The Aviator Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Scorsese's repeated DiCaprio casting for blockbuster allure contrasts with desires for new leads and diverse performances, despite successes.
Disc Release Date
Video: 69
'The Aviator' Blu-ray offers visually stunning 1080p imagery, capturing Scorsese's artistry and homage to film history, despite a purposely softer, sepia-toned first hour.
Audio: 44
The 'Aviator' Blu-ray audio, while clear and dynamic, lacks immersive depth and PCM quality, underscoring a mixed yet decent experience.
Extra: 76
The 'The Aviator' Blu-ray dazzles with Scorcese's engaging commentary, a rich array of featurettes exploring Hughes' life, OCD, aviation history, detailed production insights, and engaging visual effects discussions, complemented by deleted scenes and HD trailer.
Movie: 71
The Aviator," directed by Scorsese and starring DiCaprio, pays homage to Hughes' aviation passion and Hollywood's golden era, capturing his tragic descent into madness with stunning detail and artistry.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Aviator" emerges as a visual spectacle, showcasing Martin Scorsese's directorial nuances with remarkable clarity. The 1080p/VC-1 transfer excels in rendering the film's meticulous details, especially in the vivid portrayal of old Hollywood’s glamour and the breathtaking aerial sequences. From the life-like flashing of antique camera bulbs to the immersive depiction of screening room scenes, every frame benefits from the high-definition treatment. Notably, the flight scenes, a highlight of this release, are presented with such mesmerizing detail that they captivate the viewer entirely. Despite a stylized approach to coloration that leans towards a slightly washed-out look, the choice is deliberate, aiming to pay homage to the era’s technological limitations while maintaining aesthetic appeal.
However, some may find the early part of the film visually softer due to Scorsese's intention to mimic two-tone cinema, resulting in a sepia-toned effect that impacts color dynamics, particularly reds and greens. This deliberate choice serves as a narrative technique rather than a flaw, transitioning to a richer, more saturated palette as the story progresses into the Technicolor era of the '40s. This sudden influx of vibrant colors might be jarring at first but ultimately enhances the viewing experience. The transfer is largely free from blemishes or artifacting, exhibiting stable color reproduction and avoiding contrast wavering or bleeding—issues sometimes noted in standard-definition DVDs.
The Blu-ray’s presentation handles fine details with precision, unraveling even the most minute elements in both brightly lit and shadow-cloaked scenes. Despite an initial softness and a somewhat subdued color scheme in parts of the film, this release stands out for its clean print, lack of distracting noise, and overall immaculate source quality. These technical merits ensure that "The Aviator" on Blu-ray not only respects Scorsese's visual storytelling but elevates it, making for a compelling viewing experience despite not becoming an instant demo disc. Fans and newcomers alike will appreciate this high-definition realization of Scorsese's vision, marking it as an essential addition to their collection.
Audio: 44
The audio presentation of "The Aviator" on Blu-ray, while not as exceptional as its visual counterpart, still offers a reasonably good auditory experience. The Dolby Digital 5.1 surround mix, provided at 640 kbps, delivers dialogue that is crisp and clear, ensuring that voices come through convincingly. Cate Blanchett's portrayal of Katharine Hepburn and Leonardo DiCaprio's Howard Hughes are notably well-rendered through their vocal performances, with Blanchett's lilting delivery and DiCaprio's hesitancy shining through. However, the absence of a PCM track is felt, limiting the overall soundstaging and imaging capabilities compared to other releases. This leaves the soundscape feeling underutilized, particularly with the front channels bearing the brunt of the audio, resulting in a rather front-heavy mix that misses out on a more immersive surround experience.
The use of rear speakers is minimal, with notable exceptions during key scenes such as the airplane crash, which momentarily elevates the level of immersion. The soundfield's limited dynamism hampers ambiance and acoustics, making the audio experience less enveloping than what might be expected from a high-definition release. On a positive note, the LFE channel does provide some depth with its bass responses during certain moments, and the film's score benefits from stable treble and smooth pans, enhancing the overall dynamics and giving subtle effects their due in the mix.
Despite these strengths, the track's inability to fully exploit an immersive soundscape limits its effectiveness. Directionality sometimes misses the mark, with audio cues not always optimally placed within the soundscape, further emphasizing the constrained nature of this audio presentation. Thus, while there are moments that stand out and certain technical aspects like dialogue clarity and treble stability are commendable, the audio package of "The Aviator" Blu-ray ultimately presents a mixed experience that does not quite rise to the heights attained by higher caliber Blu-ray audio offerings.
