The Watchers 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Watchers offers a visually moody experience and solid Dolby Vision transfer, but its execution falls short, making it suitable mainly for dedicated fans.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 76
The Watchers' 4K UHD Blu-Ray transfer presents a richly detailed, though remarkably dark visual experience, benefiting from Dolby Vision HDR10's precise black levels and controlled color, yet facing challenges with dim scenes and a gloomy, almost monochromatic styling that occasionally softens the image.
Audio: 83
The 4K UHD Blu Ray of 'The Watchers' boasts an impressive and moody Dolby Atmos track with excellent use of surrounds, LFE, and discrete effects, though occasional front-channel dialogue can seem buried. The sound design thrives in quiet moments, effectively using height channels to build tension.
Extra: 43
The Watchers 4K UHD Blu-ray offers an interesting behind-the-scenes look through several featurettes like 'The Making of The Watchers' and 'Creating The Watchers.' Although the extras lack depth, the audio mix is exceptionally impressive and the film blends moody atmospheres with dark fantasy, despite predictable narrative and derivative elements from M. Night Shyamalan's style.
Movie: 43
The Watchers delivers an intriguing premise hampered by overly familiar tropes and clunky exposition. Despite its beautifully sleek cinematography and high-concept potential, the narrative falls predictably short with repetitive mythology and lackluster twists. The 4K UHD Blu-ray release features commendable technical specs but can't compensate for the film’s shortcomings.
Video: 76
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "The Watchers" presents a challenging video experience primarily due to the film’s inherent visual style, which is dominated by dark and gloomy settings. Presented in 2160p Dolby Vision HDR (with HDR10 compatibility), the film frequently places viewers in dimly lit forests with dark greens and blues, accented by soft ambers and browns. The overall picture maintains a misty, foggy aesthetic, which can introduce a hint of banding and slightly soft imagery. Despite these inherent challenges, the transfer does a commendable job bringing out fine details and compositions, particularly in well-lit outdoor scenarios, which exhibit impressive clarity and near three-dimensional depth.
One of the technical highlights of this UHD disc is its handling of black levels and shadow detail. The Dolby Vision grade works effectively to bring out crucial details in the darkest scenes, although these moments can sometimes feel unnaturally dimmed even by HDR standards. This dimming effect could require users to ensure their viewing environment is suitably dark to fully appreciate the nuances. Outdoor daytime scenes contrast starkly with the film's darker sequences, showcasing remarkable detail in character faces and costumes. Even with the murky lighting and muted color palette employed throughout "The Watchers," the 4K transfer excels in rendering primary colors when they are allowed to shine, helping to maintain an overall visual balance.
In summary, while not the most visually striking film due to its artistic choices, "The Watchers" benefits greatly from the comprehensive 4K Ultra HD treatment. Those equipped with larger screens will particularly notice the disc's relatively tight encoding, which enhances the film's depth and detail. Though some may find the overall brightness levels lacking during key scenes, both HDR10 and Dolby Vision provide enough enhancements to make this presentation a worthy showcase for the film’s atmospheric cinematography.
Audio: 83
The audio presentation of "The Watchers" on 4K UHD Blu Ray is an effective and immersive experience, notably featuring a moody Dolby Atmos track. It captures the film's essence by employing a dynamic range, providing a gripping auditory landscape. While primarily anchoring the main activity in the front/center channels, the mix excels through its strategic use of surrounds and height channels, particularly in scenes set in expansive environments, such as the characters foraging in the woods. The Atmos track adeptly uses natural sounds like bird calls and creaking trees, enhancing the tension.
The sound design, while occasionally reliant on gimmicky jump-scare moments, meticulously represents its source material with precise fidelity. Though front-channel dialogue can occasionally seem buried within the mix, the majority of audio elements are rendered cleanly with an exemplary balance of surrounds, LFE, and discrete effects. The Atmos mix shines as it allows spatial elements to unfold naturally, engaging viewers without overwhelming them. Even during intense scenes like Mina exploring one of the Watcher's holes, the soundscape tightens definitively, making full use of surround spaces and height channels to create an enveloping experience.
