American Underdog Blu-ray Review
Score: 83
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
American Underdog delivers a heartwarming tale of perseverance, with solid performances and strong technical merits on Blu-ray; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 88
American Underdog on Blu-ray offers a crisp and detailed 1080p AVC-encoded presentation in 2.39:1, showcasing the vibrant colors of Rams' uniforms and football fields with deep blacks, while maintaining clean visuals, despite a neutral palette and minimal visual noise. Finished at 4K, it provides outstanding clarity and color saturation.
Audio: 85
American Underdog's audio presentation is a subtle yet effective Dolby Atmos mix with dynamic dialogue, immersive football sequences, and punchy low-end, while the 7.1 channel track offers robust dynamics and engaging surround sound, all enhancing the film's thematic tone within a generally limited sound design context.
Extra: 73
American Underdog's Blu-ray extras deliver a comprehensive and insightful experience, featuring engaging audio commentary with the Erwin brothers and producer Downes, rich behind-the-scenes content, in-depth featurettes on casting and filmmaking challenges, and interviews with key figures like Kurt Warner and Dick Vermeil—all packaged in crisp HD.
Movie: 75
"American Underdog" is a heartfelt portrayal of Kurt Warner's ascent from obscurity to NFL stardom, focusing on his personal struggles and triumphs rather than just his sports achievements. With standout performances by Zachary Levi and Anna Paquin, the film navigates faith, family, and perseverance while maintaining authenticity in football portrayals, despite some pacing and writing shortcomings.
Video: 88
"American Underdog" on Blu-ray offers an outstanding visual experience, faithfully presented by Lionsgate Films in a 1080p AVC-encoded transfer, maintaining the original 2.39:1 aspect ratio. Shot using Arri Alexa camera variants and reportedly finished in 4K, the film benefits from a crisp and clean look with remarkable clarity throughout its depiction of Kurt Warner's journey. While the narrative does not rely heavily on CGI or flashy effects, the natural vibrancy and realism in colors stand out, particularly in the brilliantly saturated blues and yellows of the Rams' uniforms. Each frame delivers impressive detail, from the texture of jerseys to the stubble on faces, enhancing the down-to-earth authenticity of the film.
The Blu-ray transfer excels in rendering deep, inky black levels with commendable shadow detail, essential for the film's variously lit scenes, although some more dimly lit settings might exhibit a slight murkiness that leads to minimal deficits in fine detail. Overall, the picture remains sharp as a tack, aided by virtually non-existent visual noise or compression artifacts that could distract from its cinematic realism. This spectacular transfer ensures that high levels of fine detail are maintained, whether in wide framings or up-close shots.
Moreover, the film showcases a distinct and resonant palette, capturing everything from muted shades of a blizzard to the lushness under stadium lights with true-to-life accuracy. It's a highly detailed presentation that firmly cements itself as one of the better examples of Blu-ray’s capability to produce pristine picture quality, making "American Underdog" an excellent choice for those seeking high-definition visual storytelling without compromise.
Audio: 85
The audio presentation of "American Underdog" on Blu-ray offers a robust yet nuanced Dolby Atmos track, enriched by varied dynamic elements. Dialog is delivered with crystalline clarity, indicative of professional attention to detail. While the film predominantly consists of dramatic narratives interspersed with ambient sounds, the track shines vividly during the energetic football sequences. These moments leverage the expansive soundstage effectively, with directional effects and ambient crowd noise immersing the viewer in the action. The accurate placement of sounds within the listening environment enhances spatial depth and audience engagement, although this Atmos mix might not exhibit the flashiness found in other releases.
Complementing the Dolby Atmos track, a 7.1 channel audio option is also available, characterized by its clear dialogue and robust dynamics. Notably, this mix underscores the emotive musical score and thematic tone of the film, providing a symphonic backdrop that elevates the storytelling. The surround sound implementation successfully transports viewers into the scene through precise directional effects, enabling an enveloping experience that aligns seamlessly with the visual elements.
While not necessarily a demonstration piece for high-end audio systems, the audio mix of "American Underdog" remains commendably effective within its design parameters. It balances subtle atmospherics—such as gentle winds or subdued bar room chatter—with periods of strong low-frequency energy during critical game scenes. This engagement peaks when bone-jarring tackles and cheering crowds resonate throughout the soundstage. The resulting experience is a satisfying auditory complement to this personal yet vibrant sports narrative, providing listeners with an appreciably layered audio landscape. Optional English, French, and Spanish subtitles are available to further enhance accessibility and viewing enjoyment.
