Concussion Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Concussion offers a harrowing yet essential exposé on sports safety, with superb Blu-ray video and audio quality, and worthwhile extras—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 78
Concussion's Blu-ray transfer in 1080p AVC MPEG-4 faithfully presents the directors' aesthetic choices with excellent clarity and precise detailing, despite its somewhat flat and cold appearance. Black levels are deep, and colors, while muted, offer life with occasional pops. Minimal artifacts enhance this top-tier presentation.
Audio: 78
Concussion's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix delivers a clean and immersive sound experience with precise dialogue prioritization, lifelike environmental details, and an engaging score by James Newton Howard. Despite its dialogue-heavy nature, the soundfield impresses with effective bass and subtle ambient effects.
Extra: 40
The Blu-ray extras of 'Concussion' include a meticulously detailed and insightful audio commentary by director Peter Landesman, engaging featurettes such as 'Inside the True Story' and 'Crafting Concussion,' and a set of deleted scenes, providing an enriching behind-the-scenes experience.
Movie: 67
‘Concussion’ presents a compelling exposé on the link between football and severe head trauma, driven by strong performances, particularly Will Smith as Dr. Bennet Omalu. The film deftly balances intricate scientific details with the political and personal impact of CTE, while challenging the NFL's practices. Despite following some predictable sports drama tropes, it leaves a significant emotional and ethical imprint.
Video: 78
The Blu-ray presentation of "Concussion" offers an impressive 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer that remains faithful to the original cinematographic vision of Director Peter Landesman and Cinematographer Salvatore Totino. The digitally sourced image reproduces the intended cold, blue-gray dominant visuals exceptionally well, with fine detailing evident in facial pores, surgical scrubs, and high-end suits. Colors, while generally neutral, include striking splashes like the vivid blue of surgical apparel and the rich yellow of the Steelers' uniforms. The transfer boasts excellent clarity and sharpness, with fine lines and objects distinct in every scene. Black levels are deep and consistent, preserving detail even in complex textures.
However, the film's somewhat sterile, smooth digital appearance may detract for some. The lack of grain texture results in a clean look that could be perceived as overly polished. While this avoids issues like the soap-opera effect, it trades visual warmth for precision. The heavy contrast lends a subdued and somewhat gloomy tone that underscores the somber subject matter effectively. Despite this, brighter elements like whites remain crisp and brilliant. Skin tones throughout are natural, with precise facial details such as stubble and makeup clearly visible.
The aspect ratio of 2.40:1 helps to maintain an immersive viewing experience with impeccable clarity and depth. Exterior daylight scenes occasionally appear flat due to the controlled color palette, yet nighttime sequences are particularly striking. Minor artifacts such as light noise, negligible aliasing, and slight posterization do appear but do not significantly detract from the otherwise noteworthy presentation. Overall, Sony delivers a top-class transfer that brings "Concussion" to life with stunning clarity and detail sure to satisfy both fans and first-time viewers alike.
Audio: 78
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Concussion" is highlighted by a robust DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that exhibits an impressive balance between dialogue, music, and environmental sounds. While the movie’s sound design is mostly straightforward and dialogue-driven, there are moments of intricate sound details that elevate the experience. For instance, auditory hallucinations experienced by Justin Strzelczyk provide an immersive layer that heightens the psychological tension. Background music demonstrates exceptional smoothness, spatial definition, and clarity, especially during energetic club scenes that deliver potent low-end weight and a convincingly enveloping soundstage. The dialogue remains the focal point of the soundtrack, impeccably prioritized and crisply rendered from the center channel.
The surround presentation genuinely adds depth, capitalizing on ambient details like the nuanced chirping of birds and rustling trees to craft a satisfying 360-degree auditory landscape. The rear speakers come alive with atmospheric effects during bustling moments such as football game crowds or city noises, enhancing the sense of immersion without overwhelming the front channels. James Newton Howard's score particularly benefits from this sophisticated layering, stretching across the sound field with meticulous bleeds into the surrounds that offer a wider and larger soundstage. Subtle orchestral elements traverse discreetly, aided by a distinguished mid-range clarity that underscores delicate emotional tones.
