No Good Deed Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
This thriller's uninspired storyline is saved by excellent video and audio quality, making it a potential rental for those seeking mindless escapism.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 86
No Good Deed's Blu-ray, mastered in 4K and presented in 1080p, delivers a phenomenal visual experience with striking detail, lifelike precision, deep black levels, and natural color reproduction, free from any artifacts or noise.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack excels with superb dialogue clarity, immersive sound effects during the storm scenes, robust low-frequency extension, and a well-balanced surround mix, creating a wide and dynamic soundstage that enhances the film's suspenseful atmosphere.
Extra: 28
No Good Deed's Blu-ray extras include three brief, insightful featurettes and a digital HD copy: "Making a Thriller" (12 mins) explores character dynamics, casting, and the director’s vision; "The Thrill of a Good Fight" (6 mins) delves into fight choreography; and "Good Samaritan" (4 mins) examines creating authentic, relatable characters.
Movie: 28
Despite Idris Elba's standout performance elevating 'No Good Deed,' the film falters with clichéd plot devices, lack of suspense, and predictable tropes, leaving it as a technically sound yet ultimately forgettable thriller, overshadowed by its promising trailer and cast yet trapped in a formulaic execution.
Video: 86
"No Good Deed" delivers a visual performance on Blu-ray that is nothing short of mesmerizing, benefiting significantly from its 4K mastering. The 1080p HD transfer shines with exemplary clarity and detail, from the finest facial features to intricate household items. Even in subdued lighting conditions, the digital image remains razor-sharp and natural. The film's commitment to high fidelity is also evident in the consistent and richly saturated color palette, which avoids any artificial manipulation. Skin tones appear lifelike, and black levels during nocturnal rain sequences are profoundly inky, evading any sign of crush. There are no instances of visual noise or artifacts, ensuring an uninterrupted viewing experience.
Every frame of "No Good Deed" offers a depth that is rarely seen, providing a near three-dimensional visual richness. This immersion is further enhanced by the meticulous detail in wider shots and background elements, contributing to the overall depth and realism. Close-ups are particularly striking, capturing each hair strand, wrinkle, and blemish with precision. The film's black levels are outstandingly deep and stable, while color reproduction remains bold and consistent throughout. Every scene, regardless of lighting, is meticulously detailed and clear, reinforcing the film's overall visual integrity.
Sony's transfer of "No Good Deed" into Blu-ray is technically exemplary, demonstrating a flawless AVC MPEG-4 encoding at a 2.40:1 aspect ratio. The result is an incredibly sharp, noise-free image that maintains superb visual integrity throughout the viewing experience. While the film itself may not appeal to everyone, its video presentation undeniably sets a high standard, showcasing what is possible with 4K mastering for a 1080p Blu-ray release. Overall, "No Good Deed" stands as a benchmark in video quality for Blu-ray presentations.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack of "No Good Deed" achieves excellence in its audio presentation, delivering a balanced and dynamic soundscape that significantly enhances the film's suspenseful atmosphere. Dialogue clarity is impeccably maintained, allowing for even subtle vocal intonations to be distinctly heard. The soundstage is expanded with precision, enveloping the listener and adeptly utilizing surround channels to create an immersive experience, particularly during the recurring thunderstorm depicted in the film. Lower frequency effects are reproduced with palpable depth, ensuring a robust and engaging auditory experience.
The mix effectively leverages its surround capabilities to heighten both musical and elemental atmospheric effects. From the nuanced rumbles inside the prison transport van to the immersive sounds of pouring rain and cracking thunder, the audio track excels at bringing these environments to life. The music score, rich and full, seamlessly integrates with other elements to maintain the film's suspense without overwhelming dialogue or sound effects. Notable dynamic range and directionality are evident throughout, with sequences involving gunshots and action scenes depicted with potent authenticity. Despite occasional limitations in lifelike realism for some effects, the soundtrack consistently delivers a high level of engagement and fidelity.
Overall, this release's audio presentation stands out for its precise technical execution, contributing significantly to the viewer's immersive experience. The balanced use of surround sound, along with the seamless integration of dialogue, music, and environmental effects, makes this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix a notable highlight of the "No Good Deed" Blu-ray.
Extras: 28
The extras on the Blu Ray of "No Good Deed" provide an insightful yet concise look into the film's behind-the-scenes processes, though they might feel somewhat lightweight for those seeking in-depth analyses. The featurettes cover both thematic and technical aspects, including story development, character dynamics, and physical action sequences, but do not delve deeply. Each segment is complemented by interviews with cast and crew, decorating the presentation with various perspectives on the production and casting decisions. Despite their brevity, these clips offer value for fans of the film. Additionally, a digital HD copy of the film is included, adding convenience for digital viewers. Overall, while modest in scale, these extras serve as an engaging accompaniment to the main feature.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making a Thriller: An examination of story basics, character attributes, script quality, casting, on-location shooting, and more.
- The Thrill of a Good Fight: Insight into the creation of the movie's fight scenes from both physical and acting perspectives.
- Good Samaritan: Discussion on crafting authentic characters and situational relatability based on human instincts.
- Trailers: Previews of additional Sony titles.
Movie: 28
"No Good Deed" features Terri (Taraji P. Henson), a suburban wife and mother whose life takes a dangerous turn when Colin (Idris Elba), an escaped convict, arrives at her home feigning car trouble. What unfolds is a tale of survival against a backdrop of predictable thriller tropes. Idris Elba's portrayal of Colin stands out as the film's saving grace. His character, torn between regretful introspection and menacing violence, provides the movie's only significant depth. The film's technical elements, including its visual presentation and editing, are competent but fail to elevate a lackluster script filled with clichés and formulaic twists.
