The Fatal Raid Blu-ray Review
Score: 45
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A flawed attempt at blending narrative and action, 'The Fatal Raid' is redeemed by frequent explosive set pieces and solid technical merits.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 63
The Fatal Raid's Blu-ray presentation offers commendable detail with its AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.38:1, showcasing mostly consistent definition, albeit some scenes appear overly bright. Scenic Macau shots shine, but overall the digital cinematography and contrast could use more polish and consistency.
Audio: 58
The Fatal Raid's audio offers a dynamic experience with its Cantonese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and Dolby Digital 2.0 tracks, yet English speakers face challenges due to poor subtitle translations and sub-par dubbing, forcing a choice between immersive sound and comprehensible dialogue.
Extra: 2
The Blu-ray of 'The Fatal Raid' includes a professionally authored sequence beginning with its HD trailer, followed by automatic trailers for other Well Go USA releases, complemented by a slipcover, and coded for Region A.
Movie: 26
The Fatal Raid, a Hong Kong police thriller directed by Jacky Lee, offers a cavalcade of formulaic female-led action sequences amidst an incoherent plot and inconsistent tone. While it ambitiously revisits the 'girls with guns' subgenre, the film suffers from underwhelming action choreography, insipid character development, and subpar acting, ultimately failing to capitalize on its vibrant Macau setting.
Video: 63
"The Fatal Raid" is presented with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.38:1 aspect ratio, courtesy of Well Go USA. The transfer displays commendable detail levels despite its erratic digital cinematography. This Hong Kong production from 2019 benefits from consistently decent black levels that enhance its overall clarity. However, contrast and color correction fluctuate, occasionally impacting the definition of the video. Despite these inconsistencies, the transfer offers a serviceable visual experience, particularly during the scenic shots of Macau, which provide some of the more visually striking moments.
The film, likely finished with a 2K digital intermediate, maintains reasonable sharpness but lacks the polish typically expected from modern digitally-originated content. While the slow-motion sequences offer opportunities to admire detailed effects such as squibs bursting, the overall presentation occasionally appears too bright, notably in outdoor scenes where stronger contrast would have added depth. Furthermore, there is no notable video processing detected, allowing for a natural presentation that captures the essence of the film's intended aesthetic.
In summary, while "The Fatal Raid" does not deliver an impeccable visual experience, it remains a competently captured production on Blu-ray. Its strengths lie in its ability to maintain clarity through adequate black levels even amidst varying lighting choices and definition. Although certain scenes might benefit from enhanced contrast and color uniformity, viewers are still treated to moments of eye-catching detail and scenic beauty, making it a visually intriguing watch despite its imperfections.
Audio: 58
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Fatal Raid" offers the original Cantonese soundtrack in both DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and Dolby Digital 2.0 formats, along with mirrored offerings in an English dub. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 format provides a discrete and immersive listening experience, with an emphasis on surround sound that actively engages the side and rear channels. The film's sound design is typically propulsive, featuring a multitude of effects during action sequences, such as gunfire, that dominate the soundstage with clarity and dynamics. However, dialogue can often come across as almost comically stiff despite being free from delivery issues.
For English speakers, the Cantonese dialogue poses challenges due to poorly translated English subtitles, which are awkward and often barely comprehensible. These translation issues essentially force non-Cantonese speakers to resort to the English dub, which comes with its own set of problems, such as inappropriate character names like "Shirley." Both language tracks in surround sound formats are almost identical in overall mix, making the DTS-HD MA 5.1 track the preferable choice for its dynamic range, unless one is opposed to reading subtitles. Additionally, the presence of optional English subtitles is available in white font, consistently displayed within the scope presentation. Overall, while there are no perfect audio choices for English speakers, Cantonese speakers will find the audio presentation engaging and technically sound.
Extras: 2
The Blu-ray extras of "The Fatal Raid" offer a concise and enticing collection that enhances the viewing experience. Presented in high definition, these extras provide an enticing glimpse into the film's action-packed theme, while also offering a curated selection of trailers that engage audiences with upcoming Well Go USA releases. The disc is well-authored, seamlessly transitioning to promotional content automatically, which can either be a nuisance or a treat depending on viewer preference. Functionally, the Region A coding and included slipcover add technical appeal, catering to collectors and cinephiles alike. However, the focus remains primarily on trailers, offering limited variety in content beyond promotional previews.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Fatal Raid Trailer: A teaser that showcases the film's intense action sequences.
- Raging Fire Trailer: Preview of another high-octane Well Go USA release.
- Deliver Us From Evil Trailer: Insight into a thrilling narrative.
- Undercover Punch And Gun Trailer: Revealing a mix of clandestine operations and explosive action.
Movie: 26
"The Fatal Raid" is a Hong Kong police thriller that attempts to rejuvenate the girls-with-guns subgenre, albeit with mixed results. The film showcases a team of female officers equipped with various combat skills engaging in an arsenal of action-packed sequences, featuring both close-quarter battles and gunfights. Although there is an effort to weave a plot through the recurring theme of a botched raid impacting future events, the narrative often takes a backseat to the relentless action. Characters are largely archetypal, serving as vessels to perpetuate the film's continuous flow of combat scenes, occasionally breaking for cliched dialogue intervals that feel more like filler than substance.
