Brian and Charles Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A unique and charming film with deep narrative simplicity, but Blu-ray lacks extras; recommended for its engaging storytelling.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 79
The Blu-ray of "Brian and Charles" offers a proficient 1080p transfer with strong visual details, effective textures, and a stable color palette. While not groundbreaking, it satisfies format expectations, making the digital image crisp despite mild noise in low-light scenes and dense blacks occasionally veering towards crush.
Audio: 74
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack of 'Brian and Charles' is unremarkable yet sufficient, offering clean dialogue and occasional immersive elements like thunder and rain, effectively meeting the film's simple audio needs.
Extra: 6
This Blu-ray release of 'Brian and Charles' is minimalist in extras, offering only a 3:16 gag reel featuring unique humor with a dishwasher-constructed character, accessed via a basic in-film pop-up menu without a top menu, slipcover, or digital copy.
Movie: 76
Brian and Charles is a charmingly odd film exploring companionship and human condition via a socially awkward tinkerer and his robot, Charles, made from scraps like a washing machine. With a quasi-documentary style, it's a delightful, thought-provoking gem for fans of unique narratives akin to Swiss Army Man or The Lighthouse.
Video: 79
Universal's release of "Brian and Charles" on Blu-ray delivers a commendable 1080p transfer that embodies the film's digital origin. The AVC HD presentation ensures a strong and consistent contrast, crucial for maintaining the cinematic atmosphere and details, especially in a movie that creatively uses limited resources to tell its story. The film's visual storytelling thrives on the clarity and efficient depiction of textures—be it in the clutter of Brian's shop or the knitwear on the titular robot, Charles. While it doesn't vie with blockbuster spectacle, the sharpness in depicting these details is noteworthy.
Color performance is stable with a generally warm and neutral palette, appropriate for the film’s internal settings, providing a pleasant viewing experience. However, some limitations are evident; black levels occasionally skew toward crush, impeding shadow detail in darker scenes—for instance, near the timestamp of 1:02:45. Despite these minor setbacks, overall integrity is maintained with satisfactory white balance, ensuring flesh tones remain lifelike.
The Blu-ray presentation may not redefine the potential of 1080p but certainly meets and even slightly exceeds baseline expectations for films of its scale and scope. While mild noise can appear in lower-light sequences, it is not obtrusive enough to detract from the viewing experience. This video quality demonstrates that impressive image fidelity can be achieved without an exorbitant budget, enhancing the believability and charm of the film's quirky narrative elements, despite the simplistic cinematic ambition.
Audio: 74
The sound presentation of the Blu Ray for "Brian and Charles" is delivered through a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack. While not earth-shattering, the track adequately fulfills the film’s uncomplicated audio demands. Occasional moments of enhanced audio depth include a sequence with well-spaced thunder at around the 14-minute mark and music that benefits from improved spatial dynamics thereafter. Additionally, the drizzly atmosphere around the 41:57 mark provides a subtly immersive experience. Nonetheless, the soundtrack predominantly maintains a straightforward and minimalistic approach, with limited ambience and sparse complexity in its audio cues.
The mix's primary focus is on maintaining crystal clear dialogues, effectively presented with precise center placement and impressive prioritization to ensure natural and lifelike speech rendering. Though the soundtrack is dialogue-centric, moments of surround ambiance are strategically incorporated to enrich specific scenes, offering heightened mood and engagement where necessary. This measured use of surround sound ensures that while the audio might not be overtly dynamic or encompassing, it serves the narrative without unnecessary embellishment, meeting the listening needs efficiently.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray release of "Brian and Charles" presents a sparse selection of extras, focusing on a singular addition: the Gag Reel. Despite the limited offering, this gag reel stands out for its quirky content, featuring humorous moments involving a character assembled from an old dishwasher—a novelty for viewers. Access to this extra is streamlined through a simplistic in-film pop-up menu, though it necessitates reducing the main feature to a thumbnail, which may detract from viewing convenience. No traditional top menu, DVD, digital copies, or slipcover accompany this release, suggesting a bare-bones approach-oriented purely towards digital media experiences. Overall, while the lack of additional content or features may disappoint some, the unique nature of the Gag Reel provides a niche attraction for fans of the film's unconventional humor.
Extras included in this disc:
- Gag Reel: Humorous outtakes featuring unique content with a dishwasher-constructed character.
Movie: 76
"Brian and Charles" offers a peculiar yet profound exploration of human connection through the lens of an artificial companion. At the movie’s heart is Brian, portrayed by David Earl, a socially awkward tinkerer whose imaginative, impractical inventions provide him a sense of purpose. Among his eclectic creations—ranging from an egg belt to a flying shopping cart—emerges his most ambitious project, the robot Charles. This relationship offers a whimsical narrative that evolves into a reflection on human needs for companionship, love, and acceptance. As the story unfolds, Charles's quest for freedom and understanding intersects with Brian's shy affection for Hazel, crafting scenes that blend humor with poignancy.
