What's Eating Gilbert Grape Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
'What's Eating Gilbert Grape?' is an unexpected, moving classic with excellent Paramount Blu-ray release.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
While awaiting a potential Criterion restoration, Paramount's Blu-ray release of 'What's Eating Gilbert Grape?' impresses with vivid colors, lifelike skintones, and excellent detail, despite minor flaws.
Audio: 73
What's Eating Gilbert Grape? impresses with its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, maintaining clarity and immersive ambiance despite its '90s origin, blending nostalgia with subtle, effective audio elements.
Extra: 46
Director Lasse Hallström and writer Peter Hedges provide in-depth commentary on the film's creation and cast, alongside three featurettes exploring the characters and essence of Gilbert Grape, plus the original trailer.
Movie: 86
'What's Eating Gilbert Grape’ receives a praised Blu-ray release, celebrated for its timeless, universal story and performances, despite review delays.
Video: 83
In the high-definition realm of Blu-ray presentations, the release of "What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" by Paramount might not have the touch of a Criterion restoration, but it certainly stands tall with its 1080p/AVC-encoded video transfer. The image quality is so vibrant and crisp that it's hard to conceive of a noticeably superior version barring a return to the original film elements for a more exhaustive overhaul. The colors in this transfer shine brightly, with vivaciousness that seems almost three-dimensional. Skintones are particularly impressive, reproducing natural hues with an authenticity that adds a layer of realism to the cinematic experience. The image is complimented by excellent contrast adjustments, yielding deep blacks and shadows that are both well-defined and textured, despite occasional hints of crushing which are easy enough to overlook given the overall excellence of the presentation.
Detail resolution across the board is remarkable, maintaining an appreciable level of grain that enhances rather than detracts from the visual experience. Fine textures on skin, clothing, and environments are sharp and clearly delineated, making the most of the film's nuanced cinematography. Edge definition is handled with care, avoiding the pitfalls of excessive sharpness that can mar a presentation by making it appear unnaturally processed. This considered approach confirms that the transfer has been derived from a master of high caliber, free of common digital disturbances such as blocking or banding. Such quality ensures that viewers can immerse themselves fully in the narrative without being distracted by technical imperfections.
The Blu-ray release of "What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" thus emerges as a commendable effort from Paramount, showcasing a visually stunning rendition of an already compelling story. The video presentation respects and amplifies the film’s aesthetic virtues, from its lifelike skintones to its dynamic color palette, all while staying true to the source material. While there remains room for potential improvements in future restorations, this release undoubtedly deserves its place amongst the finest in any collection, affirming its worth through a combination of rich detail, balanced sharpness, and a careful preservation of filmic texture.
Audio: 73
The audio presentation of "What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" on its Blu Ray edition, equipped with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, faithfully respects the movie's original 1990s sound mix nuances without attempting to artificially modernize its profile. This technical choice ensures that dialogue delivery remains crisply intelligible throughout, effectively standing out against the backdrop of music and varied sound effects. The mix successfully leverages the full soundscape, with its rear speakers enriching scenes with a multifaceted auditory environment. From the detailed ambience of household scenes to the vibrant noise of a carnival and the tranquil atmosphere of a country field at sunset, the audio track ensures each setting is conveyed with an engaging yet subtle spatial awareness, achieving an immersive experience despite the inherent limitations of its era's sound design.
Notably, the soundfield crafted for this release demonstrates a commendable level of directionality and smooth transitioning between channels, facilitating a convincing immersion into the film's environments. While the use of sound effects and their integration into the overall soundscape reveals a certain '90s-style artificiality, this aspect is negligible in light of the audio track's ability to faithfully reproduce and enhance the original listening experience. Interestingly, the LFE channel is judiciously employed to add necessary depth and heft to specific moments and sounds within the film, such as Gilbert’s beleaguered pickup truck, which benefits from this thoughtful attention to detail.
In essence, while "What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" may not redefine the heights of what can be achieved with catalog surround sound in contemporary home theater setups, it undeniably surpasses expectations for an audio presentation of a film from 1994. Through its proficient use of a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track, it presents an audio experience that not only pays homage to the film's original sound design but also enhances the viewing experience with meticulous care and attention to ambient and directional details.
Extras: 46
The extra presentation of the Blu Ray "What's Eating Gilbert Grape" offers an insightful and enriching behind-the-scenes journey into the making of this beloved film. The cornerstone of the extras is an audio commentary by Director Lasse Hallström and writer Peter Hedges, who dive deeply into various aspects of the film's creation from casting decisions to the hunt for the film's setting, offering a treasure trove of information for fans and cinema students alike. Complementing the commentary, the set includes three featurettes in standard definition that explore the film through different lenses; characters, narrative voice, and the reasons the film remains revered. Lastly, it features the original theatrical trailer, rounding off a succinct yet comprehensive package that enhances appreciation for the movie's craft and story.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: A detailed discussion by Director Lasse Hallström and writer Peter Hedges.
- The Characters of Gilbert Grape: Exploration of the film's characters.
- The Voice of Gilbert Grape: A look at the narrative voice of the film.
- Why We Love Gilbert Grape: Insights into why the film endures in popularity.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: The film's original promotional trailer.
