Starting Over Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Starting Over" presents a highly satisfying visual experience, thanks to a meticulous 1080p transfer encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, sourced from a recent 4K master by Paramount Pictures. The presentation retains the original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, capturing the film’s photography in striking detail. The delineation, clarity, and depth achieved here are impressive for 1080p and could be mistaken for native 4K quality. The color balance is precise, though in certain scenes, there might be a slight warm/creamy overtone. However, these instances do not detract from the visual integrity. The entire film image is stable and clean, devoid of any digital correction artifacts.

Shot on 35 mm film using Panaflex cameras and Panavision lenses by acclaimed cinematographer Sven Nykvist, the transfer respects and enhances the film’s visual nuances. Paramount’s 4K scan of the original camera negative ensures no visual imperfections mar the experience. The color palette is intentionally subdued, capturing the wintery feel of the settings, particularly evident in outdoor scenes shot under overcast skies. Fine details are rendered beautifully, from the intricacies of Phil's new bachelor apartment to the subtleties in candlelit dinners and the costumes worn by Marilyn and Jessica. This Blu-ray release truly highlights the texture and depth of the original film stock, offering an exceptional visual representation.

The Blu-ray release of "Starting Over" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track that greatly enhances the viewing experience. Optional English SDH subtitles are available for accessibility. The remastered lossless audio shines, displaying no age-related anomalies. This results in clear, sharp, and stable exchanges throughout the film. The sound balance is meticulously maintained, with dialogue, music, and ambient sounds coming together seamlessly. Although dynamic contrasts are average, this is consistent with the film’s production era and does not detract from the overall audio quality.

The expertly mixed soundtrack, scored by Marvin Hamlisch, plays a vital role in conveying the narrative's emotional depth, especially during pivotal moments between characters Phil and Marilyn. The clear and distinct dialogue allows viewers to fully engage with each scene, while the natural integration of music and ambient sound delivers a rich auditory experience. Whether it’s a tender conversation or a more dynamic scene, the audio presentation feels lifelike and immersive, making the Blu-ray edition a notable upgrade for audiophiles and casual viewers alike.

The Blu-ray extras for "Starting Over" provide a deep dive into the film's production, emphasizing both its historical context and stylistic choices. The informative and engaging audio commentary by critics Daniel Kremer and Howard S. Berger particularly stands out, offering insights into Alan J. Pakula’s directorial nuances, such as his unconventional pacing in comedy and distinct visual style. They also highlight Burt Reynolds' dedication to the role of Phil and Candice Bergen's daring performance, which was influenced by her complete trust in Pakula. Additionally, the commentary addresses James L. Brooks' emerging voice as a screenwriter and the film's reception. The thoughtfully curated extras enrich the viewing experience by exploring the intricacies behind the film’s creation and its players.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Exclusive new audio commentary by critics Daniel Kremer and Howard S. Berger.

Alan J. Pakula's "Starting Over" (1979) on Blu-ray, released by Kino Lorber, features an exclusive new audio commentary by critics Daniel Kremer and Howard S. Berger. The film, in English with optional SDH subtitles and Region-A locked, examines complex relationships grounded in insecurity and emotional baggage. Burt Reynolds stars as Phil Potter, struggling emotionally after his wife, Jessica (Candice Bergen), leaves him to pursue her dreams of becoming a singer-songwriter. Phil turns to Marylin Holmberg (Jill Clayburgh), forging a relationship built on mutual therapeutic need rather than genuine love, resulting in a dynamic where both characters use one another to mend their emotional wounds rather than seek authentic connection.

The film's portrayal of these flawed characters—like the needy and manipulable Phil and the reclusive Marylin—offers a realistic but somewhat one-dimensional take on relationships forged from desperation. The movie does encapsulate moments of humor through its mocking of the protagonists' minor victories and failures. Still, it often strays into sadness by highlighting the depth of their insecurities. Candice Bergen’s portrayal of Jessica adds complexity, showing a woman who quickly disengages from her family reality to chase her aspirations, inadvertently revealing her self-centered nature through awkward post-divorce interactions.

Visually, the film benefits immensely from the expertise of Oscar-winning cinematographer Sven Nykvist, known for his work with Ingmar Bergman. Nykvist's cinematography produces stunning visuals, although sometimes these seem incongruent with the fundamentally light-hearted nature of the dramedy. Despite its often insightful depiction of insecure and broken individuals attempting to "start over," the film’s messaging remains weak by both 1970s and contemporary standards, making its characters appear as caricatures in an easily avoidable, albeit thought-provoking farce.

Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Starting Over" is notably sourced from a pristine new 4K master prepared at Paramount Pictures, ensuring an outstanding visual quality that truly elevates the viewing experience. The improved clarity and detail are immediately evident, showcasing the film's cinematography with vibrant colors and sharp images. Audio fidelity has also been given considerable attention, with a well-balanced sound mix that complements the visual upgrade. Yet, despite these technical enhancements, "Starting Over" remains a film that struggles to wholly satisfy in both comedic and dramatic aspects.

"Starting Over" features first-rate performances from its lead actors Burt Reynolds, Jill Clayburgh, and Candice Bergen, who inject life into their characters with commendable skill. The film's premise shows promise, addressing the complexities of divorce and the emotional turmoil of establishing new relationships while dealing with lingering feelings for a former spouse. However, the narrative loses coherence in its final third, becoming somewhat aimless before reaching a rather predictable conclusion. This detracts from what could have been a more tightly woven and impactful story.

In summary, "Starting Over" offers some humorous moments and benefits from strong performances and excellent technical presentation on Blu-ray. However, it ultimately falls short of delivering a wholly compelling comedy or thought-provoking drama. Its dated feel and narrative meanderings prevent it from achieving its potential, resulting in an experience that is somewhat underwhelming despite its happy ending.