The film juxtaposes Brian’s eccentric world against societal norms through its mockumentary style, occasionally breaking the fourth wall for comedic or introspective effect. Charles, with his washing machine-based physique and mannequin head, serves as a mirror to Brian’s own social ineptitude and unrealized dreams. Despite his robotic demeanor, Charles channels a childlike curiosity about the world, evoking empathy from viewers and highlighting the deficiencies as well as potentialities inherent in human relationships. The narrative escalates as Eddie, played by Jamie Michie, becomes the antagonist embodying the societal fringe of bullies, culminating in a tension-filled clash between creativity and societal repression.
While peculiar in its storytelling and visual execution, "Brian and Charles" captivates audiences willing to delve beyond its surface eccentricities. Its unique charm lies in its willingness to explore fringe themes and its ability to draw viewers into a world where oddity is embraced and questioned alike. This film stands out for its originality and invites viewers to reflect on the absurd yet moving parallels between human emotional journeys and the quest for companionship.
Total: 62
"Brian and Charles," a film that daringly embraces creativity, marks itself as a significant departure from the conventional storytelling approach prevalent in mainstream cinema. Its uniqueness lies in its simple yet profound narrative, which delves into genuine emotional and psychological themes without falling into the traps of pretentiousness. The film deftly explores human eccentricities through its engaging storyline and well-developed characters, offering viewers a memorable experience. The narrative cleverly utilizes understated humor and a touch of whimsy to present a story that resonates with audiences long after the credits roll.
The technical presentation on Blu-ray is satisfactory, although Universal’s release falls short in the supplementary department, providing little beyond a gag reel. This lack of additional content is a letdown, especially given the depth and creativity displayed in the main feature, which would have benefited from more in-depth explorations or behind-the-scenes insights. On the positive side, the video and audio quality deliver solid performances, adequately capturing the film's unique aesthetic and ensuring an immersive viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Brian and Charles" possesses an offbeat charm that makes it an intriguing choice for those seeking something innovative yet emotionally substantial. Despite the disappointing absence of noteworthy extras in the Blu-ray release, the film's compelling narrative and quality technical execution make it a recommended watch. It stands as a poignant reminder of the strength unique storytelling continues to hold in captivating audiences.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Overall clarity is fine, boasting good, efficient textures throughout, which are vital when the camera lingers, for example, on Brian's shop full of junk and odds and ends, and of course on the sweater...
Audio: 80
However, most of the track is very simple, with straightforward cues, limited ambience, and frankly not much going on....
Extras: 10
The bonus feature, as well as on-screen subtitle options, must be accessed by a simplistic in-film pop-up menu that reduces the film to a thumbnail....
Movie: 80
Above in this review is a very superficial, first-thought sort of look into the film, but audiences with an open mind and a willingness to engage with the characters and the material, to look beyond its...
Total: 60
It's unique in approach, characterization, and even narrative superficial simplicity, all of which is balanced by a wonderfully deep story that audiences will think about for a long time after the film....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
Detail is sharp as well, I can’t imagine watching this movie and trying to believe that the constructed “robot” was real if not for the uptick in picture quality....
Audio: 80
And when we really only have one main character, there’s not a lot of cause for “dynamic audio” if you get my drift....
Extras: 10
Gag Reel – You ever see a gag reel with a “person” constructed from an old dishwasher in a gag reel?...
Movie: 0
If you thought Wilson, Tom Hanks’ “friend” in the movie Cast Away was a bit out there, this one takes it to a whole new level....
Total: 80
I imagine if my wife ever kicks me out, I could see myself living a desolate life somewhere and attempting to build a friend out of old dishwasher parts....
Director: Jim Archer
Actors: David Earl, Chris Hayward, Louise Brealey
PlotIn a secluded Welsh village, Brian, an eccentric and lonely inventor, spends his days crafting peculiar gadgets that seldom work. Desperate for companionship and driven by his unyielding creativity, Brian embarks on constructing something truly unique—a robot. Using discarded bits and pieces, including a washing machine and a mannequin head, he miraculously brings Charles to life. The robot, Charles, quickly becomes sentient, developing a distinctive personality marked by curiosity and childlike wonder. As Charles learns about the world around him, the unlikely duo strikes up a comical and heartwarming friendship. The pair embark on adventures through the idyllic countryside, with Charles's naive observations providing lighthearted moments and a poignant exploration of friendship and belonging.
However, their unorthodox bond attracts unwanted attention from Eddie, the local bully with a menacing streak. As the townspeople become aware of Charles's existence, tensions rise, and Brian must confront the reality of his creation's impact on their quiet community. Navigating threats and misunderstandings, Brian is faced with choices that test his character and the extent of his loyalty to Charles. Framed by lush landscapes and underscored by genuine humor, this tale of companionship challenges the boundaries of loneliness and invention. As events unfold, it becomes apparent that Brian must protect not only his creation but also the newfound bond that empowers him in unexpected ways.
Writers: David Earl, Chris Hayward
Release Date: 08 Jul 2022
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English