Open Windows Blu-ray Review
Score: 52
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Open Windows offers solid technical merits and an intriguing start, but ultimately becomes overly convoluted and less credible.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 56
Open Windows on Blu-ray presents an intentional disparity in sharpness, clarity, and color due to its use of varied digital platforms like webcams and security footage. Despite noise in darker scenes and generally flat imagery, its AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.78:1 and steady black levels free of transfer glitches.
Audio: 66
Open Windows' Blu-ray features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix, offering a dynamic and aggressive soundstage with a particularly effective LFE channel. While dialogue can occasionally seem flat, surround channels are well-utilized for environmental ambience and action sequences, making it a nearly reference-quality track overall.
Extra: 21
Extras for 'Open Windows' include a standard 16-minute making-of feature with cast and crew interviews, a brief visual effects reel showcasing green screen work, and the original theatrical trailer, providing an insightful yet concise glimpse into the film's production.
Movie: 47
Open Windows demonstrates an innovative approach with its narrative told through computer screens and webcams, but despite solid performances from Elijah Wood and Sasha Grey, the film ultimately becomes convoluted and loses momentum, making it a one-time watch for most viewers.
Video: 56
"Open Windows" is presented on Blu-ray by Cinedigm with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. This film's unique presentation poses a challenge for typical technical analysis due to its diverse array of source formats, including laptop streams, security footage, and webcams. Such sources inherently feature lofi visuals, augmented by intentional distressing techniques, particularly noticeable in scenes involving the French hacker group and infrared photography. The result is a wide disparity in sharpness, clarity, and color reproduction, with some darker scenes exhibiting noise which could be an intentional artistic choice.
The film's visual fidelity is consistently flat and unimpressive throughout, largely due to the predominant use of webcam-style footage. Handheld camera shots in the latter half of the movie offer improved imagery but still suffer from mediocre black levels and lackluster detail. Colors generally appear drab, primarily rooted in directorial and cinematographic decisions, leading to an overall unremarkable visual experience. However, the transfer itself is free from technical issues like banding and aliasing.
Clarity and detail within "Open Windows" are tied closely to the film's inherent source material, showing notable fluctuations. While certain segments, such as the opening prologue, present a vibrant and cinematic quality, scenes switching to found footage angles exhibit deliberate graininess and softness. Black levels are deep and immersive in select scenes, particularly those not employing found footage techniques. The color palette performs well during quieter moments, with flesh tones maintaining a natural appearance throughout. Despite inherent noise and artifacts during intense sequences, these effects are intentional and add to the film's immersive atmosphere.
Audio: 66
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for "Open Windows" delivers an unexpectedly aggressive and claustrophobic soundstage that fully immerses the viewer. While the initial half of the film is predominantly front-loaded with dialogue anchored in the center channel, which occasionally sounds flat and muddy, it gradually evolves to take full advantage of the surround speakers. The low-frequency effects channel adds substantial depth, particularly during moments of heightened tension, such as chase scenes and explosions, providing a satisfying LFE rumble without distortion.
Despite some limitations in spatial differentiation for voice placement, the surround channels are effectively utilized to convey a wealth of sound effects and ambient noise. The dynamic range is well-executed, transitioning seamlessly between scenes of tranquility and intense action. Background noises and ambience from the rear channels enhance the overall auditory experience without overwhelming the primary soundstage.
In summary, while the audio experience of "Open Windows" may start modestly, it builds into an engaging and near-reference quality soundtrack. Dialogue remains clear and free from clipping or echoing, ensuring comprehension. Although there are moments where the track does not fully leverage its DTS-HD potential, the overall presentation remains impressive and immersive.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray extras for "Open Windows" offer a concise yet insightful exploration into the making of the film and its visual effects. "The Making of Open Windows" is an informative featurette, lasting just over 15 minutes, and includes interviews with director Nacho Vigalondo (subtitled in English) and stars Elijah Wood, Sasha Grey, and Neil Maskell. This segment provides a behind-the-scenes look at the creative processes and logistical complexities involved in the production. Additionally, the Visual Effects Reel offers a brief but fascinating glimpse into the extensive green screen work utilized throughout the film, juxtaposing final scenes with their original, unenhanced footage. Completing the extras is the original theatrical trailer.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of 'Open Windows': Behind-the-scenes featurette with interviews and production insights.
- Visual Effects Reel: Comparison of final scenes with original footage.
- Trailer: The original theatrical trailer for "Open Windows."
Movie: 47
"Open Windows," directed by Nacho Vigalondo, presents a compelling premise centered around the themes of internet intrusion and privacy invasion. Elijah Wood stars as Nick Chambers, a superfan and webmaster devoted to actress Jill Goddard, portrayed by Sasha Grey. The film kicks off with an eccentric faux trailer, setting an unusual tone that Vigalondo attempts to sustain through a high-concept narrative. The storyline unfolds largely through various computer and webcam screens on Nick's laptop, offering a unique cinematic structure. Despite intriguing initial gimmicks and a nod to Hitchcock’s voyeuristic elements, the convoluted plot points begin to unravel as unrealistic twists pile on, affecting the film's overall coherence.
As the plot progresses, Nick's sweepstakes win turns into a cyber-nightmare orchestrated by the mysterious Chord (Neil Maskell), who manipulates Nick into illegal activities under the guise of accessing Jill's private life. Vigalondo's ambitious but scattered narrative introduces an array of technologically driven scenarios that fluctuate between engaging and far-fetched. When the story shifts from laptop screens to handheld cameras and mobile devices, it loses some creative momentum. The movie attempts to deepen its impact with subtexts on privacy, yet stumbles with the implausible turns and ultimately excessive complication.