The film's setting in Macau offers an exotic backdrop, occasionally diverting attention from its narrative shortcomings. Yet, the execution falters with inconsistent tones, oscillating between a serious thriller and a light-hearted action flick. The opening sequence, depicting a chaotic firefight, highlights the film's over-the-top direction and precarious performances that unwittingly verge on parody rather than homage to its genre. Despite being marketed as an exhilarating police narrative delving into post-traumatic stress themes, "The Fatal Raid" sidesteps meaningful exploration, underscoring the narrative disconnect and lack of depth.
While the film delivers on the expected action front, some sequences lack the finesse inherent in quintessential Hong Kong cinema, culminating in amateurish choreography and unrealistic firefight portrayals. With underwhelming performances and a substandard screenplay, "The Fatal Raid" presents itself as a mediocre offering, failing to eclipse superior action titles from the region. Ultimately, it leaves aficionados of the genre yearning for the intricate storytelling and high-caliber stunts characteristic of its better-esteemed counterparts.
Total: 45
"The Fatal Raid" on Blu-ray presents a mixed cinematic experience that oscillates between exhilarating action sequences and a lackluster narrative. This film endeavors to merge high-octane escapades with a story arc that never truly gains momentum. The attempt to infuse depth into the plot is overshadowed by its inability to effectively develop a coherent storyline, resulting in extensive segments that feel like filler material waiting for the next action sequence to activate. Despite this narrative shortcoming, the film's ability to deliver frequent action set pieces ensures that audiences are never left in limbo for long.
In terms of technical execution, "The Fatal Raid" excels in maintaining a visual and auditory fidelity that complements its action-heavy scenes. The picture quality is consistently sharp, capturing the kinetic energy of the sequences with precision. The audio mix is equally impressive, providing robust and immersive effects that enrich the on-screen chaos. These technical merits make the Blu-ray edition a worthy consideration for action enthusiasts who prioritize spectacle over substance.
Ultimately, "The Fatal Raid" may struggle with genre clichés and a thin plotline but redeems itself through relentless action and solid production values. Its appeal is primarily for those seeking pure adrenaline and visceral thrills. While it may not offer groundbreaking narrative depth, its proficiency in delivering explosive entertainment marks its place within the action genre. The Blu-ray edition is recommended chiefly for viewers who appreciate action film aesthetics and are willing to overlook its narrative deficiencies.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
One kind of curious thing that struck me is that large swaths of the presentation looked just a tad too bright to my eyes, and in some of the outdoor material in particular I personally would have preferred...
Audio: 90
The sound design in the film is typically propulsive, offering a glut of effects in the many action sequences that help to keep the side and rear channels regularly engaged....
Extras: 10
Note: As tends to be the case with Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the the disc has been authored to automatically move on to trailers for other Well Go USA releases after the trailer for this film plays....
Movie: 40
There's probably a serious film to be made about how police deal with post traumatic stress disorder, and in fact that element has informed the subtexts of all sorts of films, including memorably in productions...
Total: 40
The problem with The Fatal Raid is it doesn't seem to totally trust its tendency toward exploitation level action featuring butt kicking women....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
The Fatal Raid belongs on Blu-ray; it’s just not a consistently clean and crisp experience with outstanding detail....
Audio: 40
Unless you understand Cantonese, English speakers are more or less forced to go with the sub-par English dub, which uses ridiculously American names like Shirley for characters....
Extras: 2
The backcover claims the BD is coded for Region A.The Fatal Raid Trailer (01:26 in HD)Raging Fire Trailer (01:47 in HD)Deliver Us From Evil Trailer (01:23 in HD)Undercover Punch And Gun Trailer (01:33...
Movie: 20
Playing into the usually fun girls-with-guns exploitation tropes, the mostly mediocre flick lacks compelling characters, decent writing, and worst of all, ridiculously underwhelming action choreography...
Total: 31
...
Director: Jacky Lee
Actors: Patrick Tam, Michael Tong, Jade Leung
PlotThe story begins with an ill-fated police mission in Macau, where a group of elite Hong Kong police officers engages in a bloody confrontation with a notorious gang. The operation goes wrong, incurring heavy losses and leaving a lasting impact on the survivors. Years later, the echoes of this disastrous mission reverberate through the force as it grapples with political pressure and internal turmoil. The survivors find themselves reluctantly drawn back into action when a string of mysterious crimes in Hong Kong and Macau reveal connections to the past tragedy. Their mission is to stop a new wave of criminal activity linked to an elusive adversary from their past. As old wounds are reopened, loyalties are tested and personal motives come into play.
The seasoned officers, each burdened by their own emotional baggage, join forces with a younger generation of ambitious yet inexperienced recruits. Tensions arise as the team navigates a volatile urban landscape, trying to prevent history from repeating itself. Amidst high-stakes firefights and intense car chases, they collide with underworld factions vying for control. As they dig deeper into the case, they unravel a complex web of betrayal and conspiracy that threatens to overshadow their mission. Alongside breathtaking action sequences, the narrative explores themes of redemption and justice, compelling the characters to confront their past mistakes while forging unlikely alliances to stop imminent chaos.
Writers: Men-Wa Choi, Jacky Lee, Lam Siu Fu
Release Date: 26 Sep 2019
Runtime: 91 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese