Stir of Echoes 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Amazon Exclusive SteelBook
Score: 87
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Stir of Echoes shines in its 4K UHD release with solid technical merits, distinct unsettling ambience, and appealing SteelBook packaging for collectors.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 81
"Stir of Echoes" offers a compelling 4K UHD Blu-ray release from Lionsgate with an HEVC/H.265 2160p transfer in a corrected 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Featuring enriched detail and color grading through HDR/Dolby Vision, it sees improved texture and depth, despite some grain and shadow limitations. A must-see upgrade for fans.
Audio: 98
Stir of Echoes delivers an impressively immersive Dolby Atmos audio experience, with atmospheric sound effects and clear dialogue. The mix utilizes height channels, swirling voices, and impactful low-frequency extension to enhance the film's thematic tone, maintaining a perfect balance of engaging volume and clarity.
Extra: 83
Stir of Echoes 4K UHD Blu-ray offers a captivating mix of new and vintage extras, including insightful commentary from director David Koepp, a new retrospective featurette, engaging interviews, and comprehensive behind-the-scenes materials, all packaged in an exclusive SteelBook with a striking lenticular slipcover.
Movie: 76
The 4K UHD release of 'Stir of Echoes' offers a significant technical upgrade with Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos, packaged in a sleek SteelBook. While the outdated 1080p disc leaves much to be desired, the film's engaging, suspenseful narrative and Kevin Bacon's solid performance redeems it, making it a valuable addition despite its overshadowed cinematic history.
Video: 81
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Stir of Echoes" offers a visually compelling upgrade that presents the film in its best possible light. Lionsgate Home Entertainment has delivered a 2160p transfer, encoded with HEVC/H.265 technology, and enhanced by Dolby Vision HDR. This release corrects the original 1080p version's aspect ratio from 1.78:1 to a more accurate 1.85:1. The transition to 4K brings enhanced detail levels, notably improved over the outdated 1080 presentation, although a conscious interpretation of heavy film grain is necessary, as it is omnipresent due to original composited effects. Ever the purist's delight, this grain infuses the film's texture with an analog warmth that some critics might find contentious.
The film retains its intended dark cinematography, with Dolby Vision HDR adding slightly heightened color nuances. However, it doesn't fundamentally transform shadow detail as some may expect; deep black levels intermittently obscure intricate details and character visibility in shadowy scenes. Despite occasional instability from film processing, particularly in opening sequences and high-contrast edges, the presentation largely respects the filmmakers' intentions, with shadows potentially offering improved clarity for close-ups. Colors exhibit a polarizing palette, with warm bronzed flesh tones contrasting against cool, haunting blues, each rich and dense in execution, reinforcing the film’s psychological underpinnings.
Ultimately, while "Stir of Echoes" on 4K UHD exhibits some gritty remnants of its original production quality—betrayed by its somewhat messy print and grain—the prowess of HDR’s palette highlights in dream sequences captivates. The transfer maintains clarity and focuses effectively on depth in tracking shots, presenting a polished yet inherently authentic portrayal. This video presentation serves both fans and new viewers by enriching visual storytelling through subtle but significant advances in modern visual lore while preserving the film’s eerie aesthetic.
Audio: 98
The Dolby Atmos audio presentation of "Stir of Echoes" is an exemplary model of immersive sound mixing, establishing its multichannel presence from the outset with an engaging and atmospheric experience. The old-style Lionsgate logo, brought to life with creaky sound effects, sets the tone for a track rich with atmospheric detail and discrete sound elements that beautifully complement the film's eerie narrative. This track excels particularly in scenes involving Tom's visions, where sound effects richly envelop the listener and utilize the overhead speakers to enhance the ghostly atmosphere. Everyday ambient sounds are distinct and present throughout, from street-level work scenarios to bustling communal gatherings, ensuring enveloping audio participation.
The use of height channels in the Dolby Atmos configuration impressively accentuates the psychological elements of the film. Voices and spectral sounds swirl intricately, providing not just frontal engagement but surround involvement as well. The carefully calibrated low-frequency extension delivers powerfully resonant bass, seamlessly binding the auditory wall of sound without overshadowing dialogues. Dialogue clarity is paramount across the board, ensuring crisp and comprehensible speech amid the cacophony of thematic sounds and effects.
The audio masterfully balances aggressive volume with refined dynamics, making effective use of both jump scares and subtle musical cues to sustain tension and suspense. Tangible ambient sounds emerge vividly in moments of heightened intensity, such as sporting events or urban settings, enhancing listener involvement. The Dolby Atmos mix stands out as a priority in this release, offering a gripping sonic experience that elevates the cinematic escapism of "Stir of Echoes."
