Jack Goes Boating Blu-ray Review
Score: 49
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Jack Goes Boating" delivers genuine performances and solid technical quality, but its slow, understated narrative may not captivate all viewers.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 57
The 1080p, 1.85:1-framed transfer of 'Jack Goes Boating' presents a filmic and natural look, with light grain, strong details, fair blacks, and steady colors while retaining clarity without excessive sharpness; a pleasing release near the top of Blu-ray quality, though slightly marred by occasional digital noise and bright contrast.
Audio: 52
Jack Goes Boating's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack is dialogue-centric and well-balanced, with clear center-channel audio and subtle atmospheric effects. While front-heavy and lacking surround activity, it offers fine musical fidelity and occasional punch, handling the reserved material with ease.
Extra: 21
Extras for 'Jack Goes Boating' fall flat with limited, non-essential content; brief featurettes 'Jack's New York' and 'From Stage to Screen' offer basic insights, while minor deleted scenes and standard trailers add little value.
Movie: 66
Jack Goes Boating, a modest and emotionally satisfying film, masterfully adapted from an off-Broadway play, offers a grounded portrayal of real-life struggles and triumphs, featuring stellar performances, particularly by Philip Seymour Hoffman. Despite some pacing issues, it resonates with its truthful depiction of human fragility and aspiration.
Video: 57
"Jack Goes Boating" arrives on Blu-ray with a commendable 1080p, 1.85:1-framed transfer that provides a pleasant viewing experience. Anchor Bay's release stands out for its filmic quality, preserving a light layer of grain that enhances the overall texture and keeps it true to the source material. The image offers strong detail, particularly in close-up shots where facial features and textures such as Jack's winter ski cap appear intricate and well-defined. Despite not always achieving razor-sharp precision, it maintains an inviting middle ground that replicates the theatrical experience admirably, showcasing the potential of Blu-ray quality. Colors tend to stay consistent with natural lighting and location-specific elements, although they occasionally warm depending on the scene's light source.
The 1080p/MPEG-4 AVC transfer is characterized by its natural yet somewhat flat appearance, which slightly detracts from the film's immediacy. The maintained grain accentuates an earthy texture suitable for the film's working-class narrative. The subdued color palette heightens the urban atmosphere and subtly reflects the characters' inner conflicts. However, contrast levels can appear overly bright at times, causing white levels to push too far and resulting in some loss of vibrancy in the primary colors. While Hoffman's complexion appears quite pale in certain scenes like those set in the swimming pool, other flesh tones remain balanced and appear natural. Black levels are robust but lack the density needed to cause any crushing issues.
Foreground and background details are nicely defined, though the transfer lacks the vivacity and sharpness found in crisper Blu-ray presentations. Occasional digital noise is present but minimal, ensuring the image largely remains clear with no detected banding, pixelation, or edge enhancement. This transfer serves its purpose well, providing a solid, reliable viewing experience without offering any particular visual spectacle that might provoke significant excitation.
Audio: 52
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack for "Jack Goes Boating" is engineered precisely for the film's character-driven nature. As expected, dialogue plays a pivotal role and is meticulously rendered through the center channel, ensuring clarity and balance without being overshadowed by musical or ambient elements. The relatively subtle use of atmospheric effects, such as city sounds and the serene ambiance of a public swimming pool, creates an engaging auditory environment that adeptly moves across the soundstage and occasionally utilizes the back channels for added depth.
While the mix is primarily front-heavy, it provides a sufficiently full-bodied experience despite its minimal surround activity. The subwoofer remains largely inactive, but when integrated, its low-end tones enhance the richness of certain scenes. Music composed by Grizzly Bear and Evan Lurie is well-represented with fine fidelity, achieving good spatial separation across the front channels and occasionally delivering energetic, punchy moments. Overall, the audio track is well-balanced and adeptly supports the film's undemanding material, ensuring a pleasant viewing experience without any notable deficiencies.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray extras for "Jack Goes Boating" are limited in scope and depth, failing to provide essential or particularly enlightening content. The bonus features offer a basic glimpse into the film's transition from stage to screen and its New York setting, but they lack substantial insights and behind-the-scenes material that would cater to avid film enthusiasts. The featurettes primarily deliver surface-level reflections from the cast and crew. Furthermore, the deleted scenes, while intriguing, don't add any critical narrative elements that would enhance the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Jack's New York: Cast and crew discuss New York and how it becomes a character in the film.
- From the Stage to the Big Screen: Cast and crew offer a brief look at the process of transitioning the play to the screen.
- Deleted Scenes: Two scenes focus on character interactions in a subway setting.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original trailer, along with previews for other films.
Movie: 66
Adapted from Robert Glaudini's stage play, "Jack Goes Boating" is a nuanced drama directed by Philip Seymour Hoffman, who also stars in the titular role. As Jack, Hoffman portrays a lonely New York City limo driver whose life takes a tentative turn when his friend Clyde (John Ortiz) sets him up with Connie (Amy Ryan), an equally introverted funeral home worker. The storyline captures their journey of self-improvement and budding romance, framed within the simplicity of daily life and enhanced via Hoffman's directorial debut. The film stands out for its genuine representation of ordinary individuals striving for connection and purpose, winning favor for its low-key realism and emotional depth.