Overall, despite a few instances where dialogue may sound inorganic and sections where the mix appears flat or overly loud, this Atmos track achieves remarkable moments that can be genuinely fun. Optional subtitles, including English (SDH), are provided for both the main feature and the supplementary extras, ensuring an inclusive viewing experience. This active and largely well-balanced presentation encourages both high-volume playback and normal listening levels, making it a versatile addition to any collection.
Extra: 43
The extras on the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "The Watchers" offer insightful glimpses into the film's production, although they lean more towards promotional content. Through a series of concise featurettes, viewers are provided with a behind-the-scenes look at the making of the movie, the creation of its mysterious creatures, and the construction of the key set piece, "the coop." The inclusion of discussions on the Irish fairy folklore that inspired the story adds depth. Notably, the deleted scene humorously extends a satirical fake reality show clip, adding entertainment value. While not overly comprehensive, these features provide a modest enhancement to the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Welcome to the Show: The Making of The Watchers: Insights from director Ishana Shyamalan and key cast and crew.
- Creating The Watchers: Focus on designing the film's creatures, featuring VFX supervisor Gabriel Regentin.
- Constructing the Coop: A detailed look into set design with producer M. Night Shyamalan and production designer Ferdia Murphy.
- Ainriochtán and the Irish Fairy Folklore: Exploration of the legends and myths used in the film.
- Deleted Scene – Lair of Love: Satirical set of mock reality show clips.
Movie: 43
Ishana Night Shyamalan’s debut film, "The Watchers," reflects a significant amount of influence from her father, M. Night Shyamalan’s signature narrative style, and thematic elements. The narrative follows Mina, portrayed by Dakota Fanning, who relocates to Northern Ireland in an attempt to outrun past traumas. She inadvertently becomes entrenched in a mysterious forest alongside a group of trapped souls, contending with looming beings known as 'the Watchers.' While the initial setup holds promise, the plot’s direction becomes markedly predictable, drawing heavily from familiar tropes seen in M. Night Shyamalan’s catalog, such as overstated mythological components and lackluster twist endings.
The film’s pacing also significantly hampers its engagement factor. Introduced in a fashion akin to a traditional horror setup, the first act soon devolves into an exposition-heavy narrative dump that regularly stalls momentum. Despite a potentially compelling premise—humans observed by enigmatic creatures akin to captive pets—the story’s execution falters with convoluted plot devices and sluggish reveals. Notably, lengthy explanatory sections stifle suspense-building and result in the plot becoming a foreseeable sequence more than a thrilling mystery.
Visually, "The Watchers" is commendable and showcases Ishana’s prowess in cinematography with lush scenes and moody atmospherics reflecting her penchant for dark fantasy settings. These visual strengths, however, are not enough to overshadow the narrative weaknesses. Performances from the cast are solid, particularly Fanning’s portrayal of the anguished Mina. Still, the film struggles to maintain tension amidst its scattered storytelling and ill-timed revelations, culminating in an anticlimactic conclusion that lacks the profound impact intended. While there are glimmers of potential and creativity, "The Watchers" ultimately reveals Ishana’s need for cutting narrative refinement to complement her technical capabilities.
Total: 69
Ishana Night Shyamalan's directorial debut, "The Watchers," marries an engaging premise with a moody, atmospheric visual style. The film, starring Dakota Fanning, Georgina Campbell, and Olwen Fouere, unfolds in a 1.85:1 HEVC aspect ratio and comes equipped with a Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD 7.1 Core) audio track. While the movie attempts to build an intricate narrative through its dark fantasy elements, it unfortunately stumbles into the pitfalls of excessive self-narration, frequent exposition dumps, and uninspired jump scares. This results in a high-concept plot that is ultimately hindered by sporadic pacing and somewhat predictable story arcs.
On the technical front, Warner Bros. delivers "The Watchers" in both Blu-ray and 4K UHD formats. The 4K UHD edition notably features a pleasing Dolby Vision transfer, enhancing the film's visually rich scenes, and a respectable Dolby Atmos mix that brings the audio to life with immersive soundscapes. The subtitle options include English SDH, French, and Spanish, and the film runs for a concise 102 minutes. While the video and audio specifications are solid, bonus features are sparse and lack the depth that might entice collectors or offer deeper insights into the film's production.
