The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 74
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
4K UHD release of The Hobbit refreshes Middle Earth with stunning visuals and sound, a must-see.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 82
2021 brings a 4K UHD Middle-earth collection and remastered LOTR, while The Hobbit's 4K upgrade offers mixed results but impresses with HDR and detail.
Audio: 91
Dolby Atmos delivers an immersive, reference-quality audio experience for films, enhancing every detail from subtle ambient effects to powerful action sequences with crystal-clear clarity and depth, making it a highly satisfying mix.
Extra: 34
Warner Bros' 4K UHD release of The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey excludes all previous bonus features, offering only the movie cuts, hinting at a future Middle Earth collection with new extras.
Movie: 71
The Hobbit Trilogy, starring Martin Freeman, is an epic yet ponderous prequel to LOTR, filled with CGI splendor but criticized for its lengthy exposition and lack of novelty.
Video: 82
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" on 4K UHD Blu-ray presents a transformative leap in visual quality, bringing the splendors of Middle Earth to life with unsurpassed clarity and vibrancy. Warner Bros.' 2160p HEVC / H.265 encode, supervised by Peter Jackson himself, is showcased in a 2.40:1 widescreen aspect ratio, offering a reference-quality presentation that exceeds even the most optimistic expectations. This edition outperforms previous Blu-ray releases and theatrical screenings, boasting stunning resolution, enhanced color reproduction through HDR grading, and meticulously upgraded special effects. From the lush landscapes of The Shire to the minutiae of character details and costume textures, every scene benefits from a significant enhancement in visual fidelity, providing a jaw-dropping experience that highlights the prowess of 4K technology.
However, it's worth noting the original digital filming techniques and the limitations of the Red cameras used have imposed constraints on image quality, particularly in medium and long shots where detail resolution faces challenges. Despite these minor setbacks, close-up shots reveal an impressive depth of detail, from facial textures to the intricate designs of costumes. The Dolby Vision implementation enriches the viewing experience further, enhancing contrast and enriching colors to offer a more immersive and visually spectacular journey. While some inconsistencies in the digital effects and slight wavering in sharpness are noted, they are few and far between, not detracting significantly from the overall visual excellence.
Filmed on Red Epic cameras and eventually mastered at 2K for a traditional 24fps presentation, the 4K UHD upscale manages to dazzle with its sharpness and depth, bringing forward an astonishing level of detail across landscapes and sets. Despite some criticisms regarding the adequacy of upscaling practices and slight digital artifacts in complex scenes, the improvement over previous iterations is undeniable. Enhanced HDR grading brings out stunning contrasts and vibrant colors, from the dynamic battles under stormy skies to serene moments in Rivendell lit by natural light, culminating in a cinematic experience that pays fitting homage to Jackson's vision. The richness of the film's palette, bolstered by Dolby Vision, introduces viewers to a Middle Earth that is more alive and inviting than ever before, demonstrating the capability of 4K UHD to redefine our engagement with this beloved saga.
Audio: 91
The 4K UHD Blu Ray Dolby Atmos surround mix of "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" elevates the already immersive adventure to new heights, providing an aural experience that is as captivating as the visual splendor of Middle-earth. With a keen attention to detail, the audio mix wonderfully complements Howard Shore's powerful score and the rich soundscapes of this fantastical world. The Atmos presentation's additional height channels introduce an expansive breadth to the listening experience, allowing dramatic fight scenes to burst with ferocity and quieter moments to resonate with an enveloping sense of calm and majesty. Dialogue remains crisp and well-balanced amidst the dynamic range of sound effects, ensuring every spoken word is as clear as the clashing of swords or the crackling of fire, demonstrating a masterful handling of the sonic landscape.
Venturing into the realms of trolls and goblins, the audio design is fearlessly adventurous, tracking the story's progression with a meticulousness that enriches the narrative. The Atmos configuration crafts a captivating hemispheric soundfield; in scenes like Bilbo's stealthy maneuvers in the troll camp or the tumultuous stone giant brawl, sounds move with pinpoint accuracy, truly embodying the physicality and scale of these encounters. The added depth to ambient effects, such as rain and thunder or the echoing calls within Gollum's cave, further immerses the viewer in a meticulously crafted auditory experience that rivals the visuals in its ability to transport one to another world.