Extras: 83
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "Stir of Echoes" offers an impressive array of extras, balancing both new and archival content. Dominating the lineup is a newly produced 17-minute retrospective, "Visions of the Past," which, along with Fred Murphy's "Establishing Shot," provides fresh insight into the film's production. Fans will appreciate director David Koepp's engaging audio commentary, alongside a blend of vintage features from the 2006 release. Although these legacy features may reflect some technical restraints, such as upscaled video quality, they remain crucial for comprehensive exploration. Notably, the packaging, featuring striking SteelBook art and a lenticular slipcover, adds a visually appealing touch for collectors.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director David Koepp: Director's insights.
- Visions of the Past: Re-visiting Stir of Echoes: Newly produced retrospective.
- Establishing Shot with Fred Murphy: Interview with cinematographer.
- Flipping the Switch: Directing Stir of Echoes: Director's journey.
- Maggie's Memories: Inside Stir of Echoes: In-depth look.
- Opening the Door: Designing Stir of Echoes: Art design exploration.
- Making of Stir of Echoes: Behind the scenes insight.
- Sight of Spirits: Channeling the Paranormal: Paranormal themes discussion.
- Behind the Echoes: Production subtleties revealed.
- The Mind's Eye: Beneath the Trance: Psychological elements analysis.
- Special Effects: Visual effects overview.
- Production Design: Set and art design deep dive.
- Interviews with Cast and Crew: Cast and crew perspectives.
- Behind the Scenes: General behind the scenes footage.
- Scene Comparisons: Original vs. final scenes comparison.
- Screen Tests: Casting process insights.
- Deleted Scenes: Unused scene additions.
- Promotional Materials: Marketing elements collection.
- Breathe Original Music Video: Music video feature.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original movie trailer.
Movie: 76
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Stir of Echoes" brings a forgotten gem of late 90s supernatural thrillers back into the limelight, enhanced by a modern audiovisual upgrade. This Kevin Bacon-led narrative offers an intriguing blend of psychological depth and suspense, framed within a narrative that expertly ties personal unrest to supernatural phenomena. Tom Witzky, a blue-collar worker, is plunged into a world of ghostly visions post-hypnosis, seeing things that are pieces of a haunting puzzle. These visions compel him to investigate a long-buried crime, providing a well-executed premise for character-driven storytelling.
Lionsgate's release enriches "Stir of Echoes" with Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos, offering notable visual and audio improvements from its outdated 2006 MPEG-2 predecessor. The movie’s transfer to 4K enhances the film's atmospheric cinematography, making the shadowy visuals more immersive and vivid. The audio upgrade plays a crucial role in amplifying the suspense, allowing viewers to fully appreciate the unsettling whispers and creaking sounds that punctuate Tom’s eerie encounters. This version is packaged in a sleek SteelBook design, featuring additional supplements, including newly produced content that adds value to the release.
Director David Koepp's signature style—commercial and plot-focused—shines through in this efficiently paced 100-minute thriller. Known for his work on mainstream hits like "Jurassic Park" and "Spider-Man," Koepp successfully crafts a tightly woven narrative that manipulates tension and emotion. Bacon’s performance grounds the supernatural elements in relatable human challenges, offering a critique of masculinity while maintaining suspense. "Stir of Echoes" weaves familiarity with fantasy, resulting in an engaging film that prompts viewers to ponder the invisible forces at play within their own lives. This technical and narrative refinement seals its stature in contemporary home viewing collections.
Total: 87
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Stir of Echoes" presents a fresh opportunity to reassess this intriguing film, often overshadowed by its contemporaries. Although it may not achieve the iconic status of "Rosemary's Baby," a film director David Koepp admires, "Stir of Echoes" still manages to carve its own niche with an unsettling ambiance that captivates the audience. This release not only enhances the visual and audio experience with impressive technical precision but also offers exemplary supplements that enrich the viewing experience. The SteelBook packaging is an added attraction for collectors, bolstering the overall appeal of the release.
Set against a post-"Sixth Sense" cinematic landscape, "Stir of Echoes" retains a familiar yet unique focus on domestic life, weaving a narrative that is both engrossing and thrilling. It masterfully combines well-crafted direction with stellar performances, drawing audiences into its eerie yet relatable world. The new 4K edition significantly upgrades the film's presentation, ensuring it meets contemporary audiovisual standards while maintaining the original's atmospheric essence.
