Red Desert Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
BFI's release of Red Desert & Salo brings long-awaited quality to English markets. Essential & highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 69
The BFI's Blu-ray release of Red Desert offers a superior, restored 1080p transfer with accurate colors and preserved grain, reflecting Antonioni's vision despite minor source damage.
Audio: 69
Red Desert's Blu-ray release features a superior Italian PCM mono track with English subtitles, outshining the SDVD’s audio. It delivers clear, deep, flawless electronic-ambient music, despite minor sync issues due to original overdubbing.
Extra: 86
BFI's release of Red Desert includes expert commentaries and essays delving into the film's history, symbolic themes, and Antonioni's innovative approach, enriched by insights on Italy's socio-cultural changes.
Movie: 96
Michelangelo Antonioni's *Il Deserto Rosso*, a visually striking critique of modern industrialization, recognized with the Golden Lion in 1964, explores the profound emotional and existential turmoil of its characters amidst vivid landscapes and innovative sound design.
Video: 69
This Blu-ray release of "Red Desert" from BFI, encoded with MPEG4-AVC in 1080p and maintaining the original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, marks a significant upgrade from previous SDVD iterations, offering a restoration that vividly enhances the film's visual dynamics. Utilizing the original 35mm negatives, the transfer is meticulously restored to mitigate dirt, scratches, and stabilize the image, albeit with minute unavoidable instances of weave and flutter due to the original film elements' slight wear. The color rendition is notably superior, with a palette that brings out the vivid reds, yellows, greens, and blues, while presenting lush blacks that vastly improve the depth of the image. This high-definition transfer breathes new life into Antonioni's masterpiece, ensuring that its visual richness is more pronounced than ever.
Audio synchronization follows the original post-production process, reflective of the period's Italian film production methods, thus preserving authenticity despite minor sync variances not constitutable as technical faults. The restoration's respectful avoidance of excessive DNR application retains the intended grainy texture, further authenticating the film's original aesthetic and mood. Scenes throughout the film exhibit an unprecedented clarity and detail, showcasing the restoration team's dedication to honoring Antonioni's vision.
Despite minor preservation limitations, this release indeed serves as the definitive version of "Red Desert," evidencing BFI's commitment to excellence in film restoration. The improvement in image quality, from color accuracy to contrast and depth, is genuinely impressive. Film enthusiasts and purists alike will find this Region-B locked Blu-ray an indispensable addition to their collection, offering an experience as close to the filmmaker's original intention as current technology allows.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Red Desert" on Blu-ray showcases a newly restored Italian PCM mono track that elevates the auditory experience significantly when compared to previous formats, such as the SDVD audio treatment found on the Australian release. The PCM track endows viewers with an auditory clarity and an immersive depth that was previously unseen, particularly benefiting the film's intricate electronic-ambient soundtrack. This robust restoration ensures that the unique soundscape of "Red Desert" is conveyed with the utmost fidelity, making each scene more evocative. The track’s purity is exemplary, with no detectable disturbances such as pop-ups, cracks, or hissings—a clean execution that serves to enhance the viewer's engagement without distraction.
While the restoration work has evidently paid off in terms of clarity and sonic depth, it's worth noting that there are minor sync issues present in the audio. However, these are not flaws introduced by the restoration process itself but are instead original elements from the post-production overdubbing done in Rome. As highlighted by expert James White, these minor discrepancies are inherited from the master elements and reflect the historical production methodologies rather than any shortcomings in the restoration process. This small caveat does little to detract from the overall exceptional quality of the audio presentation.
In essence, the Blu-ray audio output for "Red Desert" presents a definitive aural experience that admirably serves the film's atmospheric and thematic needs. The PCM mono track's exceptional handling of the electronic-ambient score alongside its clarity and depth offers an immersive auditory experience for enthusiasts and newcomers alike. Despite minor sync issues related to post-production processes, this audio presentation is a testament to the meticulous restoration efforts, providing a clear, clean, and profound sound that beautifully complements the film’s visual artistry.
Extras: 86
The British Film Institute (BFI) has curated a remarkable compilation of extras for their Blu-ray release of Michelangelo Antonioni's "Red Desert," preserving its monumental status in film history with erudite precision. Anchored by a detailed essay from David Forgacs that eloquently explores the film's intricate social and industrial symbolism against the backdrop of Italy's cultural transformation, this collection is essential for both scholars and enthusiasts. The inclusion of a rare interview with Antonioni himself, translated for broader accessibility, offers invaluable insights into his creative process, especially concerning the innovative use of color and electronic music. Complementing these written materials, Professor Forgacs' full-blown commentary on the Blu-ray disc exemplifies academic rigor, providing a scene-by-scene analysis that illuminates the director's vision. Together, these features not only celebrate Antonioni's legacy but also enrich the viewing experience with deep contextual understanding, making this release a paradigm of scholarly film treatment.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Michelangelo Antonioni: A deep dive into Antonioni's thoughts on color, music, and societal themes within "Red Desert."
- Essay by David Forgacs: An exploration of "Red Desert's" historical significance and symbolic complexity.
- The Life and Work of Michelangelo Antonioni: Offers a comprehensive overview of Antonioni's career, penned by Geoffrey Nowell-Smith.
- Commentary by Professor Forgacs: A scene-by-scene breakdown that enhances appreciation for Antonioni's groundbreaking work.