This Dolby Atmos mix not only brings out the best in Howard Shore's iconic score but also adds a layer of acoustical realism that enhances every scene. From the subtle nuances of wildlife in the background to the full-bodied roar of battle sequences, the soundtrack offers an exceptional clarity and depth across all elements. The low-end resonates with a palpable presence, giving weight to action sequences and lending a majestic scale to the musical score. Vocals maintain a precise priority throughout, ensuring that dialogue is never lost but rather enhanced by the surround mix. This audio presentation is a testament to the prowess of modern sound engineering, offering a reference-quality experience that pushes the boundaries of home theater audio to create a thoroughly engaging and satisfying Atmos mix.
Extras: 34
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" has stirred a mix of expectations, primarily due to the explicit exclusion of the once-included bonus features familiar to fans from previous releases. Warner Bros has chosen to provide only the film in this upgraded format, incorporating both theatrical and extended cuts across separate discs, leaving out any additional content. This decision is rooted in an anticipation of a comprehensive Middle Earth collection scheduled for summer 2021, promising new supplements not ready for the standalone 4K set. Potential buyers should adjust expectations accordingly, recognizing that this purchase offers the pure cinematic experience in superior resolution without the frills of behind-the-scenes insights or enhancements.
Extras included in this disc:
- None: This edition comes exclusively with the film; no supplemental features are included.
Movie: 71
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" on 4K UHD Blu-ray delivers a visually stunning leap back into the heart of Middle-earth, setting the stage for Bilbo Baggins' epic adventure with a blend of breathtaking CGI and captivating scenic designs. Directed by Peter Jackson, the film is filled with the familiar allure of Tolkien’s universe, brought to life with an enhanced sharpness and depth that only 4K resolution can offer. As Bilbo sets out from the safety of The Shire, joining a band of dwarves on a quest to reclaim their homeland, the film navigates through its narrative with a mix of heart and spectacle, though it occasionally succumbs to pacing issues and a sense of familiarity from its prequel connections. The journey, while abundant in thrilling action sequences and heroic feats, occasionally feels stretched beyond its natural narrative capacity, echoing the director's ambitious yet contentious decision to extend a singular book into a trilogy.
Technically, the 4K presentation is impeccable, enriching every frame with vivid details and a color palette that enhances Middle-earth's fantastical elements. The high dynamic range (HDR) boosts the visual storytelling, providing contrast and luminance that elevate both the mystique of darker scenes and the vibrancy of the sprawling landscapes. Audio-wise, the soundtrack benefits immensely from the Dolby Atmos mix, enveloping viewers in an immersive auditory experience that complements the on-screen action perfectly. Despite these technical merits, the adaptation's decision to incorporate additional Tolkien lore and expand minor plot elements into significant story arcs has drawn criticism, resulting in a narrative experience that occasionally feels bloated and detached from its source material.
Despite its narrative flaws and pacing issues, "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" shines as a visual masterpiece in its 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation. This edition not only serves as a treat for fans eager to revisit Middle-earth with enhanced visual fidelity but also stands as a testament to the enduring charm of Tolkien's world. Even amidst its attempts to weave in new storylines and characters, the film retains an underlying charm and enthusiasm for adventure that mirrors Bilbo's own transformation from a reserved hobbit to an integral part of a grand quest. As a technical achievement, it's an illustrative showcase of how advancements in home entertainment technology can breathe new life into existing cinematic experiences.
Total: 74
Warner Bros. Home Entertainment elevates "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" to unprecedented heights with its release on 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray, offering both Theatrical and Extended Editions. This 4K rendition brings forth a remastered video alongside a new Dolby Atmos sound mix, providing an immersive viewing experience that rejuvenates the charm and excitement of the epic journey through Middle Earth. The enhancement in video and audio quality serves not merely as an upgrade but almost as a rediscovery of Peter Jackson's meticulous creation, breathing new life into the beloved fantasy adventure. Critics and fans alike praise the release for its unparalleled presentation, affirming it as a must-have for enthusiasts to experience the beginning of The Hobbit trilogy like never before.
Peter Jackson's vision for "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" masterfully balances action, comedy, and adventure within the vast expanse of Middle Earth, setting an impressive precedent for the trilogy. Despite some perceived pacing concerns and debates over the decision to extend a singular book into a trio of films, this first installment has established itself as a modern classic within the fantasy genre. The 4K UHD Blu-ray not only showcases the best video-audio presentation to date but also cements its status as a crucial addition to the collection of series fans, thanks to its strikingly beautiful Dolby Vision HDR visuals and reference-quality Dolby Atmos soundtrack.