In conclusion, "Stir of Echoes" in 4K UHD is an essential acquisition for thriller enthusiasts, offering both long-time fans and new viewers a compelling reason to explore or revisit this captivating tale. Its nuanced storytelling and technical finesse make it a noteworthy addition to any collection. Whether you are a collector or simply appreciate a well-crafted thriller, this release holds significant value and merits inclusion in your library.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Note: The first four screenshots are sourced from Lionsgate's now ancient 1080 release, since I frankly feel as old and outdated as it undeniably is, it may still provide a (relatively?) more accurate...
Audio: 100
Clear and pretty spooky engagement of both the "traditional" surround channels as well as the Atmos speakers then is evident in the first "stir of echoes", as ominous spectral sound effects start whirling...
Extras: 100
Establishing Shot with Fred Murphy (UHD; 8:22) profiles the film's director of photography....
Movie: 70
Lionsgate has long been a purveyor of just such a strategy, though kind of hilariously I just mentioned that maybe Disney / Buena Vista had gotten wind of it considering their recent Willow 4K which did...
Total: 80
If the film doesn't really come close to Rosemary's Baby, a film David Koepp overtly cites as being one of his favorites and one that provided an inspiration for mood and style if not actual content, it...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Crush is organic to the source, although this Dolby Vision pass doesn’t appear to find any additional detail at all in the shadows....
Audio: 100
With booming range, Stir of Echoes presents a constant wall of sound, all while balancing the dialog and losing nothing....
Extras: 60
A new 17-minute retrospective feature and an interview with cinematographer Fred Murphy join the legacy features that include a commentary from director David Koepp, interviews, and deleted scenes....
Movie: 80
Sent to theaters mere weeks after Sixth Sense, this Kevin Bacon-starring thriller never had a chance, unfortunate timing for what is a conventional, familiar studio thriller that’s excellent on its own...
Total: 75
Lost in a post-Sixth Sense world, Stir of Echoes has a familiar style, but it’s distinctive in its focus on domestic life....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
The result is an outstanding offering that shouldn’t be missed, and, is among my favorite releases of the year....
Audio: 100
In listening to the Dolby Atmos soundtrack, it was evident right from the opening moments that this was going to be an involving immersive sound mix....
Extras: 100
Audio Commentary with Director David Koepp Visions of the Past: Re-visiting Stir of Echoes (2024 NEW featurette) Establishing Shot with Fred Murphy (2024 NEW featurette)...
Movie: 80
As the horrific visions intensify, Tom realizes they are pieces of a puzzle, echoes of a crime calling out to be solved....
Total: 95
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu? review by Adam Toroni-ByrneRead review here
Video: 80
There is a nice focus on the majority of the film, with nothing too soft or out of focus on display....
Audio: 100
Surround Sound Presentation: Surround channels carry over the creepy ambience, and make parties, train stations, stadiums and block parties come alive....
Extras: 80
The new extras are highlighted in bold below and are excellent additions to an already stacked list of vintage extras!SPECIAL FEATURESAudio Commentary with Director David KoeppVisions of the Past: Re-visiting...
Movie: 80
This is when Jake and Tom begin to communicate with Samantha, who they believe is dead and buried somewhere in the neighborhood....
Total: 90
As it stands for me, this edition of Stir of Echoes is essential for fans of any thriller, and one that I’ll be happy to revisit again and again!...
Director: David Koepp
Actors: Kevin Bacon, Zachary David Cope, Kathryn Erbe
PlotIn Chicago, a blue-collar worker named Tom Witzky leads a normal, if unremarkable, life with his wife Maggie and his son Jake, who appears to have the ability to communicate with spirits. One evening at a party, Tom skeptically agrees to be hypnotized by his sister-in-law, Lisa, who is known for her interest in psychic phenomena. The hypnosis unexpectedly opens his mind to a previously untapped realm, imbuing him with an ability that drastically alters his perception of reality. Following the session, Tom begins to experience disturbing visions and hears eerie whispers that he cannot explain, leading him to believe that his home and neighborhood are haunted by a malevolent presence.
The sudden onset of supernatural experiences drives Tom to obsess over the meaning behind the cryptic messages and spectral appearances, particularly the persistent vision of a mysterious young girl who seems to be reaching out to him from beyond. His obsession with deciphering the cryptic messages disrupts his family life, straining his relationships with Maggie and alarming them with his increasingly erratic behavior. As he delves deeper into the unsettling mystery, his search for answers pulls him into a dark and tangled web of secrets lying at the heart of his seemingly tranquil community. Tom's quest not only threatens his sanity but also forces him to confront uncomfortable truths about the people closest to him and the fabric of his reality.
Writers: Richard Matheson, David Koepp
Release Date: 10 Sep 1999
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish, Korean