The Chamber Blu-ray Review
Score: 52
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite its Hollywood treatment and dated image transfer, 'The Chamber' remains a decent entertainment piece, bolstered by Hackman's performance and strong DTS 5.1 audio.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 50
The Chamber's Blu-ray release presents a 2.35:1 1080p transfer with dated mastering reminiscent of an upconverted DVD, limited by a BD-25 disc with a 21462 kbps average bitrate. Despite occasional artifacting and detail loss, colors like lavender and red are vibrant, and the transfer marks a noticeable improvement over the original DVD.
Audio: 80
Kino's Blu-ray presentation of 'The Chamber' features a deep and resonant DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround and a stereo mix, both delivering clear, crisp dialogue and impressive dynamic range. The 5.1 track excels in atmospheric detail, effectively placing elements and enhancing Carter Burwell's haunting score.
Extra: 6
The Chamber's Blu-ray extras are limited to standard trailers, including a full-frame theatrical trailer with omitted shots and additional previews of titles like 'The Gingerbread Man' and 'The Interpreter,' delivering basic promotional material with no substantial bonus features.
Movie: 56
The Chamber lacks the suspense of Grisham's best but offers a methodical exploration of family legacies and racial tensions, underpinned by a standout performance from Gene Hackman. As a Blu-ray release, it remains a lesser entry in Grisham's adaptations, despite its ambitious themes and strong cast.
Video: 50
"The Chamber" arrives on Blu-ray, more than a decade after its theatrical premiere, with a 2.35:1 1080p transfer that feels dated but functional. It’s clear that the transfer might have originated from an older master, likely calling back to the DVD days rather than benefiting from modern enhancements. The MPEG-4 AVC encoding on a BD-25 averages a bitrate of 21462 kbps, with an overall bitrate of 26.74 Mbps, resulting in a somewhat compromised detail retrieval reminiscent of an upconverted DVD. While film grain persists, it's often unresolved, leading to a smoother yet less textured visual representation, occasionally marred by mosquito noise replacing the subtlety of natural grain.
Colors are notably well-rendered, with hues like lavender, red, and vibrant greens appearing distinct, although some aliasing is noticeable particularly in titles during the main credits. The overall clarity offers improved close-ups, highlighting facial features and production elements, albeit with some edge enhancement contributing to a slight crunchiness in the image. Thankfully, issues such as haloing and banding are minimal, yet the presentation doesn’t quite escape the visual markers of the mid-90s era to which it belongs.
In terms of structural presentation, Kino Studio Classics issued eight chapter breaks, in contrast to previous releases offering more plentiful options. Despite these limitations, the source material is commendably preserved without prominent speckling or age-related flaws. While "The Chamber" on Blu-ray surpasses previous DVD editions in several aspects, it falls short of delivering the full potential a re-mastered high-definition release might offer, maintaining a charm more nostalgic than groundbreaking.
Audio: 80
The Blu-ray release of "The Chamber" comes equipped with an impeccable DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround track at 2043 kbps and a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Stereo mix at 1509 kbps, both in 16-bit resolution. The 5.1 surround track excels with its deep and resonant audio quality, effectively delivering an immersive audial experience. Despite avenues for expansive soundscapes being somewhat limited by the intimate settings of the film, when the scenes transition to vibrant locales like Chicago's streets or thematic sequences like a Klan rally, the surround activity appropriately intensifies. Dialogue remains unwaveringly clear and precise across all scenes, attesting to its finely-tuned audio engineering.
The surround channels are surprisingly articulate, capturing subtle background noises that enhance the viewing experience. Notably, scenes where footsteps echo through hallways or prison doors clang shut are exceptionally vivid, demonstrating the track's capability to create dimensionality even in limited spaces. The fervent plane engine sounds and strategic sound placements further bolster the energetic dynamic of the audio track. The inclusion of Carter Burwell’s poignant score, replete with guitar riffs and textured strings, further establishes a compelling auditory ambiance that aligns seamlessly with the film's setting.
Additionally, for viewers requiring accessibility features, the feature is effectively subtitled with optional English SDH. Overall, "The Chamber's" audio presentation on this Blu-ray substantially elevates the film's impact with its masterful sound engineering, ensuring both 5.1 and 2.0 options deliver robust and captivating auditory experiences catered to varied listener preferences.
Extras: 6
The Blu-Ray extras for "The Chamber" are minimal and primarily consist of a standard collection of trailers provided by Kino Lorber Studio Classics. The disc features the full-frame theatrical trailer for "The Chamber," notable for including scenes that were cut from the final theatrical release. However, there is a lack of substantial bonus content aside from these promotional materials. The technical presentation of the trailers is in standard definition, which may not meet the expectations of viewers seeking insightful behind-the-scenes material or commentary. Overall, while the provided extras contribute some historical context for the film's original release, they do not add significant value for enthusiasts looking for in-depth special features.
Extras included in this disc:
- Theatrical Trailer: Includes additional shots not in the released version.
- Bonus Trailers: Features trailers from other Kino Lorber titles such as "The Gingerbread Man," "The Package," and "The Interpreter."