Extras: 76
Combining the essence of the reviews provided, it's clear that the extra presentation of "The Aviator" Blu-ray disc is a treasure trove for both cinema lovers and aviation enthusiasts. The inclusion of an additional scene not seen in theaters and the detailed audio commentary by Martin Scorsese, along with insights from producer Michael Mann and editor Thelma Schoonmaker, stand out as significant highlights. Equally compelling are the featurettes that dive deep into Howard Hughes' life, his contributions to aviation, his battle with OCD, and the meticulous recreation of the era by Scorcese and his team. Whether it's the behind-the-scenes look at the making of this epic film, the detailed exploration of its visual effects, or the attention to costume and set design, each extra adds a layer of appreciation for the craft. Despite some features being seen as less engaging, such as the segment on the Wainwright Family, the overall package is exhaustive and enhances one's understanding of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Engaging insights from Scorsese, Mann, and Schoonmaker.
- Deleted Scene: A brief, yet intriguing cut from the film.
- A Life Without Limits: The Making of The Aviator: An overview with cast and crew interviews.
- The Role of Howard Hughes in Aviation History: Deep dive into Hughes' aviation impact.
- Modern Marvels: Howard Hughes: A History Channel documentary on Hughes' life and innovations.
- The Affliction of Howard Hughes: Obsessive Compulsive Disorder: An exploration of Hughes' OCD.
- OCD Panel Discussion: A detailed discussion at UCLA about OCD in Howard Hughes’ life.
- An Evening with Leonardo DiCaprio and Alan Alda: A behind-the-scenes conversation.
- The Visual Effects of The Aviator: Examination of the film’s visual effects.
- Constructing The Aviator: The Work of Dante Ferretti: Insight into production design.
- Costuming The Aviator: The Work of Sandy Powell: Focus on costume design.
- The Age of Glamour: The Hair and Makeup of The Aviator: Exploring hair and makeup efforts.
- Scoring The Aviator: The Work of Howard Shore: Discussion on the film’s score.
- The Wainwright Family: Loudon, Rufus, and Martha: Their roles as lounge singers.
- Stills Gallery: A collection of stills from the film.
- Theatrical Trailer: Presented in high definition.
Movie: 71
The Aviator," under the deft direction of Martin Scorsese, resurrects the golden era of Hollywood and the pioneering days of aviation with an authenticity and enthusiasm that only a filmmaker of his calibre can achieve. This Blu-ray presentation illuminates Scorsese's masterful creation, bringing Howard Hughes' aeronautical endeavors and the 1920s-1940s period to life with mesmerizing clarity. The 1080p resolution accentuates the vibrancy and detail of the era, from the swing/big band era bandstands to the meticulously recreated aircraft that Hughes so cherished. Scorsese's portrayal transcends mere cinematic experience; it is a visual spectacle, especially in the sequences where aircraft gloriously take to the skies. The commitment to capturing the essence of this epoch is evident in every frame, lovingly reconstructed sets and landscapes immerse viewers completely into Hughes' world.
However, the film's heart lies in its narrative and character dynamics, rather than sheer visual splendor. Leonardo DiCaprio's portrayal of Howard Hughes, while not universally lauded, is ambitious and ranks among his most intense roles. DiCaprio channels Hughes' fervent, obsessive spirit with palpable earnestness, albeit with a reminder of his limitations when compared to chameleons like Robert De Niro. Yet, his interactions with Cate Blanchett's Katherine Hepburn and the depiction of Hughes' spiraling descent into obsessive-compulsive disorder lend a tragic layer to his character. The ensemble cast, including notable performances by Alec Baldwin and Alan Alda, elevates the narrative, depicting a compelling chess match of corporate and governmental politics that surrounds Hughes' ambitious projects and mental decline.
Despite DiCaprio's compelling performance and Scorsese's rigorous attention to period detail, "The Aviator" challenges viewers by refusing to simplify or sentimentalize Hughes' complex psyche. The film's focus on power, ambition, and eventual disintegration into madness presents a haunting yet fascinating character study that remains engaging throughout. From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray is an exceptional means to witness Scorsese’s vision in its intended glory—a meticulously crafted homage to one of aviation and cinema's most enigmatic figures. Although the ending may feel abrupt for some, "The Aviator" stands as a testament to Hughes’ enduring legacy and a pinnacle in biographical filmmaking.