Elijah Wood's performance as the beleaguered Nick provides a solid anchor for the movie, his expressions capturing a mix of intrigue and horror. Sasha Grey, with noticeably less screen time, manages to carry her role convincingly despite her minimal acting prowess. While "Open Windows" initially grips with its novel approach, it struggles to maintain its intrigue throughout. The film’s ambitious blend of a tech-thriller with voyeuristic thrills may not hit every mark, but it offers enough novelty in its first half to keep viewers engaged—at least until its overly complex second act takes over.
Total: 52
"Open Windows" offers an intriguing premise and a unique presentation in the domain of cyber thrillers. While the film begins with a promising setup, it gradually loses coherence as its plot becomes increasingly convoluted and less credible. Elijah Wood's performance lacks the dynamism needed to anchor the film, often appearing bewildered rather than engaging. On the other hand, Sasha Grey delivers a notable performance, particularly in scenes where she is meant to showcase her physicality rather than dramatic range.
The film ambitiously combines elements of cybercrime, murder mystery, and conspiracy theories, creating a blend that is entertaining albeit highly improbable. While "Open Windows" does not break new ground, it manages to entertain, particularly in its first half. However, its narrative overstays its welcome, dragging on unnecessarily in its latter portion. This diminishes the overall impact of what could have been a taut and thrilling experience.
Technically, "Open Windows" excels with high-quality visual and audio presentation suitable for those invested in Blu-ray purchases. The film's direction by Nacho Vigalondo shows potential, hinting at a deeper well of creativity, as observed in his previous work "Timecrimes." For viewers new to Vigalondo, this film serves as an entry point to explore his more refined pieces.
In conclusion, "Open Windows" is a mixed bag that starts strong but falters due to an overly complex and unconvincing plot. While it may not be a must-watch thriller, it holds some value for fans of the genre and those interested in Nacho Vigalondo's evolving directorial career. Despite its flaws, the film's technical merits make it a worthwhile addition to a Blu-ray collection for enthusiasts seeking quality audiovisual experiences.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
This is a bit of a difficult film to give a typical technical review to, since everything in the film (other than the misleading opening of the faux trailer) is delivered through a variety of less than...
Audio: 90
There's not much spatial differentiation in voice placement, but the surrounds are nicely used for a glut of sound effects and ambient environmental noise and a kind of pulsing, trance like score....
Extras: 30
The Making of Open Windows (1080p; 15:51) is a pretty standard EPK with interviews and the like, though there is some fun behind the scenes footage included....
Movie: 50
And the presentation itself of course is both appropriate and appropriately "meta," though it struggles to maintain narrative coherence in the end run, when a series of revelations and the weird, hallucinatory...
Total: 50
Open Windows has a decent premise and an intriguing presentation, but it simply cannot sustain its conceit, especially once the plot becomes less and less credible as it goes along....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The second half of the movie makes use more of hand-held cameras than stationary ones, and these images come off a bit better, but black levels still aren't all that great, there's not an impressive amount...
Audio: 60
During the second half of the movie, there are more scenes involving car chases, car crashes, and a few explosions – and here the track sounds much better, including a handful of nice directional moments....
Extras: 0
– A short vignette of footage (with no dialogue) that shows the completed scene in the movie followed by the original scene, minus the special effects....
Movie: 40
Eventually, the plot leads Nick outside of his hotel room and into a car, and it's at this point that 'Open Windows' begins to fall apart – making the plot both more complex and more convoluted at the...
Total: 40
'Open Windows' is a rather fun idea for a thriller that almost manages to work – that is, until the movie becomes hopelessly (and needlessly) convoluted and outstays its welcome by a good 30 minutes or...
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 80
The opening prologue looks outstanding and cinematic, because it was shot that way and the scenes featuring Elijah and some of the cast members look grainy and soft, because those scenes call for it....
Audio: 90
The rear surround sound channels are exquisite in their reproduction of background noise, ambience, voices, etc....
Extras: 20
This making of featurette runs just over 15-minutes and is crammed with interviews and behind the scenes footage....
Movie: 60
Total: 60
Open Windows takes a formula that’s actually been done several times before and combines it into a hodgepodge of cyber thriller, murder mystery, conspiracy theory, etc., and it works....
Director: Nacho Vigalondo
Actors: Sasha Grey, Elijah Wood, Neil Maskell
PlotNick Chambers, a devoted fan of actress Jill Goddard, wins an online contest to have dinner with her. However, when Jill cancels the contest, Nick receives a call from a mysterious man named Chord, who offers him the chance to spy on Jill through his computer. Chord provides Nick with access to various live cameras and digital feeds, demonstrating intricate surveillance capabilities. As Nick becomes increasingly entangled in Chord's manipulations, he realizes that Jill's safety may be at stake and that he is being coerced into a dangerous game.
Nick faces mounting dangers as he delves deeper into the twisted web orchestrated by Chord. He must navigate through a series of escalating threats and puzzles, all while struggling to retain control of his own computer. The plot thickens with revelations about the true nature of Chord's intentions and the sinister scope of his plans. As tensions rise, Nick must find a way to outwit Chord and rescue Jill before it's too late. The story builds towards a gripping climax with high stakes and a race against time.
Writers: Nacho Vigalondo
Release Date: 02 Oct 2014
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Spain, United States, France
Language: English, Spanish, French