Extras: 73
The Blu-ray extras for "American Underdog" offer a comprehensive and insightful behind-the-scenes experience. The disc includes an extensive Audio Commentary by directors Andrew and Jon Erwin with producer Kevin Downes, where they share intricate details about the film's production, including the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. The Featurettes vary from casting insights in Inspired, to technical perspectives in Making the Cut, showcasing the editor's test screening processes, and a notable interview with former Rams coach Dick Vermeil in A Coach's Faith. The set also highlights young actor Hayden Zaller's debut in New to the Scene: Hayden Zaller, and provides an in-depth football lens in Behind the Game. Despite some content overlap, these high-definition extras are thoughtfully curated, enhancing fans’ understanding of the film’s thematic and production complexities.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful discussion on production challenges and collaborations.
- Inspired: Cast and crew interviews focusing on casting choices.
- Making the Cut: Examination of the film's editing.
- A Coach's Faith: Interview with coach Dick Vermeil.
- New to the Scene: Hayden Zaller: Introduction to the young actor.
- Meet the Champion: Discussion with Kurt Warner.
- Behind the Game: Exploration of football action sequences.
- American Underdog: Behind the Story: Brief EPK trailer.
- Deleted Scenes: Additional footage with optional commentary.
- Theatrical Trailer: Preview of the film.
Movie: 75
"American Underdog" offers an inspiring portrayal of Kurt Warner's improbable ascent from grocery store stockboy to NFL legend, with Zachary Levi delivering a commendable performance as Warner. The film, directed by Andrew and Jon Erwin, focuses less on sports action and more on the personal and romantic dimensions of Warner's life, particularly his relationship with Brenda, portrayed by Anna Paquin. Despite the film’s occasional pacing issues and moments of clichéd dialogue, it manages to capture the emotional core of Warner's story—a testament to perseverance, family support, and unwavering faith. Levi’s striking resemblance to Warner adds authenticity, while Paquin impressively depicts Brenda's steadfastness and faith.
The film succeeds by not overplaying its Christian undertones, instead emphasizing universally relatable themes of personal growth and determination. It celebrates Warner’s journey through life's adversities, including his trials in the Arena Football League and eventual recruitment by the NFL's St. Louis Rams, without becoming overtly preachy. This balance is further enhanced by strong supporting roles, such as Dennis Quaid’s portrayal of coach Dick Vermeil, and standout performances from secondary cast members.
While the script occasionally takes liberties with factual details for narrative cohesion, particularly in Warner's transition from the Arena League to the Rams, the film's engaging nature keeps audiences invested. The football sequences, choreographed by Mark Ellis, effectively blend real NFL footage with dramatized scenes, adding a layer of realism. Overall, "American Underdog" is a heartfelt drama that resonates through its true-to-life depiction of challenges conquered through tenacity and the power of belief—both in oneself and in a greater good.
Total: 83
"American Underdog" is a sports film that delivers an uplifting and heartwarming experience, vividly recounting Kurt Warner's incredible journey to becoming an NFL MVP. Directed by Andrew and Jon Erwin, the movie stays true to Warner’s story, showcasing powerful performances by Zachary Levi and Anna Paquin. The Blu-ray's technical specifications are impressive, featuring a 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio and Dolby Atmos audio, ensuring an immersive viewing experience. The disc includes informative extras that enhance the understanding of both the film and the real-life events it portrays.
The film is notable for its effective narrative centered on perseverance and family values, drawing viewers into a tale of personal and professional resilience. Despite its overshadowed box-office release against major blockbusters like "Spider-Man: No Way Home," "American Underdog" holds its ground, offering universal themes that resonate with a wide audience. While the subject matter is deeply rooted in faith and determination, it appeals to those outside the sports community or lacking specific ties to elements like the University of Northern Iowa.
In conclusion, "American Underdog" is a commendable addition to sports cinema. It combines solid performances with technical excellence on Blu-ray, making it a valuable viewing experience whether for inspiration or entertainment. The film garners a well-deserved recommendation for its engaging storytelling and production quality, affirming it as a worthwhile watch for families and individuals alike.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
The older bits of Brenda and Kurt dating tend to look more brown and soft around faces, but when Kurt is on the field playing ball it’s clean as can be and sharp as a tack....
Audio: 90
Things like a bar room dance hall are pretty immersive, and the bass does kick on during those elements, but it’s really the ball playing where things get chaotic and stretch the track’s legs, so to speak....