Total: 62
The Blu-ray release of "The Aviator," directed by Martin Scorsese and starring Leonardo DiCaprio, serves as a remarkable example of modern cinema's blend of star power and technical finesse. The collaboration between Scorsese and DiCaprio has been a recurrent theme, sparking discussions regarding Hollywood's reliance on bankable stars to greenlight high-budget films. While some may question the repetitive casting of DiCaprio in Scorsese's works, it's impossible to overlook the commercial strategy behind such decisions. Despite these debates, "The Aviator" stands out not only for its compelling narrative and DiCaprio's performance but also for the high-quality Blu-ray presentation that brings Scorsese's vision to vivid life.
Technical aspects of the Blu-ray, such as the stellar video transfer and a wide array of supplements, highlight the release's value. The visual clarity enhances the film's period aesthetic, making every frame a testament to the era of aviation it seeks to recreate. Although the audio track might not impress all, it is competently mixed, ensuring that dialogue and Howard Shore's score are delivered with clarity. Supplementary materials, including a comprehensive three-hour commentary, various featurettes, and documentaries, enrich the viewing experience by providing in-depth insights into the film's production and historical context.
In conclusion, regardless of one's views on the repetitive collaboration between Scorsese and DiCaprio, "The Aviator" Blu-ray represents a pinnacle of home entertainment. It couples an engaging cinematic narrative with exceptional technical quality, offering both newcomers and seasoned fans an immersive viewing experience. This release reinforces the notion that foundational talent combined with superior production values can result in a highly recommendable piece for any collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 90
The popping bulbs symbolize the pressure of public scrutiny and the ever-present eye of the media, but Scorsese shows these camera accessories as living, breathing creatures....
Audio: 70
Unfortunately, Warner includes no PCM track and the soundstaging and imaging is not as impressive as many other Blu-ray releases....
Extras: 80
While the lack of PCM is regrettable, fans of Scorcese will be delighted with the supplementary material offered by Warner....
Movie: 70
Both help define Scorcese himself and much of his work, but a third ingredient in the film benefits the most from the director's attention to detail: the passion of aviation....
Total: 80
He may not be the best actor of his generation, but he's one of the best looking and the teens flock to the theaters in droves to see him....
High-Def Digest review by High-Def Digest staffRead review here
Video: 90
While this is a direct product of Scorsese's filming methods, it still keeps the high definition transfer from packing the punch of the last half of the film....
Audio: 60
Ambiance and acoustics are hindered by the limited soundfield and the track doesn't have the immersive characteristics of better high definition audio offerings....
Extras: 80
It even gathers the perspectives of aviation enthusiasts, pilots, and aviation Hall of Fame inductee Robert Hoover, and ultimately stands as a testament to the incredible level of detail and accuracy Scorsese...
Movie: 80
While his early work explored the behavior of morally questionable characters felled by their own ambition, his more recent films have focused on characters who rise and fall in the face of noble challenges...
Total: 80
While everyone may not personally respond to the story of 'The Aviator,' this release is still an easy one recommend....
Director: Martin Scorsese
Actors: Leonardo DiCaprio, Cate Blanchett, Kate Beckinsale
PlotAn ambitious and innovative industrialist with a passion for aviation and film sets his sights on revolutionizing both industries in the early 20th century. Battling his personal psychological struggles, he makes bold moves to disrupt the standards of filmmaking with the production of one of the most expensive movies of its time. His love for aviation drives him to design and build extraordinary aircraft, setting new benchmarks in the world of flight. His endeavors elevate his stature among the affluent and influential, drawing the attention and admiration of Hollywood's elite.
Meanwhile, his personal life is as tumultuous as his professional one, entwined with relationships with several prominent actresses who captivate his heart and imagination. His relentless push for progress in the aviation industry leads him to take risks that have never been attempted before, culminating in the creation of a revolutionary aircraft that could transform the future of air travel. However, his growing obsessions and compulsions hint at an underlying struggle that threatens to unravel his empire and his mind. His aviator dreams soar as high as his private demons run deep, challenging the limits of both his genius and his sanity.
Writers: John Logan
Release Date: 25 Dec 2004
Runtime: 170 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Germany
Language: English, Persian