Moreover, the dynamic range and bass performance of this lossless mix are commendable. The subwoofer asserts itself convincingly in scenes requiring palpable heft, whether through score hits or diegetic sounds like slamming doors and engine roars. This carefully balanced approach ensures that every whisper and nuanced interaction is precise and full-bodied, providing a rich auditory experience that complements the film's dramatic themes. Overall, "Concussion's" audio mix delivers a multifaceted and engaging listening experience, remaining true to its narrative while showcasing impressive technical execution.
Extras: 40
The Blu-ray of "Concussion" offers a robust set of extras that provide substantial insight into both the film's production and real-life story. The audio commentary by Director Peter Landesman is particularly noteworthy, diving deep into character motivations, shooting locations, and the real-life inspirations for the narrative. The deleted scenes offer additional context, showcasing moments like "Webster Works Out" and "Bennet Discovers the Disease," which enrich the film's narrative. The featurettes are well-produced, with "Inside the True Story" delivering a captivating look at the real-life events behind the film and "Crafting Concussion" providing a comprehensive overview of the production process, including interviews with key cast and crew members.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Peter Landesman discusses characters, motivations, and real-life inspirations.
- Deleted Scenes: Nine scenes depicting additional narrative context.
- Inside the True Story: Features real events and people inspiring the film.
- Crafting Concussion: Explores production aspects including casting, direction, and filming locations.
- Previews: Additional Sony titles.
Movie: 67
"Concussion" delivers an intense, enlightening narrative on the devastating effects of Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE) within the realm of professional football. The film centers on Forensic Pathologist Dr. Bennet Omalu (Will Smith) and his groundbreaking discovery of CTE in former NFL player Mike Webster (David Morse). Omalu's relentless pursuit of truth highlights the significant dangers that repeated concussions pose, not just in football but in contact sports broadly. Will Smith's portrayal is marked by a deep emotional resonance and a commitment to the character that transcends the screen, although some critiques suggest his performance, while commendable, blends with other strong contenders rather than standing out exceptionally.
The film's direction by Peter Landesman balances scientific complexity with human stories, making the dark reality of brain injuries accessible to a general audience. Landesman’s approach interweaves unsettling real-life issues such as political gamesmanship and the NFL's resistance to acknowledging the health crisis within its sport. Supporting actors Albert Brooks and Alec Baldwin deliver compelling performances that add depth and credibility to the narrative. Notably, the film employs juxtaposition effectively, contrasting moments of normalcy or tenderness with scenes depicting the brutal violence intrinsic to football, thereby elevating the emotional impact.
While "Concussion" follows a somewhat formulaic sports drama structure, it distinguishes itself through its unique outsider perspective, viewing football without the rose-colored glasses typical of fan-centric narratives. It exposes the darker side of a beloved sport and confronts the audience with moral and ethical questions that linger beyond the film’s runtime. Ultimately, "Concussion" stands as a gripping exposé that is both heartbreaking and thought-provoking, challenging viewers to reconsider their relationship with football and acknowledge pressing health concerns in today's sports culture.
Total: 69
"Concussion" brings a vital conversation about sports safety into the spotlight, focusing on Dr. Bennet Omalu's courageous confrontation with the NFL regarding brain damage in athletes. Under the direction of Peter Landesman and bolstered by Will Smith's compelling performance, the film navigates a distressing narrative while illuminating the significant health crises borne from professional football. Although the storyline adheres to familiar sports drama tropes, its foundation on real-life events lends it weight and urgency.
The Blu-ray edition delivers near-reference quality in both video and audio presentations, ensuring a highly immersive viewing experience. The visuals maintain exceptional clarity, with detailed picture quality that captures the film’s tense atmosphere perfectly. Similarly, the audio mix is superb, providing clear dialogue and impactful soundscapes that heighten the film's dramatic impact. Supplementary materials may be minimal, yet they are thoughtfully selected and add value without overstaying their welcome.