Movie: 86
What's Eating Gilbert Grape" arrives on Blu-ray, presenting a classic '90s narrative with a heartwarming tale of family, love, and personal growth. Despite the lateness of this review, the film, under the direction of Lasse Hallström and penned by Peter Hedges, remains a testament to storytelling that navigates the complexity of human emotions with grace and depth. Set against the backdrop of Endora, Iowa, it portrays the life of Gilbert Grape (Johnny Depp), tasked with the daily care of his family, including his intellectually challenged brother Arnie (Leonardo DiCaprio) and his morbidly obese mother. The arrival of Becky (Juliette Lewis) introduces the possibility of a life beyond the confinements of his responsibilities, weaving a narrative rich in character development and emotional nuance.
The technical aspects of the movie, from its casting to performances, music, and cinematography, enhance its storytelling, rendering it more than just a "sugary tear-jerker." Leonardo DiCaprio's portrayal of Arnie is particularly notable, offering a glimpse into his early prowess as an actor, alongside Johnny Depp's compelling depiction of Gilbert. The film's pacing mirrors the slow burn of transformation witnessed within its characters and the town of Endora itself—a portrayal augmented by the support cast, including performances by Darlene Cates, Mary Steenburgen, and John C. Reilly, which collectively enrich the tapestry of Gilbert's world.
The Blu-ray presentation captures not only the technical finesse but also the emotional layers of "What's Eating Gilbert Grape." Its narrative poses questions of familial duty versus personal happiness in a way that remains relevant and poignant. The film's strength lies in its ability to embrace its characters' imperfections and complexities, inviting viewers into a cinematic experience where empathy and understanding prevail. This Blu-ray release ensures that both new audiences and longtime fans can experience the timeless appeal and warmth that have defined "What's Eating Gilbert Grape" for decades.
Total: 72
What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" stands out as an unexpected gem from the '90s, captivating audiences with its depth and emotional resonance. The portrayal of familial love and the unique dynamics within the Grape household are both heartwarming and poignant, offering an experience that moves beyond mere entertainment to touch the viewer on a personal level. The film manages to weave a tale that is both uplifting and grounded, guiding the audience through a spectrum of emotions that are as surprising as they are profound. Its impact is not just in the storytelling but in the authentic connections it fosters with its characters, making it a must-watch for those seeking cinema that both entertains and enlightens.
Paramount has treated this film with the respect it deserves in its Blu-ray release, presenting a package that enhances the viewing experience remarkably. The video quality is exceptional, with a striking presentation that brings out the intricate details and vibrant life of the film's setting. Accompanied by a robust DTS-HD Master Audio track, the film's auditory experience is as compelling as its visuals, ensuring that viewers are fully immersed in the world of Gilbert Grape. Additionally, the inclusion of a decent collection of extras adds value for fans and newcomers alike, providing deeper insight into the making of this cherished movie.
In conclusion, Paramount's Blu-ray release of "What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" goes beyond merely offering a high-definition rendition of the film. It presents an enriching experience that complements the movie's emotional depth and narrative complexity. With superb video and audio quality, alongside thoughtful extras, this release is highly recommended for those looking to discover or revisit this '90s classic. It not only celebrates the film's enduring legacy but also ensures that new audiences can experience its profound impact in the best possible way.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 90
I can imagine Criterion swooping in one day, returning to the original film elements, inviting Hallstr�m into the restoration bay and creating the be-all, end-all high definition release of What's Eating...
Audio: 80
LFE output is solid and reliable, bolstering moments that call for it and elements like Gilbert's coughing, rattling pickup truck that need a bit of weight to sound more ragged and hefty than they might...
Extras: 50
Featurettes (SD) - Three rather self-explanatory archive featurettes are included: "The Characters of Gilbert Grape" (11 minutes), "The Voice of Gilbert Grape" (6 minutes) and "Why We Love Gilbert Grape"...
Movie: 90
Its that warmth, and the further warmth that arrives with Gilbert's love interest Becky, that lifts the film on its waves, cresting at a point that tears flow, hearts are moved, and a movie weaves its...
Total: 80
It's not the movie you expect, and what it does to you while watching it is not something you'll be prepared for....
Director: Lasse Hallström
Actors: Johnny Depp, Leonardo DiCaprio, Juliette Lewis
PlotIn a small Midwestern town, Gilbert Grape is burdened with more responsibilities than most people his age. He works at a grocery store to support his family, which includes his morbidly obese mother, who hasn't left the house in seven years, and his younger brother, Arnie, who has a developmental disability. Gilbert's life is a cycle of care, as he provides for his family and ensures Arnie's safety, often saving him from his own misadventures. The monotony of Gilbert's world is compounded by the stigmatization his family faces from the community, and his personal dreams and desires are constantly put on hold.
The arrival of Becky, a free-spirited young woman traveling through town with her grandmother, brings an unforeseen spark into Gilbert's life. Her presence and perspective offer him a glimpse of what life could be outside the confines of his responsibilities. This new friendship challenges Gilbert's sense of duty and loyalty to his family, forcing him to confront the choices he has made and the ones he has avoided. As Gilbert grapples with these conflicting feelings, he begins to question what it means to truly love and care for someone while trying to carve out his own identity and happiness.
Writers: Peter Hedges
Release Date: 04 Mar 1994
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English