi' debuts with a nice set of special features, a couple of which are exclusive to the Blu-ray, and mostly presented in standard definition....
Movie: 80
And with Francella's performance of a sly talent agent and his voice-narration philosophizing the techniques of the game, this sports flick, which is not really a sports flick, is amusing and enjoyable,...
Total: 60
With a narration on the philosophies of football (or soccer, for all you Yanks), 'Rudo y Cursi' is a terrific comedy on the ironies of life through the eyes of two rural brothers....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 78
Primary colors arenÂ't especially vibrant but the earth tones that permeate the sequences shot in the Mexican village are well balanced and visually pleasing....
Audio: 76
Primary colors arenÂ't especially vibrant but the earth tones that permeate the sequences shot in the Mexican village are well balanced and visually pleasing....
Extras: 60
Commentary with director Carlos Cuaron & actors Gael Garcia Bernal and Diego Luna Making of featurette Â- 27 minutes (HD) Q&A with director Carlos Cuaron & actors Gael Garcia Bernal and Diego Luna Â- 71...
Movie: 70
But success leads to excess as Rudo descends into gambling debt and drug abuse and Cursi is distracted by beautiful women and a second career as a pop singer....
Total: 71
Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio...
Director: Carlos Cuarón
Actors: Gael García Bernal, Diego Luna, Guillermo Francella
PlotIn a small rural town in Mexico, two half-brothers, Beto and Tato, work on a banana plantation to support their families, while dreaming of escaping their monotonous lives. Beto, a responsible and skilled goalkeeper, dreams of building his family a house, while Tato, a carefree and charming forward, aspires to become a famous musician. Their lives take a dramatic turn when they are discovered by Batuta, a charismatic and opportunistic soccer scout. Seizing the opportunity of a lifetime, Beto and Tato are whisked away to the big city's professional soccer world, where they begin their new careers under the nicknames "Rudo" and "Cursi" respectively.
As they adjust to their newfound fame and fortune, the brothers face various challenges that test their bond. The lure of luxury and the pressure of professional sports lead to conflicts and distractions. Beto struggles with gambling issues, while Tato becomes infatuated with the glamorous lifestyle and pursues his musical dreams on the side. As tensions mount and personal ambitions clash, the brothers' relationship is strained. The lessons they learn and the choices they make ultimately shape their futures, revealing the fragile nature of dreams and the inherent complexity of familial ties.
Writers: Carlos Cuarón
Release Date: 15 May 2009
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: R
Country: Mexico
Language: Spanish