In conclusion, while "The Watchers" shows glimpses of Ishana Night Shyamalan's potential, it does not fully escape the shadow of her father's weaker cinematic endeavors. Despite competent acting and sections of well-crafted suspense, the film's overall execution falls short, lacking significant emotional impact. It's a decent watch for rental, particularly for fans of dark fantasy genres, but it may not be compelling enough for a blind purchase. The 4K UHD presentation offers a robust viewing experience, although it is mainly recommended for enthusiasts familiar with Ishana's work or those with a keen interest in dark fantasy narratives.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 80
There’s a misty, foggy look to the whole thing, giving us some really nice dark forest shots, but ones that have a HINT of banding, and looks a bit soft as well....
Audio: 90
Welcome to the Show: The Making of The Watchers • Creating The Watchers • Constructing the Coop • Ainriochtán and the Irish Fairy Folklore • Deleted Scene – Lair of Love...
Extras: 60
Ishana could be seen almost as a direct clone of her father’s narrative style, using most of his tropes and tricks throughout, even going so far as to use his same clunky use of mythology and fantasy lore...
Movie: 60
Ishana could be seen almost as a direct clone of her father’s narrative style, using most of his tropes and tricks throughout, even going so far as to use his same clunky use of mythology and fantasy lore...
Total: 70
The film is competently acted, but Ishana’s feature film debut feels a bit TOO much like her dad’s weaker endeavors, and not enough of her identity....
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 80
Luckily this 2160p/HDR10 (Dolby Vision compatible) transfer makes the most of the situation with a largely well-balanced approach that features excellent fine detail, solid depth, carefully controlled...
Audio: 90
Outside of a few moments where front-channel dialogue seemed lightly buried in the mix, the wide majority of its sonic elements are cleanly rendered with excellent use of surrounds, LFE, and specific discrete...
Extras: 40
Creating The Watchers (5:02) - A brief but focused featurette about realizing the mysterious creatures seen in the film with several returning participants as well as new ones like VFX supervisor Gabriel...
Movie: 40
Frustrating signs of promise dot The Watchers but, for the most part, it's a clumsily-realized story that's equal parts boring, obvious, and confusing....
Total: 40
Ishana Night Shyamalan's The Watchers has all the intrigue and inevitable disappointment of her father's movies, tempting viewers with an engaging premise but falling victim to self-narration, exposition...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This one will likely stress the nits for the average consumer setup for those deep dark creepy scenes....
Audio: 80
Other sections where the film feels in a hurry to just get through a scene dialog can sound inorganic, the score can just be loud, and the mix can sound flat....
Extras: 40
The funniest is the extended footage of the fake reality show, so that’s pretty entertaining....
Movie: 40
Another draft or two, a cleaner edit, and a trust that the audience isn’t stupid and needs to be handheld through reveals would have gone far to make a better film....
Total: 60
Not intimately knowing the novel, I don’t know if the film was trying to be too slavish to the source, but the frequent and extremely dull patches of exposition upend the suspenseful nature of the film...
Director: Ishana Shyamalan
Actors: Dakota Fanning, Georgina Campbell, Olwen Fouéré
PlotIn a remote region of Ireland, an esteemed artist named Mina finds herself stranded after her car breaks down. Seeking help, she stumbles upon a secluded, seemingly abandoned cottage. Inside, she encounters a young woman named Alva and her elderly grandmother, Niamh, who offer her shelter for the night. As the evening unfolds, Mina senses an eerie atmosphere and notices peculiar symbols adorning the cottage walls. Despite her unease, Mina is intrigued by Alva’s cryptic talk of ancient local folklore and the looming forest surrounding them. Little does she know, an ominous and otherworldly presence lurks in the darkness, watching their every move.
As night falls, strange occurrences intensify around the cottage, and Mina grows increasingly suspicious of her hosts. Tensions rise as she uncovers dark secrets about the land and its inhabitants. The forest's secret watchers seem to be closing in, their intentions a frightening mystery. Faced with growing peril, Mina must decide whether to trust Alva and Niamh or rely on her instincts to find safety. As dawn approaches, the lines between friend and foe blur, forcing Mina into a harrowing conflict that will test her courage and will to survive.
Writers: Ishana Shyamalan, A.M. Shine
Release Date: 07 Jun 2024
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Ireland, United States
Language: English