Hoffman's performance as Jack is compelling, showcasing his deftness at embodying characters marked by both emotional and physical imperfections. His portrayal of Jack's transformation—learning to swim and cook for Connie—rings true to real-life struggles and dreams, making the character deeply relatable. The rapport between Hoffman and Ryan is subtle yet powerful, bolstered further by strong performances from Ortiz and Daphne Rubin-Vega, who add layers to the secondary narrative surrounding Clyde and Lucy's marital challenges.
Critics acknowledge the movie's quiet strength, comparing its slice-of-life texture favorably to works like "Marty." Hoffman's direction respects the story's theatrical origins without resorting to intrusive techniques, allowing the film’s real-world authenticity to shine through. However, some find its pacing languorous and its emotional impact somewhat subdued. Unlike more grandiose dramas, "Jack Goes Boating" invites viewers into a contemplative space, rewarding those willing to engage with its characters’ understated victories and setbacks. Its success lies in the film's ability to evoke the gentle ebb and flow of everyday life, wrapped in the reliable charm of Hoffman's earnest direction and acting.
Total: 49
"Jack Goes Boating" arrives on Blu-ray with a presentation that showcases the film's endearing qualities and subtle storytelling. Directed by Philip Seymour Hoffman, this indie romantic drama excels in delivering an authentic portrayal of ordinary lives underscored by delicate performances. The Blu-ray features a commendable film-like video transfer that captures the nuanced visual tone of the movie, alongside a quality lossless soundtrack that complements the film's understated narrative.
However, the pacing may come across as slow to some viewers, and its understated approach may not capture everyone's interest despite its relatable themes. The Blu-ray offers limited supplemental material, but the technical aspects are robust enough to satisfy most fans of indie cinema. The performances are noteworthy, particularly Hoffman's directorial finesse and engaging portrayals.
In conclusion, "Jack Goes Boating" is a sweet and innocent depiction of real-life struggles and simple aspirations. It explores genuine human connections without exaggeration, making it a relatable and heartwarming experience. The Anchor Bay Blu-ray release, despite sparse extras, is recommendable for its solid presentation and the film's inherent quality.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The image isn't always razor-sharp, but it's never excessively soft, either; it finds an inviting and pleasing middle ground that replicates the theatrical experience quite nicely and therefore represents...
Audio: 80
The track engages in subtle atmospherics that do a good job of inserting listeners into various outdoor locales through the implementation of sirens, passing traffic, and other city din, not to mention...
Extras: 30
From the Stage to the Big Screen (1080p, 4:35): Cast and crew offer a brief look at the process of transitioning the play to the screen....
Movie: 80
The film strives only to capture a snapshot of life for four ordinary people -- their triumphs and failures, as small-scale as they may seem compared to the larger issues of the world around them; their...
Total: 70
It's a simple story of simple people striving to make their lives a little bit better while remaining true to who they are, looking for acceptance -- and willing to give it -- even through all the flaws...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
A slight amount of digital noise sometimes creeps into the picture, but for the most part the image remains clear, and no banding, pixelation, or edge enhancement could be detected....
Audio: 60
The front-heavy mix rarely employs any surround activity, even during exterior New York City scenes, but the audio sounds sufficiently full-bodied, with well-modulated highs and lows....
Extras: 20
A celebratory look at the "hidden gems" of New York where much of the film was shot, and how the location acts as an additional character in the drama....
Movie: 60
As a director, Hoffman shows some talent, and tries valiantly to both maintain the play's small focus and preserve its subtleties, but I often questioned such choices during the film....
Total: 40
Slowly paced and a tad too understated, the movie never gripped me despite its interesting characters and relatable themes....
Director: Philip Seymour Hoffman
Actors: Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Ryan, John Ortiz
PlotJack is a shy and introverted limo driver living in New York City. He is best friends with Clyde and his wife, Lucy, who introduce him to Connie, a similarly quiet and reserved woman. Jack and Connie start a tentative relationship, culminating in Jack's decision to learn how to cook and swim to impress her. Clyde supports Jack in his endeavors, while harboring his own marital issues with Lucy. Lucy confides in Connie about her struggles with Clyde, adding a layer of complexity to both their relationships.
As Jack continues to build confidence through his cooking lessons and swimming practice, tensions between Clyde and Lucy escalate. Jack and Connie grow closer, navigating their vulnerabilities and insecurities. Jack's journey of self-improvement and the evolving dynamics between the characters form the crux of the story. Through various emotionally charged interactions and personal challenges, the characters confront their desires and fears, leading to a deeper understanding of themselves and each other.
Writers: Robert Glaudini
Release Date: 29 Dec 2010
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English