In conclusion, "Concussion" confronts a critical issue with precision and emotional depth, making it an essential watch for anyone engaged in the ongoing conversation about athlete health and safety. Its Blu-ray release does justice to the film's technical demands and enhances its narrative gravitas. This is a well-crafted dramatized exposé that deserves attention, recommended for purchase or rental and highly considered for fans of sports dramas or impactful biographical films.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Colors, as noted, can push rather cold, favoring a heavy blue-gray dominant appearance, but that said there's no shortage of otherwise impressive, albeit neutral, colorings....
Audio: 90
The movie's sound design is inherently straightforward, mostly, with a few morsels of extracurricular details and music pushing into an otherwise dialogue intensive film, such as some of the "sounds in...
Extras: 50
A quick run-through of the film's production, including approach, structure, direction, cast and performances, the love story in the film, shooting in Pittsburgh, and more....
Movie: 80
Director Peter Landesman masters the movie's needs, creating a foundational knowledge that's detailed but accessible and refusing to shy away from the realities of repeated head injury and, most notably,...
Total: 100
What happens to the former players is harrowing, and just as disturbing is the larger world around the NFL that pushes back against Dr. Omalu's findings....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The transfer is squeaky clean and generally spotless, but it still comes with that somewhat unattractive digital appearance, lacking the sort of grain texture that would give the movie some character....
Audio: 80
Nevertheless, being a dialogue and character driven drama, much of the heavy lifting is done by the front channels, where more of those same sound effects are discretely and convincingly heard off-screen....
Extras: 20
Inside the True Story (HD, 11 min) - As the title suggests, the interviews focus on on the real-life events and people which led to the magazine article and eventually the film....
Movie: 40
The faces of those listening to his impressive background are basically the same reaction some viewers are likely to have, but in also doing this, Landesman reveals just how scripted, intentional and ultimately...
Total: 60
Inspired by the 2009 GQ article, which was based on real-life events, ‘Concussion’ tells the story of the doctor who challenged the powerful National Football League with evidence of brain damage caused...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Flesh Tones: Skin tones are very natural with some sequence erring on the side of being a bit cooler....
Audio: 100
Low Frequency Extension: Score hits, doors closing hard, engines and feet clip clopping are some of the bits captured in a role playing (but strong) performance by the subwoofer....
Extras: 60
Audio CommentaryWith Director Peter LandesmanDeleted Scenes (HD, 12:52)Inside The True Story (HD, 11:10) – Will Smith talks briefly about what made him want to to do the film, but the bulk of this is swift...
Movie: 90
In addition to informing us on one of the biggest and most important subjects challenging the beloved and worshiped sport, it exposes a lot of the ignorance, shady practices and downright despicable things...
Total: 90
For those who are big fans of sport of football, Concussion will prove to be a tough, but educational watch about such a beloved American spectacle....
Director: Peter Landesman
Actors: Will Smith, Alec Baldwin, Albert Brooks
PlotDr. Bennet Omalu, a forensic pathologist working in Pittsburgh, stumbles upon an unusual pattern of brain damage while conducting the autopsy of Mike Webster, a former NFL football player who died under mysterious circumstances. Omalu's discovery leads him to suspect that the repeated head traumas sustained in football could lead to severe cognitive decline in the form of a disease he calls Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE). As he delves deeper into other cases of former NFL players with similar symptoms and untimely deaths, his research begins to suggest a disturbing link between football-related head injuries and long-term neurological damage.
Driven by a commitment to truth and the scientific method, Omalu publishes his findings, hoping to shed light on the issue and protect players. However, his work quickly faces fierce opposition from the NFL, which has a vested interest in downplaying the risks associated with America's beloved sport. Omalu's resolve is tested as he encounters personal and professional backlash. He must navigate the complicated intersection of sports, medicine, and business, while trying to maintain the integrity of his research amid efforts to discredit him. Despite the mounting challenges, Omalu persists, driven by his duty to tell the truth and prevent further harm to players who risk their lives on the field.
Writers: Peter Landesman, Jeanne Marie Laskas
Release Date: 25 Dec 2015
Runtime: 123 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, Australia, United States
Language: English