In conclusion, "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" on 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray is a spectacular release that significantly enhances the movie's viewing experience. While it may not reach the epic narrative heights of its Lord of the Rings predecessors, this release provides a most satisfying upgrade with demo-worthy visuals and sound. Despite the absence of extensive special features in this edition, the overall package comes highly recommended for devotees and newcomers alike, offering a splendid reintroduction to Peter Jackson's fantastical universe and setting a high standard for home entertainment.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 100
This isn't a small upgrade at all: every scene looks significantly better with the resolution boost and because of the HDR grading....
Audio: 0
The audio design is similar to previous releases of the film but features some breathtaking expansiveness that is the direct result of the extra Atmos height channels....
Extras: 100
Another factor to consider: Warner Bros has announced a mega Middle Earth collection will be released in the summer of 2021 (which will include brand new supplemental features)....
Movie: 90
A spectacle filled with fantastic CGI and breathtaking imagery, the first film in the Hobbit trilogy dramatically unfolds from the get-go as a group of dwarves gather at the home of Bilbo Baggins (Martin...
Total: 0
The adventure, action, and comedy were beautifully intertwined to form a cohesive and entertaining vision of Middle Earth....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
From the earlier generation of Red cameras, the image struggles in resolving complex detail at medium or long range....
Audio: 100
It’s more than the action ending the scene, but prior as Bilbo stealthily wanders, troll chatter keeping a constant sense of space....
Extras: 2
...
Movie: 60
Then, in those final moments, Unexpected Journey lays into the luster and glow possible in such fantasy, flying toward a sunset on the backs of giant eagles, a visually scintillating series of images,...
Total: 56
The Hobbit begins with An Unexpected Journey that’s too often expected and too long, if still enjoyable fantasy fare....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 90
Gollum also has more of a silver coin tone to him, and the browns in the costumes are impressively varied while reds and greens are more vibrant and richly-saturated, making for a stunning upgrade overall....
Audio: 100
Even the loudest segments enjoy excellent precision and accuracy in the higher frequencies, supplying each roaring yell and clash of metal upon metal with extraordinary intelligibility that extends into...
Extras: 0
This UHD edition of The Hobbit Trilogy is a standalone release without any of the previous bonus features ported over....
Movie: 60
With the same CG spectacle and visual eye candy as seen in The Lords of the Rings trilogy, director Peter Jackson returns to Middle-earth with the bloated idea of stretching a tale that Tolkien told in...
Total: 80
Minor, negligible quips with the filmmakers bloating a single book into three films aside, The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey makes for a decent start to a larger trilogy that eventually provides a more...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
It was announced that a 4K UHD “Middle-earth” Ultimate Collectors’ Edition featuring the theatrical and extended versions of all six films, along with new bonus content, previously released Blu-ray discs...
Audio: 96
In listening to the Dolby Atmos surround mixes for each of these films, I found it to be an entertaining listening experience that made steady use of the platform....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 80
For Bilbo, a simple fellow that looks no further than the warmth of his hearth or the confines of his Shire home for comfort, this journey will come to define him and place in his hands an object of power...
Total: 72
The experience of watching each of these presentations, in many ways, felt as though I was discovering them all over again....
Director: Peter Jackson
Actors: Martin Freeman, Ian McKellen, Richard Armitage
PlotIn the peaceful Shire, Bilbo Baggins, a content and unadventurous Hobbit, is approached by the wizard Gandalf the Grey, who invites him on an adventure. Bilbo initially refuses but reconsiders when a company of thirteen dwarves, led by the warrior Thorin Oakenshield, unexpectedly arrives at his doorstep. The dwarves seek to reclaim their homeland, the Lonely Mountain, from the dragon Smaug, and they need a "burglar" to help them infiltrate the mountain. Bilbo, moved by their cause and the promise of an exciting life beyond his front porch, reluctantly agrees to join. The group sets out on an arduous journey across Middle-earth, facing perils and wonders beyond Bilbo's wildest dreams.
As they travel, they encounter various creatures and characters; trolls that capture them, elves that distrust them, and beasts that threaten their lives. Bilbo, initially struggling to find his place within the group, begins to prove his worth. A key moment comes when Bilbo encounters Gollum, a strange and twisted creature, in the depths of the Misty Mountains. Their game of riddles results in an unforeseen discovery that will impact not only Bilbo's fate but the future of all Middle-earth. The company's quest continues toward the Lonely Mountain, unaware of the dangers that still lie ahead on their quest to face Smaug.
Writers: Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Peter Jackson
Release Date: 14 Dec 2012
Runtime: 169 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: New Zealand, United States
Language: English