Extras: 70
• Audio Commentary with Directors Andrew and Jon Erwin and Producer Kevin Downes • Inspired • Making the Cut • A Coach's Faith • New to the Scene, Hayden Zaller • Meet the Champion • Behind the Game •...
Movie: 80
Brenda is smitten with Warner as much as he is with her, but he’s been burnt by a divorce already, and wants to make sure that her children are first, rather than fall head over heels for a sports star...
Total: 80
The Blu-ray is fantastic, with great video and audio, and a decent array of extras that actually are quite informative....
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Captured with a variety of Arri Alexa models and finished at 4K, at least according to some online data (which I have not been able to independently verify, for those who care about such things), this...
Audio: 90
American Underdog features an intermittently propulsive Dolby Atmos track, but as even Brenda Warner mentions, this may not be a "sports movie" as much as a personal story, and as such, there's quite a...
Extras: 70
Hayden Zaller (HD; 6:10) features the adorable and remarkable little boy who portrays Zach in the film....
Movie: 70
But here's where things get kind of interesting, at least in a "meta" sense: Anna Paquin, who portrays Kurt's wife Brenda, is on hand in some interviews included as supplements that she is not a "believer"...
Total: 70
If many will find this heartwarming tale viscerally touching due to the hard earned success of Kurt Warner and the struggles he and Brenda endured separately and together, I reacted emotionally to the...
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 90
The 1080p AVC-encoded transfer, which retains the film’s theatrical aspect ratio of 2.39:1, provides naturally vibrant colors with a great attention to details, particularly the green grass of the football...
Audio: 90
The default Dolby Atmos track is a subtle but effective one, allowing for a wide and deep soundstage, allowing heights to fill in the atmospherics such as wind, crowds, etc....
Extras: 80
Making the Cut (1080p; 13:45): The Erwin Brothers and Sean Albertson discuss the editing and test screening process....
Movie: 80
Directors Andrew and Jon Erwin (no relation to me) could have easily made this a sugar-coated story of a man going from store clerk to Super Bowl MVP, but the script by Jon Erwin & David Aaron Cohen and...
Total: 80
American Underdog is a surprisingly good film with solid performances from its cast, and a story that will appeal and resonate with nearly everyone....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 88
I found this to be an engaging audio presentation that complimented the video resulting in an involving and evocative viewing experience that enhanced the source material....
Extras: 80
“New to the Scene: Hayden Zaller” Featurette • “Meet the Champion” Featurette • “Behind the Game” Featurette • “American Underdog: Behind the Story” Featurette • Deleted Scenes with Optional Audio Commentary...
Movie: 80
The film centers on Warner’s unique story and years of challenges and setbacks that could have derailed his aspirations to become an NFL player – but just when his dreams seemed all but out of reach, it...
Total: 85
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-RS2000 4K Ultra High Definition Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
The film’s palette shows up with a realistic resonance that ranges from the muted hues of a blizzard to the lush blues and yellows of the Rams’ jerseys under stadium lights....
Audio: 90
First, the standard audio critique as dialogue is of course delivered through the front channels, nothing too exciting there, but it’s some of those bone-jarring hits and crowd cheers that reverberate...
Extras: 70
Behind the Game (8:13) – Deciding what kind of film this was going to be and incorporating the football action sequences within....
Movie: 70
Nevertheless, the sequence is short-lived and the story finds a way to mature from there as do the characters with their shared experiences....
Total: 80
It is a film that can be appreciated and enjoyed by the whole family and can provide some great motivation at the same time....
Director: Andrew Erwin, Jon Erwin
Actors: Zachary Levi, Anna Paquin, Hayden Zaller
PlotAn undrafted football player fights against the odds to pursue a professional career in the NFL. With humble beginnings in a small Iowa town, the protagonist faces a series of setbacks that threaten to derail his dreams of becoming a quarterback. Displaying considerable talent in high school and college, his journey to the top is plagued with obstacles, including being overlooked by NFL teams and grappling with the harsh realities of minor-league sports.
Navigating through personal challenges and professional disappointments, the main character marries his college sweetheart, who believes in his potential and supports his ambitions. While working a supermarket job and struggling with the idea that his football career might be over, an unexpected opportunity arises. He gets a second chance in the NFL when he is called to try out for a professional team. With determination and relentless perseverance, he must prove his worth in a world that barely gave him a passing glance.
Writers: Kurt Warner, Michael Silver, Jon Erwin
Release Date: 25 Dec 2021
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English