Movie: 56
"The Chamber," directed by James Foley, presents a methodically paced legal drama that delves deeply into the complexities of the American judicial system and its racial biases. This adaptation of John Grisham's novel deviates from his typical thriller formula, engaging with themes of familial legacy and moral culpability rather than suspense. Chris O'Donnell embodies Adam Hall, a young lawyer determined to save his grandfather Sam Cayhall (Gene Hackman), a convicted Klansman on Death Row. Their tense interplay is a cornerstone of the narrative, exploring the psychological and emotional strains of confronting a family's racist history.
Grisham's exploration of such weighty topics as capital punishment and systemic injustice is mirrored in the film’s portrayal of courtroom struggles and personal reckonings. Gene Hackman delivers a standout performance as the unrepentant Sam Cayhall, presenting a character that is both repulsive and meticulously crafted, reminiscent of his role in "Mississippi Burning." Despite Hackman’s prowess, "The Chamber" struggled to distinguish itself, overshadowed by thematic similarities to contemporaneous adaptations like "A Time to Kill," and never quite reaching the critical heights of other Grisham-based films due to its unfocused narrative in later stages.
The production values are modestly presented on the Kino Lorber Blu-ray edition, which features standard technical specifications without offering any significant enhancements. The disc caters to those interested in a straightforward presentation rather than potential supplemental content. While the film may not stand out in the wider Grisham cineverse, it suits audiences interested in probing legal dramas and features capable performances that engage with the intricate effects of legacy within families and communities. Despite its mixed critical reception, "The Chamber" remains a curious examination of justice and familial bonds amidst racially charged tensions.
Total: 52
"The Chamber" transitions from John Grisham’s complex novel to a cinematic interpretation that attempts to capture the essence of its source material, albeit with a standard Hollywood treatment. While the film may not match the intricacy of the book, it offers an engaging narrative, highlighted by Gene Hackman's commanding performance. Despite the film's production challenges, including multiple screenplay revisions that left both Grisham and screenwriter William Goldman unsatisfied, it manages to deliver a story that resolves certain narrative ambiguities that remain in the novel.
The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber Studio Classics presents "The Chamber" with a serviceable image transfer, which, although not state-of-the-art, adequately serves its purpose. The DTS 5.1 audio mix stands out, offering an immersive sound experience that enhances the viewing. Unfortunately, the absence of substantial bonus materials leaves fans wanting more. Despite this, the Blu-ray is recommended for those who appreciate the talents of Hackman, Chris O'Donnell, and Faye Dunaway.
In conclusion, "The Chamber" offers a satisfying experience for Grisham enthusiasts seeking entertainment in the legal thriller genre. While it may not surpass other film adaptations like "A Time to Kill," it provides an intriguing narrative propelled by strong performances. The film captures an acceptable blend of drama and resolution, making it a worthy addition to any collection of 90s legal dramas.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Stephen LarsonRead review here
Video: 60
Kino Studio Classics has put the 113-minute feature on a BD-25 and the MPEG-4 AVC-encoded transfer averages a bitrate of just 21462 kbps, with the total bitrate clocking in at a mean of only 26.74 Mbps....
Audio: 100
It's important to remember that DTS had only been around for three years when The Chamber opened in American theaters in October, 1996 and the 5.1 track here is deep and resonant....
Extras: 10
Theatrical Trailer - a full-frame trailer for The Chamber that includes shots cut from the theatrical version....
Movie: 60
In one of his few leading dramatic roles for the silver screen, Chris O'Donnell is quite good as the progressive-minded, very determined young lawyer....
Total: 60
Overall, The Chamber as a motion picture definitely could have been better but it's a decent piece of entertainment....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
This transfer doesn't look to have been touched in quite some time, probably dating back to the original DVD mastering, however, that isn't entirely a bad thing....
Audio: 80
There isn't a dramatic amount of surround activity as the film takes place in small places but when it opens up in the streets of Chicago or a few party sequences to the Klan rally towards the end it's...
Extras: 0
Not surprisingly, The Chamber doesn't come with any bonus features beyond KLSC's standard bundle of trailers Theatrical Trailer (SD 2:32)...
Movie: 60
However, it does offer an interesting look at how a crime affects not only the criminal and the victim but the family of the criminal who has to live down their family legacy....
Total: 60
The Chamber isn't the best Grisham flick to come out of the 90s, but it's still decent enough entertainment largely because of a magnetic performance by the always excellent Gene Hackman....
Director: James Foley
Actors: Chris O'Donnell, Gene Hackman, Faye Dunaway
PlotYoung attorney Adam Hall takes on the emotionally charged case of defending his grandfather, Sam Cayhall, who is on death row for a Ku Klux Klan bombing that killed two Jewish children in Mississippi in the 1960s. As Adam delves into the case, he learns about the deep-seated racial tensions and dark family secrets that have haunted his family for generations. Despite his limited experience, Adam is determined to save his grandfather from execution, believing there may be more to the story than the public and the courts have seen.
As Adam digs deeper, he confronts his own inner conflicts and disapproval from his colleagues and loved ones. The journey forces him to re-evaluate his stance on justice, forgiveness, and redemption. With the execution date looming closer, Adam unravels layers of deception and struggles against time to uncover crucial evidence that might exonerate his grandfather. The case becomes an intense exploration of moral ambiguity, a reflection on the legacies of hate, and the potential for personal redemption amidst societal prejudice.
Writers: John Grisham, William Goldman, Phil Alden Robinson
Release Date: 11 Oct 1996
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English