The movie's tension relies on well-worn narrative conveniences, such as thunderstorms and malfunctioning car alarms, which propel the story in an all too familiar direction. The plot's predictability is a significant drawback, diminishing the impact of what should be tense, thrilling sequences. Despite these issues, Elba's multifaceted performance manages to keep the audience engaged. His ability to switch between a seemingly reformed individual and a remorseless killer adds layers to an otherwise straightforward role.
Henson's role as Terri, however, is comparatively underdeveloped. Her character's decisions often appear illogical given her background as a former prosecutor specializing in violence against women. This undermines the potential for a strong female lead fighting against her captor. Leslie Bibb’s character also falls into the trap of genre stereotypes, contributing little beyond fulfilling typical thriller conventions. In summary, while "No Good Deed" fails to innovate within its genre, Idris Elba’s commanding performance offers a reason to watch, albeit one unlikely to leave a lasting impression.
Total: 65
"No Good Deed," despite its promising premise and talent fronted by Idris Elba, falls short in its execution. The film, directed by Sam Miller, lacks the depth and imaginative risks that could have made it memorable. While Elba delivers a commendable performance as the film's villain, the storyline remains predictable and fails to engage on a deeper level. The film’s structure is formulaic, leaning more toward conventional thrills rather than creative ingenuity. Though it avoids complete dullness, "No Good Deed" doesn’t offer much to linger in the minds of its viewers beyond immediate escapism.
Technically, the Blu-ray release of "No Good Deed" excels with outstanding video and audio quality. The high definition transfer ensures crisp visuals and the sound mix complements the movie's atmospherics effectively. However, the supplementary content accompanying the Blu-ray leaves much to be desired. The extras, which include a few promotional featurettes, could have been more substantial with additional on-set footage or commentary tracks to provide greater insight into the film’s production.
In conclusion, while "No Good Deed" might entertain those looking for a simple thrill with no lasting impression, it is otherwise unremarkable. For audiences drawn by technical perfection in home viewing experience, Sony’s Blu-ray release is a technical winner and worth considering. However, a rental would be advisable before committing to a purchase. The film’s lack of originality and depth places it firmly in the realm of forgettable suspense dramas.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Whether intricate facial features and clothing lines or kitchen appliances and other household items appearing throughout a number of interior backgrounds, every inch of each frame reveals with striking,...
Audio: 90
The stage is open, with a balanced surround support structure utilized to enhance both music and atmospherics....
Extras: 30
The Thrill of a Good Fight (1080p, 6:10): A closer look at the inner workings of making the movie's fighting sequences, both the physicality and the deeper actor requirements necessary to create authentic...
Movie: 50
As the movie builds towards its revealing climax that, to this twist's credit, does help to better define several of the "hows" and "whys" that lead up to it -- while also opening up a few more questions...
Total: 60
It's not dull, just unremarkable, a movie that does what it does with commendable craftsmanship but nothing in the film ever gets under the skin, unsettles the mind, or lingers in the soul....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Not only are closeups very detailed, but the wider shots and background props and sets look very sharp as well, giving the picture quite a bit of depth....
Audio: 80
For being a thriller, this audio track hits all the right notes with its excellent LFE and a very wide dynamic range....
Extras: 20
- This is a better than average promo reel for the movie with cast and crew interviews as they discuss the themes, story, characters, overall shoot and production....
Movie: 20
He is denied parole and in this scene, we see Idris's talent come full force as he plays a man who is regretful of his actions and sincere, while still holding that mysterious and sadistic side we see...
Total: 60
And while the trailer to this film promised something very suspenseful and scary, we ended up getting something silly, mundane, and unoriginal....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 90
Dynamic range is excellent and the soundstage has an open expression that allows its elements to extend well into the room....
Extras: 40
The thrill of a good fight – 6 minute featurette * Exclusive (HD) Good Samaritan – 4 minute featurette Digital HD Copy...
Movie: 30
Terri (Taraji P. Henson) is a devoted wife and mother of two, living an ideal suburban life in Atlanta when Colin (Idris Elba), a charming but dangerous escaped convict, shows up at her door claiming car...
Total: 63
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SVS PB-13...
Why So Blu? review by Aaron NeuwirthRead review here
Video: 100
The color palette is consistent, bold, and even quite stunning in some instances, given how stark the general atmosphere of this film is....
Audio: 90
This lossless soundtrack is pretty much everything it needs to be to make a film like this sound as good as possible, given the clarity of every aspect and the way various channels are used to create the...
Extras: 30
Good Samaritan (HD, 4:28) – Some discussion of an aspect of the film involving what lengths to go to in some cases for the sake of the audience....
Movie: 20
Total: 40
That is a similar film to No Good Deed, but it is slightly better, while this film is just somewhere at the bottom of mainstream 2014 films....
Director: Sam Miller
Actors: Taraji P. Henson, Idris Elba, Leslie Bibb
PlotIn a quiet suburban neighborhood, a devoted wife and mother named Terri is home with her young children when a charming stranger named Colin shows up at her door during a stormy night. Claiming to have car trouble and asking for help, Colin seems polite but increasingly unsettling. Despite her initial hesitation, Terri allows him inside, unwittingly inviting danger into her home. Colin’s true motives are revealed when he exhibits violent behavior, throwing Terri and her children into a perilous situation.
As the night progresses, tension escalates as Terri endeavors to protect her family and outsmart Colin. The intruder's true identity and intentions slowly come to light, building a suspenseful narrative of cat-and-mouse. Terri must summon all her strength and resourcefulness to fight for survival and ensure the safety of her children against the looming threat within her own walls. The film intensifies with psychological and physical confrontations, leading to a dramatic and high-stakes climax.
Writers: Aimee Lagos
Release Date: 12 Sep 2014
Runtime: 84 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English