Seeking Justice Blu-ray Review
Score: 56
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Seeking Justice' boasts reference-quality A/V with outstanding detail and dynamic sound, but the film itself is a predictable and unoriginal time-waster.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 72
Seeking Justice' on Blu-ray delivers outstanding 1080p visual fidelity and a dynamic, enveloping audio mix. The transfer excels in clarity and definition, with remarkable textures and colors, impressive black levels, and well-defined dark scenes. Minor issues such as occasional shimmering and light banding do not detract from the overall superb quality.
Audio: 65
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 sound mix of 'Seeking Justice' is generally dynamic and enveloping, offering articulate dialogue and deep, smooth bass, although inconsistencies such as underwhelming ambient effects and occasional high-pitched feedback during some scenes detract from its overall impact.
Extra: 17
The Blu-ray of 'Seeking Justice' offers a succinct glimpse behind the scenes with a 7-minute featurette in 480p, and an HD trailer, alongside a DVD copy, providing basic thematic insights and cast interviews but reveals major plot points.
Movie: 43
Director Roger Donaldson's 'Seeking Justice' delivers a technically sound but painfully unoriginal thriller. Despite high-quality video and audio presentations, the film lacks originality, with a cookie-cutter plot and clichéd characters that fail to engage. High-energy sequences offer brief excitement in an otherwise forgettable experience.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray presentation of "Seeking Justice" is a meticulous showcase of high-definition video quality. With a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, the image consistently produces a crisp and almost impeccably defined picture. The finer details in both foreground and background images are apparent, allowing textures like skin, clothing, and even worn objects to emerge vividly. Black levels are rich and deep, with no signs of crushing, ensuring that darker scenes are exceptionally well-defined. Colors are well-balanced, maintaining true-to-life palettes even in varied lighting conditions. While minor issues such as very slight shimmering, light banding, and rare instances of moiré in corduroy jackets are present, these are negligible in comparison to the overall visual fidelity.
Additionally, the film showcases an impressive depth of field; even in scenes with challenging focus, the image layers remain sharp and intact. This meticulous attention to detail covers everything from stray hairs to tiny cracks on concrete surfaces, affirming the disc’s capacity to render textures faithfully. Skin tones remain mostly even, occasionally veering towards warmer hues but never detracting from the visual experience. Overall, "Seeking Justice" on Blu-ray demonstrates audiophile and videophile reference quality in its video performance, creating an immersive visual experience that leaves little to be desired.
Audio: 65
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray edition of "Seeking Justice" features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack that showcases a dynamic and immersive sound mix. Dialogue is seamlessly balanced and crisply articulated, ensuring clear communication even amidst complex background effects. The soundtrack crafts a believable and enveloping soundstage, employing surrounds with finesse to create an authentic auditory environment. Low-frequency effects are delivered with depth and smoothness, adding substantial weight to the intricate mid and high-frequency details.
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track stands out for its precise portrayal of various sound elements, from the breaking of glass to the heavier gunshots. The wide soundstage accommodates pitch-perfect music and ambient sounds that range from bustling New Orleans street festivities to the subdued murmur of a busy restaurant, effectively drawing the listener into the film's atmosphere. The track also excels in more intense scenes, such as the cacophony of a train rumbling or the confined echoes of gunfire in a deserted mall.
However, some listeners might find certain aspects lacking. The track occasionally falls short in rear ambience and bass presence in typically intense scenes, impacting the overall cinematic experience. Additionally, there are moments of high-pitched feedback within dialogue-heavy hospital settings which detract from the sound fidelity. Despite these minor inconsistencies, the dialogue remains clear and well-prioritized throughout, supported by an impressive musical score that is both forceful and detailed. Overall, this is a first-class soundtrack that bolsters the viewing experience of "Seeking Justice."
Extra: 17
The Blu-ray release of "Seeking Justice" offers two concise yet informative extras, alongside a DVD copy of the film. The Behind the Scenes feature provides a seven-minute exploration of the film's production, complete with cast and crew interviews, film clips, and behind-the-scenes footage. This extra highlights Nicolas Cage's unique approach to his character and delves into basic filmmaking techniques and thematic elements. Additionally, the theatrical trailer presents a high-definition (HD) preview of the film but includes several significant plot revelations.
Extras included in this disc:
- Seeking Justice: Behind the Scenes: Insightful coverage of the film's making, including interviews and production details.
- Theatrical Trailer: High-definition trailer offering a glimpse of the plot.
- DVD Copy: A standard DVD version of the film.
Movie: 43
In Roger Donaldson's latest outing, "Seeking Justice," Nicolas Cage takes on the role of Wil Gerard, a New Orleans high school English teacher whose life is upended when his wife Laura (January Jones) is brutally attacked. Shortly after the incident, Wil is approached by Simon (Guy Pearce), a mysterious figure who proposes an immediate but ethically questionable form of justice: in exchange for the swift elimination of Laura's rapist, Wil must agree to a favor at some undisclosed future date. This impulsive decision plunges Wil into a complex web of clandestine operations and moral dilemmas as he is later coerced into committing murder or facing deadly repercussions.