Movie: 96
Michelangelo Antonioni's seminal work, "Red Desert," holds a prestigious place in cinematic history, marking his foray into color filmmaking. The film's restoration from original negatives and its presentation on Blu-ray by the British Film Institute is a testament to its enduring impact. Featuring an Italian language track with optional English subtitles and region-B lock, this release brings Antonioni's vision into sharp, contemporary focus. "Red Desert" explores the emotional turmoil of Giuliana (Monica Vitti), as she navigates an unstable marriage and a fleeting affair with engineer Corrado (Richard Harris), set against the backdrop of Italy's industrial landscape. The narrative, enriched by the director's personal relationship with Vitti, delves into themes of industrial alienation and environmental degradation, making profound statements on human connection and isolation.
Antonioni's mastery shines in his pioneering use of color and setting to reflect emotional states. The bleakness of industrial settings and polluted landscapes serves not just as a backdrop but as a character in itself, influencing and interacting with the human elements of the story. Innovations such as the use of electronic music, which evokes the early sounds of sci-fi cinema, further underscore the film’s abstract nature. "Red Desert" deviates from traditional storytelling, prioritizing mood, atmosphere, and visual expression over linear narrative. This approach is encapsulated in memorable scenes that blend physical and emotional landscapes, using color and sound to convey complex themes of alienation and existential inquiry.
The film concludes with an abruptness that reinforces Antonioni's critique on progress and industrialization. Giuliana's journey through mental anguish to a brittle recovery symbolizes a broader human struggle against the encroachments of modernity. "Red Desert" not only received the Golden Lion at the Venice Film Festival in 1964 but also solidified Antonioni's reputation as a filmmaker willing to challenge narrative conventions. Its innovative cinematography was awarded the Silver Ribbon for Best Cinography in 1965, highlighting Carlo Di Palma's significant contribution to the film's haunting and unforgettable visual landscape. Through this Blu-ray presentation, "Red Desert" remains a vital exploration of the intricate dance between humanity and its environment, proving the film's stature as a cornerstone of world cinema.
Total: 75
The British Film Institute (BFI) continues its tradition of excellence with its latest Blu-ray release of Michelangelo Antonioni's "Red Desert," further solidifying its reputation as a purveyor of fine cinema. This release stands as a testament to BFI's commitment to preserving cinematic history, offering an edition that does justice to Antonioni's masterpiece. The significance of this release cannot be overstated, given that "Red Desert" has long been difficult to access in a quality format in English-speaking territories, including the US. This has been a sore point for cinephiles who strive to experience films as their creators intended. The BFI has rightfully addressed this gap, presenting "Red Desert" in a format that honors its visual and auditory essence.
This edition not only meets but exceeds expectations, providing a viewing experience that is unparalleled. The meticulous attention to detail in the transfer process ensures that every hue and tone of Antonioni's vision is presented with fidelity. The sound has been treated with equal care, offering clarity that enhances the immersive experience of the film. The BFI's release elevates "Red Desert" from an inaccessible gem to a must-have for collectors and enthusiasts alike. It's a rare occurrence when a release can be deemed the definitive version of a film, but in this case, it's an apt description.
In conclusion, the BFI's Blu-ray release of "Red Desert" is a monumental achievement that reignites interest in Michelangelo Antonioni’s work and ensures its preservation for future generations. It bridges the gap between past and present viewers, offering both a visually stunning and technically impeccable experience. For anyone who cherishes the art of cinema and the importance of film preservation, this release comes highly recommended. It's not just a Blu-ray; it's a piece of cinematic history that has been given the treatment it so richly deserves.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
The important thing to remember is that with the grain structure of the film intact the 1080p transfer reveals a degree of clarity that will most certainly impress those who have been wishing for a solid...
Audio: 90
For the record, as James White points out, there are a few very minor sync "issues" but these are a byproduct of the post-production overdubbing Red Desert received and are inherited via the master elements...
Extras: 90
Next, there is a terrific interview with Michelangelo Antonioni (conducted by Francois Maurin and originally published in Humanite dimanche on September 23, 1964 - the piece is translated by Andrew Taylor...
Movie: 100
The use of multiple sequences of unique electronic tunes, some mimicking sci-fi film scores from the early 40s-50s, also suggest that Red Desert was meant to be a much broader canvas where specific sounds...
Total: 90
I feel that we are quite fortunate to have BFI release two films (Salo and Red Desert) that until recently were impossible to see in an acceptable form in any English-speaking market, not just the US....
Director: Michelangelo Antonioni
Actors: Monica Vitti, Richard Harris, Carlo Chionetti
PlotIn an industrial landscape marred by factories and technological upheaval, Giuliana, a woman struggling with profound emotional and psychological turmoil, navigates the complexities of her life. Her distress manifests as an acute sense of alienation and existential anxiety, exacerbated by the cold, mechanical environment surrounding her. Her husband Ugo, who manages a nearby factory, remains largely oblivious to her inner turmoil, preoccupied with the demands of his work and the technological advancements of the time.
Seeking connection and a respite from her isolation, Giuliana enters into a tentative relationship with Corrado, a business associate of her husband. Corrado, who is in town overseeing the startup of a new project, seems to offer Giuliana a semblance of understanding and perhaps a way out of her existential predicament. However, the evolving dynamics between Giuliana, Ugo, and Corrado highlight the profound disconnection and communication barriers that manifest in their industrialized world, reflecting broader themes of environmental disruption and human alienation.
Writers: Michelangelo Antonioni, Tonino Guerra
Release Date: 08 Feb 1965
Runtime: 117 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Italy, France
Language: Italian, Turkish