Donaldson's direction brings a high level of technical competence, evident in the film’s polished look and brisk pace. However, the narrative lacks originality and depth, relying heavily on familiar thriller tropes. The script adheres to a predictable formula, populated with one-dimensional characters whose backstories are as shallow as their development. Despite the fast-moving plot and some well-choreographed action sequences, the film suffers from a severe case of the "Unoriginals," presenting twists and turns that savvy audiences will see coming from a mile away. While there are moments of tension, such as a suspenseful candy bar purchase in a vending machine scene, these instances are overshadowed by an overarching sense of déjà vu.
Cage delivers a monotonous performance, oscillating between emotional numbness and mechanical intensity, never quite capturing the depth of his character's turmoil. January Jones and Jennifer Carpenter are underutilized, their performances ultimately stifled by the script's limitations. The film does manage to maintain viewer engagement on a superficial level, catering to those seeking a basic thriller experience without much substance. However, "Seeking Justice" falls short of being a memorable entry in Donaldson’s diverse directorial portfolio, appealing mainly to completists or viewers undeterred by its clichéd execution.
Total: 56
"Seeking Justice" on Blu-ray is a notable release that offers spectacular A/V quality, both in visual fidelity and audio performance. The picture excels in videophile reference quality, presenting pristine foreground and background detail. Black levels are deep and nuanced, while colors and flesh tones appear natural and lifelike. Technically, the video presentation leaves little to be desired, ensuring viewers enjoy every frame to its fullest extent. The audio mix complements the visual experience with dynamic and enveloping sound. Dialogue is clear and correctly positioned, while the surrounds are utilized to create a believable soundstage. Low-frequency effects hit deeply with a smooth, rounded sound, enriching the mids and enhancing the crisp top-end frequencies.
Despite the top-tier technical execution, the film itself falls short in content. Directed by Roger Donaldson, "Seeking Justice" suffers from a predictable plotline and lack of originality. While the pacing remains steady and includes several well-filmed chase scenes, the narrative offers no surprises. This predictability makes it difficult to capture and retain the full attention of discerning viewers. The film may only appeal to novice filmgoers or those looking for easy-to-digest background entertainment rather than an engaging cinematic experience.
In conclusion, "Seeking Justice" is a visual treat with reference-quality audio and video presentations, making it valuable for A/V enthusiasts. However, its uninspired storyline limits its appeal to a broader audience. The minimal extras on the Blu-ray further point toward a rental recommendation rather than purchase unless you are a Nicolas Cage completist or willing to overlook the lack of originality for high-quality technical delivery.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Very minor shimmering and light banding are evident once or twice, but this is otherwise nothing short of a marvelous Blu-ray picture....
Audio: 90
Everything is in finely-tuned working order, from the piercing sound of shattered glass to the heaviest gunshots....
Extras: 20
Seeking Justice: Behind the Scenes (480p, 7:08): A brief look at the making of the film, with cast and crew interviews, clips from the film, and behind-the-scenes footage....
Movie: 50
It's the sort of picture sourced from a script that astute audiences could pen with some rapidity and proficiency, given a deep knowledge of Thriller clich� and enough time to iron out whatever details...
Total: 60
While Director Roger Donaldson's picture certainly isn't going to find much favor with well-versed audiences, it'll serve duty as a passable time waster for the disinterested viewer who only wants background...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Detail levels in random settings, like the cracks and wear and tear on concrete really shine, while picture depth is regularly pretty darned deep, with even hard focused shots maintaining great back layers....
Audio: 60
The problem is, there's some high pitched feedback beneath some of the dialogue in the hospital, and it doesn't sound like the hum of a fluorescent light....
Extras: 20
Behind the Scenes (HD, 7 min) - We learn how Nic Cage summoned the caveman inside him to play this role of violent revenge and masterful investigation....
Movie: 40
The funny thing is, this agency and Guy Pearce's character, promise Cage that revenge will not cost him any money, only a favor in the future....
Total: 40
It's surprisingly entertaining for being as brain dead as it is...possibly because of how fun it is to make fun of!...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 94
Dialouge is perfectly placed and articulate, and surrounds are used with care, creating a believable sound-stage....
Audio: 92
Dialouge is perfectly placed and articulate, and surrounds are used with care, creating a believable sound-stage....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 50
Roger Donaldson is an interesting director, with a career spanning over 30 years, has a consistently made good films, but never made it to the ranks of being a great director....
Total: 64
Dialouge is perfectly placed and articulate, and surrounds are used with care, creating a believable sound-stage....
Director: Roger Donaldson
Actors: Nicolas Cage, January Jones, Guy Pearce
PlotWill Gerard, a high school English teacher in New Orleans, is thrust into a nightmare when his wife, Laura, becomes the victim of a brutal assault. While vigilantly waiting at the hospital, Will is approached by a clandestine man named Simon, who offers an unconventional form of justice. Simon represents a vigilante group that proposes to eliminate Laura's attacker in exchange for a future favor. Desperate for quick retribution and frustrated by the slow and uncertain nature of the legal system, Will reluctantly agrees.
Soon after, Laura's attacker is found dead, and Simon returns to collect on Will’s end of the bargain. The favor isn't what Will expected—it's morally questionable and puts him in danger. Realizing he's trapped in a dangerous game with a network of ruthless operatives, Will's life unravels as he struggles to protect his wife and expose the corrupt organization. Amid escalating tension and moral dilemmas, Will must navigate a treacherous path to reclaim his sense of justice and integrity.
Writers: Todd Hickey, Robert Tannen
Release Date: 02 Sep 2011
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English